News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by walexander on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @09:24PM (#3422439)
I froze for a second after reading that statement, which I was completely unaware of.

I sometimes buy and sell rare coins (particularly US Morgan dollars), which regularly go for thousands of dollars. I have one on eBay at this very moment that I'm attempting to get $3000+ for.

I've never heard of such a dispute happening before, or have I had any issues in the past, but now knowing this, i'm really scared of what might happen.

We seriously need a viable competitor to the paypal/ebay system yesterday.

Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by tokenadult on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @10:32PM (#3422621)
We seriously need a viable competitor to the paypal/ebay system yesterday.

That may be, and I make extremely little use of PayPal (only as a processor of credit card payments for merchants I trust on other grounds, and never as a seller of goods). But any new viable competitor to PayPal will have to solve all over all the cases of fraud and abuse that were responded to over the years by PayPal's current policies. "The life of the law has not been logic; it has been experience." Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr., The Common Law (1881), page 1.

Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by wcoenen on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @04:18AM (#3423397)
I think that the problem is exactly that paypal and credit cards try to solve the trust issue, but they do it in a simplistic way that heavily favors the buyer.

Let payments be payments like cash, and solve trust issues separately with things like escrow services.

Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @10:23PM (#3427206)
It seems like this rule is designed to benefit not the buyer but an extra-transactional party, namely, the IP owner - that is usually the case in anti-counterfeit programmes. The case of the violin is just a perversion of a rule that was probably implemented to prevent the sale of fake watches, handbags, and the like.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by epscylonb on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @04:58AM (#3423489)
This is where bitcoin may be useful.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by WettowelReactor on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @09:55AM (#3424316)
Except that Paypal has only solved fraud from the consumer side. Policies like this leave the sellers ripe for fraud.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by kls on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @11:52AM (#3424799)
If I where in your situation, I would immediately add that text to all of my auctions with a justification as to why you will not accept pay-pal for your particular transactions. I would then use a third party escrow service for anything that pay-pal could consider a counterfeit. This sounds to me like Pay-Pal is doing the bidding of trademark holders. When that is not it's role in society. It's not the counterfeit police and it should not be in the business of destroying counterfeit merchandise. They should require it be returned and if they feel like being good Samaritans, notify the trademark holder of the infringement. Let the holder police their own crap.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by rlpb on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @12:41PM (#3425010)
On eBay, accepting Paypal is mandatory.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by kls on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @01:20PM (#3425198)
Is that a contract requirement to using Ebay? I understand that the system allows them to pay via Pay-Pal, but can you not stipulate that payment's via Pay-Pal will be refunded and the purchase will be canceled?
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by psychotik on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @10:30PM (#3422618)
Out of curiosity, how do you destroy a coin?
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by walexander on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @11:16PM (#3422713)
The easiest way to destroy the value of numismatic coin would probably be to clean it. A coin at the highest level of grading would be "destroyed" (lowered to a less valuable rating) by simply picking it up outside of its sealed, graded holder.

There are plenty of ways to destroy it physically (throw it in a forge, bend it with pliers, etc).

I'm a bit more concerned that a scammer wouldn't destroy the coin per se, but make a claim on authenticity, causing me to lose my money and also the coin.

Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by prawn on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @12:29AM (#3422920)
Would it be trivial for someone to dispute the authenticity of the coin, receive PayPal's request for its destruction, photograph something that looked like a mangled coin, and then essentially get the coin for free?
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by walexander on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @02:08AM (#3423149)
Considering the amount of money to be made, I think it's reasonable. I present the following:

1) Get the original (say, $3000 coin) carefully out of the holder - then smash the holder with a hammer.

2) Find a replica of that year coin, which really is a fake, for $10-$50. Scratch it up, bend it, whatever.

3) Send the original coin back for grading to be certified with a new graded coin holder and serial number, to be sold for $3000.

Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by kls on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @11:58AM (#3424833)
Right which is what seems so illogical to me about this policy. I having little experience with coins could probably come up with that one pretty quickly. As well with the subject of this post a violin. I could easily go get a kids First Start violin for under $100 and smash it, take a photo and send it in. This to me seems like the most ill conceived business process ever dreamed up. Hell 20 minutes in Photoshop and I could destroy anything.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by praptak on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @04:18AM (#3423398)
Heck, with ones made of precious metals you can even actually destroy them and still make a good buck selling the gold.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by bmuon on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @08:15AM (#3423956)
That's why PayPal insists on you destroying the counterfeit item and providing proof that you did.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by marshray on Thursday January 05, 2012 @02:00AM (#3427760)
Except that the destruction is far easier to prove than the counterfeitness of the item.

This is just the "kill them all and let God sort them out" mentality applied to property.

Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by stcredzero on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @01:00PM (#3425114)
Yes, but as pointed out elsewhere, the "proof" is easily photoshopped.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by sitkack on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @01:24AM (#3423064)
Lets do this?! We could buy anything, dispute the validity of said item, send them pictures of the destruction (keeping the original) and PROFIT! All these years of collecting underpants have paid off.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by burgerbrain on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @11:03PM (#3422686)
I remember a year or three ago there was a story going around about Chinese scrap metal recyclers getting shipments of "destroyed" euro coins and reassembling them to pass off as intact money. Turns out at the time the official method to decommission the coins was to pop out the center piece.

So to answer your question: In some cases, not well enough. ;)

EDIT: source: http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2011/04/euro_coin_recy...

Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by catwell on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @04:06AM (#3423371)
A physics teacher of mine destroyed one in class by putting it in acid for an experiment.

Funny fact: at that time it was illegal in my country (France). This law has been abrogated since then to allow machines that crush coins to make souvenirs.

Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by andrewkreid on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @10:36PM (#3422630)
Traditionally, by leaving it on the train tracks.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by kilburn on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @09:32AM (#3424235)
I'm pretty sure it would blend...
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by rmc on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @05:24AM (#3423548)
I presume you could take a bolt cutters to it and cut it up?
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by kd5bjo on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @10:36PM (#3422631)
Melting.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by MPSimmons on Tuesday January 03, 2012 @10:59PM (#3422676)
Square. Authorize payment via phone.
Re:PayPal forces buyer to destroy $2500 pre-WWII antique vio... by _rknLA on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @03:37AM (#3423318)