However, I think you're right, in the circumstance where domestic abuse is ongoing in the moment. If there is physical violence happening, the police need to be called.
If this is more of a "when he gets home he'll be so mad" situation, I think other resources are probably a good first step. Then a police report will need to be filed so a restraining order, etc., can be pursued.
We shouldn’t let a misguided sense of equality blind us to the real nature of the problem. Women are not only twice as likely to be murdered by an intimate partner as the other way around, but in over 40% of cases where women murdered men, there was evidence it was in response to violent acts by the man: https://www.encyclopedia.com/reference/encyclopedias-almanac...
Statistic after statistic bears out the fact that men are by far the more violent sex, and “women and children” are the victims of male violence.
I do not doubt that given their significantly higher natural testosterone men have both a greater raw rate of violence and more incidences reported.
That said, Intimate Partner Violence carries significant psychological trauma. You are completely downplaying that trauma, focusing on only the most extreme and rare cases.[2] 1 in 3 women and 1 in 4 men report having experienced Intimate Partner Violence.[3]
[1] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/15248380211043...
[2] https://psychiatry.org/psychiatrists/diversity/education/int...
[3] https://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/intimatepartnerviolen...
I’m far less likely than many people to be a victim of police violence, but I categorically won’t call cops for anything that would put them in the same space as my pup, because I know they’re much more prone and able to kill dogs on the spot. That’s not ideologically motivated, it’s just risk assessment and precaution.
That said, I do agree that bit of advice is ill advised. Call the police, they're trained for this stuff.
And hopefully you'll never have to use your weapons.
I'm all for gun rights, but this strikes me as a super weird thing to say.
It's like saying "Good news, in the US at least, all cars have safety features. Seat belts, especially, save lives. So, there's that stopping oncoming traffic from harming you and them if you drive at full speed going the wrong direction on the interstate."
An assailant with a gun is prepared to do you harm. There is a 100% chance that they are going to have their gun with them and be ready. They are no more going to wait for you to prepare to defend yourself than the person with a knife is going to swing it widely in a way your corner self defense class is going to prepare you to defend yourself.
That’s like people saying they want guns to protect themselves from the federal government when a small town SWAT team could take them out without breaking a sweat. Let alone the federal government with the worlds largest military.
If they sent community resource officers (not pointing pistols/rifles at people) around that would be a nice option to de-escalate but most departments I know of don't do that.
Either/or, you can become a statistic
So this do/don't call cops dichotomy is not reliable. It's pointless to argue over it & new ideas are needed.
26 unarmed individuals die from police shootings.
Of those 26 probably 3-4 are women.
Your odds of getting shot by the police are 1000x lower than getting killed by your partner.
Like, if your image of domestic violence is two people on their front porch throwing chairs, maybe it's too late to do that. But there are probably less volatile moments where you can act if they are your friends or neighbor.
I can start a video stream on one of my servers that will just be several hundred videos of police killing unarmed people, if you'd like. would that count as a source?
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskSocialScience/comments/b9fkny/is...
Once that’s established though… cops are disproportionately domestic abusers. People who live with cops are disproportionately abused. People who encounter cops are confronted with people who are disproportionately abusive in the privacy of their own home with the benefit of doubt of most of society and almost all legal mechanisms.
Your odds of being abused by cops are much greater than by any other person you meet outside your own community, and those odds increase as your odds of being abused by anyone else do too. And as those odds increase, so too do your odds that an otherwise gentle cop won’t do a thing about anyone else who abuses you. Those odds are correlated to the cop relating more to the abuser than their victim.
I’m more likely to die of heart failure but that doesn’t mean I trust the guy who probably beats his wife and probably won’t shoot me. And as I mentioned in another comment, that distrust goes so far as I will not under any condition allow a cop in my pup’s presence if I have a choice. See, they do actually shoot dogs, a lot.
I've embellished or lied to survey takers a couple times, mostly to protect my anonymity or because i forgot something. I assume they try to correct for "self-reporting" in statistics.
but 40% of active law enforcement had no problem saying "yep i beat my partner".
you may be confusing some statistics here. About 26 police die each year. about half are from violent conflicts, the rest are traffic incidents, gun cleaning accidents, etc.
I'm not sure where you're getting "26" from, but that's literally never been true in the United States. I can probably collate and link 26 videos of cops shooting people without weapons this year. and what is a "weapon"? they brandished, aimed? or just had one nearby? if i have guns in my house and the cops shoot me in my house, was i armed? what if i was asleep in bed when the cops busted in my door? does this change your calculus at all?
Once it gets beyond a rounding error, you get a vicious cycle. An armed criminal now has to make a judgment call: if they disarm, will they be shot anyway? An unarmed civilian has to watch every cop to wonder if this is the one with a bad attitude and a gun. And now the police are worried, too: every single person has to be treated as if they are armed, and has to be prepared to shoot them on very short notice if they are.
Exacerbating matters is that there is a large contingent of people who will excuse every single unarmed shooting. There is no circumstance so egregious that won't bring out a lot of people finding excuses for it, no matter how absurd. So people believe that each unjustified shooting is prelude to even more, because you never get a unanimous "This was a bad thing and we need that to not happen again". Instead, we hear loudly "This was an OK thing and could happen to you."
So people are reacting rationally to a "very small fraction" of shootings, because the consequences are so bad. It doesn't matter that the overall number is small: it's enormous when it's you, and that enormity overshadows many people who want nothing more than to have it not be them.
> Remember that police can escalate domestic violence situations. You can support friends and neighbors who are being victimized by abusers by offering them a place to stay, a ride to a safe location, or to watch their children. Utilize community resources like safe houses and hotlines.
If you’re in this situation, call the police. This just happened in our neighborhood. The cops came and dragged the abusive guy off to jail where he belongs. Don’t risk becoming a statistic out of some misguided ideology.