Women get left behind by biological realities. Pretending this is just some form of social tyranny is clearly nonsense.
> you're acting as if a woman's value is decreased once she can't have children anymore. That sounds a lot like social tyranny to me.
A woman’s value as a partner would be decreased for anybody who wanted to have children, or who at least wanted the option of having children. The idea that if you want a partner, you’re going to have to attract one, is not a tyranny. There are some people who think that this is tyrannical, for instance the incel community, but they are clearly wrong.
Again, please explain why this is any concern of yours. If you want to seek out and help woman who voluntarily want help finding a partner and having children, get at it. Otherwise, supporting a system that coerces or forces young people into decisions against their will is a form of tyranny.
It takes a mountain of propaganda to convince women against their natural, healthy urge to have a family. I don't think it should be taken for granted that that's a positive endeavour, for her or her community.
Biological impetuses aside - what is a nation ? And why should any individual care about it more than one self
My countries will continue to exist whether I have kids or not
Unlike country, your nation faces extinction without children and family.
I'm sorry you succumbed to this but I don't believe it's ever too late to do some good in the world.
Regardless of the definition, the reason most people _should_ care about their nation is because their welfare depends on it to some extent. Most people wouldn’t be able to adequately care for themselves and their dependents without the entitlements and infrastructure that the nation administers.
There are some people who don’t have to care about which nations succeed and which fail, because they are either rich enough or skilled enough benefit from the institutions of any nation they choose (probably a reasonable amount of HN readers are in this category). But these people are an elite minority in this respect.
Almost certainly is. I wouldn’t be surprised if “most women I know” are women who work for corporations.
In what universe is this any of your concern? Not this one.
And of course it's tyrannical. People with little or no power (children, very young adults) are being forced, coerced, threatened by the power structures in their lives to make decisions they don't want to make. This is nearly a textbook definition of tyranny.
In what universe is this sentiment any of your concern? I presume you imagine this one?
I’m simply pointing out your mistake, which is that this is not simply some sentiment that can be modified with the appropriate social conditioning. It is the ordinary human reaction to undeniable biological realities. Nowhere in my comment did I suggest that this was an appropriate basis for actual tyrannical behaviour, so please don’t try to gaslight me into defending such a position, because it won’t work. As I have said elsewhere, even in the most progressive countries in the world, this is still a ubiquitous concern.
Here is a novel idea that apparently never occurred to you, let's allow each ordinary human to have their own reaction.
The subsequent choices made by a lot of Western women are far from ordinary.
You might argue that correlation is not causation, I would assume without even bothering to look up statistics that childless women in the West are the biggest consumers of anti-depressants in the world.
I don’t buy that “humanity” and “autonomy” belong together in that sentence. I’m pretty sure that having kids by roughly 25 is how the human species has evolved to function. The biology and math being what it is, no long-term sustainable society can have the numbers depart too far from that. The what you call “progressive” societies where that number has creeped up toward and past 30 are almost uniformly on a path of unsustainability, and are being propped up by immigration from non-“progressive” societies. Thus, “autonomy” in this context, whether you think it’s a good thing or bad thing, comes at the expense of “humanity.”
(It goes without saying that the extreme measures adopted in Kyrgyzstan are unnecessary. But any long-term sustainable society probably has moms and aunties clucking at you, like mine did, to get married once you hit 25.)
More seriously though, I don’t think it will be so bad. Evolution works. Blood lines of the autonomous people will perish, and the breeders will inherit the earth. For me, I’m doing my part.
Me too. My mom started talking about arranged marriage before I brought my now wife home at 26.
The modern Western idea appears to be to treat life like an infinitely reconfigurable video game tuned to every individual. That will soon become a luxury for only the richest people. The rest of us need to get by as best we can, and that may mean young women and men will have to take what they can get and make themselves happy with it.
My wife dreams of winning the lottery and transforming our lives. Meanwhile we are genuinely content in our relatively hardscrabble existence… only because there is no alternative to it.
BTW I kidnapped my first wife (well she ran away from home to live with me, so her parents thought of it as kidnapping). She was 18, I was 17. But I had my own apartment, so… My second wife kinda sorta kidnapped me. Or at least she stalked me for a year before revealing herself and unleashing her plan to marry me. My son’s wife of eight years came for a visit from Canada and never returned home (for immigration reasons they were forced to get married sooner than they wanted to, so I guess America kidnapped her?).
"if you’re unwed at 25, you’re thought to be on the verge of spinsterhood, pretty much the worst failure imaginable"
This sentiment seems to be near-universal in all but the most "progressive" societies (and even in some parts of those). And it results in all manner of grotesque and absurd behavior that robs people - mostly women but also men - of their humanity and autonomy.
I applaud every young person with the courage to buck this trend in their own societies. The cost of doing so is often very high, but the pattern can only be broken by people brave enough to face those consequences and help craft a less restrictive world for the next generation.