Re:Nuclear-fusion lab achieves ‘ignition’: what does it mean?
by cpleppert on Tuesday December 13, 2022 @09:30PM
(#33979298)
from a brief look, both publications prominently feature discussions about target survival within the reaction vessel.
Of course there are tradeoffs between MCF and ICF. They involve different sets of challenges to achieve viable fusion energy production. Neither has been demonstrated to have commercial viability to date. The consensus view that MCF is more viable is rooted in the much better understanding of how to comercialize a MCF reactor.
and
https://www-pub.iaea.org/MTCD/Publications/PDF/TE-1911_web.p...
actually layout some of the challenges. they are not as you state and there ARE tradeoffs between MCF and ICF. Most experts agree MCF is closer to realization, but that's a very well educated guess not a surity.
https://scientific-publications.ukaea.uk/wp-content/uploads/...
lays out some of the differences and tradeoffs
Even more interesting is to look at approaches which might combine the two: https://medium.com/fusion-energy-league/the-fundamental-para...