Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by UncleEntity on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @03:24PM
(#33899749)
I think it’s labeled “uninstall”.
At some point people have to take responsibility for their own actions and realize government regulators aren’t their sugar daddies in charge of making sure they don’t do anything self destructive. If that’s what sugar daddies do, no clue?
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by com on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @03:38PM
(#33899895)
The argument is akin to the bans on toxic chemicals in domestic products. It worked for lead, mercury, asbestos and a host of other things. These have saved many, many lives.
Similar rules around predatory lending, predatory insurance, mandatory all-in air flight pricing have all done wonders for consumers’ sanity and improved market offerings enormously.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by nunez on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @04:33PM
(#33900596)
there's a difference between "taking responsibility for your own actions" and "designing a platform that is expressly designed to be addicting enough to subvert that responsibility"
chief example: infinite scroll.
why does content need to scroll infinitely other than to keep eyeballs on the site and make it easy to lose track of time?
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by deadly_syn on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @03:36PM
(#33899874)
Unfortunately, I personally dont think the average person is that capable of self regulation at this point. Social media culture has become a cornerstone for genz and late millenials, and is designed to make these dark patterns work on you better.
Meaning in future this issue might actuslly compound. And i dont think any of this is malicious intentionally. I think its just self serving assholes exploiting whatever gets them what they want.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by WastingMyTime89 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @04:07PM
(#33900252)
How can we talk about uninstalling when Facebook has shadow profils based on your friends and monitor your traffic outside of Facebook without you agreeing to it via the share buttons? And don’t tell me you can use a complex technical solution to avoid it. The EU is legislating for the average user, not people who can block JS.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by frobolo on Thursday December 08, 2022 @09:39AM
(#33908306)
Great line:
“The company keeps delivering bad news to investors, who are not mollified by Mark Zuckerberg's promise to rescue the company by convincing all of humanity to spend the rest of their lives as highly surveilled, legless, sexless, low-polygon cartoon characters.”
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by hobbitstan on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:07PM
(#33897801)
I’m quite impressed that Facebook has lasted this long with its business model. A combination of being based out of the US, where legislators look the other way if jobs are being created and taxes paid, and the snail-like movement of European law makers and enforcers, allowed companies like Facebook to become highly profitable spy machines.
It was never going to last, but it lasted far longer than I thought it would. Just look at TikTok as an example. A literal spy app by communist China that experts have been warning about for years, and it’s still functioning with little resistance. Amazing.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by Hamcha on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:15PM
(#33902819)
The current tech industry really needs a big change, I'm dead tired of all these companies putting profitability as "some VC's problem down the line". We keep seeing companies offering products at a loss, then dying and leaving their users in the mud as they scramble to raise prices above reason.
Why do I, as a customer, need to worry if the company providing me a service is making enough money?
The average person doesn't care about this ofc, or how they're being emotionally manipulated to reach some engagement metric.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by greatgib on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @09:31PM
(#33903367)
The fb and ad-tech argument will be that "non-customized" ads are bad because of the low match with user interests.
So one ad will cost you a lot more displays for getting a click/worth view.
But this is maybe not a bad thing in itself. When you see the benefits that google, Facebook and co can extract from ads, you can see that the 'pay per views'/'pay per click' rate is probably way too expensive compared to the marginal costs of running the business.
So, contrary to people saying that this will kill all the business financing with ads, I think that it could be a good reset to still be effective but just with less margin for big ad techs.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by lofaszvanitt on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:24PM
(#33902887)
Someone in the know should enlighten us whether these measures have any benefit after years and years of practice? Meaning the mentioned companies already got what they were after. I mean humans rarely change, they got the behavioural patterns needed and now they don't want anyone else to get this data and these restrictions are actually helping big tech or this data quickly deteriorates and fresh data on humans is needed all the time, so it's useful after all for Europeans.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by fxtentacle on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:35PM
(#33902505)
"if you're planning to steal 700 pieces of information from me and then use it in 700 ways, you need to ask me 1,400 questions and get a Yes to each of them."
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by tinalumfoil on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @02:41PM
(#33899179)
While it's possible the US just has more tech companies, I think it should be pointed out the top fines here are to Amazon Inc, Meta Platforms Inc, Meta Platforms Inc, WhatsApp Inc (owned by Meta), Google LLC, Facebook Ireland Ltd, Google Ireland Ltd and Google.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by WastingMyTime89 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @04:10PM
(#33900291)
Yawn. The US is passing straight protectionist laws and most of the American fines for embargo violations are targeting foreign companies. At this point talking about reciprocity is a joke. If the EU had modicum of a backbone, we would straight up ban American companies from sensitive markets and put tariff on the rest.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by samizdis on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:16PM
(#33897923)
I don't know of any EU corporates with the scale, reach and depth of US corporates such as Meta, Google, Twitter et al. Their dominance globally is going to prompt GDPR scrutiny. If an EU corporate were to grow to relative relevance, I'd expect similar scrutiny. I see no protectionism, largely because there's nothing to protect.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by vineyardmike on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:41PM
(#33898299)
What EU firms? The EU is starved in big tech, and doesn’t have nearly the international impact as Silicon Valley/ US. Many EU companies that get big move to the US (eg Spotify).
If the EU was host to surveillance advertising I’m sure the narrative would be that companies should provide services cheaply instead for the social good. While you can have whatever opinions you want on invasive tracking tech, the reality is that the EU never had their share of profits from it and have always been more critical of US based companies. Yes they’re protectionist.
Edit: it can be good for consumers and good for national protectionism. I’m not questioning if it’s good for consumers but it is definitely good for nationalism.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by science4sail on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:57PM
(#33898572)
This is pretty similar to a common argument that we see on HN: "Apple cares more about user privacy because the bulk of their revenue comes from selling devices, not ads".
The issue here is whether Apple's pivot to services and advertising revenue will corrupt their privacy protections. Similarly, we can wonder if EU privacy protections will vanish if a future adtech unicorn gets born in France or Germany.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by vineyardmike on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @03:34PM
(#33899847)
> The issue here is whether Apple's pivot to services and advertising revenue will corrupt their privacy protections
Considering the way they treat FB data collection vs their own data collection… I’d guess yes. Apple has a not-so-subtle growth in ads that we’ve been hearing rumors about, and I wouldn’t be surprised to see a suit from Eg. Facebook. Apple ads will focus on app content - which the biggest competition used to facebook.
> Similarly, we can wonder if EU privacy protections will vanish if a future adtech unicorn gets born in France or Germany
I think the bigger likelihood is that this cements the reality that no new ad-tech giants will emerge. If you ban geese, you’ll never get a golden one.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by 6510 on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @03:25PM
(#33899760)
It's not really a question if but if enough of their revenue comes from selling ads they have to push it to the legal limit. Companies are suppose to make money but do so within the law. Of course they do have to create their own policies where laws are oddly missing but I imagine more of that kind of fuzzy logic would be the last thing big tech is interested in.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by clnq on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @03:36PM
(#33899872)
> What EU firms?
All dealing with personal data, not just tech. Hotels, hospitals, retailers, banks, government organizations, insurance brokers, education institutions, and so on.
Re:EU to Facebook, 'Drop Dead'
by htrp on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:23PM
(#33898021)
>Facebook will doubtless appeal, but the writing is on the wall here: it's the end of the line for surveillance advertising in Europe, an affluent territory with 500m+ residents.
Left unsaid in this.... facebook will spend whatever amount of money it takes to win on appeal.
At some point people have to take responsibility for their own actions and realize government regulators aren’t their sugar daddies in charge of making sure they don’t do anything self destructive. If that’s what sugar daddies do, no clue?
Similar rules around predatory lending, predatory insurance, mandatory all-in air flight pricing have all done wonders for consumers’ sanity and improved market offerings enormously.
chief example: infinite scroll.
why does content need to scroll infinitely other than to keep eyeballs on the site and make it easy to lose track of time?
Meaning in future this issue might actuslly compound. And i dont think any of this is malicious intentionally. I think its just self serving assholes exploiting whatever gets them what they want.
“The company keeps delivering bad news to investors, who are not mollified by Mark Zuckerberg's promise to rescue the company by convincing all of humanity to spend the rest of their lives as highly surveilled, legless, sexless, low-polygon cartoon characters.”
It was never going to last, but it lasted far longer than I thought it would. Just look at TikTok as an example. A literal spy app by communist China that experts have been warning about for years, and it’s still functioning with little resistance. Amazing.
Why do I, as a customer, need to worry if the company providing me a service is making enough money?
The average person doesn't care about this ofc, or how they're being emotionally manipulated to reach some engagement metric.
So one ad will cost you a lot more displays for getting a click/worth view.
But this is maybe not a bad thing in itself. When you see the benefits that google, Facebook and co can extract from ads, you can see that the 'pay per views'/'pay per click' rate is probably way too expensive compared to the marginal costs of running the business.
So, contrary to people saying that this will kill all the business financing with ads, I think that it could be a good reset to still be effective but just with less margin for big ad techs.
That sounds about as fun as the Metaverse :P
You can see it here: https://www.enforcementtracker.com/
If the EU was host to surveillance advertising I’m sure the narrative would be that companies should provide services cheaply instead for the social good. While you can have whatever opinions you want on invasive tracking tech, the reality is that the EU never had their share of profits from it and have always been more critical of US based companies. Yes they’re protectionist.
Edit: it can be good for consumers and good for national protectionism. I’m not questioning if it’s good for consumers but it is definitely good for nationalism.
The issue here is whether Apple's pivot to services and advertising revenue will corrupt their privacy protections. Similarly, we can wonder if EU privacy protections will vanish if a future adtech unicorn gets born in France or Germany.
Considering the way they treat FB data collection vs their own data collection… I’d guess yes. Apple has a not-so-subtle growth in ads that we’ve been hearing rumors about, and I wouldn’t be surprised to see a suit from Eg. Facebook. Apple ads will focus on app content - which the biggest competition used to facebook.
> Similarly, we can wonder if EU privacy protections will vanish if a future adtech unicorn gets born in France or Germany
I think the bigger likelihood is that this cements the reality that no new ad-tech giants will emerge. If you ban geese, you’ll never get a golden one.
All dealing with personal data, not just tech. Hotels, hospitals, retailers, banks, government organizations, insurance brokers, education institutions, and so on.
Left unsaid in this.... facebook will spend whatever amount of money it takes to win on appeal.