News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Linux Evening by ronjouch on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:04PM (#34017027)
Not OP, but chiming in nevertheless, as I do also "set up Linux for computer-illiterate old ladies".

They all roll Debian stable with unattended_upgrades and it's an absolute joy of stability.

Not that I would use Debian stable for my personal machines: I want the latest shiniest and I want to be close to upstream to report bugs when they're fresh and easy to fix by the maintainer (yes, "I use arch btw" indeed), but for "computer-illiterate" people, stability trumps everything else.

The "computer illiterate" isn't amused by constant breaking behavior / visual changes. They want the thing to work reliably and unsurprisingly. Debian delivers this and never breaks. Once every major dist-upgrade I review changes with them, and they're good to go until next time.

Re:A Linux Evening by freeplay on Friday December 16, 2022 @12:19PM (#34017256)
Nice. What is your go to desktop environment for them?
Re:A Linux Evening by ronjouch on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:13PM (#34018005)
- Generally, GNOME with the dash-to-panel/dash-to-dock extension-du-jour to have a left-side panel with app buttons (so, a "Ubuntu/Unity"-like look). It baffles me how stock GNOME still insists not to provide a left/bottom "dock" / task switcher as a built-in option, and force you to go to the menu every time you want to access / switch to an app, but here we are with extensions oÔ.

- That being said, a well-configured/simplified Plasma these would certainly be all well (or not, see my final paragraph below about locking things down; GNOME is less infinitely configurable than KDE/Plasma, so there's less room for user fuckup). Also I'm certainly biased towards GNOME because that's what I choose to use for my machines. Also also, I go where there are the most eyeballs (again, for stability & maximal guarantee that bugs are seen), and for now it's GNOME.

- Exception: one grandma has a particularly old laptop (x86-32 old :D) with meager RAM, so for her setup I went with MATE. I hesitated between LxQt and MATE, tried both, and MATE (at the time) seemed a tad more polished.

Finally, since I have your interest and GUIs are a subject I love ranting about, one more thing you need to do when setting up an old ladies machine, is to LOCK DOWN ALL THE THINGS YOU CAN:

- LibreOffice toolbars that can be accidentally dragged, then maybe dragged offscreen or closed? LOCK THEM.

- Thunderbird folder column titles that will change email ordering if accidentally clicked? HIDE THEM with userChrome.css until https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=237051 is fixed.

- Etc etc, when I'm done provisioning such a machine, I spend an hour playing with it and wondering "How could someone haphazardly clicking and dragging everywhere break/mismanage this?" , and I disable/lock/hide everything I can. There is a million configurable / breakable things that we power users don't imagine being confusing to a user, because we know the features and we're precise at clicking on stuff. But to non-computerists, these things are veeeeery confusing! They'll email you with a gibberish issue description when invoked accidentally, and when it happens too often they get scared. There's potential to build a whole distribution aimed at such users, with everything properly locked down.

Re:A Linux Evening by nephanth on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:55PM (#34018517)
For thunderbird column header, there is an extension that locks them (unless you're ctrl+clicking them)

Might be more intuitive than locking them?

Re:A Linux Evening by ronjouch on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:01PM (#34018582)
Thanks! Yup, if you look at the bugzilla link I shared above, you'll see I mention this extension in the last comment: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=237051#c11 .

I couldn't check it as I run Tb beta (which the extension doesn't support last time I check), but I might give it a try next time I maintain one of these machines ..... or not:

0. They never ever need to click it to re-order. Why bother with an unneeded feature?

1. Extensions break! UserChrome.css too, but maybe less so :) , and a CSS rule is simpler/smaller in added complexity & potential for bugs than an extension.

2. Also, hiding the columns means one less bit of chrome to read/parse. Hiding stuff avoids misclicks, but also increases GUI legibility for people with bad eyesight.

Re:A Linux Evening by swayvil on Friday December 16, 2022 @05:06PM (#34021143)
Mate
Re:A Linux Evening by bradwood on Friday December 16, 2022 @01:45PM (#34018411)
what about Fedora workstation for the old-lady use case? I'm about to give my 12 year old non-technical daughter a linux laptop, and wondering on distro. I'm thinking Fedora but open to be convinced otherwise?
Re:A Linux Evening by ronjouch on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:09PM (#34018664)
For the old ladies, no: Fedora has a short release cycle, and no LTS; not great for maximal stability. "a version of Fedora is usually supported for at least 13 months" ( https://endoflife.date/fedora ), while Debian is security-supported at least 5 years! ( https://endoflife.date/debian )

Debian's whole project architecture & release cycle is built towards being stable bedrock, I see virtually no reason to use anything else if you aim at max. stability.

That being said, for your daughter tinkering with a distro, yeah Fedora sounds awesome :)

Re:A Linux Evening by chungy on Friday December 16, 2022 @02:07PM (#34018644)
Pick something you're willing to maintain. Stable releases tend to reduce maintenance and surprises.
Re:A Linux Evening by LBJsPNS on Saturday December 17, 2022 @10:12AM (#34028369)
MX. Fast. Stable as a rock.