News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Linux Evening by antihero on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:50AM (#34015086)
Linux is like driving a car with your hands in the engine
Re:A Linux Evening by JP_Watts on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:56AM (#34015188)
And thinking "why doesn't everybody want to do this?"
Re:A Linux Evening by swayvil on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:10AM (#34015373)
This contradicts my experience.

I use Linux every day and I never touch the engine.

I also set up Linux for computer-illiterate old ladies. They love it.

Re:A Linux Evening by seanw444 on Friday December 16, 2022 @10:43AM (#34015823)
Some people just don't like the Linux (or Unix) way of doing things. I personally can't understand the predisposition against it, but hey, whatever works for them I guess.
Re:A Linux Evening by swayvil on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:28PM (#34021461)
For your average user it's exactly the same desktop as windows and mac : there's menus and icons, you click on stuff, there's a browser... What's this "way" that they don't like?

They don't like free, stable and fast? They don't like how it isn't going after your wallet every 5 minutes?

It's gotta be propaganda at work. It's the only explanation.

Re:A Linux Evening by iraqmtpizza on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:08PM (#34021875)
Ubuntu desktop is anything but stable. Nuke-and-pave is the only sane solution to the OS corruption issues. The GUI is more stripped down than a holocaust victim. They still haven't figured out drag and drop. And on top of that, everyone swears such-and-such distribution is actually the good one, but it never is. The desktop is in permanent demo mode. A back-burner school project that turned into a part-time hobby.

Maybe you just use it for web browsing. But for everyone else, there's Windows. Which is still crap but at least you can set an environment variable without doing a research project into the differences between .bash_profile, .bashrc, .profile, and /etc/environment. None of which have a GUI. And the best part is that none of them can ever be renamed because muh scripts would break and the entire OS would come crashing down.

Re:A Linux Evening by swayvil on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:13PM (#34021917)
Ok, ya, last time I used Ubuntu I didn't like it either. I like Debian (Ubuntu is derived from it apparently), with MATE desktop.
Re:A Linux Evening by iraqmtpizza on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:22PM (#34022023)
It is about what I would expect from an OS that considers UI to be bloatware and viral anti-business licenses to be more free than permissive ones.
Re:A Linux Evening by opan on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:39PM (#34022205)
Freedom 0 of free software, use the software for any purpose, includes commercial usage. There's nothing anti-business about it.
Re:A Linux Evening by iraqmtpizza on Friday December 16, 2022 @06:55PM (#34022353)
I agree. Using software modifications as a competitive advantage in business does not violate free software licenses. It does, however, violate non-free licenses like GPL
Re:A Linux Evening by inkblotuniverse on Sunday December 18, 2022 @12:51AM (#34035384)
It's just the equivalent of a consumer protection law: you have to sell people the software, not a build artifact.
Re:A Linux Evening by freeplay on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:14AM (#34016257)
Out of curiosity, what distro do you use and what is your distro of choice for the old ladies?
Re:A Linux Evening by lrvick on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:35AM (#34016569)
I have been setting up Ubuntu for non-technical folks for a decade. Chromebooks work great too, but I cannot justify recommending them given the proprietary Google bits included. De-Googled chromeos would probably suffice for most people though.
Re:A Linux Evening by tempest_ on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:51AM (#34016816)
Honestly if you have older hardware, like a couple years old most of the most popular distros are pretty stable.

Ubuntu on hardware a few years old will chug along without issues more often than not especially if you are just using it as a glorified thin client for Chrome which is an increasingly large base of users.

There are of course some gotchas with things like integrated graphics and dedicated graphics in laptops or some device drivers for peripherals like printers (it is still linux after all, year of the linux desktop any year now aha)

Re:A Linux Evening by ronjouch on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:04PM (#34017027)
Not OP, but chiming in nevertheless, as I do also "set up Linux for computer-illiterate old ladies".

They all roll Debian stable with unattended_upgrades and it's an absolute joy of stability.

Not that I would use Debian stable for my personal machines: I want the latest shiniest and I want to be close to upstream to report bugs when they're fresh and easy to fix by the maintainer (yes, "I use arch btw" indeed), but for "computer-illiterate" people, stability trumps everything else.

The "computer illiterate" isn't amused by constant breaking behavior / visual changes. They want the thing to work reliably and unsurprisingly. Debian delivers this and never breaks. Once every major dist-upgrade I review changes with them, and they're good to go until next time.

Re:A Linux Evening by freeplay on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:19PM (#34017256)
Nice. What is your go to desktop environment for them?
Re:A Linux Evening by ronjouch on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:13PM (#34018005)
- Generally, GNOME with the dash-to-panel/dash-to-dock extension-du-jour to have a left-side panel with app buttons (so, a "Ubuntu/Unity"-like look). It baffles me how stock GNOME still insists not to provide a left/bottom "dock" / task switcher as a built-in option, and force you to go to the menu every time you want to access / switch to an app, but here we are with extensions oÔ.

- That being said, a well-configured/simplified Plasma these would certainly be all well (or not, see my final paragraph below about locking things down; GNOME is less infinitely configurable than KDE/Plasma, so there's less room for user fuckup). Also I'm certainly biased towards GNOME because that's what I choose to use for my machines. Also also, I go where there are the most eyeballs (again, for stability & maximal guarantee that bugs are seen), and for now it's GNOME.

- Exception: one grandma has a particularly old laptop (x86-32 old :D) with meager RAM, so for her setup I went with MATE. I hesitated between LxQt and MATE, tried both, and MATE (at the time) seemed a tad more polished.

Finally, since I have your interest and GUIs are a subject I love ranting about, one more thing you need to do when setting up an old ladies machine, is to LOCK DOWN ALL THE THINGS YOU CAN:

- LibreOffice toolbars that can be accidentally dragged, then maybe dragged offscreen or closed? LOCK THEM.

- Thunderbird folder column titles that will change email ordering if accidentally clicked? HIDE THEM with userChrome.css until https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=237051 is fixed.

- Etc etc, when I'm done provisioning such a machine, I spend an hour playing with it and wondering "How could someone haphazardly clicking and dragging everywhere break/mismanage this?" , and I disable/lock/hide everything I can. There is a million configurable / breakable things that we power users don't imagine being confusing to a user, because we know the features and we're precise at clicking on stuff. But to non-computerists, these things are veeeeery confusing! They'll email you with a gibberish issue description when invoked accidentally, and when it happens too often they get scared. There's potential to build a whole distribution aimed at such users, with everything properly locked down.

Re:A Linux Evening by nephanth on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:55PM (#34018517)
For thunderbird column header, there is an extension that locks them (unless you're ctrl+clicking them)

Might be more intuitive than locking them?

Re:A Linux Evening by ronjouch on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:01PM (#34018582)
Thanks! Yup, if you look at the bugzilla link I shared above, you'll see I mention this extension in the last comment: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=237051#c11 .

I couldn't check it as I run Tb beta (which the extension doesn't support last time I check), but I might give it a try next time I maintain one of these machines ..... or not:

0. They never ever need to click it to re-order. Why bother with an unneeded feature?

1. Extensions break! UserChrome.css too, but maybe less so :) , and a CSS rule is simpler/smaller in added complexity & potential for bugs than an extension.

2. Also, hiding the columns means one less bit of chrome to read/parse. Hiding stuff avoids misclicks, but also increases GUI legibility for people with bad eyesight.

Re:A Linux Evening by swayvil on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:06PM (#34021143)
Mate
Re:A Linux Evening by bradwood on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:45PM (#34018411)
what about Fedora workstation for the old-lady use case? I'm about to give my 12 year old non-technical daughter a linux laptop, and wondering on distro. I'm thinking Fedora but open to be convinced otherwise?
Re:A Linux Evening by ronjouch on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:09PM (#34018664)
For the old ladies, no: Fedora has a short release cycle, and no LTS; not great for maximal stability. "a version of Fedora is usually supported for at least 13 months" ( https://endoflife.date/fedora ), while Debian is security-supported at least 5 years! ( https://endoflife.date/debian )

Debian's whole project architecture & release cycle is built towards being stable bedrock, I see virtually no reason to use anything else if you aim at max. stability.

That being said, for your daughter tinkering with a distro, yeah Fedora sounds awesome :)

Re:A Linux Evening by chungy on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:07PM (#34018644)
Pick something you're willing to maintain. Stable releases tend to reduce maintenance and surprises.
Re:A Linux Evening by LBJsPNS on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:12AM (#34028369)
MX. Fast. Stable as a rock.
Re:A Linux Evening by swayvil on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:30PM (#34021493)
Debian and Debian.
Re:A Linux Evening by naikrovek on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:29AM (#34016496)
> I also set up Linux for computer-illiterate old ladies. They love it.

I think you're trying to say that they don't have problems with the browser, and maybe an email client. If they're computer-illiterate, they don't know enough about an operating system to have an opinion at all, other than being happy about it turning on and off when they want.

Don't mistake that for loving Linux, because it is not really praise of Linux, it is praise for a computer that works well enough to run a web browser, which is an extremely low bar.

Re:A Linux Evening by lrvick on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:39AM (#34016633)
Linux can manage a browser, and email client, and a word processor, on a early 2000s computer found for $50 at a thrift store.

Meanwhile the latest supported versions of MacOS or Windows will not work on such a machine. Those ecosystems demand you continually buy new hardware.

I think is -is- Linux they love here.

Re:A Linux Evening by themaninthedark on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:04PM (#34018612)
Contradicts my experience as well.

I started out using DOS in the mid 90's to play games, used Windows 3.1, skipped over to 98SE then XP and 7.

I have used Macs before, not enough to make an impression.

I tried Linux back when I was in collage during the XP days but it always seemed to need more tweaking than my XP install and the lack of gaming kept me on Windows.

Currently I am running Linux Mint. I install the OS and go. No need to tweak or mess with command line.

I am not that interested in which OS I am running aside from the fact that I dislike telemetry and forced updates. I want the OS to get our of the way so that I can do whatever I am trying to do, Linux seems to be there now. It feels like Windows has regressed, with setting pages buried in 5 different places.

Re:A Linux Evening by nicoco on Friday December 16, 2022 @09:55AM (#34015164)
Can I steal this? I just started a microblogging career and it's too good.
Re:A Linux Evening by lrvick on Friday December 16, 2022 @11:46AM (#34016750)
Windows is like driving a car that is actually a city bus full of hostile randos that take a lot of effort to constantly remove.

MacOS is like driving a car by yelling at the driver from the kids seat in the back.

In the end, learning how an engine works to maintain one myself is not so bad.