It seems reasonable to survey or research bank robbers with intention of making their further attempts as miserable as possible and as unattractive as possible.
In the same way I expect that any good privacy related regulation will be analysing and researching what FB/Google/etc is doing and designing policy to outlaw their undesirable data gathering.
I think what's being characterized as crazy is that the laws as written are at best vague. It takes years to find out what they actually mean in implementable detail. This makes it very difficult to comply.
Have you read through GDPR? I have. It talks a lot about "reasonable measures" and includes vast swaths of other laws while being very light on details. Compare to, for example, electrical codes. Those tend to be quite specific and clear with sharply limited room for interpretation.
With this in mind, I can see why someone might regard this as an insane way to create laws.
In the context of GDPR? I was left guessing what a regulator in Brussels might consider reasonable when their path to career advancement might run through my employer. Coupled with being uncertain what various national regulators (or empowered industry bodies) might add in, as they were allowed to do so until quite literally the last second. It left a person with no good way of judging what might be considered reasonable, only nervous paranoia.
It was a distinctly unpleasant experience and one I was left thinking was both anticipated and avoidable.
GDPR is a radical step forward considering how poor the situation was. We're talking about a fundamental right to privacy. It was absolutely expected that it would shake some businesses, that's why it was announced years before implementation. Also, the courts don't come suddenly stab companies in the back out of nowhere. There was and there is a lot of pedagogy around it and usually the cases escalates gradually with warnings. The ones getting fines are clearly the ones who are still trying to do it the old way.
It is really not hard at all to comply with GDPR. Don't collect private informations you don't need, and don't share them.
Now what's hard is to build a system that complies with GDPR's letter _and_ breaks GDPR's intent. And you know what? That's intended.
The problem is, not all personal data corresponds to the intuitive notion of "private informations". For instance, I, as a U.S. citizen, would be violating the GDPR if I operated a dumb HTTP server that stores request logs indefinitely and does no other processing, such as "python3 -m http.server". (IP addresses are personal data, and U.S. authorities can make me turn over my logs; thus, I cannot store the logs for however long I want.)
Even when you have clear legal obligations to collect a bunch of private data, you still have to figure what reasonable measures to protect it are. What's a reasonable measure when you're obligated to keep seven years of financial records about your customers in a way that lets you produce ready reports for regulators? Complete with mandatory personal identifiers for tax purposes?
GDPR is not just about being obligated to ask for consent. Its requirements go a great deal further. Probably. Maybe. Depending on what someone unknown with an unknown background considers reasonable based on unknown factors.
I'm sure that will be easy to write requirements around. Right?
so when you say a crazy way of making laws, you mean the way that laws basically get made?
>No regulator has had the idea of just going to Facebook,
pretty sure there was all sorts of conversations with Facebook and others over at least 5 years where it was quite clear people wanted to fix privacy issues and it was also clear that it was in Facebook's financial interest that it not get fixed.
>tried to draft a forward-looking law that will make the whole system better?
Facebook doesn't want the system better, Facebook wants the system to benefit them. At some point these things are incompatible. No body has gone to a bank robber and tried to discuss with them how to best draft the laws on how to stop the robbing of banks, because of an intuitive understanding that it is not the bank robber's intention to help stop the robbing of banks.
So when the law gets made to stop the robbing of banks, the bank robber than goes ahead and breaks it.
Or in the case of Facebook they say we are obeying the law! But still try to do what the law wants them not to do.
But I think this is the core of our disagreement here >according to their fair reading of that law
I would say according to their desire to get around that law.