Add to that the fact that I sleep worse due to pain...
So my appetite is even worse, as I eat to compensate the lack of energy because of my bad sleep.
I want these meds, if only until I've had my surgery and have completely recovered.
And after that? We'll see..
Food abuse is instilled during childhood, it's incredibly hard to change. For alcohol abuse we accept that abstaining is the right thing to do. Can't do that with food, so we need some help.
If these meds work with minimal side effects, and people are genuinely having a benefit, why not?
>If these meds work with minimal side effects, and people are genuinely having a benefit, why not?
I suppose that is true! It's been my experience that if something is too good to be true, then it often is. I hope I'm wrong here though.
If we have tools available that can solve problems—as humans are not perfect—then why not use them? Do you not enjoy the benefits of other medicine that solves problems you have, like susceptibility to Covid?
We should always be on the conquest to improve our livelihoods. If that means introducing a drug to combat obesity so that scores of people can extend their lifespans by being healthier, that is a good thing.
Purely anecdotal N=1 but I was also 285 at one point in my life and went through an intensive weight loss program through my work and lost about 60 lbs in 3 months. That was about 15 years ago. Since then I've done several 3 day fasts and many weeks of One Meal A Day. I think that program showed me experientially what its like to go without as much food as I thought I needed.. so even when the program ended I had a totally different concept of food. Maybe this drug can do something similar. I think so much of overeating for a lot of people is just purely habitual or a misconception that 'my body needs food every 3 hours' when really it doesn't at all, that's just how you've currently conditioned it.
Food was very much a comfort thing so I would stress-eat during exams, stressful jobs and so forth.
The other thing I noticed is that I got less hungry(!?) when I ate less after like fasting for 2 weeks. It seems to me that eating less after getting over the initial hump was key for my weight loss.
This comment of yours made me think of this comment from another article about another obesity drug I read recently:
"The history of medicine includes the following story many times: there’s some condition that doctors recommend lifestyle changes for. Then an exciting new medication comes out that treats the condition effectively. Over a generation or so, doctors go from demanding the lifestyle change, to gesturing at the lifestyle change before prescribing the medication, to mostly just prescribing the medication. We saw this with cholesterol and statins, with hypertension and ACE inhibitors, with depression and SSRIs. You can form your own opinion on whether this is good or bad, but we’re probably in the very beginning of this process with obesity. Opinions will be all over the map for a while before the inevitable pharma company victory makes everyone agree that semaglutide is first-line therapy."
There really shouldn’t be a stigma associated with taking drugs like these for the rest of your life.
I remember reading a study on the effect of obesity on sperm counts in men, which showed a significant increase in sperm counts for the men once they lost weight after a few months.
Sperm replace themselves more quickly than other cells in the body, but presumably the same normalization should occur in this case absent some sort of persistent self reinforcement mechanisms.
That's a good point I hadn't considered. Thanks!
It's also not necessarily either-or: maybe lower doses might be enough to get someone over a hump or something with exercise and other lifestyle changes. Or some dosing protocol in tandem with other things might allow people to go off the drug eventually. Or maybe not. But it's early and who knows what research will show. Having another option that actually works and isn't harmful is better than not having that option.
I took a cursory glance at the wiki page (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tirzepatide) and it seems like it's working wonders on weight loss by targeting satiety. Weight loss still occurs when calorie out exceeds calorie input so it's not fundamentally changing anything as far as I know biochemically. Why is it so popular then? Should we be concerned about needing drugs to treat obesity? My guess is that patients who lose weight this way still needs this drug to keep it off.
Medical professionals/experts - please ream me or just correct me if I'm wrong here.
FWIW - I also struggled with weight loss. I was 284(!!!) during peak covid but managed to get myself down to 224. I'm hoping to get it down to 174 by end of this year. I found fasting + exercise + will power to be key for weight loss but I also understand that this is an anecdote and won't work for others.