> It's sad that the only reason this case was prosecuted is because the founders were stupid enough to admit to fraud in writing.
A prosecutor worth their salt will never have one damning piece of evidence. They got a warrant to get access to their suspects emails and electronic files based on other evidence sent to a judge.
Incriminating files and emails don't necessarily exist when smart people who see each other in person all the time do crime.
We can't even say that its price crashed, because there was never a market for it. It's closer to Madoff's securities than it is to, say, Terra.
I'm all for hating on cryptocurrencies, but this doesn't even qualify as one.
Wait so crypto is only worthless if you prescribe it worthlessness in writing first?
There wasn’t any cryptocurrency in OneCoin. They didn’t even literally have any cryptocurrency. It was all completely 100% MLM.
That’s different from, say, BitConnect, that was a MLM with some sort of cryptocurrency. Or of course all the “DeFi” that’s MLM but with more steps.
But yeah OneCoin had literally nothing to do with any cryptocurrency. They said they are planning one one day.
A good definition for "real" cryptocurrency is whether or not it's possible for it to be banned.
Yes? I am assuming you are either not very technical, or do not know a lot about how cryptocurrencies work.
Disclaimer: I am not a proponent of cryptocurrency, I don't own any cryptocurrency, and I am only arguing the technical issue.
If you're talking about banning the hardware, it's probably possible to essentially stop the production and sale of ASIC miners since they have no other purpose, but that's only one type of hardware. People would still be able to use regular CPUs and GPUs to mine.
If you're talking about completely banning the participation in a blockchain, this would be impossible to detect as long as the traffic is encrypted -- if you constantly look for IP addresses and keep a blocklist up to date, you could essentially null-route them (breaking DNS is not enough).
If you do all of the above, which is a lot of work and already completely untenable to sort out on an international level, you still haven't solved the issue of darknets, like Tor or any similar solution.
Take the Silk Road for example, probably one of the most famous darkweb marketplaces for illicit drugs ever. We can only guess how much money and time the FBI spent building a case, and even when they managed to find him by bending every opsec weakness they could find, they still had to ambush him in a library and catch him with his laptop unlocked.
My point here is that nobody claims darknets will protect you completely, but it raises the bar immensely for the amount of necessary work to catch you. If blockchains (currencies) were made illegal globally, it's a pretty safe bet this would accelerate technology for doing the exact same things as before, just in an anonymized fashion.
Then what? Do you illegalize writing code that facilitates cryptocurrency? Illegalize darknets?
Just saying "make it illegal" is naive. It chooses to ignore the massive violations of our rights that would have to be made to not even succeed, but create the appearance of succeeding.
If you have a concrete proposal on how it would be technically possible to ban miners and exchanges, without also banning encryption and anonymity online, I'm listening.
You are effectively saying Free and Open Source Software should be banned. If that's you're feeling, I can't imagine why you are on HN.
I'm not allowed to create software, and incentivize many different people to dedicate resources to operate that software creating a decentralized network?
EDIT: Downvoted within 3 min. Disallowing downvotes for everyone means HN allows older more active accounts to dominate these discussions. They push out reasonable replies that happen to not be anti-crypto. It disincentivizes further discussion because I just keep losing more and more precious internet points that dictate my value to HN as a commentator.
Wild people think mathematics, cryptography, OSS, and free markets should be banned. No one is forcing anyone to buy/sell/hold crypto. It is completely voluntary.
Nobody is proposing banning blockchains. Cryptocurrency, however, is clearly more than just software in the way missile-targeting system is more than ones and zeroes.
The block reward is the incentive for miners/stakers to operate a decentralized network. It is not a separate concept. The actual value of each reward is emergent. It is the result of resources being used to operate the network, and how we value that network. If we don't value the network enough, the value of the block reward will drop below the resources required to maintain it. I don't see why any external party should dictate how we may value that block reward or network.
> the way missile-targeting system is more than ones and zeroes.
This is an irrelevant comparison attempting to moralize software by comparing it to a weapon.
The moment that reward becomes a currency, and is traded for U.S. dollars, it leaves the domain of just being software. Banning that is quite different from banning the software per se.
> an irrelevant comparison attempting to moralize software by comparing it to a weapon
Comparing Bitcoin to free software seems similarly disingenuous.
>Comparing Bitcoin to free software seems similarly disingenuous.
Bitcoin is free software. https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin
Furthermore, giving someone US dollars for something doesn't make that thing a "currency."
> Comparing Bitcoin to free software seems similarly disingenuous.
Bitcoin is literally FOSS.
Some guy in Nigeria I don't know starts swapping it for Zimbabwe dollars. Now I'm not writing software anymore?
Downvotes and upvotes on HN should reflect the quality of the comment and not agreement/disagreement.
I don't believe that it is. Certainly not to the point where it would be worthy of depromoting. It was a worthy discussion point. It could have easily just been left alone. My edit was highlighting that it was the typical outcome.
> Downvotes and upvotes on HN should reflect the quality of the comment and not agreement/disagreement.
Keyword: "Should"
You must know that it's often not how it works out. I frequently see thoughtful or otherwise harmless comments downvoted. Yet, rude and vapid, anti-crypto comments remain or are boosted. Downvotes are especially common when it's a reply to an older account with lots of internet points. They rule these threads.
EDIT: I'm not able to reply again because I am disallowed from posting too many times within an unspecified time. Probably also a consequence of not having enough internet points. I've already lost 5 of my precious points so faR!
As the other comment points out, a founder of the site thinks differently than you.
I obviously disagree with you. As PG suggests, I should downvote you to make sure that nobody else has the chance to agree with you. But then HN doesn't allow me to disagree with you, so your comment will remain.
My downvoted comments will also be grayed out to warn others of HN disagreements like a colorful snake that warns against danger. Stay back!
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34068318
> The advancements in AI are as incredible as they are overstated. AI is nowhere near making human coders obsolete.
Already grayed out. No replies. Bottom of all comments at the moment.
Abrassive? Rude? Unwarranted? Let me know what was wrong with that one. Or did multiple people disagree with you? Does it make you want to continue offering your comment on a topic? Seems like people can downvote for any reason they like. Well.. they can if HN bestows that honor on them.
This is how echo chambers form.
Surely you disagree with this comment as well, so feel free to take away more of my internet points.
I will, however, stop responding to you because your comments are not constructive.
If people upvote/downvote for agree/disagree the comments and stories become a tedious hivemind.
I also stand by my original comment, people are mostly downvoting him because he is engaging in very silly hyperbole.
A) please point where in my post I even came close to suggesting bitcoin should be banned.
B) even if I had said bitcoin should be banned, did I suggest anywhere that distribution of the software be banned?
For example, let’s accept the extremely problematic premise that I somehow said bitcoin should be banned. What that could mean is that I think the US (and other governments) should regulate any marketplaces that are currency on and off ramps for customers. Stable coins claiming to be backed by US dollars can be banned outright (easy) or that you have to register and the US government establishes an audit process to verify the claimed reserves / the software you’re using to control the stable coins (eg Tether is a highly suspect stable coin that’s likely another huge fraud). The US controls a lot of the world’s banking (not all) but they can also say that those banks aren’t allowed to support such systems and it’s citizens aren’t allowed to engage with unregulated stable coins. Correct me if I’m wrong but that’s an example of something the US could do to regulate / ban the coins without touching the software. That also doesn’t touch distribution of FOSS but places a significantly regulatory burden on the networks themselves. Additionally, by placing sanctions on these coins, the US currency is so ingrained they could theoretically ban coins from most of the western world. Finally, if they wanted to (and there may be national security reasons to not do it), they could also deploy meaningful compute resources to do a nation level attack to further undermine such networks by raising the transaction costs too high or doing 51% attacks (there’s no evidence that these networks are immune to 51% attacks from a nation state like the US). I think you’re really underestimating the power the US could wield to take down the running network (production instance) vs needing to ban the source code (much harder and not worth anyone’s time since I imagine the government learned their lesson with the war in the 90s about cryptography + the free speech implications it has).
So, in summary. You put words in my mouth I never said and then used that to draw the most absurd and weakest possible position from there. That’s the reason for the downvotes. My suggestion is figure out what got in your way of reflecting and figuring out what was wrong with your post (eg maybe in the future before reread the post you’re replying to to make sure they actually said what you think they said and if it’s ambiguous asking questions rather than making an assumption).
Your second edit makes it clear you failed to do that because you kept claiming that any down voters were supporting a position no one claimed around banning distribution of the bitcoin source code (or even binaries) and demanding that they provide support for an absurd position that was only voiced by you in the first place.
I never replied to you.
> please point where in my post I even came close to suggesting bitcoin should be banned.
please point to where in my post I even came close to suggesting Bitcoin should be NOT be banned? Re-read my comment.
I'm not reading any more of your totally un-hinged reply. Get help.
Any system that uses decentralized verification to wrap trading deals is DeFi.
The core quality of a MLM is that early adopters benefit more, which is totally unrelated.
Monero/XMR kind-of-sort-of falls into the second category, with "fresh" coin minting being a part of the mining process, although probably not at a rate that outpaces regular rot/deflation.
the mindset of securities trade, even when they have some external utility, will always be "getting in before it gets big". this is the idea behind essentially all analytical stock trading, yet the NYSE never seems to get called a ponzi scheme.
https://coingeek.com/sam-bankman-fried-reveals-how-defi-work...
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/02/your-money/stock-market-a...
The common case these days is to keep a company private for as long as possible, relying on private investment to grow huge. Only once you've maxed out rapid growth do you go public. Rather than going public being something you do to raise capital and keep growing, it's primarily something you do cash out and dump your shares on the plebs who are left holding the bag on a stalled out or even potentially a dying company. As in the off hour trading, insiders and rich people capture most of the gains.
This is why actively trading to try to beat the market as a part time hustle is purely a suckers game. The game is entirely rigged against retail traders.
Regulation protects retail from making money as much as it protects retail from loosing money.
That's a bizarre claim. If I buy and hold for weeks/months/years, no alpha was sucked from me.
If I day-trade, well, I get what I deserve if I have no edge or don't understand how the market works.
And extended hours trading has minimal liquidity, just because AAPL jumped 10% in after hours doesn't mean someone made billions entering/exiting during this interval, because it's just the market makers repricing minimal volumes.
“Simply holding shares while you sleep will do it. So for buy-and-hold investors, these findings are particularly encouraging: Get your rest, ignore the temptation to trade and you can do just fine.”
Its worse than that, they didn't issue a cryptocurrency at all. They didn't deliver the product they said they were giving people, thats the reason this is fraud.
All they had to do was create any token on any blockchain - including a new one - and didn't.
Our entire society is running on scams where nobody writes anything down, and any inadvertent records are destroyed through very short retention policies. I worked at an agency whose primary reason for revising a data retention policy was to keep things hidden that FOIA requests threatened to reveal. While that goal was mentioned constantly, it was never put in email or any meeting minutes.
But alas, the mainstream is busy buying into Bitconnect, Onecoin, Potcoin, PonziCoin (yes, that was a real coin and people lost money when the operator - you won't believe this now - exit scammed them and ran off with the money). And trades them on FTX.
How do you solve this problem? Checks and balances and strong institutions that actively work to remove moral hazards from society AND themselves. Sure, if you weaken institutions and then claim they’re ineffective, you’re just creating self-fulfilling prophecies. In a well-designed system, you don’t need to audit the auditors. Make sure that the auditors are secret and that randomly chosen (ie there’s no incentive to collude with the entity being audited). Provide strong incentives (training, compensatory, social, rewards) and protection (ie people with power going after them / their reputation) for both rooting out corruption/scams and that when they say a business isn’t a scam then it’s most likely not (eg clawbacks on money, prestige, recognition, etc).
Additionally, the FBI, IRS and other state and federal law enforcement agencies should be proactively auditing the largest businesses OR outsourcing to very trusted auditors (ie ones for whom the cancellation of the contract would be a death sentence which is easy to enforce by requiring that 100% of revenue for the outsourced agency comes from the federal government and there’s N such agencies that all split the pie so that if one fails and gets corrupt the others take over (the FBI is authorized to have wiretaps and secretly monitor the auditors to ensure there’s no kind of collusion communication happening between auditing agencies (ie we allow leadership in these trusted position to require that you give up more of your rights to be in it and we publish job-relevant details from ~5 years ago without any FOIA battles allowed - only personal details can be omitted and only on-the job details are revealed so no marital secrets). Additionally, anyone caught leaking or losing these records before they are released to the public is punished by getting fired and criminal charges being mandatory. If an audit of the FBI reveals the director is asleep / didn’t properly establish best practices to keep the data in control, the president fires them.
Anyway these are all obvious wildly radical ideas and not necessarily possible to implement due to various laws / there may be flaws in the specific details. My overall point still stands. It’s fraud because we let it exist, not because it’s impossible due to human nature / the way society works.
It was in reply to the above comment saying our entire society is run on scams, which is true. We can start cleaning it up from the top, which is the smart way to go about it instead of tilting at legal windmills. In the current system, you're more likely to get caught and punished as a petty criminal than someone who siphons off millions. Yes, some fraud will always be possible in free societies but it doesn't have to be the way it currently works. More transparency and better record keeping are a positive thing. Even if we take your example of someone inputting wrong data, they're more likely to be found than if there is no data at all and thus nothing to scrutinize. People who falsify data make mistakes just like anyone does.
It's precisely because crypto is worthless that where ever crypto is, there is only scams.
People point to FTX and say "see it's not crypto that's the cause, it's classic corruption!" but that misses the point critics of crypto are making.
Because crypto has no real practical value, its only function is as a tool for traditional scams and corruption.
Critics of crypto generally don't believe that crypto itself is a tool that creates fraud, but because it is a useless tool, when you see it being "used" what you must be seeing is fraud.
We've seen this borne out over and over again.
I think it is more likely that she bought a new look and identity as a rich widow and is living the life.
However, on a different level... how is this really any different from all the cryptocurrencies that are also only co-opting the language of cryptocurrencies to push a scam, but that go the extra mile to make the grift realistic by creating a cryptocurrency in the process?
Think of, for example, Helium, which goes as far as to have a realistic-sounding business model behind it (it certainly fooled me) but in practice is just funnelling money from investors into their pump-and-dump shitcoin, and from miners into their expensive certified devices that they take a cut from.
Is Helium any less of a scam, or did they just put more effort into their scam?
People who think that all crypto is worthless may be confused by this. The actual reason was far more silly. They blatantly admitted to the scam in writing making it an open and shut case:
> OneCoin was a multi-level marketing (MLM) pyramid scheme
> As Ignatova allegedly put it in an email to Greenwood, "We are not mining actually – but telling people shit."
> OneCoin's value, according to the Feds, was simply set by those managing the company – they manipulated the OneCoin exchange to simulate trading volatility but the price of OneCoin always closed higher than it opened.
> Ignatova allegedly told Greenwood that one of the goals for the OneCoin trade exchange was "always close on a high price end of day open day with high price, build confidence – better manipulation so they are happy
> Email correspondence between Greenwood and Ignatova, as cited by the Justice Department, describes how the defendants referred to OneCoin privately as "trashy coin." And in an August 9, 2014 email exchange with Greenwood, Ignatova's first option on a list of possible exit strategies is said to have been, "Take the money and run and blame someone else for this…"
It's sad that the only reason this case was prosecuted is because the founders were stupid enough to admit to fraud in writing. How many blatant scams are out there where the founders are using purely euphemistic language & making sure to have short data retention periods (~1 yr is standard in businesses).