News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by neilv on Saturday December 24, 2022 @08:34PM (#34123152)
Greenspun started an early Web business, before some of today's founders were born. :)

The best personal finance advice I know of comes from the Bogleheads community (basically, total-market index investing with low expense ratios and allocated for risk tolerance and tax efficiency, and misc. forum advice like recognizing your salary probably has bigger impact than any investing details): https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Main_Page

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by paulpauper on Saturday December 24, 2022 @09:05PM (#34123345)
The sorta defeatist attitude in this essay contradicts his own life story. If being wealthy requires so many family connections or luck, how did he do it then? I think there are still plenty of opportunities for smart, hard-working people to get ahead in society without favoritism.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by wmf on Saturday December 24, 2022 @09:20PM (#34123441)
PhilG became incredibly cynical at some point and I stopped reading him. I'm not even sure where his money came from after the VCs "stole" ArsDigita.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by rst on Saturday December 24, 2022 @09:50PM (#34123651)
The VCs wound up paying him, reportedly, over $7 million for his shares. https://www.bizjournals.com/boston/blog/mass-high-tech/2002/...
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by neilv on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:10PM (#34123794)
That article:

> gave Ferraris to employees who recruited 10 programmers,

I might be misremembering from when that was first promoted, but I though it was a year's use of a Ferrari (a Spider or similar).

> Greenspun defends those expenditures as inexpensive ways to retain and attract talent. He also writes that it created the impression of a wildly successful company.

At the time, it seemed a little indulgent. Like all the fresh startups that would buy Aeron chairs for everyone, and have expensive launch parties.

But in hindsight... How else were you going to get MIT grads to feel like they were in on the dotcom boom, when they were working as TCL programmers in gloomy Cambridge? (Rather than move to the sunny SF Bay Area, where most of the action seemed to be happening, and where most of their friends were moving.)

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by rst on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:25PM (#34123887)
I recall more like a month. There was only one Ferrari, mostly parked in the company lot.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by neilv on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:40PM (#34123989)
Yeah, and a month sounds more likely than a year. In any case, the article seemed to overstate it, and overall was kinda harsh.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by wmf on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:30AM (#34124592)
Ironically if he never took VC and remained in charge he may have ridden the company all the way down to zero during the dotcom crash, leaving him with little or nothing.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by 082349872349872 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:26AM (#34124937)
I believe the cynicism starts when one scores the big pile of the ready, and slowly realises that very few of one's new peers have arrived there on the startup path, but in general have preferred marriage and inheritance instead. (theft, thankfully, not being so common in Cambridge circles)

(OTOH, "homies on lock / for insider trading" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JaXZI81gRvk

fwiw my spouse doesn't interpret this ad as parody: "for once you send me a video with normal people in it")

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by roflyear on Saturday December 24, 2022 @09:28PM (#34123494)
Chances are different than opportunities.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:10PM (#34123798)
One simply does not get rich by diversifying and I wish more people understood this. This Bogleheads stuff is just weeeeirdest things ever… It teaches you to be a slave, work hard for “the man” and put money in “index funds” and when your health is poor and corporate America has drained every ounce of life out of you if you can live of 4% of money you have been putting away for the last 85 years you might be able to retire in Panama… Just amazing stuff that Americans have bought in!
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by hklgny on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:21PM (#34123859)
I’ve been following the bogleheads philosophy since I graduated college. I’ve done it while working normal jobs, pursuing startups, side projects, sabbaticals abroad and everything in between. I’ve had some luck with startups, but the majority of my savings has come from monthly contributions.

I’m now at a point where my investments in index funds kick off nearly enough to cover my expenses. It’s an incredible thing that I’m super proud of.

Your take here is reckless and I hope nobody takes it seriously. I’m not advocating for putting your life on hold to work a 9-5 just to save - but if you’re not sticking some cash into safe investment vehicles as you go then you’re just playing on hard mode.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:35PM (#34123955)
“safe investment vehicles” might be the funniest thing I have read in a loooong time…
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by hklgny on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:38PM (#34123973)
You do you, man. But you haven’t replied to anyone asking your thoughts on alternatives and if total market index funds hit the ground we’ve got bigger fish to fry.

I just hope nobody takes you seriously.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:48PM (#34124042)
just know that everyone who has ever taught you about “safe investment vehicles” and “diversifying” and all that jazz does not invest in said “safe investment vehicles” nor is diversified. then think hard about why that is…
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by mangosteenjuice on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:29AM (#34124587)
What do they invest in?
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bittercynic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:49AM (#34124713)
Is this disagreement really about different meanings of 'safe'?

I think most people would agree that we're in a bit of a weird time financially. It seems possible to me that total market index funds might go sideways for a while, and that we might, in fact, have bigger fish to fry as well.

On the other hand, if you've paid down your debts, and emergency fund is in good shape, and you still have extra cash, is there a better bet than a total market index fund?

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:11AM (#34124863)
yes, Apple. Will outperform any index fund over the next decade just like it did the previous decade but hedge it a bit with few other companies
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by germinalphrase on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:16PM (#34123838)
What’s your approach?
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by xupybd on Saturday December 24, 2022 @10:18PM (#34123849)
What's the alternative?
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:22PM (#34124226)
how about something as simple as following what greatest investor that ever lived Warren Buffet does? Pick a few companies, do a finacial colonoscopy on them, learn their business inside out and then go all in. over 50% of his investments are in two companies (me too, just not same as his), over 75% in 6 companies…

no one gets rich by diversfying, it is just a fairy tale US workers are being fed once they start working with company-sponsored 401k’s and the like

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bmitc on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:33PM (#34124295)
Warren Buffet was born wealthy and to a connected congressman who helped him get started on his adversarial takeovers.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:42PM (#34124332)
how he got wealthy is not relevant to how the wealth is grown. if you have $1,000/month to invest or your mum/dad gave you $1,000,000/month the principle of growing wealth is the same. and it is not diversifying nor is buying index funds
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bmitc on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:47PM (#34124371)
So you're saying starting off with money, help overtaking profitable companies, and investing over the easiest window in history to make money is irrelevant to the claim of someone being the greatest investor that ever lived?

And if you go by your principle argument, several others are far greater than Buffet, such as James Simons, who's strategy is diametrically opposed to Buffet's.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by twelve40 on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:53PM (#34124399)
well we're back to this infinite circle of crap at this point. Aside from random people, there are thousands of people whose entire career, well-being and life depends on portfolio performance, and close to 90% of them underperform a random portfolio. Why can't they just "copy Warren Buffett"? maybe it simply hasn't occurred to them yet?
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:22AM (#34124547)
name one rich person who is “diversified”?! take top 1000 richest people on the planet and find one that got there buying index funds… I’ll wait
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by twelve40 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:27AM (#34124576)
they are an equivalent of Michael Phelps. I like to swim, but I probably in all honesty could not really keep up with him. In fact, I would probably just die if I did.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:42AM (#34124665)
this isn’t a competition though? you can learn to swim too…
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by rgifford on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:05AM (#34125090)
This is hilarious. You're wrong for like every reason, but I'll give you 3:

1. Berkshire has not significantly outperformed the S&P500 for 20 years. Go take a look, they've basically converged. Markets become more competitive over time. People lose their edge.

2. Investment returns in excess of diversified market returns (which represent underlying growth across the entire economy) ARE zero sum. If you get them, Berkshire does not and quant firms do not and hedge funds do not. If you can beat these guys, don't use your money. Go get a job doing this.

3. Watching Michael Phelps swim is a terrible way to learn to swim. Anatomically he's totally aberrant, but he's also optimizing for fractions of a second racing across an indoor olympic pool. That's all inapplicable to basically everyone swimming anywhere.

You're choosing not to hear what folks are saying and I wish you luck. Your hubris will be rewarded justly by markets, but perhaps only after a few confidence building wins that convince you random jitters of a trend line are really signs of your hidden brilliance yet to be recognized.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by ricardobayes on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:18AM (#34125362)
Yes, it's better to take advise from someone who's doing a little bit better than you.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bluecalm on Sunday December 25, 2022 @11:00AM (#34128292)
Berkshire doesn't have a chance to outperform because it's too big. It can do a little bit better (either in EV or in some risk adjusted EV measure) but it's able to capitalize on opportunities smaller traders have.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by rgifford on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:08AM (#34124835)
I have a buddy that's a wealth advisor with a high net worth (100M+) wealth management firm. Wealth preservation -- and really diversification -- is all ultra-high net worth folks care about. They buy lots of index funds.

I'm not sure if this is some prosperity gospel silly-ness, but I think folks reading this deserve a disclaimer: Buffett's college mentor was Benjamin Graham -- the father of value investing, Gates mom was friends with Buffett and set up Bill's first contract with IBM, Zuckerburg's parents offered each of their children the opportunity to go to Harvard or open a McDonald's franchise. Six of the top 1000 richest people have the last name Walton. Failure -- as most of the world know's it -- never exists for most folks in the Forbes list. They were always going to be very very comfortable.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:28AM (#34124944)
$100M is not ultra high net worth. and also absolutely no one here is talking about “wealth preservation.” what I was saying is that none of even those “ultra high” earners made their money diversifying.

once you are super rich surely you’ll set some money aside to make sure you stick around in high society. but no one - not a single soul has ever gotten rich that way.

I have no idea what your 2nd paragraph is for…?

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by rippercushions on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:14AM (#34125120)
UHNW is $30 million or higher, so yes, $100M is very much in that bracket
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by trentgreene on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:24AM (#34124924)
Warren Buffet is pretty diversified, owning stakes across many different sectors. He’s also advocated investing in index funds with the old ‘time in market’ line
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by xupybd on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:31AM (#34125193)
The top 1000 richest people are probably not good examples for the rest of us. They're extreme outliers. Much like professional athletes few make it to the top 1000. The average Joe is not going to make it.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by imtringued on Sunday December 25, 2022 @04:20AM (#34125610)
There will only ever be thousand people in the top 1000 richest people. There is no guide that can help you become one, you will have to displace one of them to get that title and you cannot displace them by copying them by the way so the argument that the advice doesn't match their behaviour is kind of useless because you want unique circumstances that nobody else had before you.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by robjan on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:54PM (#34124407)
So in other words, gambling. Some will win, many will lose.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:20AM (#34124530)
and investing in “index funds” is not gambling?! :) if you buy index funds do you even know what you bought? or is it just “hey everyone else is doing imma do it too?”
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by robjan on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:45AM (#34124689)
Most index funds are quite transparent about their constituent assets. The purpose of index investing is to capture the market as a whole which includes assets held by the few people who make their millions / billions and the many others who blow up their accounts going all in in single stocks.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:02AM (#34124793)
no pressure, no diamonds!

jokes aside surely there are plenty of people who gambled and lost their entire accounts on 1 or 2 stocks. but there is a difference in buying biotech startup out of Springfield MO and buying Apple

my basic argument isn’t that you should blow your savings on some single stock of some rando company but that doing something like 45% Apple, 20% Amazon, and spred another 20% among 2-3 companies in energy etc… is much better option than buying index fund. and over last decade would have 100x your money over VTSAX… and is just as “safe”

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by RussianCow on Sunday December 25, 2022 @03:36AM (#34125431)
But there is zero reason to believe that any of those companies will continue giving the same returns. It's entirely feasible that they will plateau, or even begin to fall, whereas the rest of the market will continue to climb. There are plenty of historical examples of "solid" investments that evaporated over time, so it's not like this is unprecedented.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by lottin on Sunday December 25, 2022 @05:04AM (#34125831)
No, it isn't "just as safe", by any stretch of the imagination. "Safety", in the context of investing, refers to the distribution of possible outcomes around the expected return of an investment. In most instances, diversification will reduce the standard deviation of the expected return of a portfolio, without sacrificing the expected return. In other words, a diversified portfolio is safer, all else equal. This has been known for at least 70 years. You're not providing any counterpoints to established investment theory. You're simply making false claims that contradict both the theory and the empirical evidence.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by xupybd on Sunday December 25, 2022 @02:33AM (#34125202)
Index funds are much lower risk. I would not call them gambling.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by xupybd on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:32AM (#34124608)
What do you consider rich?

I'd like to retire like the people in this study https://www.ramseysolutions.com/retirement/the-national-stud...

If you want to be Warren Buffet rich you're playing a different game than me.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @12:48AM (#34124711)
I don’t want (and even if I did chances are I never would be) Buffet-rich. But that doesn’t mean I cannot be smart with money I set aside for investment. These studies offer one way of looking at things, they are based on “work looong time, put money for retirement into something you can’t pick (in most company plans or have limited options), pay high fees for… and be happy you are “millionaire” when you are with one foot in grave…”

no thanks, not for me

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bittercynic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:00AM (#34124782)
I might be misunderstanding the context here, but are you starting from the assumption that investors are trying to get rich?

I think many investors are trying to preserve what wealth they've accumulated through saving/inheritance, and are very happy with modest returns, or even just preserving what they have.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:13AM (#34124872)
buying a house is much better way to “preserve what you have” than buying securities.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by sifar on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:42PM (#34124335)
It doesn't make you poor or bankrupt either. That is what people are aiming for primarily.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by wmf on Saturday December 24, 2022 @11:43PM (#34124337)
One simply does not get rich by diversifying...

This is right but your implication is wrong. You get rich from working and index funds are a way to preserve and modestly increase that wealth. Boglehead thinking probably won't help people making minimum wage or whatever because if you invest almost nothing to begin with you'll get fairly little out. It also won't make you super-rich if that's what you want.

when your health is poor and corporate America has drained every ounce of life out of you

This sounds completely wrong. Working a salaried job in tech is one of the least stressful, lowest risk, and highest paying ways to earn money. It's easy mode (if you can get in the door). Hustling leveraged real estate or some other kind of "passive income" is much harder and riskier.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by bdangubic on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:08AM (#34124834)
you cannot be serious?? have you ever met a healthy “salaried tech worker”?! I know a few but percentage-wise I’d say 98.48% are about as healthy as my 76-year old Mum. This has to be a joke, right?
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by holoduke on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:34AM (#34124970)
I worked at a obline gambling/games company for 5 years. I think half of the people started a company while working there. Nobody worked 40 hours. Maybe 10,20 or so. Company was basically a automatic train with everybody having a party on it.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by saiya-jin on Sunday December 25, 2022 @07:01AM (#34126482)
I got much healthier with my last job as salaried tech worker. 4x a week gym or running outside during lunch breaks, frequent early finish and off rock climbing. Once I started going to gym, all those colleagues obsessed with the projected image of professionalism said fuck it, and they started doing similar things. Now half of IT does something active during lunch breaks, finishing at same time but much happier and filled. It took just one guy who had the balls to not give a fuck that much. Just to clarify this is banking world and working on/next to core package of our bank, not some laid back low paid government job or similar.

If you dont like your current dev work, negotiate or move, its stupidly easy compared to any other engineering or sciences, anywhere in the world.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by wahnfrieden on Sunday December 25, 2022 @06:39AM (#34126345)
Working doesn’t make anyone rich (though the dream is alive with many)
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by c22 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:15PM (#34129599)
Some professions can make you rich but real wealth takes generations to build, or some sketchy ethics...
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by jmathai on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:17AM (#34124890)
I didn’t read the article.

If you want to become wealthy without learning a ton about finances then read the total money makeover by Dave Ramsey or spend a few months listening to his podcast (go back a couple years before some of the new personalities who will be replacing him have started to come on).

Then, if you get curious enough to learn more advanced topics (don’t look to Dave for these) then head over to boggleheads.

The path to wealth is boring consistency. But it’s a much shorter path than most people think with the right discipline.

Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by cman1444 on Sunday December 25, 2022 @10:49AM (#34128192)
I really don't think Dave Ramsey is a good source of information for very many people. The debt snowball method is the best example of this. There's no reason anyone should be employing that strategy unless they just need the mental satisfaction of paying off "a debt" to get on the right headspace to pay off the rest.
Re:Money, Money, Money (and Investing) (2015) by jmathai on Sunday December 25, 2022 @01:26PM (#34129685)
That’s a common counter argument. But if you listen enough then you understand that he (correctly) identifies that personal finance is more psychology than math. And the aggressive debt repayment he advocates makes the accrued interest trivial.

People who follow his plan pay tens of thousands of dollars in debt off in 1-2 years on modest incomes.