News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by ekianjo on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:11AM (#34065370)
"some bucks" are defined by how much people are willing to pay for goods. salaries dont occur in a vaccuum.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by 2000UltraDeluxe on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:37AM (#34065667)
If demand is so low that under-paid staff is needed to keep things afloat, is the business even worth the effort from a societal view-point? Or even as a business case?

Only if the demand for underpaid jobs is large enough, I assume.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by buggythebug on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:41AM (#34065719)
Eh from a superficial view no, but there will be a cascade event. The after effects are more complex

For example, many small businesses that are not "big mean corporations" that run on already small margins either jack up their prices enough to afford paying more. The customer then gets screwed with much higher prices.

OR all these mom and pop places go under because they still can't find labor, then more people are out of work - where do they then get jobs?

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by AdrianB1 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:48AM (#34065791)
Mom and pop places are supposed to be run by mom and pop, with no other labor, so they should not be affected too much.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by buggythebug on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:31AM (#34092661)
That's not the definition of a "mom and pop" place. lol
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by 2000UltraDeluxe on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:10AM (#34066089)
I agree that this isn't a black and white thing; and that wasn't the point I was making.

It's kinda like the tireless recruiters on LinkedIn, who keep spamming me about call center jobs. I.e. the problem in that case isn't people don't want to work; the problem is that call centres are a toxic work environment that has systematically burnt through the entire 80's generation of self-taught IT-techs only to find out they were a finite resource.

As for Mom and Pop places, it's a sad situation, but if we want to help smaller stores then the key is specialization and finding niches that can't be handled online. As with everything specialized, feasability is a matter of supply and demand, and wages shouldn't be kept down artificially just to keep them running.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by dotluis on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:27AM (#34065541)
But people pay for goods using the "some bucks" they earned as salaries.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by CraigJPerry on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:41AM (#34065712)
Which people? Unemployment is low. Immigration is restricted to skilled people.

In the aggregate, people who want a job already have better paying skilled labour options. Why take a job as a cashier for example?

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by phkahler on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:38AM (#34065681)
You guys are missing the point. If we take X percent of the workers out of the market due to retirement (and age discrimination?) there will simply not be enough people to do all the work. Paying more at any or all levels will not create more workers.

Inflation is starting to affect retirement plans, and some are coming out. But companies need to want them.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by CraigJPerry on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:42AM (#34065724)
The article claims people are not coming out of retirement and are unlikely to do so as the early retirees are comparatively well off.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by Jensson on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:52AM (#34065844)
If there isn't enough labor to pay for their retirement then inflation will eat up all their retirement until there is enough labor.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by CraigJPerry on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:19AM (#34066228)
>> enough labor to pay for their retirement

Labour doesn't pay for their retirement.

>> inflation will eat up all their retirement

Their state pension increases in line with inflation thanks to the penion "triple lock" in the UK (this is temporarily the "double lock" for 22/23).

>> until there is enough labor

Adding labour has no direct impact on pension income, there can't be "enough labour" to reinstate a standard of living in a person's pension situation

Instead what will happen is existing groups who are already below water (e.g. foodbank users) will suffer more pain.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by Jensson on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:27AM (#34066330)
> Their state pension increases in line with inflation thanks to the penion "triple lock" in the UK (this is temporarily the "double lock" for 22/23).

In that case you have a feedback loop creating infinite inflation that goes faster than those rate adjustments goes. There is no magical wand to wish away inflation like that.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by vaidhy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:06AM (#34066034)
They do not have to retire in UK either, right? You can take your nest egg and move to SE Asia?
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by wrycoder on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:24AM (#34066296)
Most people don’t have a nest egg these days.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by randomdata on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:15AM (#34066168)
You don't need more workers, though. Supply and demand. As prices rise, demand wanes, not requiring as many workers.

When labour is free the amount of work is infinite, but with a higher price some work is no longer worth doing and workers get reallocated into the jobs that are still viable.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by ilammy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:22AM (#34066259)
You heathen, how can you even suggest that the number goes down!?
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mantas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:24AM (#34065512)
If clients ain't willing to pay enough to pay salary workers are willing to work for... Maybe there's no product-market fit and/or business model just does not work?
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by BlueTemplar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:36AM (#34065653)
Yes, but these don't happen in a vacuum.

Though that they are still focusing on growth as a goal is somewhat perplexing, since this is what got us in this situation (and we are going to pay for it for the next decades, centuries, even millenia...)

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mantas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:52AM (#34065838)
Yes. Products and services would get more expensive. Overall reducing consumption in volume. Which may be negative for the „growth“ in neoliberal sense. But positive in crapload of other metrics.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by CraigJPerry on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:59AM (#34065936)
It can be more complex than that. My town has a lot of hairdresser salons. It’s hard to make the argument that there’s too many, but that would be my feeling. It’s a small town and the most popular business type on the high street is a food venue followed in 2nd place by hair salons. I’d have expected convenience stores or pubs.

However, there’s actually a lot of demand for hair styling. Maybe even enough demand to fill all those salons given how long my wife waits for an appointment.

But there’s not enough staff to satisfy all the demand. Chairs in the salons sit empty as you walk past.

So what’s happening? There’s already salons with empty chairs, there’s still excess demand and… new salons are being opened!

According to n=1 (i.e. anec-data), staff who used to work at an existing salon are opening their own. Meanwhile existing salon is proclaiming to all customers that no one wants to work. I don’t know how they square this world view with their ex staff opening their own salon.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by VLM on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:42AM (#34066526)
Owning a salon was a financially sustainable lifestyle, so you get more salons.

Working at a salon for minimum wage + tips is not a sustainable lifestyle, so you get empty chairs in those salons.

All it takes to open a salon is the ability to work there and easy credit. So you get a lot of salons.

Think of the fast food model. The owner of a McD used to make $200K+/yr, so there is intense demand to open new fast food restaurants. The employees make less than it takes to survive even with massive government program assistance, so the restaurants are empty with help wanted signs posted and early closing hours and drive-thru only. Then the prices have to go up until it takes $25 to take your daughter to burger king for lunch (true story...) so the customers all go away. Its not real food anyway. Then the owners of McDs make $0. "Everyone knows" you'll be a millionaire if you open a fast food restaurant and credit is very easy so there's an infinite line of people trying to make $200K but getting $0K. The cycle takes some time to stabilize. All those people in line have to get educated (LOL thats not happening) or go bankrupt one at a time, it takes awhile.

Service businesses always collapse from the bottom up. I've seen this in food stores, when an area has too much grocery store sq footage for its population. The collapse always starts with permanent help wanted signs and poor service, but it ends with "nobody would open a grocery store here, the just go out of business".

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by wrycoder on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:31AM (#34066385)
Unless the owners of the new shop are more skilled than average, the shop will be marginal and probably go out of business, as the debts pile up.

What about a coop shop?

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by CraigJPerry on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:44AM (#34066554)
>> Unless the owners of the new shop are more skilled than average

Why? It's the same workers cutting and styling hair. as when they worked in the existing salons. Many of their customers follow "their" hairdresser to whatever new venue they work at.

>> What about a coop shop?

There's another existing model for temporary hairdressers where they begin working at a salon and they keep all income from all clients they serve. In turn they pay the owner a fixed price to rent their chair for the day. AIUI this is no longer popular but i don't know the specifics. It seems to me that renting a chair should be a lot cheaper than starting up & marketing a salon.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by wrycoder on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:01AM (#34066777)
Relative to your first point, two shops with two chairs each have much more overhead than one shop with four chairs.

Whether or not customers follow is a complex social issue, assuming an average haircut.

But, it’s human nature to try to do better. Most small businesses fail fairly quickly.

Renting out chairs is a reasonable business model, but it’s not the same as a co-op, because the proprietor gets greedy (or is perceived to be so) and bossy.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by CraigJPerry on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @12:38PM (#34069282)
>> Relative to your first point, two shops with two chairs each have much more overhead than one shop with four chairs.

I don't think that follows - the business rates, heating costs, energy usage, insurance, etc. will all be cheaper in the 2-chair shops than the 4-chair shop. The 4-chair shop just has extra chairs (but they remain unused since there aren't staff available to fill them) . At the same price point for customers, it's less viable.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mantas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:31PM (#34071179)
Extra chairs need extra space. More space = more heating, probably more insurance too. Extra hairdressers will consume extra electricity too.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mantas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:29PM (#34071147)
Hairdresser owning his own salon is pretty close to coop.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by wrycoder on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:51PM (#34073170)
If he owns it, he will want to recover his overhead and make profit beyond that to compensate for his risk and extra effort. That profit typically isn't shared with the other stylists. On the other hand, the owner will likely diligently pursue his own interest in making the shop as profitable as possible by attracting the most customers to the best service, which may greatly benefit the stylists (and make them willing to pay more for use of the chair).

If it's a co-op, all expenses and profits will be split among the members. (I'm assuming that the co-op members are limited to the stylists in this case.) The business is not likely to be pursued as diligently as it would be if it was a sole proprietorship, as an individual member will not be proportionately compensated for making an outsized effort. If the co-op is large enough to require a full-time employed manager and other staff, then it's just a privately held corporation, and will perform as such.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mantas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @11:33PM (#34076683)
I was thinking about a hairdresser having a salon with a single chair for himself.

Full-on co-op wouldn't work if 1 hair dresser is super popular and 2 others are not so popular. It's a very personal business and a big part of it is one's own contacts. Now if only salon is co-op and hairdressers have to decide together how much they charge per chair to split among themselves... That may get interesting. If hairdresser pays a %, then worse performers may get a chunk of better-off profits. If hairdresser pays for chair days, then worse performers may be subsidising the better ones.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mantas on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @10:03AM (#34066806)
Salon owners probably charge obscene prices for a spot. That makes opening your own salon much more lucrative.

And customers are probably not willing to pay higher prices to attract more workers into this line of work..

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:18AM (#34065442)
> "some bucks" are defined by how much people are willing to pay for goods.

In a lot of cases, the company owners rake in hundreds of thousands to millions and sometimes billions of dollars a year in profit. The benefit of becoming so large that competition barely exists or simply cannot keep up with economies of scale. Even if you're barely making one cent of profit per unit sold: if you manage to scale up so massively you can sell 100 million pieces of it, you'll still make a million dollars profit overall.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by bombcar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:37AM (#34065660)
An example: Walmart’s yearly profit divided by the number of employees: $4k per employee.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by nickpp on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:20AM (#34065467)
Their profit is your opportunity then: open a competing company, pay people better while still making a decent profit and enjoy!
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by kdmccormick on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:26AM (#34065531)
That level of profit oppptunity doesn't occur until the company is massive. Small business owners, in contrast, mostly run on tight margins and have to live with a high likelihood of their business failing.

Effectively, you're asking us to solve the income gap by becoming billionaires ourselves. Can you see the irony in that?

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by nickpp on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:33AM (#34065610)
Jeff Bezos managed to. I wish more people would try, instead of saying "can't be done".
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by qwytw on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:38AM (#34065677)
> more people would try

What makes you think they didn't? There are hundreds of thousands (or way more) who 'failed' for every self-made billionaire.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by BlueTemplar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:38AM (#34065673)
These companies managed to because antitrust (and protectionism) are asleep on their job.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:37AM (#34065665)
Just look at how long it took Amazon to get as big as it did - and Amazon didn't have much competition in its first few years ffs, they were the pioneers of e-commerce. The survivors from the first dot-com boom are so entrenched by now they are literally impossible to ever unseat unless government regulation intervenes - either in the form of marketplace regulation, anti-trust action or, like the EU is trying to break PayPal, forcing banks to offer fast payments.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by BlueTemplar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:39AM (#34065692)
You mean "how fast" ? GAF(AM)s didn't even exist a quarter of a century ago !

P.S.: What makes you think Amazon had no competition ? Were there no other booksellers, or generalist stores selling books ?

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:56AM (#34065888)
> GAF(AM)s didn't even exist a quarter of a century ago !

Yes, and look how entrenched they have become. Search engines, for example, are dominated by Google holding 80%+ for well over a decade. Even Bing, with Microsoft's deep cash coffers, can't get above 9% [1]. Facebook just went ahead and bought the biggest threats (Whatsapp, Instagram) or copied the features of competitors to destroy them (Snapchat). The only threat in the social media marketplace comes from TikTok, who are backed by the Chinese government. Twitter is tiny and Musk is driving it to the ground. Amazon, while "only" at 38% market share in e-commerce, still leaves everyone else including Wal-Mart in the dust [2]. Microsoft utterly dominates the PC and laptop market [3] as well as the office suite market [4].

Even with these multi-billion companies fighting against each other, they can't manage to land any kind of significant blows - so how should a small startup stand a chance?

> P.S.: What makes you think Amazon had no competition ? Were there no other booksellers, or generalist stores selling books ?

Amazon had no competition online, mostly because the competition was asleep at the wheel. And by the time the competition woke up, it was too late - and now "classic" book stores are dying out left and right, not to mention other kinds of specialized stores. Here in Munich, all the small electronics specialty stores closed down, even famous chain Conrad closed down because they couldn't compete any more.

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/216573/worldwide-market-...

[2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/274255/market-share-of-t...

[3] https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/desktop/worldwide

[4] https://blogs.gartner.com/craig-roth/2022/08/02/market-share...

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by BlueTemplar on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @01:08PM (#34069756)
Well, US companies being effectively illegal in EU since 2015 might shake things up ?

For instance :

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33751805

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by hutzlibu on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:47AM (#34065789)
Jeff Bezos is not seen by most as evil, because he is rich, but because he became rich by exploiting working people and other buisnesses wherever possible.

It is not possible for everyone to successfully exploit others. You need some victims, too.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by nickpp on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:38PM (#34071293)
Jeff Bezor is seen as "evil" only by leftists who would love to steal people the freedom to choose where to work and how.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by vaidhy on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @04:45PM (#34073083)
If you cannot see the asymmetry of power between an individual warehouse worker and Amazon, then everything progressive will sound like forced choice.

If you start from the assumption that people should live and die under reasonable expectations of health, growth and participation in labor, able to bring up their children to aspire to a better living standards than their own, then progressive policies will make sense.

If you start from the assumption that people deserve the life they have and everyone can pull themselves from their bootstraps, and only thing people lack is ambition and hard work, then the progressive policies will sound like stealing from the successful people.

I personally believe that corporations should exist to serve their customers, their workers and then the shareholders, in that order.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by nickpp on Wednesday December 21, 2022 @07:06AM (#34079578)
Actually I want what "progressives" say they want:

> people should live and die under reasonable expectations of health, growth and participation in labor, able to bring up their children to aspire to a better living standards

But I have enough real-world experience and I've been lied to by enough politicians to know that we will never get that through policies. We can only get it though the same mechanisms that pulled us out of poverty and exploitation and offered us this amazing bounty of choice we are enjoying every day in non-government-controlled-domains: free markets.

This is why I support less restrictions and more opportunities for companies and startups.

> I personally believe that corporations should exist to serve their customers, their workers and then the shareholders, in that order.

I do not believe these are separate classes and instead they should be comingled instead: anybody should be able to become shareholder at the company they work or consume from.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by headhasthoughts on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:26AM (#34066315)
Bezos got three hundred thousand dollars from his parents to start Amazon. Gates only got the DOS deal because of his mother's connection to IBM. Zuckerberg's mother was a doctor, and his father a dentist. Musk's father owned an emerald mine.

How rich are your parents?

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by nickpp on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @02:34PM (#34071229)
Growing under communism, my parents were dirt-poor. So after the fall I had to do it the hard way: first got a job, saved enough money to have a little runway, then start a small business, etc.

But I have nothing against people who grew up under a humane system, got help from parents or VCs and made something of themselves. Because I know plenty of bums who had everything they ever needed and did absolutely nothing with it.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by dontlaugh on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:33AM (#34065613)
With what capital? Those that own the monopolies already have most of it.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by nickpp on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:35AM (#34065641)
Lots of VCs willing to give you money to try, if you have an idea. This very forum belongs to one of them.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by jacooper on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:37AM (#34065664)
VCs won't pay you to give better wages thats for sure.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by nickpp on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:38AM (#34065672)
Have you tried?
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:25AM (#34065515)
The problem is: you can't compete with the scale of these mega-corporations unless you have something like a sovereign wealth fund backing you. It is simply unviable to try and open up an alternative to Amazon or Walmart - network effects, exclusivity deals, credit history, officials letting it slide to pay your workers pittances because they don't want to battle with the lawyers a billion dollar company can put up against you... and especially, if you do try it, then the mega corporations can and will price-dump you out of business. Subsidising losses for one location for a year or two is nothing for Wal-Mart, especially not if every other store around them is closed afterwards and you are the only player left.

Oh, and not to mention that while $VENDOR is willing to give Wal-Mart a special deal for, say, a bottle of soda for 20 cents in exchange for Wal-Mart placing an order for a million bottles, they will not give that same price to your small corner store. You cannot compete with that without going into loss leader territory, which is highly dangerous.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by ethbr0 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:35AM (#34065637)
Thank god for SoftBank, funding competition at scale and making the world a better place!
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by nickpp on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:39AM (#34065687)
> you can't compete

Have you ever tried? You can always compete - your imagination is the only limit.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by refurb on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:39AM (#34065686)
The problem is: you can't compete with the scale of these mega-corporations unless you have something like a sovereign wealth fund backing you.

I mean, clearly that’s not true or else we’d live in a world where old companies don’t die and no new companies come about.

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:48AM (#34065792)
Just take supermarkets as an example. In Germany, 3/4 of the market has been taken by the four largest chains [1], which poses an immense competition problem for vendors like farms, or for small corner stores which have vanished in large parts of the country because they can't compete with the big-box store 20km away.

[1] https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/4916/umfrage/...

Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by refurb on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @07:31PM (#34075050)
How much of that is just consumer choice? Of course you can’t compete against large grocery stores if you charge a higher price but offer nothing of higher value.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by buggythebug on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @08:42AM (#34065730)
People forget that a lot of these companies are small businesses that are not raking in millions and billions....
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:00AM (#34065946)
Being a small business does not entitle them to exist at the cost of exploiting underpaid labor.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by buggythebug on Thursday December 22, 2022 @07:29AM (#34092649)
"Exploit" is a strong as word. No one is forcing anyone to work for the ABC company.
Re:Early retirement and ageing population are causing labour... by danaris on Tuesday December 20, 2022 @09:09AM (#34066079)
I don't know if it's as true in the UK, but in the US, companies have been reporting record profits over the past year or so.

This means that there's plenty of extra money to pay salaries. The people at the top just don't want to use it for that.