>https://twitter.com/cz_binance/status/1602510004795367424
>It has caused a bit of a bank run and cz says things are processing just fine (along with tons of 3rd party confirmations).
>https://twitter.com/cz_binance/status/1602676998094069760
>I know HN wants to see crypto die in a giant ball of flaming fire, but let's not lower ourselves to the point of just passing on FUD.
>Edit: -4 incoming. I'm going to leave this here because it is worth it. I'm not a fan of FUD and neither should you be.
I'm going to quote this full comment for posterity's sake, but I also think that you're a bit confused. You say that "it was pre-announced downtime" and cite a tweet from yesterday that says "Also done now. All resumed". In point of fact, withdrawals are not resumed, and a tweet from CZ today confirms that withdrawals are down and they're waiting for a US bank to open[1].
Edit: Shit, Binance themselves even admit this is because of a token swap, not planned downtime[2]. How is this FUD?
Edit 2: Withdrawals back online as of ~5 minutes prior to my comment[3].
[1]https://twitter.com/cz_binance/status/1602579499903852544
Thus the proper expansion of the initialism FUD is, (directed at grandparent,) "Facts U Dislike"
Yes, the downtime was yesterday, scroll up on the thread that I quoted. The FUD started with this tweet:
https://twitter.com/Travis_Kling/status/1602400700192985100
The point being that this is FUD, and HN is pushing something full of it. Which is gross and low bar.
If Binance does go belly up, it won't be because of USDC withdrawals being paused. It will be a lot deeper than that and will likely cover USDT, since the majority of their customers are outside of the US (or at least should be, legally) and because, well, USDT.
Hours after that tweet you quoted (which was at 12am), things are processing as normal.
With all due respect, the FUD in this thread is coming from you. Taking a look at Binance's announcement about the downtime[1], it mentions withdrawals and deposits both being frozen yesterday morning for a "network upgrade and hard fork", and that ended at about 11PM Eastern[4] yesterday. The withdrawal freeze that this HN thread is about only happened ~3:30AM Eastern today[2] because "[they] have seen an increase of withdrawals" and they needed to perform a swap through a US bank, and deposits remained available (a key difference between the two freezes).
These were two separate freezes that you are conflating into one.
>Hours after that tweet you quoted (which was at 12am), things are processing as normal.
They only started processing as normal at ~11:54AM Eastern, just now[3].
[1]https://www.binance.com/en/support/announcement/binance-will...
[2]https://twitter.com/binance/status/1602579775721283584
[3]https://twitter.com/binance/status/1602708590271385600
[4]https://twitter.com/cz_binance/status/1602510004795367424
Binance: "Hey guys, we're gonna have some down time soon for a fork."
Binance: "Hey guys, here's our planned downtime."
Binance: "Hey guys, our planned downtime is over."
Binance: "Oops, hey, there have been a lot of withdrawals, we're freezing them."
HN: "Oh wow, there was a run on Binance and now they've frozen withdrawals, shouldn't they have the cash?"
You: "Stop spreading FUD, this was just a planned downtime."
Me: "No it wasn't, here's proof."
You: "This is FUD, it was just a planned downtime."
Me: "... here's more proof?"
You: "I said I wasn't defending Binance."
Make sense?Certainly, except that isn't all that I said. After the above, you dropped:
* You: Here is a bunch of links of people getting withdrawals no problem.https://twitter.com/cz_binance/status/1602510004795367424
* https://twitter.com/cz_binance/status/1602676998094069760
https://twitter.com/Travis_Kling/status/1602400700192985100
... and I'm scrolling through the replies and not really seeing anything about anyone confirming functional withdrawals. But that's ignoring the fact that third-party claims of functional withdrawals are irrelevant to my point. None of those claims would change the fact that this downtime was not "pre-announced downtime for a hardfork on their BSC chain". Binance themselves have publicly confirmed this today, regardless of what you're saying third parties have claimed.
* Okay, so you have to click through the shared Tweet on this one, but this appears to be what you're getting at. The few tweets from people at the start of the thread confirming withdrawals all posted during the time that Binance themselves said withdrawals were frozen, and they conveniently offer no actual proof of a successful withdrawal. Scrolling further, there are other people who commented around the same time (or even more recently, since Binance announced they'd resumed) who have been having trouble performing withdrawals. Unreliable anecdata at best.
You’re 100% the one spreading misinformation.
Keep it up.
Actually it makes thing easier for user because now USDC and BUSD always calculated as 1:1 with no swap fee. Crypto pair are more lean since they only need to pair with BUSD.
Options to withdraw USDC still available and will use BUSD balance.
They've been extending this promotion for a while now...
https://www.binance.com/en/support/announcement/binance-exte...
Or maybe crypto has always been a "giant ball of flaming fire" and HN is just trying to discourage people from throwing real money into it.
- USDC is on eth, BSC chain halts impact USDC is like saying apple halted because android updated. Did not see anything to indicate it was USDC on BSC, but if so that changes things. If they did USDC -> BUSD, still should have 0 impact on w/ds off-platform.
- managing liquidity reqs via silvergate or w/e the USDC w/d bank is called is managed just fine without USDC down time by plenty of other parties conducting USDC treasury operations.
At best, this indicates binance has really bad treasury management and is cause for concern. At worse, smoke -> fire. Anything to do with internal treasury ops (fair enough, do a pause) does not have cascading effects on user w/ds
I'd rather apply a lens of FUD to hard problems than the latter.
An honest crypto exchange might see a "bit of a bank run" without raising any significant alarm.
What's so taboo about everyone having their own money in hand?
> In addition to acknowledging that free programs can compete with commercial software in terms of quality, the memorandum calls the free software movement a "long-term credible" threat and warns that employing a traditional Microsoft marketing strategy known as "FUD," an acronym for "fear, uncertainty and doubt," will not succeed against the developers of free software.
https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/library/tech/98/...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halloween_documents
edit: and for the record, I'm firmly in the "crypto is a scam" camp
An argument? Crypto is facing a crisis moment. An "exchange" which has never been audited and won't say where it is, legally or physically, has halted redemptions. That prompts legitimate questions as to their liquidity. Dismissing any criticism as FUD short circuits asking why we should believe their liquidity is adequate.
Temporarily, which is something that happens, for better or worse, all of the time with CEX, for a myriad of reasons.
It doesn't always mean that it is because of insolvency, which is what my FUD comment revolves around.
> Dismissing any criticism as FUD
That isn't what I was doing, at all.
Straw man. Nobody said this is definitive proof of imminent insolvency. Just that it raises legitimate concerns, concerns Binance has done a bad job addressing. The perception problem that itself creates is quite real.
More broadly, not all fear and caution is unwarranted. Telling someone pointing at what looks like a crocodile that they’re being fearful for not wading is technically correct in the most useless way.
In politics, they call it "misinformation" or "fake news".
In slashdotting neckbeard techery, we say "fud".
The term exists in all fields, but signals your tribal affiliation in your choice of symbol.
https://twitter.com/cz_binance/status/1602510004795367424
It has caused a bit of a bank run and cz says things are processing just fine (along with tons of 3rd party confirmations).
https://twitter.com/cz_binance/status/1602676998094069760
I know HN wants to see crypto die in a giant ball of flaming fire, but let's not lower ourselves to the point of just passing on FUD.
Edit: -4 incoming. I'm going to leave this here because it is worth it. I'm not a fan of FUD and neither should you be.