News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by borbulon on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:20AM (#33893497)
I have a couple of thoughts on this but they're more parallel than in complete agreement:

1. I don't think we need a phone and a home computer. There's really very little reason at this point why they can't be one and the same. A device that plugs into a dock at home and becomes a home computer, and when you undock it it becomes a phone. And I don't mean the ham-handed attempts we've seen, I mean a full-on contextual OS switch.

2. I think the next major evolution in phones should be removing the screen. We need to develop a voice assistant technology which retains context and can "understand" in a more conversational style, but I think that once we've jumped that hurdle there would be plenty of people—for whom phone-staring is currently an act of boredom or filling time—who would willingly get rid of that screen in favor of a voice assistant.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by GekkePrutser on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @07:46AM (#33893694)
I think Samsung DeX is not half bad for your point #1.

The only real issue with it is that the current generation of their smartphones doesn't come with enough memory. Only 8GB (S22) or even 6 (S21FE). You need more for decent multitasking.

But I think generally it's pretty underrated. It had done really annoying issues in the beginning but right now I could imagine doing a working day on it. I don't because I am really a power user, but for someone with normal office use I could see it being viable.

I wish this feature would make it to mainstream AOSP because right now it's too obscure to really take off. They made a developer thing with Android 10 but didn't take it the whole way after that.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by bzzzt on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:38AM (#33894173)
> The only real issue with it is that the current generation of their smartphones doesn't come with enough memory. Only 8GB (S22) or even 6 (S21FE). You need more for decent multitasking.

Since we're fantasising about future computers I hope there won't be more than 8Gb necessary to multitask. I remember running Windows and Office in the 90s on 16Mb. Seems like the 1000-fold increase in memory was mostly negated by wasteful software engineering...

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by vel0city on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @10:43AM (#33895636)
My personal laptop has 8GB of RAM running Windows. It has plenty of RAM to run multiple chat applications, SDR software, a mail client, several browser tabs, streaming music playback, several SSH sessions, a few RDP sessions, a few text editors open, all at the same time. That's kind of a common set of applications open at any given moment on the thing when its being used. I'd say that's decently multitasking.

I don't doubt some things swap (pagefile, windows after all), but whatever its putting in swap is not noticeable. I don't experience stalls.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by GekkePrutser on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @05:50PM (#33901510)
Android is not really optimised for desktop usage, this is the problem. It doesn't have swap and it forces apps to reload instead, which is really annoying when doing work in multiple windows. Like I said below, go to an excel sheet to look something up, come back to the browser and it will refresh due to low memory. It's something that can be fixed but it's really inherent to Android's underlying design as a one-app-at-a-time OS.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by dboreham on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @10:52AM (#33895745)
Also remember using a VAX with 30 other people with 8 Megabytes of RAM.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by aspyct on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @09:21AM (#33894593)
I really like Dex, at least the idea of it. I've been trying to work off my phone for a few years now, my first attempt was with the Galaxy S6, some version of container linux, and a raspberry pi with X11 forwarding as screen. It was brilliant, though a little underpowered.

My main issue with Dex is the perennity of the system. Is Samsung going to keep pushing this, or will a native android version takeover? Or maybe at some point they'll say "well that didn't work out" and abandon it completely?

I want to believe!

Every year I get closer to being able to do my work completely off a phone. I also think 8GB of RAM is plenty. Most administrative tasks can be done on that, and for the heavy tasks, you could always leverage a remote server. Think of github codespaces, or modern virtual machines in the cloud. Sure, you need internet, but don't you always, for this kind of workload?

Yeah, yeah, I want to believe :)

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by GekkePrutser on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @05:48PM (#33901493)
> My main issue with Dex is the perennity of the system. Is Samsung going to keep pushing this, or will a native android version takeover? Or maybe at some point they'll say "well that didn't work out" and abandon it completely?

Agreed, this is also a worry of mine. In fact they did exactly this with Linux on DeX.

> Every year I get closer to being able to do my work completely off a phone. I also think 8GB of RAM is plenty.

Remember that Android devices don't do swap. What I see with DeX is a LOT of tab refreshing when it starts running out of memory. Which is really annoying when you're trying to do actual work (e.g. going to an Excel sheet to look up something, but then going back to the browser to continue filling in a form, but in the mean time this has reset due to a forced page reload).

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by aspyct on Thursday December 08, 2022 @04:13AM (#33905919)
Ah yes, linux on Dex was looking sweet!

Right now I'm using termux, which is working really really well. I'm amazed! I have this big PHP app wich runs perfectly fine on it, with dependencies and all, I honestly expected trouble, but it just worked.

As for the swap: yeah that sounds annoying :(

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by GekkePrutser on Thursday December 08, 2022 @06:03PM (#33915005)
Yes Termux is great. It can even do SSH key authentication on a Yubikey with OKCagent, with key forwarding which other options e.g. Termbot can't do.

Unfortunately the restrictions in later Android versions make it more and more difficult for Fredrick to continue supporting it. I'm currently using the F-Droid version which targets an older Android version but eventually that will become impossible too because newer android versions will eventually drop the older APIs altogether.

In particular in later Android API versions it's no longer allowed for an APK to load binaries from other sources and execute them there. Which makes the apt repository impossible. So what should it do? Include all binaries in the APK? Or distributute each app inside termux as a separate APK? Neither option sounds very appealing.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by aspyct on Friday December 09, 2022 @06:26AM (#33920160)
Well that's a shame. Termux is fantastically useful and a great addition to the android's ecosystem, at least for us techies. It would be sad to see it go.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by pornel on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:02AM (#33893856)
On the hardware side, it's getting close. iPad Pro and MacBooks are basically the same hardware. If only iPadOS wasn't like wearing mittens…
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by Aardwolf on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:16AM (#33893972)
I do like having both separated. Different devices for different use cases.

You also don't use e.g. the same pair of pants for swimming and office work.

Mobile OS's give you almost no control over anything, but you're forced without choice to use them and their apps you have zero say over for half the things today (e.g. parking, banking, choosing the color of your LED lamp, ...). It's great to keep that separate from my desktop computing workflow.

Unless I can bring my home computer paradigm to the phone. But are those parkings, banks and LED lamp manufacturers going to allow me to run their stuff on my OS of my choosing over which I have full control?

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by borbulon on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:28AM (#33894086)
You seem to be missing the part where I said a full-on contextual OS switch. To borrow your metaphor, it would be like putting on a pair of pants which turned into swim trunks at the pool, then turned into work pants at work.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by Aardwolf on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @09:54AM (#33894973)
But then what does the phone still do? Perhaps just act as a key for an OS running in the cloud that you can access from anywhere? Or do you mean to use the phone's hardware for the computing and storage? At the very least I wouldn't want important documents stored on something so easy to lose.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by borbulon on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @11:42AM (#33896562)
My gut tells me that cloud-based OSes have too much of a user-server lag? I could be wrong. I don't claim to have all the answers for this worked out, TBH - otherwise I'd be starting a company that's working on this problem. I do think it's an avenue to be explored, though.

But as far as document storage, Maybe the dock acts as a home server? Either way, it seems like off-device document storage is a problem that's been solved multiple ways already?

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by hulitu on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @09:44AM (#33894847)
> I don't think we need a phone and a home computer. There's really very little reason at this point why they can't be one and the same

My phone can only run some stupid games and some web apps. You cannot program on it and you have a very limited choice on what you can run on it.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by LegitShady on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @01:10PM (#33897837)
Addressing your two points:

1) One device that does everything will work well if it does everything well. I can take a laptop anywhere and have a usable computer just about everywhere. A phone dock works in locations where you visit often and have a dock, and I wouldn't trust docks in locations I don't control. If I want to work at a coffee store or in a car I can't use a dock.

2) Human design needs to be centered around humans. Humans are designed to rapidly take in lots of information through vision. Designing a device that removes the primary interface between human senses and the device is making that device significantly less useful. I would guess that 90% of the time I spend on my phone is spent reading. I don't want to be read to, but I already have that option if I want. Purposely ruining the device UI and its primary purpose in an attempt to reduce "phone staring" is directly hostile to users. Any sort of general computing device should have the ability to engage directly with your most detailed and useful sense.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by jxdxbx on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @11:00AM (#33895884)
The thing is, computers are pretty cheap. And you still need electronics to turn your phone into a laptop or a desktop, which might contain mini embedded computers themselves. Would it really be that much cheaper or even simpler? (Forgetting my nerd-type need to run a Plex server and so on.)

Like, with TVs. Like a lot of people I want something more like a display, than a crappy computer running a crappy operating systems, since I use my own set-top box and such. But I don't think the parts needed to turn a TV into a crappy Android computer are really all that expensive. (Also "thin clients" are often just decent computers themselves!)

All that being said I personally like the idea of having a giant house supercomputer like the one in Enterprise, with various tablets and such just interfaces to that one single computer.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by robofanatic on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @10:04AM (#33895104)
> I think the next major evolution in phones should be removing the screen. We need to develop a voice assistant technology which retains context and can "understand" in a more conversational style, but I think that once we've jumped that hurdle there would be plenty of people—for whom phone-staring is currently an act of boredom or filling time—who would willingly get rid of that screen in favor of a voice assistant.

have you heard of Google Assistant? It does exactly what you are saying. They do have a screenless device too. Also there is Amazon Alexa that basically does the same thing.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by eimrine on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @10:35AM (#33895527)
These things can not do anything except of delivering some adware to be honest. I will change my mind when it become possible to do anything in REPL using this kind of screenless device. And, of course, author tells nothing about online-only devices.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by borbulon on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @11:31AM (#33896366)
I'm not sure if you mean me by "author" or the article's author, but I think we have different base thoughts. Mine would need to be online.

I'd like to be able to get information, store information, get and receive calls, texts, slack messages, make appointments, etc. I started with "what do I want to be able to do on a regular basis, from anywhere I am?" Then I go to "does a technology exist which allows me to do that without a screen?" Google Assistant is close-ish, but there's still a lot of work to be done to get past "the Beat up Martin -> Eat up Martha problem," and TBH I don't think they're putting much work into it anymore, progress seems stalled.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by eimrine on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @03:49PM (#33900024)
> "author"

The article's author. I agree with the every single point of the article and I want to develop author's idea here because it resonates with some ideas of mine.

> I'd like to be able to get information, store information, get and receive calls, texts, slack messages, make appointments, etc.

This is what Iphone does maybe in the best possible way. My needs are: to write, to program, to use Vim and Emacs, to be as close to body as possible, to be able to control others computers and screens in my house.

> the Beat up Martin -> Eat up Martha problem

That's why author's poind about keyboard-centric device is timeless.

But Google was never close to the computer the author describes (in my opinion). Perfect listening (recognizing everything with no errors) is not a big deal if you already have a perfect keyboard but perfect sounding of anything happening on the screen is where the progress is absent.

Imagine working with CLI using sound only in such a way which make your CLI experience better than GUI.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by robofanatic on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @10:49AM (#33895707)
well, my point was that the technology exists. Obviously it doesn't replace the traditional computer or a phone but you can do things like making phone calls, setting reminders, timers, alarms, playing songs etc. for some of these tasks you don't need wifi connection on.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by eimrine on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @11:17AM (#33896125)
> my point was that the technology exists

> for some of these tasks you don't need wifi connection on

And all of this abilities are literally baked in chip. For example, if Google (or user/owner of the device) decides to change "OK Google" to "OK Alphabet" than all the old chips will be unable to support such a newcoming. So, I do not agree that the technology exists, these are way closer to speaking dolls than to computers.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by robofanatic on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @11:29AM (#33896339)
> And all of this abilities are literally baked in chip. For example, if Google (or user/owner of the device) decides to change "OK Google" to "OK Alphabet" than all the old chips will be unable to support such a newcoming.

Its not baked into chip, its software and gets updated just like your phone or computer when its connected to the internet.

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by eimrine on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @11:51AM (#33896690)
Software is too slow for this task, especially if that speaking doll does not have a powerful CPU. It is way cheaper to produce a lot of cheap ASICs which can recognize very fast only the "ok google" keyword, maybe few most common phonemes also, but otherwise it just throws recorded sound on the server. So, all the software for recognizing unusual phrases is usually running on cloud and the speaking doll has nothing to update.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by borbulon on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @11:25AM (#33896263)
GA doesn't do -exactly- what I'm saying. It's close, but not all the way there. The interactions and context would need to be seamless. And my experience with Alexa is that it's a steaming pile of garbage. YMMV.
Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by eimrine on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @08:32AM (#33894122)
> I think the next major evolution in phones should be removing the screen.

> We need to develop a voice assistant technology which retains context and can "understand" in a more conversational style

Former is about output device while latter is about input one. What is the connection?

Re:Reinventing How We Use Computers by borbulon on Wednesday December 07, 2022 @11:22AM (#33896217)
A phone screen is interactive, not output only. The idea of a conversational voice assistant is also interactive.