News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by froggertoaster on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:07PM (#34130078)
You can downplay this all you want - but remember: stuff like this is a microcosm of a larger issue.

Sections of your government worked directly with Twitter to control what information you saw.

Much bigger organizations - Facebook comes to mind - must be doing the same thing every.single.day. And no one finds this even a little bit alarming?

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by whatsu on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:30PM (#34130336)
It is true that governments have always had an influence on how we live our lives, whether through traditional media like newspapers and television, or more modern platforms like social media. This is not a new phenomenon, but rather something that has always existed in society. However, with the proliferation of the internet and social media, it has become easier for governments to monitor and regulate online content, and this has led to increased scrutiny and debate about the role of government in moderating online speech.

The United States has a distorted view of free speech, as some people believe that it should be absolute and without any limitations. However, it is important to recognize that the collective good and well-being of society should always be a priority, and that includes protecting against harmful or extremist ideas that could cause harm to others. While it is important to protect individuals' right to express themselves freely, it is also important to ensure that this freedom is not used to spread hateful or harmful messages. In short, the collective well-being of humanity should always be a top priority, and this includes moderating harmful or extremist content on the internet.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by catiopatio on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:57PM (#34130636)
I believe your comment represents speech that puts the well-being of society at serious risk, is harmful, and possibly even extremist.

If I manage to convince 50.1% of the population of the same, should we be permitted to censor your speech, and enforce prior restraint on your future speech under penalty of law?

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by birken on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:11PM (#34130752)
I'll go one further... if even 1 single person (the person who owns HN), decides that they don't like the content of that comment, then they should be free to delete/censor the comment on HN and ban the person in perpetuity from HN.

Your argument doesn't really make any sense because everybody here is talking about speech in the context of a walled garden owned by a company/person. That is a completely different situation than what you are alluding to. I can just as easily prevent the reverse question: I have a blog with a comment section, and somebody I don't know posts a horrific, rude and distasteful comment that I don't want associated with my blog post. Can the government force me to not delete that due to free speech, or do I have the power to moderate my blog however I want?

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by Vt71fcAqt7 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:54PM (#34131130)
>Your argument doesn't really make any sense because everybody here is talking about speech in the context of a walled garden owned by a company/person.

Did you read GP? If they were talking about comapnies and not governments, it certainly was not made clear:

>However, with the proliferation of the internet and social media, it has become easier for governments to monitor and regulate online content, and this has led to increased scrutiny and debate about the role of government in moderating online speech.

>[...]In short, the collective well-being of humanity should always be a top priority, and this includes moderating harmful or extremist content on the internet.

Where was GP talking about companies?

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by birken on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:11PM (#34131991)
> Where was GP talking about companies?

The initial comment says government has always used their influence through "newspapers", "television" and "social media", all of which have historically been non-government entities who take the government's input and decide if they want to follow it or not. There are obviously major historical cases in which private companies have defied what the government wanted them to do (NYT v Sullivan, NYT vs US, etc), but I'm sure there are countless examples throughout Twitter's history of the government asking for something and then not getting it, but I assume that isn't something those instances are not being highlighted that much as they don't fit the narrative.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by Vt71fcAqt7 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:53PM (#34132886)
That's perhaps a fair reading of the initial comment, although reading "regulate" in "it has become easier for governments to monitor and regulate online content" and "moderating" in "the collective well-being of humanity should always be a top priority, and this includes moderating harmful or extremist content on the internet" to both mean simply "government input" is somewhat questionable. See also your own use of the word "moderate" ("Can the government force me to not delete that due to free speech, or do I have the power to moderate my blog however I want?"). Also your point that historically non-government entities can decide whether to follow government input or not needs to be qualified considerably. Contempt of court was not considered free speech until relatively recently. for example see Los Angeles Times contempt of court 1938. Then there is of course the Sedition Act of 1918. In any case this is very far from your claim that "everybody here is talking about speech in the context of a walled garden owned by a company/person." We are most certainly talking about government here. Whether or not the initial comment was refering to government simply "giving input" or outright censoring, we are still talking about government, so your claim is in my view inaccurate even under your own explaination of the comment, which is itself somewhat questionable.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by shitlord on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:02PM (#34130689)
> However, it is important to recognize that the collective good and well-being of society should always be a priority, and that includes protecting against harmful or extremist ideas that could cause harm to others.

As an American, I disagree. We are a sovereign country, and people from other countries don't have any say in how we conduct ourselves. It doesn't whether it's online or offline.

American Nazis and Tankies have the first amendment right to spread their dumb ideas. If they want to make their own websites, that's fine with me. The government should mind its own business unless there are actual crimes taking place.

The rest of the world doesn't have to like it. It's just the way it's going to be.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by Zpalmtree on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:08PM (#34130734)
why is it distorted?
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by none_to_remain on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:18PM (#34130819)
This reads like the pure BS I see ChatGPT producing when people run into its silly filters
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by philippejara on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:22PM (#34130857)
>In short, the collective well-being of humanity should always be a top priority, and this includes moderating harmful or extremist content on the internet.

Who defines what is harmful or extremist in the government? Sounds like you either get in the good graces of the "intelligence community" or you are now harmful, as shown pretty clearly with the hordes of "intelligence community" people calling the biden laptop(whatever it had, its content is irrelevant) russian propaganda[0], while even the DOJ and FBI says it isn't[1]. And of course those officials making the stink are contracted by the news agencies to talk about it where journalists will just blindly accept whatever they're given.

The "intelligence community" isn't your friend(neither are the proper agencies but I digress), it never was if you're not an us citizen and it probably stopped being if you are after the patriot act.

[0]:https://www.politico.com/news/2020/10/19/hunter-biden-story-...

[1]: https://www.dailywire.com/news/breaking-doj-fbi-confirm-hunt...

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by Mezzie on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:16PM (#34131370)
> Who defines what is harmful or extremist in the government?

An additional related question: Are they even capable of undertaking this task? Our current government officials and bureaucrats don't understand enough about how the Internet works to effectively police it. And more fundamentally, can a government act quickly enough to outwit how quickly the Internet adapts to roadblocks? Governments need to have policies, procedures, go through chains of command, etc. A lot of Internet culture, on the other hand, is driven by random people doing random things. If a topic is forbidden, instead of policing that topic, the government then has to police the 50 ways to get around the block as well as guess which one will take root.

It's similar to trying to win a war against guerrilla insurgents. The high level of organization of a government to some degree works against them.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by zosima on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:55PM (#34131133)
The government should simply have no hand in determining what information is presented or not presented to anyone, except within the bounds of explicit legal mandate to do so.

That this sort of under-the-table cooperation between three letter agencies and information companies has been allowed to exist and develop is completely outrageous. It should not be put into perspective, but stopped, right here, right now.

Once that is done, a discussion can be had about where it makes sense to create legislation to curtail various behaviors and content that are disturbing to social order. The current list of offenses is fairly comprehensive and includes things such as violent threats, child porn and terrorism recruitment, and any addition has to be well-motivated.

But as long as the cooperation with three-letter agencies happens outside a legal framework, the only proper response, as far as I can see, is pure outrage.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by elurg on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:14PM (#34130179)
A lot of people completely agree with heavy-handed information control.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by quacked on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:18PM (#34130219)
"A well-armed and informed populace governing itself" is a pipe dream by indigenous uncontacted people and certain very intelligent dissenters. The majority of "civilized" people in the world are very happy to live in an authoritarian information-sanitized nation so long as the people in power cater to their own in-group.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by barnabee on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:44PM (#34130474)
I’d like to think this site of all places might be populated with very intermittent dissenters willing to be or at least support activists trying to change that, with the internet and technology as their tool.

It’s always jarring to discover the extent to which it’s not.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by colpabar on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:22PM (#34130862)
I've realized this recently too, and I'm trying to just ignore/flag everything even remotely political that gets posted here. If you disagree with the idea that information control is something the government has no business of doing, you're in the minority here. The response to the twitter files was the slap in the face I needed to finally understand that.

After all, it's a blog for a VC fund. I'd say a lot of people here are building things that do much worse than what the twitter files exposed.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by lovich on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:36PM (#34130972)
You don’t like that people aren’t as open minded as you’d like, so you flipped on your values and now try to flag anything you disagree with(i.e. political content)?

Am I misinterpreting your comment?

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by colpabar on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:51PM (#34131097)
I think dang kinda just looks the other way because he knows people want to talk politics, but it's literally the first thing in the "off topic" section of the guidelines.

> What to Submit

> On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.

> Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.

The exception clause is "unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon, but according to all the top comments on the twitter files threads, "this is nothing new".

So yeah, you are misinterpreting my comment. I've just realized what HN is meant to be, or at least what dang wants it to be. I think he's an excellent mod, and I respect the guidelines. I want to come here and see cool nerd stuff like "can you play minecraft inside doom inside minecraft" and as soon as I see something political it puts me in a bad mood. And yes, if you scroll my comment history, you will see that I post mostly in political threads. But I have learned my lesson - this place isn't for that. There's no revolution to be started here, given the userbase is mostly financially well-off tech bros who benefit from the status quo. Just like me!

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by lovich on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:06PM (#34131262)
>> Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.

>The exception clause is "unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon, but according to all the top comments on the twitter files threads, "this is nothing new".

You said you were flagging all of political content and then brought it back to Twitter files specifically to justify it not hitting the exception clause.

For me the Twitter files content themselves aren’t interesting, but the effect of the what seems like obviously non interesting content getting so many people up in arms just because a billionaire is claiming it’s bad is an interesting new phenomenon.

I understand this type of content might put you in a bad mood, but given that you weren’t flagging the content until you felt

> The response to the twitter files was the slap in the face I needed to finally understand that.

Kinda feels like you’re trying to engage in the same type of censorship that bothers you.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by colpabar on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:18PM (#34131396)
> Kinda feels like you’re trying to engage in the same type of censorship that bothers you.

No, because that isn't censorship. I'm participating in community moderation to the extent that this website enables me. It wouldn't be censorship for the owner of a facebook page about cooking to remove posts not about cooking, and it isn't censorship for posts not about "hacker news" on a website called hacker news. One type of censorship that does bother me is shady government agencies that have done horrible things in the past working with massive social media platforms to influence public discourse. But that's pretty political, and this isn't the place for it.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by lovich on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:30PM (#34132662)
You do you, but I can’t fathom how to reconcile the public’s reaction to the Twitter files as a “slap in the face” as you said, and then calling this “community moderation”
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by cactusplant7374 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @08:26PM (#34133522)
> I'm participating in community moderation to the extent that this website enables me.

Yes, but when Musk talked about freedom of speech but not freedom of reach he wasn’t referring to flagging that leads to removal. He meant you might not get as many views as you had hoped.

So your approach of flagging is actually more extreme because the content will be completely removed in some cases.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by fallingknife on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:14PM (#34131342)
> On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting

I would say that government agencies trying to stop me from seeing information that it doesn't like is something most good hackers would find interesting.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by colpabar on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:31PM (#34131547)
I did too! But like I said, the majority of HN does not. We love our LEOs here.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by MarkPNeyer on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:17PM (#34130806)
Bitcoin is people striving for financial self sovereignty.

“Crypto” is a bunch of people trying to get rich using some cool new technology they nobody understands.

See how much bigger the second is than the first.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by quacked on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:55PM (#34131137)
The reason Bitcoin got so large so quickly is the same reason that "Crypto" got large so quickly. The majority of people who "invest" in Bitcoin aren't trying to figure out a way to trade goods and services in a way that undermines the Federal Reserve and the IRS, they're trying to increase their holdings in USD in order to better participate in the existing economy.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by barnabee on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:42PM (#34131677)
Meh. People will try to get rich off anything— crypto, the internet, SMS scams, every type of physical business, legit or otherwise.

As a hacker I want to find out what else we can do with it. What surprising things can we build?

What if we could use some kind of blockchain tech to incentivise people to do great things despite what you’ve seen so far? (Some people really are trying to do that.)

What if we can help activists all over the world with Tor and end to end encryption?

What if the internet can give a voice to people who never had one?

What if we can find a better way than copyright to compensate people for their creations with restricting sharing and reuse?

What if we can build and online encyclopaedia many orders of magnitude grander in scope than anything that’s gone before?

Let someone else worry about what the grifters are doing to screw us this time.

Let’s see the hackers hack.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by dale_glass on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:46PM (#34132298)
That vision of bitcoin died somewhere around 2017, back when blocks filled, commerce ground to a halt and nobody in charge thought this was a problem.

Because the people that were in control already figured that what they wanted to use the system for is to buy low and sell high for huge profits, and so it didn't matter if the network didn't perform well for regular commerce. You don't need a lot of TPS if your ideal scenario is to ever make two.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by chaosbolt on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:20PM (#34131423)
The age of cypherpunks is dead, we live in the age of the "programmer who blindly believes the same thing everyone at his company believes and thinks he's right because he's intelligent because he's a programmer".

And the scary thing is, this came out of nowhere, one day everyone online is for freedom and freespeech, the next day everyone became against it, it's the same thing for Elon Musk, it's crazy how popular he was online and how everyone loved him, he didn't do anything bad between then and now (except insult a couple people here and there and other asshole things we have all done in the past) but went from "invented X" to "merely invested in X", and from "genius" to "idiot", etc.

The people who said they couldn't tame the internet were as wrong as those who said the same thing about crypto.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by helloworld11 on Thursday December 29, 2022 @06:45AM (#34171694)
>And the scary thing is, this came out of nowhere, one day everyone online is for freedom and freespeech, the next day everyone became against it

I don't think it came from nowhere. Specifically, I'd say a lot of it started very specifically after Trump won the 2016 election and a whole obsessive craze struck the progressive media and wider communities that follow it (among them, many programmers, techies and other academically educated, otherwise supposedly intelligent people) who rapidly also started to follow the line of this same craze over supposed "misinformation" and other "harmful" information.

Rapidly, the notion of free speech became something that needed to be modulated, coordinated, controlled and carefully allowed because it might lead to another case in which something disliked by the media/academic/cultural ingroup happens.

The related Russian disinformation mania of that same timeframe also introduced a strong and strangely absurd nationalist streak of controlling foreign influence in how people see information to the debate, this further reinforced the wider argument of free expression and access to it being dangerous for people.

Totally outside one's personal politics, this idea is absurd and hypocritical, but it notably became the case after that specific point in time among many people who previously used to aggressively defend the notion of free speech and online freedom. Remember the whole previous-to-that debate about net neutrality? Much of it faded away because it tacitly goes against the grain of these superseding notions about how discourse should be controlled.

The "trust science and lockdown measures" narratives during the COVID pandemic only expanded the scope of the above, and for similar reasons of partisan politics.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by tastyfreeze on Monday December 26, 2022 @12:27AM (#34134861)
If you know a site with reasonable discussions of governance, with voices from all points of view, don't hold back. I am often a dissenter here and take the down votes for it. But HN isn't really for such discussions even if dang let's it fly.

Thanks to dang I do find HN to be much more balanced on most viewpoints than the majority of sites. I can't recall a time here where I have been disgusted with someone's comment like I have on Arstechnica reading comments wishing death to Trump supporters or the unvaccinated.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by zmgsabst on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:37PM (#34130983)
Then those people are stupid:

History shows that’s the real pipe dream — where some wise and benevolent authority cares for you; as we can see right now, in the disasters unfolding in both China and Europe.

What you call a “pipe dream” is the only thing shown to work: independently having the capacity to care for yourself and those around you.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by bell-cot on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:44PM (#34130480)
And a whole lot more people don't want to think too hard - especially about complex & unhappy stuff, where they can't just wait 'till the end of the movie for "happily ever after", nor ask their doctor for the latest pill to fix it.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by SyzygistSix on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:44PM (#34130483)
Exactly. What if I WANT to be tricked by a Russian disinformation campaign? What if I just want a juicy story that justifies my biases and I have no regard for the truth at all?

Is there a Mastodon server that straight up admits that it may include Russian disinformation and is primarily for entertainment purposes rather than factual discussion?

edit: Or a mix of both true news items and disinformation! See if you can tell which is which!

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by dragonwriter on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:47PM (#34130522)
> Is there a Mastodon server that straight up admits that it may include Russian disinformation and is primarily for entertainment purposes rather than factual discussion?

It doesn't quite admit it, and its a fork, but Truth Social may be close enough.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by chaosbolt on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:13PM (#34131335)
Reading your comment felt like that hearing Anakin saying he knows what's best for the people better than they do.

As soon as you start assuming you know more than the people and that you have a right to censor the information they can access because it's bad for them, you become a tyrant.

Am I the only one who finds this rotten?

I want to read disinformation, tell me the sky is green I don't care, I can stitch stories together and arrive to a conclusion myself, false things (won't use that "(d/m)isinformation" media clickbait word) don't make sense, real things do, sure there are false things that do sound correct, but trust the people to make the difference, have your experts argue against falsehoods, let the people hear those arguments, if your expert's arguments disprove X or Y the people will not believe it, if the Russian experts disprove your arguments, then they're right and you're the one spreading falsehoods...

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by SyzygistSix on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:43PM (#34131682)
I don't like censorship but I also know that I am not unbiased/intelligent/non-human enough to not fall for disinformation. And so will anyone, if they are honest about it. Not every time but we will fall for it. And foreign operations like that should not have the freedom to be conducted on US soil and in US media.

I think labels that say who has determined something is disinformation, produced by whom, and why they have labeled it thus might be a better solution.

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by zosima on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:35PM (#34132212)
But you seem to suffer from some kind of delusion that government is somehow less biased and more intelligent, and free of human faults than you?

What in all of human history, would make you think that?

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by SyzygistSix on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:50PM (#34132847)
It would not only be the government. It would also involve the media and it would present their case for the labeling. It's not a blanket trust. And it doesn't remove the media, just labels it.
Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by eternalban on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:16PM (#34130798)
This buck stops with congress. Be alarmed if you want but make sure you address the actual root cause.

In our system of governance, it is the responsibility of Congress to hold the executive accountable. All these agencies are part of the Executive arm of the United States of America. If there is over-reach by secretive agencies of the Executive, it is the duty and responsibility of congressional members, representatives of the public, to be rigorous in the exercise of their duty and hold them accountable.

https://www.visitthecapitol.gov/exhibitions/artifact/senator...

[p.s. Support archive.org .. ^ is archived below]

"Allegations of domestic spying by the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) surfaced in the 1970s, triggering public demand for an investigation of federal surveillance operations. In 1975 the Senate established the Select Committee to Study Governmental Operations with Respect to Intelligence Activities, headed by Senator Frank Church of Idaho. The Church Committee’s reports exposed abuses and led to legislation governing domestic and foreign surveillance—most notably, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978. House and Senate permanent select committees established at that time now oversee U.S. intelligence.

The critical question before the committee was to determine how the fundamental liberties of the people can be maintained in the course of the Government’s effort to protect their security."

https://web.archive.org/web/20180227204516/https://www.visit...

The Church Committee Report: "INTELLIGENCE ACTIVITIES AND THE RIGHTS OF AMERICANS - Final Report - 1976"

https://loveman.sdsu.edu/docs/1976Churchcommittee.pdf

Re:The FBI was the primary link between the intelligence com... by matthewdgreen on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:17PM (#34131388)
Of course we find it concerning, and we'd want to look closely at it to see if it crosses legal or ethical lines. I don't currently see any line-crossing, but I guess it's good to have the discussion.

The problem with this "Twitter Files" reporting is that it's not making the situation any clearer. If anything it feels like these journalists are being used to do PR work for Twitter's new owner in order to promote the idea that Something Really Bad Happened Here, but this advocacy makes it much harder to see the real picture.