Instead, it took over ten years to simply demonstrate ignition using the indirect drive method which was chosen specifically because it was seen as being more technologically viable. This "big breakthrough" was supposed to happen immediately after operation!
No one knows whether commercialization of inertial confinement fusion is even possible. Laser efficiency is just one small part; the work to produce and develop a system to reliably shoot hohlraum targets is an order of magnitude harder than shooting a static target in ideal conditions.
Compared to these engineering challenges demonstrating ignition is the easy part.
Again, let's discuss what those challenges are. A bunch of talk about how hard it might be with no detail on what makes it hard isn't really informative to anyone.
> the work to produce and develop a system to reliably shoot hohlraum targets is an order of magnitude harder than shooting a static target in ideal conditions.
Please see my note #2 about EUV light sources and similar technology. My understanding is the timing and precision requirements are much higher here, but on the other hand the "rate" of fire would be necessarily much lower making something perhaps feasible.
From the presentation and panel today, one of the key drivers seems to be the purity of the capsules and the ability to correct for asymmetries in the implosion caused by them. The results announced today where not because of the purity of the capsule, but instead because of the correct prediction of the asymmetries in the implosion and the ability to counter that with modifications to the laser strength and timing.
The NIF isn't (as others have noted) necessarily focused on bettering these two factors.
What I'd like to understand is what are the major tradeoffs in ICF vs MCF that would drive pursuing the difficult engineering problems of one vs another.
Leaving aside rate of fire and energy efficiency you have to develop a system that can shoot the hohlraum into the reactor chamber such that the lasers can be steered onto the target with enough precision to produce ignition. I believe 100um is the miniumum for the type of targets used in the INF. This all needs to occur within the reaction chamber. Besides the thermal loads you also have residual gases within the chamber. These conditions somehow have to be accounted for or you won't get ignition.
The work they did in demonstrating ignition is great but the engineering challenges for commericalization are immense. EUV lithography took decades to develop and perfect.
>>What I'd like to understand is what are the major tradeoffs in ICF vs MCF that would drive pursuing the difficult engineering problems of one vs another.
MCF is generally seen as a much easier approach because you avoid the problems with repeatedly generating fusion conditions and you remain in the ballpark of what can be solved with better technology. You can come up with a tokamak that you can be absolutely sure will probably work with enough money; but I'm not sure the same is true with ICF.
and
https://www-pub.iaea.org/MTCD/Publications/PDF/TE-1911_web.p...
actually layout some of the challenges. they are not as you state and there ARE tradeoffs between MCF and ICF. Most experts agree MCF is closer to realization, but that's a very well educated guess not a surity.
https://scientific-publications.ukaea.uk/wp-content/uploads/...
lays out some of the differences and tradeoffs
Even more interesting is to look at approaches which might combine the two: https://medium.com/fusion-energy-league/the-fundamental-para...
Of course there are tradeoffs between MCF and ICF. They involve different sets of challenges to achieve viable fusion energy production. Neither has been demonstrated to have commercial viability to date. The consensus view that MCF is more viable is rooted in the much better understanding of how to comercialize a MCF reactor.
Coal and nuclear are uncompetitive simply from the cost of the steam side. Today you can just about give a steam plant free energy and it still makes a loss.
Solar or wind does not have this limitation. CCGT gas plants gets around it by having a turbine giving raw mechanical power and then utilizing the same awful steam side to get the last percentage points of efficiency at a much smaller required scale.
Unless you can step around the steam turbine I do not see this becoming anything outside of incredibly small niches.
Theoretically, you can bet that your traditional power plant only runs at night. But now your capacity factor is less than half the available hours for the same capital investment and it looks even bleaker.
[1]: https://www.lazard.com/media/451885/grphx_lcoe-07.png
[2]: https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...
That is ignoring capacity factor.
From your link we see that the most expensive power generation of all is residential rooftop solar. If cost is the concern, why support the most expensive option that also has a low capacity factor?
What other power source is accessible to the home owner?
If we are going nuclear and it’s so efficient and cost effective, why is it always subsidised so heavily? Its full cost has never been paid anywhere, as storage etc stretch off way into the future.
It seems eternally close to being cheap and reliable, but we keep screwing it up.
France has gone from the largest electricity exporter in Europe to an importer.
The critical question, how much of this design is to figure out how to produce energy from fusion with the aim of powerplant design, and how much of the design is to better replicate the second stage of a h-bomb?
Edit: I'll have to research, but I would have to expect that the announcement of the h-bomb had language that also heralded this as the beginning of a 'fusion age' of power generation.
River power spinning a generator? Wind farm power? Are those counterexamples?
I share GP‘s sentiment though that, in the end, there are remarkably few concepts at the bottom layer of electricity production.
(There are other means of course, but they are not in use for power generation in amounts that can drive even one household, AFAIK)
Hey, if we’re wrong life will change for the better for billions of people. I like being surprised with good news more than disappointment.
but just because fusion energy will not be responsible for warming your frozen pizza next week does not mean we need to belittle a major milestone like this one. sure some damn reporter has a quota to hit and metrics to game. it just means we need to dedicate a bit more effort to read the article, read between the lines, and apply critical thinking.
this is the dream technology of the far future we're talking about. it doesnt even need to happen for 1000 years. if we nail it we are set for Billions of years. but obviously people are not accustomed or incentivized to think about things on that sort of timeline.
When everything is presented as a "major milestone" then the term starts to lose meaning. Those with finite resources need to use imperfect heuristics to decide when to spend those resources, including the time and energy required to "read between the lines and apply critical thinking" For the majority of Gen X, "major milestone in fusion energy" has gotten the bogobit enabled by this point.
> this is the dream technology of the far future we're talking about. it doesnt even need to happen for 1000 years. if we nail it we are set for Billions of years. but obviously people are not accustomed or incentivized to think about things on that sort of timeline.
The main two issues I see with this are:
1. Maintaining a civilization capable of performing fusion research for 1000 years is an open problem
2. The estimates for how long fusion energy will last us are wildly optimistic. When you say "billions" I hear "maybe several thousand." At one point there was enough petroleum on this planet to replace all the whale-oil in use for thousands of years, and look at where we are now. Providing energy for several thousand years is great! But if we are going to think about "that sort of timeline" then fusion is a bridge-technology and with the improvements in renewables and chemical energy storage over my lifetime (which have been nothing short of astonishing!), I'm starting to suspect that it's an unneeded bridge.
As far as "appreciate anything that might only help the next generations" I think if we are still significantly burning fossil fuels 40 years from now, the next generations are in for a lot of pain even if the very next day they get replaced by fusion, so fusion just feels like it's coming too late to make a major impact.
Fusion is an energy solution that would set us up for billions of years. If we figure it out any time in the next millennium we'll have hit the jackpot.
Your take is like getting upset someone mentioned computing but didn't talk about javascript. You'd rather articles not be written about fusion until it's ready to heat your frozen pizza? God forbid we flood the news cycle with scienific progress and detract from what Elon thinks about cabbage.
Edit: for those of you feeling slightly anxious you missed new Elon gossip about cabbage, I made that up.
Let's save some time out of discussion now:
1. The lasers at NIF are not designed to be efficient, and they are very old. Modern semiconductor lasers are 20x more efficient. The 300MJ wall plug conversation is stupid, stop pointing it out.
2. Dropping crystals and hitting them with lasers is not hard, we do it in semiconductors for EUV light source generation all the time. In fact EUV light sources do it at 100khz or more.
3. Power extraction from a bundle of hot material is not a particularly unknown problem. It's in fact how every power plant on the planet works.
Make no mistake there are a lot of engineering problems to solve. The "droplets" are enormously expensive, the "firing" itself creates debries which need cleared from the chamber, dt supply is not something that's readily available in large quantities, blah blah. I'd love interesting conversation about what stands between ICF and a real energy plant, not hot takes.