News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by rqmedes on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:12PM (#34021224)
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by loxias on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:31PM (#34021503)
Interesting links, thanks!

(in case it helps anyone else...) About half a year ago I discovered that a brutally low carb diet -- leading to being in ketosis -- drastically helped my ADHD as well as other mental health things I've struggled with for my entire life. I wish I knew earlier!

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by dchristian on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:51PM (#34021714)
Two things that might also work, but be easier.

Supplement MCT oil. This turns into keytones in the body. See The Complete Book of Ketones by Mary Newport for all the science. She's got into it for Alzheimers, but the applicability is wider than that.

Go gluten-free and casein-free. That's eliminating wheat and dairy in your diet. Both of these turn into a form of morphine in the body. Look up glutomorphine and casomorphine. A slightly easier diet to stick to than keto. This cured my aspergers.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by faeriechangling on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:25PM (#34022055)
>Go gluten-free and casein-free. That's eliminating wheat and dairy in your diet. Both of these turn into a form of morphine in the body. Look up glutomorphine and casomorphine. A slightly easier diet to stick to than keto. This cured my aspergers.

This cure for Autism is broadly related to the leaky gut hypothesis of autism, rather infamously propagated by Andrew Wakefield in the 90s more generally and Jenny McCarthy more specifically went after gluten/casein in the 2000s. PETA made an infamous ad saying that milk causes Autism [1] because milk has Casein. This is to say that enough noise got made about this specific claim it got researched a bit.

Generally this diet has specifically been studied for autism treatment and the efficence of it's efficacy is very lacking for me [2][3]

This all being said, this doesn't necessarily mean that nobody can benefit from a casein or gluten free diet, there's simply insufficient evidence to say that autistic people benefit from such a diet particularly often, and people who avoid milk and bagels are less autistic.

[1] https://www.dairyreporter.com/var/wrbm_gb_food_pharma/storag...

[2] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10803-019-04266-9

[3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7651765/

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by boplicity on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:29PM (#34022649)
The problem with those studies is that a Gluten free or a gluten and dairy free diet is not enough to actually treat "leaky gut" or similar issues. It's a bit like saying you can fix an ecosystem by removing two invasive species from the environment. Sure, it might work, but it's such an oversimplification that the results will appear random, or, "inconclusive."

Studying diets is notoriously difficult, and rarely done in a helpful way. Everybody has a different internal ecosystem -- as well as different dietary stimulus, even if they're following the same diet. This makes it incredibly difficult to draw broad conclusions based on controlling just one or two dietary factors.

This is rather unfortunate -- because the right dietary treatments can be truly transformative for many people, for a variety of conditions. However, because of the difficulty of proving this scientifically, such treatments are ignored by the medical community, leaving patients to figure this avenue of treatment out on their own.

The answer, in my opinion, is massive funding -- the kind of funding that can compete with billion dollar drugs (such as Humira). However, that's really not going to happen. Oh well. Sorry for the rant!

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by dchristian on Saturday December 17, 2022 @07:28PM (#34033783)
They have done studies that showed that it "helped" about 60% of the time (sorry I don't have the reference). "Helped" is a far weaker term than cured. I've read some of McCarthy's books and this is often the first thing to be tried. Often there is a long path to finding a workable cure for a specific person.

I went GFCF for other reasons (IBS and excess mucus production) and was surprised when my Asperger's started to go away. My personal theory is that the small, but frequent, morphine effects interfere with learning. When you take that away, low level learning can begin again.

I was "face blind" (i.e. didn't automatically recognize familiar faces) and didn't pick up on social cues. Both problems when away after 6-12mo on GFCF. A lot of social awkwardness comes from not picking up on these fundamental inputs.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by loxias on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:55PM (#34021753)
Cool. Thanks!

Already using MCT oil in lots of cooking :) Had no idea about dairy... interesting, I eat a lot of high fat cheese.

Thanks for the references, I'll certainly read more.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by k__ on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:52PM (#34022872)
I had the impression that the gluten/casein morphin thesis has been debunked.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by dchristian on Saturday December 17, 2022 @07:16PM (#34033702)
A reference would be helpful :-)

Gluten and dairy are in almost all packaged foods. They drive cravability in a big way. So I'm guessing any "debunking" was funded by someone making money from this.

There are a few people who are immune to the effect. You can pick them out because they either dislike or simply don't care for cheese (which is mostly casein).

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by LocalPCGuy on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:18PM (#34022553)
I don't think I actually put this together until I read your comment. My actual diagnosis came just after I went off keto after having been doing it pretty steadily for about 3 years. I wonder now if the reason I noticed the symptoms of lack of focus more prior to seeking help and my diagnosis now was because it was better controlled while I was on keto and in ketosis.

I know looking back I still had symptoms. I can remember days during those 3 years just sitting in the office and realizing I had not gotten a single thing actually done and it was mid-afternoon already. But also had stretches of incredible productivity also.

Thanks for the prompt - been considering going back on keto, one of the reasons I went off is the mixed scientific evidence for its efficacy over other diets (not specifically for weight loss, just diet in the context of "way of eating") and some warnings about the lack of long-term study data because it's so hard for individuals to stay on long term. But this gives me another data point to consider and something to watch if I do try it again.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by boplicity on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:00PM (#34023507)
My random opinion: It's best to go on Keto intermittently; say 2 month on, 2 months off, or similar variation. I would be hesitant to be on it permanently, but doing it off and on feels safer to me.

One of the nice things, for me, in terms of having been on Keto occassionally, if that it's given me the ability to go for extended periods without needing to eat. I don't crash, in terms of blood sugar, the way I used to. Even when I'm not eating super low carb.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by kennedywm on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:03PM (#34030375)
Ketogenic diets likely increase insulin sensitivity, which may explain your experience.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by k__ on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:42PM (#34022784)
I did keto 3 weeks ago.

After 3 days of it, I felt very focused and got done a bunch of stuff I was procrastinating for months.

I thought this was a coincidence.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by FearlessNebula on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:44PM (#34022808)
Andrew Huberman recently had a Harvard educated psychiatrist on the podcast. This psychiatrist specialized in treatment resistant mental health conditions. He was trying to help a patient lose weight and inadvertently found it helped their psychiatric symptoms as well. Fast forward 5 years and he had written a book, and the tl;dr is that he has seen many patients improve their conditions be going low / no carb. For patients with less extreme disease they can often get by with low carb and eliminate fructose but keep some healthy complex carbs in their diets. Seriously ill patients may benefit more from full ketosis. In any case, he often reports patients are able to reduce or sometimes eliminate medications on this diet which helps when they have trouble with the side effect profiles.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by willhinsa on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:21PM (#34024161)
This episode, right? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xjEFo3a1AnI

Dr. Chris Palmer: Diet & Nutrition for Mental Health | Huberman Lab Podcast #99

> My guest this episode is Chris Palmer, M.D., a board-certified psychiatrist and assistant professor of psychiatry at Harvard Medical School. He explains the important connection between nutrition, metabolism and mental health and his pioneering work using the ketogenic diet to successfully treat patients with various mental illnesses, including depression and schizophrenia. Dr. Palmer explains how the ketogenic diet is an evidenced-based treatment for epilepsy, mimics the fasted state and can offset the cognitive decline in Alzheimer’s. He describes the key roles of mitochondria in mental health, how certain conditions likely arise from mitochondrial dysfunction, and how low-carbohydrate diets increase mitochondrial turnover to improve mental health. He also explains how low-carbohydrate diets positively impact the gut microbiome and weight loss, important risk factors for mitochondrial health such as marijuana and alcohol, and the best way to increase circulating ketones depending on individual needs. We also cover how a ketogenic diet impacts mood, sleep, and fertility. Dr. Palmer’s work stands as a revolutionary approach to mental health and disease that, given the prevalence of mental health challenges, should be of interest to people of all backgrounds and ages.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by FearlessNebula on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:39PM (#34024330)
Yep:)
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by fortran77 on Saturday December 17, 2022 @09:52AM (#34028194)
You wonder if it's mostly the weight-loss that solved the problems, and if a person loses weight by strict calorie counting, carbs or not, would it have the same effect.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by dchristian on Saturday December 17, 2022 @07:40PM (#34033855)
I would recommend "why we get fat" by Gary Taubes. Calorie counting has be disproved so many times, but it sticks around despite the science being against it. If you're a doctor or researcher, "Good calories, bad calories" is the same material but at a clinician's level.

Low carb diets get insulin down and ketones up. These factors are more likely to be driving these other changes.

Also, low carb diets generally eliminate wheat and therefore gluten. Gluten becomes gluteomophin, which causes it's own problems (as an opiate). The standard American diet micro-doses an opiate at every meal. What could go wrong?

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by kennedywm on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:09PM (#34030433)
I've been trying a ketogenic diet since listening to this episode and over the past few days have noticed an improvement in not only my ADHD symptoms, but a decrease in anxiety as well. I'm very optimistic about this, though I'm skeptical about being on keto in the long term.

I've seen similar effects with intermittent fasting combined with a whole foods plant-based diet. This will likely be my long-term strategy.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by adave on Saturday December 17, 2022 @04:00AM (#34026113)
Low carb diet helps, so do others based on the person. Intermittent fasting + exercise + vitamins helps everyone no matter what diet.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by badrabbit on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:23PM (#34021378)
Damn it, they have tea on that list of oxalates. Adderal to the rescue!
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by tdeck on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:45PM (#34021663)
All of these links are about autism, not ADHD. Am I missing something?
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by dchristian on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:52PM (#34021723)
Autism is a wide spectrum. Some would consider ADHD part if it. If nothing else, there is lots of overlap.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by sheepscreek on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:04PM (#34022423)
I have both and I’ve often thought the same. There are so many symptoms in one that are synonymous with the other.

Asperger’s is just a tad bit more on the socially awkward side: inability to understand social cues being a big one. I learned to fake it and it took me a long time to develop genuine empathy in situations demanding raw emotion. I’m still awkward sometimes - unsure of what the socially acceptable response is in a situation.

This is in sharp contrast to my spouse who is also ADHD. She is more easily distracted and has higher dysfunction. Yet, she is socially more aware and talking to people is second nature to her.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by rqmedes on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:47PM (#34023377)
I have the social awkward side with the same inability to understand social cues, after many decades I can fake it, but still come across as odd or strange. I guess its the uncanny valley effect. The emotions and empathy is however the opposite, its so strong and raw I have to try and shut it down as its overwhelming.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by faeriechangling on Friday December 16, 2022 @08:13PM (#34023072)
It's pretty common in discussions about Autism to talk about ADHD due to strong comorbidity in that direction.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by jasonhansel on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:04PM (#34021831)
OP didn't ask for advice about how to treat their condition. Presumably they prefer to hear that from their doctor, rather than from every stranger they mention their diagnosis to.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by bootloop on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:35PM (#34022717)
If the quality of doctors follows the same distribution as that one of SW engineers, taking advice of a stranger might have a similar use as looking for answers on stack overflow. After all, they are all self-taught..
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:28AM (#34025381)
> If the quality of doctors follows the same distribution as that one of SW engineers

How could you possibly think that it does, considering the entire ocean of difference between their education and training???

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by bootloop on Saturday December 17, 2022 @05:13AM (#34026506)
Does that have much of an impact on distribution? I don't think so. You still gonna have ones which are very good at their job, some are average and the rest is part of the long tail.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:04PM (#34030992)
It absolutely does narrow the distribution substantially.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by cactusplant7374 on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:05PM (#34021837)
What makes you think OP needs advice for ADHD treatment? He was diagnosed by a mental health professional. He may be taking medications that work quite well in the right environment.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by yalestar on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:07PM (#34022459)
What makes you think OP is a he?
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by TeMPOraL on Friday December 16, 2022 @07:25PM (#34022617)
Why do you assume this advice will make the OP abandon whatever they're doing now and jump to try it?

There are other people suffering from ADHD reading this thread. Some of us appreciate exchange of advice as more avenues to explore - for example, because current treatment regimen (medication and/or otherwise) is working well, and so not worth the risk of messing with it, but could use some addition to address remaining problems. There is no perfect cure for this, there's only stacking person-specific partial solutions until hopefully reaching diminishing returns.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by joshu on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:57PM (#34023939)
Also helps with kidney stones. Eugh
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:27AM (#34025376)
Please don't give advice like this on the Internet; you are not a qualified physician, you do not know what this person's life actually is, what medicines they're currently taking, what allergies they have, etc.

You could literally kill someone with the wrong "benign" advice at the wrong time. Turning off Slack won't kill anyone (probably) but suggesting a diet or medication very well could.

Just don't do it.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by rocqua on Saturday December 17, 2022 @03:02AM (#34025831)
A suggestion to look into something, with links to start the research, on a forum like this.

Totally fine. People can do their own research on this forum, if someone is on special meds, they are smart enough to check with doctor before implementing something weird.

Besides, a dietary change is going to have slow effects, plenty of time for correcting mistakes.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:08PM (#34031040)
It's not "totally fine" it's wildly irresponsible and dangerous, and frankly should be banned.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by 1123581321 on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:22AM (#34035279)
I was glad that he shared what helped him, and after reading your plea to prevent people from accessing this information, doubly so. You should especially be ashamed for trying to keep people struggling with mental health issues in that state.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by SpeedilyDamage on Sunday December 18, 2022 @02:47AM (#34035763)
Talk to a medical professional before engaging in any change to your diet or medication, especially if you have mental health issues.

This kind of thing is how you spiral out of control, I've seen it dozens of times. You and anyone else struggling need to find QUALIFIED people to help you, not random Internet people.

Your life literally depends on doing what I'm saying here, not in experimenting with fad diets and snake oil medications.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by 1123581321 on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:13AM (#34050061)
Me? Did you reply to the wrong post? If you didn't, why would you think I don't have a doctor and and a nutritionist, and why would you think I am looking for a new nutrition plan? You don't know 24+ people who have had this problem, either.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by SpeedilyDamage on Monday December 19, 2022 @03:31PM (#34057251)
There's a concept in English called the "royal you", I do recommend you (specifically you) look it up.
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by 1123581321 on Monday December 19, 2022 @04:34PM (#34058064)
No one is going to believe you originally meant that. I'm sorry. You are so bad for the health of the people around you and a poor discussion partner. :(
Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by SpeedilyDamage on Monday December 19, 2022 @05:27PM (#34058645)
I just.. on so many levels, I see your response here as a lower form of human communication. Honestly, and I get how pretentious that sounds, but you sound like a wounded, broken animal.

As if you're hardly even human; the embodiment of your own insecurities, lashing out in confusion about how the world around you works. You spout whatever combination of words would hurt you most to others, a whirling dervish of emotional weakness and impotency.

There's no light in your eyes is there? Just a dead, cowlike stare, a ring of sclera revealing your panicked ego constantly assessing how you fit in with the other apes, dreading even the tiniest perception of loss.

And honestly? It probably doesn't get better. This is probably it for you, there's not likely to be a grand improvement in your life or how you perceive reality. That panic will never go away, that confusion and anger is just who you are now.

You apparently rage against medicine, you rage against people who actually understand reality, but mostly you rage against yourself; this is it. This is you. You are a pile of fear and frustration from incompetence, just like you were as a child, and you'll never be anything more.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by kennedywm on Saturday December 17, 2022 @01:19PM (#34030553)
Here's what a typical primary care physician will do: prescribe you non-stimulant ADHD medication with potentially terrible side effects and since those don't work for a lot of people, they will move on to prescribing amphetamines with terrible side effects. Most physicians receive little training in nutrition (I believe one class is standard).

You should consider reevaluating your blind faith in physicians (they were an instrumental part of the opioid crisis after all), especially when it drives you to make a dismissive comment like this in response to a benign suggestion about a dietary change that you seemingly haven't evaluated before responding. Here the individual has seen success with this approach for themselves and others and is simply sharing their experience. They're not suggesting anything extreme or dangerous.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by SpeedilyDamage on Saturday December 17, 2022 @02:06PM (#34031012)
People like you kill others because of your ego. You should feel deep, profound shame and guilt for how much damage you cause to society.

Your ideas are how we got the Ivermectin craze, for example.

Shame on you.

Re:Ask HN: I have diagnosed ADHD and cannot work with Slack ... by kennedywm on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:35PM (#34034808)
Medications I was using as prescribed almost killed me and seriously derailed my life. But sure, your self-righteous emotional judgment of me is definitely going to change minds. Have a nice day.