News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by roenxi on Sunday January 08, 2023 @06:52AM (#34298326)
Due to inflation, basically. There is an effect like inflation which as far as I know is unnamed, where the credit growth & money creation in the economy hits asset prices and drives them up at a fast rate (eg, gold has been pretending to make real annual returns for the last few decades when we all know it isn't changing in value). A company that is treading water will still be growing in percentage terms year-on-year due to this, so a company that isn't growing is actually failing to position correctly vs the credit in an economy.

If that inflation wasn't part of the picture, companies holding steady would be more acceptable.

Although you wouldn't hear about it in the press; the hot companies are always the ones that are growing. There isn't much to say about companies that just sit there.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by fragmede on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:04AM (#34298392)
Would you mind explaining a bit more than "basically"? The money they take in also inflates, so if everyone who bought one last year buys another one, sales in dollars should increase by the same amount as inflation.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by arka2147483647 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @07:28AM (#34298530)
A company may not be able to increase prices as much as inflation eats. Eg, in 6 percent inflation, if you raise prices by 6%, it may result in customers shrinking their purchases by equivalent, or even larger amount. So after the price hike you could be worse off. That is the reason most companies often raise prices slowly in small increments over the months or years.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by roenxi on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:15AM (#34298859)
If we're talking about sales, then sure that should go up by CPI inflation. I thought we were talking about stock prices. Same difference either way, steady state is for economic losers if the money supply is growing exponentially.

Historically "growth" has just been a word for increased energy availability. If it is supposed to measure something else it is a bit meaningless (if some dude plays a game for 2 hours a day, then next year spends 2 hours a day playing a "much better" game on a faster XBox, what does growth as a % even mean? If he spends more hours on a game is that growth? These are profoundly silly questions to spend time on). The rough thinking is we should keep pushing for energy growth until we physically can't any more, because that helps poor people not starve which is actually important.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by Folcon on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:34AM (#34298973)
If that's the goal and I agree that's not a bad goal at all, we seem to have decoupled that from the outcomes.

Are energy companies even really doing that much to grow their energy production? Are we seeing much in the way of producers materially investing in increasing their production thus flooding their markets in a race to the bottom? It feels like a lot of these things have stalled out at present, or am I being too cynical?

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by codethief on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:31AM (#34298959)
> The rough thinking is we should keep pushing for energy growth until we physically can't any more

Not sure that's a good idea, see https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist...

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by roenxi on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:40AM (#34299018)
* * *
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by r3trohack3r on Sunday January 08, 2023 @10:32AM (#34299895)
I wouldn't put too much stock in our current believed limits on life in the universe. Humans are really immature in our understanding of the cosmos and many of these are fairly likely to be wrong.

Given what weve discovered (and been wrong about) so far, I suspect things like entropy and the heat death of the universe being limits on life will be chuckled at by future humans the same way we chuckle about the ether.

Those things are so far in the future and so poorly understood, declaring bankruptcy now would be premature. We have real problems that are a lot closer and easier for humans to overcome, like the complete extinction event facing our planet in ~400M years.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by Folcon on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:55AM (#34299108)
I forgot about this, but the point stands, we still don't use energy that we collect to achieving the outcome he states:

> that helps poor people not starve which is actually important

If we generalise that meeting a minimal bar on the Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, then we're still pretty poor on that front.

Thanks for the link, having read this, it's a valid counterpoint against generally increasing GDP as we currently think of it.

However a lot of discussions at present don't hold to limiting growth to Earth.

What this means however is up for grabs, it could take a very long time to figure out how to practically go further than Earth.

It is however probably worth more consideration than modern economics would give it.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by luma on Sunday January 08, 2023 @08:52AM (#34299090)
Inflation isn't the problem, it's investors. As others have noted, inflation is a wash for most cases. Investors expect regular returns and they sit on your board and they are NEVER satisfied.

When you put the world's greediest individuals in charge of what your business should do next, don't be surprised when the answer is ALWAYS "give us more money".

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by lotsofpulp on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:03AM (#34299160)
People expect their assets to earn 7%+ per year, both via individual retirement accounts and taxpayer funded defined benefit pensions. If that assumption is not met, then those debts cannot be repaid, which means someone (or everyone) has to take a hit on quality of life. This is politically unpopular because people get disappointed when their expectations are not met.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by luma on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:49AM (#34299518)
Your argument here is that rich people expect to continue getting richer on account of... already being rich.

I will sleep like a baby if their expectations of continued "being rich for no work" doesn't pan out for them.

Get a job, slackers.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by lotsofpulp on Sunday January 08, 2023 @09:56AM (#34299578)
My argument is that a very large proportion of people benefit from borrowing from the future (obviously some more than others). Enough that it is politically unpopular to vote against the government ensuring these returns.

For example, taxes are lower today because of off the books borrowing from the future via these expected future asset valuations, as well as people liking their own 401k/IRA account numbers going up.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by chalst on Sunday January 08, 2023 @10:33AM (#34299904)
> My argument is that a very large proportion

What is the actual proportion?

The proportion you argue is neither here nor there.

Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by lotsofpulp on Sunday January 08, 2023 @10:59AM (#34300146)
Whatever the actual proportion is, it is evident over many decades, that it is sufficiently large to ensure the election of leaders that will backstop asset prices.
Re:If you like startups you should love anti-trust by wizzwizz4 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @11:32AM (#34300471)
> Whatever the actual proportion is, it is evident over many decades, that it is sufficiently large

Sufficiently-powerful. Don't confuse the two. In an ideal world, one would be indicative of the other, but history suggests this hasn't been the case. (No comment on the contemporary political situation.)