News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by whatshisface on Thursday December 08, 2022 @03:42PM (#33913079)
RTS newbies get immediately destroyed because RTSes are mostly dead, meaning that all online players have been playing it for decades and know a lot. An RTS with a steady influx of new players and matchmaking would work just fine, if anyone were to get one going.
Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by JadoJodo on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:11PM (#33913484)
Does SC2 do rank based matchmaking?
Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by bombcar on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:20PM (#33913590)
It does (and at least when it came out) it was relatively decent.

The problem occurs when the game has been out long enough that all the active players are leagues ahead of a new player; either they wait forever for a match or get steamrolled.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by vkou on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:52PM (#33915514)
There's plenty of people playing SC2 online at ~every skill level, right now. Queue times are not long at all.

The main problem is that it's a 12 year-old game, that's been largely abandoned by the developer. The other main problem is that unlike a skill-based MOBA, you can't blame anyone else for your losses. The third main problem is that the game is incredibly stressful, demands 100% of your attention, and the smallest mistake can lose the game for you.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by throwaway0x7E6 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:37PM (#33917129)
>The main problem is that it's a 12 year-old game, that's been largely abandoned by the developer

my brother in Christ, you got it backwards - being abandoned is the biggest blessing an old Blizzard game can receive.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by 411111111111111 on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:35AM (#33920205)
Can you imagine a modern remake with up to date blizzard strategies?

They'd probably add commander level and equipable commander items which grant buffs to your units. You'd have a chance of getting one item each time you win a pvp fight and you can increase the quality/rarity of the drop by using cash shop items. Oh, and the rare items might require a higher commander level... Obviously you'd also be able to buy temporary buffs to your XP gain, so you can equip them sooner.

They could maybe even focus more on group pvp (i.e. 4vs4) so the whales can carry scrubs to wins. That would give them a chance of loot even if they're just there to be farmed and will make them properly fawn over the mighty whales that let them gain their pointless upgrades.

Perfect whale farm.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by cwillu on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:10PM (#33916525)
This doesn't invalidate your point, but it's worth noting that SC2 had a significant balance patch released yesterday.
Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by vkou on Thursday December 08, 2022 @11:43PM (#33917544)
Sure, and it's had a minor, but excellent balance patch earlier in the year, but it's also been more-or-less abandoned for a few years, and is quite clearly not being actively developed.
Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by htag on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:35PM (#33917115)
The patch was put on the Player Test Realm (PTR), which is almost like an open beta. I wouldn't say that it was "released", more like pushed to staging or open beta.
Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by plushpuffin on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:42PM (#33913922)
Back when I played it, there was a 50 game skill test for new players which determined which of the major rank pools you were placed in.

Those first 50 games were crazy because you were matched randomly with other new and established players, so sometimes you would play someone really good who would steamroll you in the first 5 minutes, and sometimes you got someone who had at most played the scripted campaigns against the AI and thought they could sit there for the first 30 minutes slowly building up an army.

It was actually pretty fun not knowing which way it would go, and whenever we matched with newbies my partner and I got to experiment with a bunch of different strategies that would never work in a real game.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by babypuncher on Thursday December 08, 2022 @05:08PM (#33914350)
> played the scripted campaigns against the AI and thought they could sit there for the first 30 minutes slowly building up an army.

This right here is my fundamental problem with multiplayer RTS games. The fun I get out of them is in the slow burn long buildup, but other players always find ways to optimize the early game so they win fast and never actually get to the fun part where everyone has massive bases lobbing nukes at eachother. The fun way to play is not the optimal way to play.

It's now been about 10 years since I've even bothered trying an RTS online.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by zemvpferreira on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:37PM (#33915377)
I don't mean to be rude (I'm a very bad Starcraft II enthusiast) but most people who complain about this problem seem to want to play a solo game for 30 minutes and then eventually meet the other player in the field of battle at the half-hour mark. That's an obvious no-go, you can't ignore 90% of the game and expect to have fun.

The way to beat players who play strong openers is to play a strong opener yourself, but not necessarily all-in aggressive. If you want to get to the late game you enjoy you must get better at the early game. Harass the other guy early, scout their build, make sure you're building counters to what the other player is playing. Defend well. Deny their economy here and there. Inevitably crush them with nukes and capital ships after 30 minutes of solid fundamentals.

(Starcraft is still a lot of fun and I'd encourage you to get back in to RTS playing)

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by turtledragonfly on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:45PM (#33915462)
> you can't ignore 90% of the game and expect to have fun.

I think maybe what you meant to say was "... and expect to _win_"

Plenty of people have fun turtling (:

This is one thing I liked about Total Annihilation — defense tech was relatively strong, so some amount of turtling and racing to get high tech artillery (eg) was a viable approach.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by gusgus01 on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:28PM (#33915837)
There's plenty of turtling for Terran and Protoss in SC2. Defense tech like cannons, planetarys, shield batteries, and bunkers help. It's definitely not fool proof but is classically something people struggle against.

I think a larger issue is that there's like 3-5 games to get ranked and then a bit more to get really ranked properly. And by SC2 design the early game is resource constrained so decisions are important and even with the right decisions execution is hard.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by LawTalkingGuy on Friday December 09, 2022 @02:36AM (#33918679)
Try playing Supreme Commander: Forged Alliance Forever - it's a Total Annihilation sequel that's now community supported. It's got a decent AI and an active community of all levels. It's on Steam and often goes on sale.

Watch a few games on Youtube.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by zemvpferreira on Friday December 09, 2022 @05:11AM (#33919661)
Well, honestly both! SC2 in particular is a game of rock-paper-scissors, you must know what your opponent is building in order to stay alive. If you turtle blindly against a half-decent player you'll get eaten alive.
Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by ptudan on Thursday December 08, 2022 @07:03PM (#33915619)
I used to play Age of Empires in treaty mode. You had XX minutes where you couldn't attack one another so just focused super hard on macro. Utter chaos when the treaty period ended as everyone had max size armies. Lagged the hell out of my computer. Good times

It was a fairly popular variant of the game too, never had trouble finding matches

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by plushpuffin on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:07PM (#33915050)
Yeah I've felt the same way at times, especially when the armor/weapon types make it very rock paper scissors. It wasn't as blatant in the original StarCraft, but WarCraft 3 and StarCraft 2 seemed to go hard into counters against certain types of units, so someone who either scouts a bit better than you do or picks an army composition that happens to perfectly counter yours will mop the floor with you.

My partner and I had way more fun in those early games when we could stretch it out to 30-60 minutes sometimes. Once you're playing against ranked people who are there to win it's just a mad rush to the first or second tech tier.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by creakingstairs on Friday December 09, 2022 @01:20AM (#33918190)
> It wasn't as blatant in the original StarCraft

It was pretty much the same as SC2, they just never told you in the UI. e.g. Dragoons do half damage to mutalisks. Yamato cannons don’t kill zealots.

Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by plushpuffin on Friday December 09, 2022 @07:29AM (#33920516)
Yeah, I was aware of the different armor types in SC1, but I thought they turned it up to 11 in SC2. Maybe they brought it down to the first 2 tiers of units? It didn't feel like armor types really came into play as early in the game. The impression I got was that you could get away with massing a single type of unit much more easily in SC1.
Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by pradn on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:36PM (#33915370)
There's a game mode in AoE2DE where everyone's behind strong walls at the start. It takes a while to be able to bring them down. So you get to turtle for a while. A game mode like this is what you'd like to play.
Re:FTC seeks to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision ... by htag on Thursday December 08, 2022 @10:36PM (#33917126)
It's more like 10 or 15 games before your MMR is pretty accurate.