News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by deanmoriarty on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @12:47PM (#33804500)
I feel envious of these folks getting such a nice severance. It would be rather nice for me to be laid off with a great cash flow of money and take a long vacation.

Naturally my life is financially in order (no debt, no kids to support, no visa issues), so I recognize my privileged position, and I say this as a first generation US immigrant who went through many precarious visas including H1B. Envy was nonetheless the first emotion the article evoked in me.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by PragmaticPulp on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:24PM (#33805167)
> I feel envious of these folks getting such a nice severance. It would be rather nice for me to be laid off with a great cash flow of money and take a long vacation.

I can tell you've never been laid off before, because even with severance it doesn't feel like a "long vacation".

Layoffs like this are heavily correlated with a collapsing job market. Finding a new job right now is orders of magnitude more difficult than finding a job a year ago. Getting laid off also works against you, as many potential hirers assume that laid off people were among the lowest performers of their company. It's not fair, but it happens.

It's also not really a relaxing vacation when you're busy prepping for interviews, dealing with interview calls and/or flights randomly scattered across the week, and other interview-related stresses. The clock is ticking and your full time job is now to interview to get a job. It's also likely (in this market anyway) that any company you interview with would prefer that you start ASAP, so you don't even have a defined end date.

Getting laid off with severance sounds fun until it happens and you're faced with the realities, especially in the middle of a collapsing hiring market that has been flooded with 100,000+ laid off FAANG engineers competing for every great job out there.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by itake on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:40PM (#33805461)
I think it really depends on your financial situation and how you want to spend your time. If they have been saving most of their salaries and have years of savings saved up, then maybe they are fine taking a 12 mo vacation before starting the interview grind. Perhaps there are some side projects they want to work on instead.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by lm28469 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:38PM (#33805411)
> I can tell you've never been laid off before, because even with severance it doesn't feel like a "long vacation".

I've been laid off with no severance and it felt like vacation, so it might depends on your specific situation. It was my first job, in Germany, 70% of so of my salary guaranteed as unemployment benefits.

I didn't look for a job for like six months, I could have used the full 12 months as I was more than cash positive and still managed to save 40% of my income without changing my lifestyle, it took me two weeks to find a new one. That being said I'm not a "study for interview" kind of dude, life's too short to grind for that imho

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by ethanbond on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:42PM (#33805495)
> I've been laid of with no severance... [but with] 70% of my salary guaranteed

Uhh, yeah obviously that felt like a vacation.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by lm28469 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:24PM (#33806167)
Isn't it the norm pretty much everywhere in the west ? I'd have been fine with 30% or so with my lifestyle
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by kayodelycaon on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @03:42PM (#33807359)
Definitely not. This last couple of years Ohio really fucked a lot of people I know. The state would not respond to claims and their system would automatically close “old” claims. You couldn’t refile or reopen the claim after this happened. The phone system would play a 6 minute message and then hang up.

Taking the state to court for this while also trying to get a job would be difficult.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by smileysteve on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @03:24PM (#33807094)
No, definitely not in the US.

I was last laid off in 2015 by a large media company, we received only 1 month of severance. (Which was 1.5 months paychecks because they paid in arrears)

Severance and notice of small scale layoffs (company under 50) has no protection in most states. 8 person company offered no severance, but we had a pretty good sense it was coming a month away.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by amrocha on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @04:39PM (#33808151)
Well yes, the US is a shit hole, we knew that already. In civilized countries it's pretty normal to have good unemployment insurance.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by dionidium on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @07:25PM (#33810328)
This is boring flamebait. We all know there are differences in employment contracts between different parts of the world. This comment adds nothing to that discussion but a useless insult.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by amrocha on Thursday December 01, 2022 @06:00AM (#33814763)
This isn't "flamebait", it's literally how the rest of the world perceives the US
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by ethanbond on Thursday December 01, 2022 @06:16AM (#33814875)
Yes this is self-evident by the 48 million immigrants who live here. Incontrovertibly proved by the people who walk across continents to get here.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by lm28469 on Thursday December 01, 2022 @09:09AM (#33816383)
Meh it's a bit more complex than that, once you remove people coming from third world country and people coming for the top 1% jobs you're not left with many people
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by amrocha on Thursday December 01, 2022 @02:55PM (#33821788)
That doesn't prove anything. Yes, people would rather live in the US than in India, China, or Mexico. In those places the floor is just as bad as the US, but the ceiling is way harder to reach. With a working class salary in the US you can support your entire family in Mexico. That's worth living in a shithole for.

The European immigrants have a plan B. Yes, the US sucks, but they're only here for the money and can go home anytime they want. Don't kid yourself, nobody chooses to live in the US because they think it's better than Europe.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by dionidium on Thursday December 01, 2022 @04:32PM (#33823110)
"I feel bad for you."

"I don't think about you at all."

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by ethanbond on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @07:42PM (#33810549)
The US has plenty of flaws but note the US has ~3x the number of EU immigrants than the EU has US immigrants (relative to population of originating countries).

That’s one attractive shithole!

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by mrtranscendence on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:56PM (#33806675)
> Isn't it the norm pretty much everywhere in the west ?

In my US state (Ohio), weekly benefits for those without dependents cap out at $530. That's about 19% of my current salary. It would be barely enough to cover my mortgage and utilities, but throw in the car (payment / gas / insurance), groceries, incidentals ... I'd be in trouble. (And unlike some of the forward-thinking individuals who've posted here, I don't have several years' worth of savings to rely on.)

Edit: and if, god forbid, I became disabled ... my government-provided benefits would be something like $150 a week. They may as well give me a kiss on the cheek for all the good that amount would do for me.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by ganoushoreilly on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:55PM (#33806672)
No, at least not in the us. There are caps and in most instances it’s close to $300-400 a week max with a limit on how many weeks you can claim.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by wheels on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @08:12PM (#33810847)
It's capped at about €2000/month, but one thing making up the 30% there is that it's income tax-free, and your health insurance payments are a lot less (since they're income based).
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by NSMutableSet on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:44PM (#33805515)
It depends entirely on your life circumstances. It can feel like a vacation if your partner is still earning 6x+ the median national household income, you have ample savings and multiple years of runway for any immediate debts that can't become delinquent without significant consequences, and you have wealthy parents to fall back on on top of everything else.

(for the record, I don't have any of these aside from the runway, since I have no significant debts due to the lack of a mortgage)

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by kilroy123 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:10PM (#33805960)
100% agreed. This is the worst time to be laid off since 2008, maybe even the dot.com crash in 2000? I'm too young to know what that era was like.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by teaearlgraycold on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @06:29PM (#33809583)
Don't y'all have previous employers you could return to?
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by jbluepolarbear on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:16PM (#33805019)
It’s not that great. I was laid off in late 2019 with about 4 months severance. I was constantly interviewing and networking. And then Covid lockdown hit near the end of my severance. At no time did I feel like I was on vacation.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by paxys on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:36PM (#33805394)
Far from being a vacation, looking for a new job while on a deadline and in a down job market is much more stressful than working a full time job.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by roflyear on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @03:37PM (#33807286)
Well, in the context of layoffs... most companies don't give you any severance.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by AmericanChopper on Thursday December 01, 2022 @02:57AM (#33813553)
Happened to me recently, it was actually a great vacation. I was out of work for a couple of months, spent most of my time doing leisure activities, turned down a number of offers, and ended up with about a 20% increase in compensation. I could have done it stressfully if I’d wanted to, but why? I would have had less fun, and almost certainly arrived at a worse outcome…
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by adam_arthur on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:17PM (#33805049)
It's certainly not the worst way to go out.

But the truth is that good jobs are going to be very competitive over the coming months. Many being laid off now are likely to end up accepting comp packages far below their previous comp. The doors are pretty much closed at the usual FAANG types

I can say anecdotally that I've already noticed an incredible easing of the difficulty in hiring (while maintaining a high bar)

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by justizin on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:00PM (#33804728)
It's not the best time to be looking for work.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by sfe22 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:08PM (#33804891)
Exactly, the best thing to do right now is hold on to your job. It is unclear when the economy will recover and you may be able to find a better job.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by itake on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:11PM (#33804928)
With a severance package and savings like OPs, why do they need to look for work now?
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by shpx on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @04:29PM (#33807997)
If many of these thousands of tech people start just spending their large savings and not working, that could lead to more inflation.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by ar_lan on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:01PM (#33804751)
It's sort of the same envy I feel when I see student loan forgiveness. I worked a ton (30+ hrs weekly) in college, and 40+ hrs during summer/winter break, to ensure I graduated college with no loans taken.

And now to see loan forgiveness for people who took far fewer sacrifices (especially lawyers/doctors, who make significantly more than me now) - it sort of reinforces that working hard is a sucker move, and definitely discourages me from doing such paths if I believe I can just get a bail out later.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by pc86 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:37PM (#33805396)
If you went to school at a time where working any non-degree-required job is enough to pay for your college (like I did), you went at a time completely different than today. College is prohibitively expensive; loans are all but required. And if a lawyer or doctor earns less than $125k they can have the extra ten grand.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by aseipp on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:23PM (#33805161)
The vast majority of debt for people under 125k/yr who qualify for the 10k relief is the interest, not principle. The forgiveness is then effectively for a tax in this case, not the actual loan, when you think of it like this.

The federal government designed the federal loan program to make them money, based on interest. It has panned out as a very stupid fucking idea, in retrospect, and has made millions of people debt slaves for years on end. They set themselves up for this, combined with stagnating wages, making everything a joke. Everybody wants to talk about bailouts and "work ethic" but seemingly forget the monetary policy was set and managed by the federal government over the past several decades. They could have done better policy if they didn't want a bunch of bullshit.

It has nothing to do with work ethic, at the end of the day. It was a policy decision from on high, and the snowball was set in motion probably long before you even went to school.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by Sohcahtoa82 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:30PM (#33805289)
In addition to the income limits (that right-wing media LOVES to conveniently leave out when lashing out against loan forgiveness), the loan forgiveness was for only up to $10K.

I can assure you that lawyers/doctors have FARRRRRR more than that.

I worked about 30 hrs/week while going to school. I didn't take a summer break. I finished my BS in CS in 2014 with about $45K of student loan debt that I paid off in 6 years.

For me to get upset now about people having some of their loans forgiven seems weird to me. It reeks of "I suffered, so should you!" energy. It'd be like fighting against new treatments for a disease because a loved one died from said disease already.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by 1986 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:13PM (#33804975)
If you're talking about the Biden administration's student loan forgiveness plan, I think you've been a bit misled about the "lawyers/doctors" part - you have to be making under $125k/yr ($250k/yr if filing as married) to qualify for forgiveness, and the vast majority of eligible loans are undergraduate, not graduate. So it would likely be extremely rare for well-paid doctors or lawyers to have their loans forgiven through this program - unless they were working in lower-paid positions (think rural doctor or public defender - arguably exactly the type of roles we should aim to encourage people into with programs like this!)
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by minhazm on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:35PM (#33805369)
> unless they were working in lower-paid positions (think rural doctor

Fun fact: rural doctors actually make more than city/urban doctors usually.

[1] https://dailyyonder.com/pay-is-higher-for-rural-physicians-n... [2] https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/practices/primary-care-docs...

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by ar_lan on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:20PM (#33805093)
Thank you for this information! I did not know this caveat.

I completely agree, some folks drastically benefit from this (in a needed way), and I feel no envy or upset towards them. It looks like my thoughts were misguided.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by vineyardmike on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:22PM (#33805134)
> And now to see loan forgiveness for people who took far fewer sacrifices (especially lawyers/doctors, who make significantly more than me now) - it sort of reinforces that working hard is a sucker move,

Just a note for anyone else reading this, but you’re only eligible for the $10k forgiveness if you have government undergraduate loans, and you make less than $125k. Few high paid professionals will qualify, and graduate law school/med school can cost $200k+.

TLDR: probably still work hard. Welfare is for the needy, or corporations.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by bdhe on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:12PM (#33804940)
> To be eligible for forgiveness, you must have federal student loans and earn less than $125,000 annually (or $250,000 per household). Borrowers who meet that criteria can get up to $10,000 in debt cancellation.

Do lawyers or doctors typically earn less than $125,000 or $250,000/household? If not, loan forgiveness does not impact them the way you think.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by PragmaticPulp on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:31PM (#33805308)
> Do lawyers or doctors typically earn less than $125,000 or $250,000/household?

One of my friend groups has a lot of young doctors and recent med school grads. They are all looking for the best ways to take advantage of this, including things like accelerating marriage timelines to be a "household" instead of individual so they can qualify under the limit. Starting salaries for family practice physicians, for example, can fit under that $250K limit.

I'm not opposed to loan forgiveness for certain people, but the $250K household limit without a gradual phaseout is a baffling move.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by pc86 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:42PM (#33805499)
100% of "recent med school grads" make less than $125k. A brand new resident will be making $45-50k and the yearly bump is in the single-digit percentages.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by steveklabnik on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @01:55PM (#33805727)
I worked 35 hours a week while in college. I had almost six figures of loans once I was done. I didn’t pay them off until my 30s.

It is precisely because of how much that hampered me that I’m glad that others are relived of that burden. It’s even harder for kids these days!

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by mynameishere on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @02:26PM (#33806198)
There's no "reliving" of the burden. It is transferred to others, including those who already paid their student loans once, and those who never went to college in the first place. That is, all taxpayers and holders of government debt.

If the money was clawed back from universities, that would be fine, since they were at the receiving end of the racket.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by fortuna86 on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @09:24PM (#33811493)
People interested in what taxpayer money is going towards really ought to google where the majority of it is spent (hint: it's not student debt relief)

https://responsiblestatecraft.org/2022/11/22/why-cant-the-do...

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by steveklabnik on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @10:34PM (#33812012)
The government is also why we’re in this situation in the first place. Their fuckup, their bill.

At the end of the day, this debt forgiveness is a drop in the bucket compared to other things that the government does that my tax dollars get spent on that I would prefer it not be. If we’re truly worried about the cost here, there’s plenty of other things we could take that money from that I would happily support.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by csomar on Wednesday November 30, 2022 @11:44PM (#33812443)
I understand your frustration. The economy is a system of incentives; and if incentives are misaligned this will lead to mistrust and eventually chaos.

Student loans are predatory. Some people fell for it and some people avoided it. I think the question: Who is (or should be) bailing any of this; rather than making you whole or keep this system just because you are the one who figured it out.

Of course, it is the tax payers (the weakest and most easily accessible $$ thing) who will pay for this (either with taxes, government debt or money go brrrrr). This will further alienate these tax payers and lead to the eventual collapse of this economic system.

So I guess I started off trying to make you feel better about it but now you are going to feel worse (since not only you won't be getting the special treatment but you are also probably the one paying both the predators and the "less intelligent" people who took these loans).

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by Jerrrry on Thursday December 01, 2022 @11:48AM (#33818871)
If it makes you feel better, there is very little chance of loan forgiveness being allowed, and it will likely be in grid-lock until GOP takes the presidency in 2024 and kills it.
Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by bawolff on Thursday December 01, 2022 @01:30AM (#33813049)
Have you considered just quiting your job and waiting a few months before getting a new one?

Engineers are quite privleged. We make money hand over fist, more than enough that its pretty trivial to save up 6 months of expenses, and just quit, and do nothing for a couple months.

After all, there is no point in making money if you don't spend it, and one way of spending it is to just take a break from working for a little while. If a break is something you think would make you happy, you should do it.

Re:DoorDash Lays of 1250 Employees by deanmoriarty on Thursday December 01, 2022 @08:03AM (#33815701)
If only humans (me) were rational beings. I will never walk away from a 7-figure salary + RSU compensation at FAANG, no matter how miserable it makes me feel. Them laying me off is sadly the only option.