The cost of money (that is, interest) is based on two things: the time value of money, which is the concept that an amount of money is worth more now than the same amount of money later (above and beyond inflation); and the default risk, that you may not get back some or all of the money that you lent out.
As the world became more stable over time, the default risk also lessened over time; and there's a good argument that the time value of money also decreased over time, as the quickening of the pace of technological advances meant that lenders could expect more returns over a shorter amount of time. Both factors combined to gradually decrease interest rates in the recent past.
If you believe that we are now in a new era of geopolitical instability, it's reasonable to bet on this long-term trend reversing.
> As the world became more stable over time, the default risk also lessened over time
I think these are both saying the same thing from two sides - the default risk going down doesn't really mean anything in isolation. The implied context is the default risk goes down for the same rate of return (or the rate of return goes up for the same default risk).
Isn't this backwards?
In a world where money has no time-value, a world where a dollar today is the same as a dollar tomorrow, and the same as a dollar five years from now, then, if there's no default risk, you can pay me back the same dollar I gave you, without interest. Zero interest rates.
In a world where everything changes rapidly and I might need money now, I'm going to demand a lot of interest before I'll lend you my cash. Because I'm incurring a lot of opportunity cost by parting with it.
If this were a reinforcement learning problem, we might specify a discount factor. If that discount factor were near one, then we'd have a long time horizon. If it were closer to zero, then we'd have a short time horizon.
I'd think that low interest rates would go together with a static, unchanging environment, in which money has very little time-value.
I do agree, however, with your earlier sentence:
> As the world became more stable over time, the default risk also lessened over time
My logic is that the market participants have the expectation that everything changes rapidly for the better; that is, advances in technology have a deflationary effect and therefore people are happy to lend at a lower interest rate, expecting the same number of dollars to buy more later.
You can argue that airlines have not returned on the capital (it may be true, I have no idea) but there's clearly demand and utility for the product, as evidenced by nearly every flight being nearly or completely full at all times.
High interest rates won't stop VCs looking for 20-40x returns under high uncertainty falling for a pitch about how everyone will use this dumb website in future, honest. (It might reduce the amount LPs put in and get out of VC as a sector, but there's no reason to believe this improves VCs' judgement)
But high interest rates are a major problem for an airline that has a few billion dollars of aircraft to finance, and lots of passengers but at low single digit profit margins.
https://samchui.com/2022/05/30/worlds-top-10-strange-airline...
The same ends up being true for publicly ran things as well. Flint is a great example of a town that was not profitable and so Michigan stepped in and changed their water supply to decrease the towns cost (a scenario that would've been avoided if Flint wasn't broke, amongst other ways it could've been avoided). It's just that at the government level you can have many services that cost more than they take in (often because you just don't charge people for the service; which is fine) which get balanced out (eventually) by other "services" (often more general taxes) that take in more money than they cost.
If you live in a town and continuously it spends $X a year and takes in $<X a year, that difference is going to eventually cause a problem. Perhaps it means that roads will stop being repaired. Perhaps it means you'll have boil water notices all the time.
We're using up our life support system when we build a highway or airliner, not investing in anything.
Highways too.
Airlines are unique in that they're essentially a public good that we've allowed to be a private market (look at how often the government intervenes in the industry).
That doesn't mean that airplanes are pointless.
Airlines are not just a toy for the rich, in fact majority of the passenger traffic is shuffled around in economy.
We’re humans. We fuck shit up. Our goal is to do it only when necessary.
Also shut down the unprofitable state funded hospitals for people too poor to afford private medical care.
Even as someone who believes in crypto, some of the stuff being built is beyond stupid, and could only be built at a time when no real work needs to be done.
Like I understand Ethereum. I also understand basic DeFi projects building on top of Ethereum - Maker, Uniswap, AAVE, Compound, etc.
But once you start going a few layer deeper, you realize the sheer excess and waste. Like a project that allows you to wrap your leveraged positions in AAVE and deposit them into a dual-token vault and earn yield if one of the two tokens goes up or if there are liquidations in your AAVE or...
It's mind boggling that people thought spending their resources creating virtualization upon virtualization upon virtualization...
Somehow, I can't imagine something like this happening if you were paying 10% interest on your mortgage.
(Airline industry is a special case, eventual "failure" is part of the business plan, so leave those aside.)
You could make this statement about today's "unicorns" too, once you start excluding things. If you're cynical, be cynical equally. WeWork? Classic "greater fool" "let it fail after we cash out" company. Many others out there too. Crypto? 10000%. I'm sure there will be a bunch of "obvious failure in retrospect" companies in a large-language-model wave too.
Other businesses like this: franchise restaurants (many, many failed), motels, car rentals (you can see the gold rush in supporting the new tourist economy back then).
You can't have it both ways; either it takes decades or it's handed over for little effort.
You also don't need much capital to start a few small businesses. Obviously it depends on what you want to do. but it won't take decades to start a dog walking business, for instance.
All business requires working with other people, and other people have money. I started selling hair products in tandem with some guy I met at a men's shed when I was unemployed. The "right connections" isn't limited to your notion of "upper class" whatever that might be.
Is it upsetting that someone on minimum wage won't be about to become a tycoon overnight? Is it upsetting that people have to talk to others to convince them to give you money?
If you have a constant interest rate aka exponential growth that actually means you are growing too slowly in the beginning and too quickly in the end.
Even if you subscribe to the classical time preference theory it doesn't make sense for the market to signal that you need to save more today and then signal once the future arrives that you need to save more. If the interest rate were stuck at a positive 3% this would imply that people will perpetually ignore the present and therefore some of the savings will never be spent ever. I.e. aggregate demand will be below aggregate supply.
So no, zero percent interest is not some abberation, it is simply the result of low inflation rates and high rates of capital formation and the lowering of capital intensity due to software companies.
Consider also social and political stability. The variability of interest rates in function of societal cohesion was already observed hundreds of years ago, and seems consistent across timescales and geographies.
The major structural phenomenon which prevents the tendency for profit to fall is technological innovation which creates disruption and temporary periods of higher profits due to things becoming more efficient. However, now that technological progress is quite far along, a lot of employment is in service fields which naturally cannot be made much more efficient (eg teaching, being a nurse).
I don’t entirely buy into all the Marx concepts but I do think the tendency for profit to fall is an inevitability in a stable, functioning free market as efficiency and competition drive down margins. This causes ROIC to lower
As far back as the 70s (when interest rates were 8-15%), there have been random business ideas being started and shutdown (pet rocks, every airline ever, etc.).
We don't remember those because they shutdown 40 years ago. Today, we only see the successful ones that survived (walmart, fedex, etc.).
There's a legit question: why have long term interests declined over the past 500 years, accelerating in the past 50-100 years.
The answer to that more likely has to do with some very broad phenomenon: capital has been accumulating due to increases in energy availability. Human talent (that turns capital into something actual) is plateauing due to slowing of population growth.
Testable Prediction: we will have <1% fed interest rates again at some point before 2030, because the long term trend remains downward for now.