NEVER use PayPal to sell anything that could in anyway be disputed as counterfeit given that the terms allow PayPal to deems what is genuine/fake remotely, without physical inspection and results in not only money witheld but a potentially genuine item being destroyed.
So so crazy.
I sometimes buy and sell rare coins (particularly US Morgan dollars), which regularly go for thousands of dollars. I have one on eBay at this very moment that I'm attempting to get $3000+ for.
I've never heard of such a dispute happening before, or have I had any issues in the past, but now knowing this, i'm really scared of what might happen.
We seriously need a viable competitor to the paypal/ebay system yesterday.
That may be, and I make extremely little use of PayPal (only as a processor of credit card payments for merchants I trust on other grounds, and never as a seller of goods). But any new viable competitor to PayPal will have to solve all over all the cases of fraud and abuse that were responded to over the years by PayPal's current policies. "The life of the law has not been logic; it has been experience." Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., The Common Law (1881), page 1.
Let payments be payments like cash, and solve trust issues separately with things like escrow services.
There are plenty of ways to destroy it physically (throw it in a forge, bend it with pliers, etc).
I'm a bit more concerned that a scammer wouldn't destroy the coin per se, but make a claim on authenticity, causing me to lose my money and also the coin.
1) Get the original (say, $3000 coin) carefully out of the holder - then smash the holder with a hammer.
2) Find a replica of that year coin, which really is a fake, for $10-$50. Scratch it up, bend it, whatever.
3) Send the original coin back for grading to be certified with a new graded coin holder and serial number, to be sold for $3000.
This is just the "kill them all and let God sort them out" mentality applied to property.
So to answer your question: In some cases, not well enough. ;)
EDIT: source: http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2011/04/euro_coin_recy...
Funny fact: at that time it was illegal in my country (France). This law has been abrogated since then to allow machines that crush coins to make souvenirs.
But I agree - it's clearly better not to use Paypal at all.
So... that means that the either:
1) The provision in the contract can't mean "we have the write to breach whenever we feel like it"
2) or, that the TOS are unenforceable.
The wording in the TOS is designed specifically to not mean "we can breach whenever we want", but instead to mean "if you sell counterfeit goods through our service we will destroy them and not refund your money".
The words "we ... reasonably believe the item you sold is counterfeit" were deliberately chosen for this purpose. The fact that paypal can use its sole discretion just tips the scales in their favor. If they have reasonable evidence that something is fake, then they can destroy it, even if they haven't done due diligence to prove it's a fake.
The question comes down to wether or not paypal had reason to believe the item was counterfeit.
Their are certain cases where only a customer complaint would be sufficient to establish a "reasonable believe".
For example, if Picasso bought a painting that was said to be a Picasso original, and he called paypal and said "I didn't paint this, it's a fake", they would definetly be within their rights if they distroyed it, even if further investigation could have revealed he was lying.
In this particular case... you could potentially argue that the customer's complaint was in no way sufficient for paypal to reach a "reasonable believe". This does make the whole thing wildly open to judicial interpretation, however.
Its a shame that contracts have these kinds of protections in them that most people are unaware of as they get pummelled by these sorts of contracts.
Principle. (JSYK)
In any case, once someone posts a comment I can't edit a post, so by posting a reply about a typeo, you only ensure that it will never be fixed....
tl;dr lawyer up.
They had a professional appraisal on the violin that said it was authentic. Paypal has its TOS saying they can call anything counterfeit and their TOS says they can't be held liable for it.
Sorry it's a judges job to say if you can or can't be held liable for your business terms and practices.
(Americans also make typos which look odd to Britons, for example "mute point".)
So there's that.
I think that tossing a coin and using reason are different, and I believe that a court would uphold my expectation that reason was used. Paypal will then have an opportunity to present their reasons. In this case, IMHO, it would appear that a "reasonable standard" of "reason" was not used.
From a brief search, it looks like eBay had to pay large sums multiple times for selling counterfeit goods. $2500 violin, as sad as it is, is small fries. It seems that it's cheaper to operate under the assumption that if there's a suspicion an item is counterfeit, then that's more likely than not. Even if they messed up and lose a lawsuit from a seller, they'll pay a small fraction of what they'd pay a manufacturer.
I thought ebay provided a marketplace, I didn't realise they also sold goods?
2. Sue Paypal for negligence.
3. Show up any conversation with buyer stating that the piece was priceless and the sale was only symbolic because he proved that he would keep the violin soul alive by playing it.
4. Add psychological trauma and other stuff to step 2.
Antiques are irreplaceable and you'd better be sure what you're doing before destroying something like that.
http://reviews.ebay.com/Buying-an-old-violin-on-ebay?ugid=10...
http://reviews.ebay.com/What-apos-s-in-a-Name-A-Guide-to-Lab...
http://reviews.ebay.com/Violins-on-Ebay?ugid=100000000142981...
Paypal TOS Covers counterfeit items:
10.1 b Further, if you lose a [Significantly Not as Described] Claim because we, in our sole discretion, reasonably believe the item you sold is counterfeit, you will be required to provide a full refund to the buyer and you will not receive the item back (it will be destroyed). PayPal Seller protection will not cover your liability. https://cms.paypal.com/us/cgi-bin/marketingweb?cmd=_render-c...
If Paypal decides you sold a counterfeit item, you lose the item and your money.