Re:In Kyrgyzstan it’s common to kidnap your future wife
by xyzzyz on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @02:34AM
(#34077722)
No, you don’t understand, it’s completely normal and healthy for a society to shrink by close to half generation-to-generation. Sure, after 10 generations of this kind of decline, the population figure shrinks to only 0.1% of the former figure, and no longer sustains culture or even economy to keep all this autonomy practical (as healthy and productive economy is crucial to any degree of autonomy, the concept of autonomy and freedom from unchosen bonds is completely foreign to poor people in places like the Bangladesh you are from, due to simple economic reality), but think about all the autonomy the generation that inherited the civilization right at its peak, before it entered terminal decline (i.e. us) have enjoyed!
More seriously though, I don’t think it will be so bad. Evolution works. Blood lines of the autonomous people will perish, and the breeders will inherit the earth. For me, I’m doing my part.
I don’t buy that “humanity” and “autonomy” belong together in that sentence. I’m pretty sure that having kids by roughly 25 is how the human species has evolved to function. The biology and math being what it is, no long-term sustainable society can have the numbers depart too far from that. The what you call “progressive” societies where that number has creeped up toward and past 30 are almost uniformly on a path of unsustainability, and are being propped up by immigration from non-“progressive” societies. Thus, “autonomy” in this context, whether you think it’s a good thing or bad thing, comes at the expense of “humanity.”
(It goes without saying that the extreme measures adopted in Kyrgyzstan are unnecessary. But any long-term sustainable society probably has moms and aunties clucking at you, like mine did, to get married once you hit 25.)