You don't need integrity while "the line goes up". Integrity is only for when it goes down. Until recently, the line has been consistently going up. SBF was banking on it going up forever. If it had gone up forever, he would not have been caught!
While the line goes up, integrity just eats into potential profits. It's an extra cost. No business willingly spends extra money they don't have to. That's why regulation and oversight is mandatory.
> ...he taught me that with customer money you cannot get even a single cent wrong.
SBF gave an accounting on FTX holdings with an error margin of "plus-minus 10 billion dollars".
Can you imagine having error bars 20 billion dollars in size!?
For reference, companies with market caps in that range include: Tata Motors, Best Buy, Komatsu, Zoom, East Japan Railway, Mitsubishi Electric, Delta Airlines, or Panasonic!
Sit down and picture telling someone with a straight face that you may or may not have misplaced "value" on the same order of magnitude as an entire airline, or an electronics manufacturer with a worldwide presence built up over seven decades of growth.
Integrity is how you behave when no-one is watching.
“Integrity is doing the right thing even when no-one is watching.”
It's outrageous that there is no honour amongst scammers.
Yes, I can imagine having error bars in 20 billion dollars in size, its what the financial audit space does every single year. It's what keeps companies like you've listed in line, because you audit against a materiality.
I don't think we're living in the same world :) Traditional financial institutions are just as bad, if not worse, than most crypto companies. You just have look at all the financial system crashes and exchange frauds. A key difference is that the government is there to bail them out because they are tightly linked, and that traditional institutions know they'll be punished because of strict regulations. It's not about the actors, or some kind of fuzzy DNA/culture, but about government and regulation.
I think it's also important to note the discrepancy in transparency. Yes, FTX was just a centralized exchange that had little to do with the blockchain, but you were still be able to see some of FTXs balance movements on-chain, simply because they are forced to use ETH/BTC/FTT/etc. If we hadn't, FTX may have gotten away with what they're doing a lot longer. Nobody may have found out.
With traditional financial institutions you have almost no transparency. You have absolutely no idea what they're doing behind your back. All you can do is trust the government to eventually bail them out if they mess up. Or trust that they're scared enough of going to prison that they don't try shady things.
I think people might have noticed that customers could not withdraw funds, and the exchange declaring bankruptcy in any case.
Banking meanwhile can fail even with honesty because of the nature of borrowing short and lending long.
On one of of my previous contracting gigs (about 20 years ago), for a very large, USA-based financial services company, the VP hired me for a full month (at consultants pay rate, 40 hrs a week) to investigate and track down a 1-cent discrepancy in $4,000,000,000 under assets for a particular division that differed between two reports by exactly 1 penny(one generated on the mainframe/cobol system, and one generated on a custom pc based system).
Turned out it was a rounding error in like the 8th decimal place on the mainframe side. I thought it was crazy at the time - but guess his thinking was there is no difference between being a penny off, or a million dollars off - you need to be able to account for every cent.
Edge cases matter a lot more to Wall Street than to Silicon Valley. Wall Street is a world where the new hire on the desk gets a talking-to by the managing director for making an error that could have led to a big loss, and where people are regularly reminded not to put anything in writing that they wouldn't want to see on the cover of the New York Times. Silicon Valley is a world where "move fast and break things" is a central mantra, and sometimes those things that get broken are the rules.
At the same time I read stories about other countries where people think it's completely normal that some third party app has replaced the bank's role as a payment processor, even going so far as to include these services within the banking environment itself.
The way I see a large amount of fintech is that business savy people see their banks struggle to get up to standards that were common elsewhere ten years ago and try to make a quick buck throwing together an implementation before the banks can get themselves together. These companies solves the needs of the end customer, but only patch over the underlying problems that keep building up because there is no reason to address them anymore.
How much can you really trust a company built on profiting off the failings of a basic institution underlying almost all commerce?
Meh. Being a middleman, or doing something better than companies do themselves, is the foundation of most economic value creation.
As Schumpeter observed, value creation is accompanied by creative destruction, and right now it looks like we're in the "creative destruction" phase when it comes to fintech.
It was one thing when in the early 2000s creative destruction was involving entities like pets.com, no-one was really hurt by those companies going down, but it's another thing when the company going down might hold your "savings" or owe you money as a SME, like Revolut or Klarna.
It's sad that the entire crypto industry happened too fast for the regulations to keep up, with the unsurprising result that vast amounts of customer money have been lost and stolen - the precise reason for regulation.
I would not be surprised if many people have taken their own lives as a result of crypto losses arising directly from lack of integrity of the companies managing the customer money.
Licenses/certifications do exist. SBF had the FINRA Series 7 and 55.
https://brokercheck.finra.org/individual/summary/6204362
The loophole is that employees at hedge funds and investment advisers don't face the same licensing requirements as employees at banks and brokerages who deal directly with customers. There are people who trade billions of dollars of customer funds a week without any required regulatory exam or license.
So he knew what he was supposed to be doing.
I have a Series 7 and have never handled client money, but I wrote software and had had access to these systems.
Not all fintechs are evil.
If exchanges and stuff had to play by any rules, they’d go out of business because there is no other reason for crypto’s existence but to run scams.
(Okay maybe it won’t entirely collapse but crypto certainly wouldn’t be valued anywhere near what it is now)
The "move fast and break things" slogan was by Zuckerberg at Facebook, though they've since abandoned it.
And, Wall St is where this isn't the case?
An interesting observation. My take is that even though Wall Street has unfathomable levels of hubris and poor ethics, it understands CYA.
Fintech on the other hand...
Would you feel comfortable wiring your money off to a bank account in the Bahamas? I wouldn't. I think safety is more about jurisdiction (and therefore regulations) than it is about what type of currency a business deals in.
Bank DNA has always coded for taking foolhardy risks with customer money. It wasn't until heavy regulation came into play that banks stopped going bust left and right, at least in the USA. Even under heavy regulation, you still see their true colors from time to time such as when they discovered risk loopholes in 2008 that led to the financial panic.
Until regulation hits crypto custodians, they will largely be fly-by-night yokels that go bust left and right, just like the first American banks did. After regulation hits, they will be just as safe as modern banks (and likely, many crypto custodians WILL be modern banks - see e.g. Fidelity entering the custody business recently.)
> The real problem behind all these crypto companies is the people who make the money have no concept of what "integrity" is.
The entirety of Wall street has no concept of what "integrity" is. The solution was heavy regulation. It happened to banks, and it will happen to crypto. Crypto custodians are speed-running banking regulation.
Yes these crypto bros are young grifters out for the big score with zero integrity or morals and hopefully they will look forward to spending their best years in a jail cell. But they are enabled and encouraged by a good old boys network of VCs, journalists, and other influential figures in the tech community. Madoff at least picked rich people as his marks; the media have blown up the likes of SBF as geniuses and encouraged ordinary people to invest money they can't afford to lose in crypto.
> One of things that tends to boggle programmer brains is while most software dealing with money uses multiple-precision numbers to make sure the pennies are accurate, financial modelling uses floats instead. This is because clients generally do not ring up about pennies.
> Traditional banks, for the most part, have DNA built around protecting ...
Traditional banks lack of "integrity" has wrecked considerable more havoc than crypto companies. Actually, the impact of these exchange crashes are completely negligible compared to the financial crisis ~2007.
Let’s not forget that these regulations they’re getting rid of came about after 2008, when banks had to be bailed out by taxpayers around the world.
As they say, what causes more damage, the founding of a bank or the robbing of a bank?
The teams managing the money-handling-software care very much about protecting your cents.
The product managers inventing new fees do not.
They aren't coming from a baseline assumption that their job is to protect and interests and the money of their clients.
Traditional banks, for the most part, have DNA built around protecting customer interests and customer money. Crypto companies have none of that attitude - behind every one of them is a sleazy tale of self interest and corruption.
My first introduction to this way of thinking was many years ago when I worked on a software development project and the project manager was extremely concerned about a single cent being wrong in the calculations - he taught me that with customer money you cannot get even a single cent wrong.
These crypto idiots are just young cowboys who see a giant pile of loot and don't have any concept of how to manage it in an ethical manner. They just wanted to work out how to gamble it all in the hope of more crypto gold. If there are crypto companies that have not yet had their rotten hearts exposed and gone bust, it's simply a matter of time.
Every single one of these companies will - and should - go bust - good riddance. It's a pity Robinhood won't go with them - the filthiest scumbags of all.