News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by toomanyrichies on Saturday November 26, 2022 @09:33AM (#33752942)
> Its then-president, John Widman, told the newspaper that it had stopped making mortgage loans because the paperwork was too much effort.

> Its single branch had three employees until this year, and didn't offer online banking or even credit cards. It instead specialised in agricultural loans to farmers.

> For a decade, Farmington's bank held around $10 million in deposits. In the third quarter this year, deposits jumped to $84 million – 85% of which came from just four accounts, according to FDIC data cited by the Times.

> The town of Farmington has just 146 residents, and is so small that Google Street View doesn't cover the whole town.

I mean, it definitely looks like they were looking for a tiny, out-of-the-way place to do shady stuff. That said (and this is a rookie question for you financial crime geeks out there):

Why buy a bank?

If you’re a criminal and your goal is to launder money, what does owning a bank do that owning a (for example) car wash or funeral home or laser tag venue doesn’t? Is it purely a scale thing? Given all the regulatory hoops you’d have to jump through in order to buy a bank, I’d think there would be other ways to achieve the same scale with less oversight.

Also, if you’re going to buy a bank, I get why you’d want to buy a small one (smaller purchase price and fewer headlines). But wouldn’t a sudden order-of-magnitude increase in assets or loans made (or whatever) set off a ton of red flags at the SEC, FDIC, and various other federal and state agencies?

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by chiefalchemist on Saturday November 26, 2022 @09:40AM (#33753010)
> But wouldn’t a sudden order-of-magnitude increase in assets or loans made (or whatever) set off a ton of red flags at the SEC, FDIC, and various other federal and state agencies?

Apparently, not. So then we should be asking, why not? Why did the SEC, FDIC, etc. look the other way?

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by belltaco on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:27AM (#33753392)
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by cratermoon on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:58AM (#33753663)
> Why did the SEC, FDIC, etc. look the other way?

I dunno, maybe we could ask the victims of the 80s/80s Savings & Loan collapse and the 2008 financial crisis?

Same song, 3rd verse.

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by fallingknife on Saturday November 26, 2022 @09:39AM (#33752995)
For one thing, a bank is necessary to issue debit cards, which is a nice way for crypto exchanges to bring in exorbitant fee income. Owning one would take away the scrutiny that most 3rd party banking partners would insist on.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by cortesoft on Saturday November 26, 2022 @09:44AM (#33753033)
It isn't necessarily criminal desires... there are a lot of financial things that require a banking license, and they aren't easy to get. This is why most fintech companies end up partnering with a bank in order to do things like take deposits and give credit.

It might be easier to just buy one if you want to do bank things.

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by throwup on Saturday November 26, 2022 @09:47AM (#33753062)
> Why buy a bank?

Applying for a banking license is time-consuming. Buying a local bank is a comparatively quick way to end-run around that process. In and of itself it's not a sign of anything shady - buying a bank is a pretty common part of the business plan for fintech startups that don't want to sit around for years waiting for government approval.

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by FormerBandmate on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:15AM (#33753298)
SoFi bought Golden Pacific Bank, a tiny, nothing bank, and runs their entire infrastructure off of its charter now. FTX was trying to expand into legitimate financial services, buying this bank up would have been a great way to do that if they were an actual financial company

That being said, SoFi bought the entirety of Golden Pacific Bank for $23 million, and they were 20x the size of this bank (as well as having actual mortgage infrastructure and a wide variety of products). Buying 10% of a bank with only $10 million in assets for $12 million is very weird, at the very least it’s a horrible deal

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by jbverschoor on Saturday November 26, 2022 @11:00AM (#33753682)
Why? He won't "officially" control it, but has a lot of influence (see all the other briberies, I mean donations, he did). SBF is one sneaky bastard that knows very well what he's doing.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by 22289d on Saturday November 26, 2022 @11:13AM (#33753843)
I think it's a mistake to assume anything connected to FTX or that SBF did is by default shady or criminal in nature. Like, if you found out they purchased their company toilet paper from Amazon - would that indicate some nefarious motivations?

Yes, they're criminals who belong in jail but only for the way they managed their balance sheet. They were also great builders who had awesome products and wanted to do all the great things they said they wanted to do.

Buying a bank is something probably every crypto exchange has considered doing, so they can have access to the financial system and not have to pay massive amounts of money and have huge headaches processing payments for their customers. I'm surprised Coinbase doesn't own one by now - or perhaps they do.

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by leethaxor on Saturday November 26, 2022 @11:24AM (#33753971)
If they paid 5x the normal price of toilet paper and they were picking it up in the middle of a desert then yes I'd assume there's something shady going on.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by e1g on Saturday November 26, 2022 @11:28AM (#33754023)
If they purchased toilet paper by paying 10-100x to a no-name supplier based in the middle of nowhere, and the same company is known for countless shady/fraudulent deals and non-existent financial checks and balances, then yeah that toilet paper has bullshit smeared all over it.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by jbverschoor on Saturday November 26, 2022 @11:54AM (#33754288)
Oh I'm all on the other side... I think it's a mistake to think anything SBF does is not shady. It's his history, everything that revolves about him, ftx, alameda, or his past is shady.

I think SBF was VERY informed, especially looking at his background. It's simple greed for power (not even the money).

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by 22289d on Saturday November 26, 2022 @01:18PM (#33755145)
What is shady about the fact that he likes to cook vegetables with oil and a lot of salt?
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by zzleeper on Saturday November 26, 2022 @12:11PM (#33754493)
Interesting. My weekend memory is not too notch, but I kinda recall that if something/someone owns more than 10% of a bank then it becomes it's high holder (top holder?) for ffiec/Frb purposes and then starts popping up in a lot of reports (y9c etc)
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by jbverschoor on Saturday November 26, 2022 @12:21PM (#33754594)
Here in NL, >= 5% has tax implications, but > 25% will make you a UBO. Not sure about the rest or any details
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by FormerBandmate on Saturday November 26, 2022 @03:06PM (#33756136)
Yeah, that’s what I meant by it being very weird. Assuming no illicit purpose, it’s a terrible deal, but this is FTX so it was probably a scam somehow, or money laundering. The bank appears partially owned by Deltec which is connected to Tether, there could be something there
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by cloutchaser on Saturday November 26, 2022 @11:17AM (#33753893)
Doesn’t really matter if it’s a bad deal if you’ve got $16bn of customer deposits to spend.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by jasonpeacock on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:34AM (#33753450)
The fancy new X1 credit card is issued by Coastal Community Bank, a local bank in WA state. It seems an odd pairing, that a "revolutionary" new credit card aimed at techies is partnered with a seemingly random bank.

Banking is weird. Like, how did they find this bank? What makes it better than other random local banks across the country? Is there a marketplace for these banking partnership opportunities?

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by theCrowing on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:40AM (#33753495)
price, morals, the usual.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by FormerBandmate on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:50AM (#33753583)
Fintechs can’t just start up and operate as banks, because regulations are really high on who can accept deposits (for obvious reasons, this is a post about FTX). They get around this by using banking-as-a-service providers, which are essentially commercial banks that accept deposits from fintechs and allow them to get cards and deposits through their infrastructure. The Bancorp Bank is the biggest one but there are a lot of them, I’ve seen Column posted a lot here and Coastal Community Bank also appears to be one
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by cormacrelf on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:05AM (#33753227)
The same thing is true of many extremely normal companies, which are sold to foreign companies wanting to list themselves on American stock exchanges.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by aliqot on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:09AM (#33753252)
Compounding pharmacies work like this too. There are people like Mikki the gambler (Spencer Cornelia's channel has a lengthy interview about this, with proof) who get the licenses and then sublet them in bulk.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by nazka on Saturday November 26, 2022 @12:16PM (#33754547)
I agree. I don’t particularly like FTX but it could be the reason. It also reduces the risks to be rejected instead of applying with your own company…
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by lordnacho on Saturday November 26, 2022 @09:57AM (#33753147)
I got suggested to buy a bank once. Nothing shady about it, the fact that it's a bank means they've got an insured deposit base, which is great for number of investment purposes.

Why it would be easier to buy a bank than to get a license I never got an answer to. Surely the authorities would not leave a loophole? But I don't know.

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by beefield on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:21AM (#33753345)
I don't think there are any loopholes in that sense. I can easily imagine you preferring to buy a ready team with existing infrastructure for regulatory reporting than building one from scratch. Especially if your financial background is from prop trading and you despise - while having zero clue about - how banks actually manage their risk and communicate with regulators.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by mcculley on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:19AM (#33753333)
There are many situations where buying an existing business is cheaper and faster than dealing with the regulatory regimes for opening a new business (e.g., gas stations, restaurants, liquor licenses). I don’t see why banks would have less of an advantage there.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by bombcar on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:22AM (#33753348)
It’s faster mainly. Bank charters take time, buying a bank takes money.
Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by 1123581321 on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:46AM (#33753539)
Part of it is that both regulators and competitors simply don’t want many more bank licenses in the US. So they won’t make the issue process easy even though analysis and background check capabilities have improved so significantly.

An analogy might be the old taxi medallion regulation in New York that had limiting the number of taxis as a goal in addition to qualifying cab owners and drivers.

It’s a frustrating situation because an organization unworthy of a license like FTX can just buy one anywhere in the country, but a worthy organization working locally can’t start a new bank, because they’d likely have to buy one too far away. Anyone who believes there should be more small banks is just out of luck.

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by olalonde on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:18AM (#33753323)
> Why buy a bank?

My guess is that it's because it's very, very difficult for Bitcoin/crypto companies to maintain bank accounts due to overly strict AML compliance departments.

Even Tether, which controls billions of dollars and is one of the largest crypto companies, was unbanked for some of its existence. I assume that FTX wanted to avoid that.

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by jbverschoor on Saturday November 26, 2022 @10:57AM (#33753652)
> Why buy a bank?

Same reason you do a reverse merger

Re:FTX owned an $11.5M stake in a tiny rural bank in Washing... by georgyo on Saturday November 26, 2022 @12:26PM (#33754645)
> what does owning a bank do that owning a (for example) car wash or funeral home or laser tag venue doesn’t? Is it purely a scale thing?

All three of those are very much focusing on _cash_ transactions. It would be difficult for any of those to hide wire fraud.

As all of those are references to TV shows revolving around drugs. Drug sales are usually done in cash. If you have over tens of thousands in illicit cash, you need a cash business to mix those transactions in. Clean cash + dirty cash = plausibly clean money. Did your laser tag place really take in 50k in cash a week? That is a harder question to prove than you don't work, where are you getting 25k a week from? You'll need good book keeping.

However crypto investments don't have any cash transactions. You need to make and recieve wire transactions. These transitions are likely legal but still questionable, and most banks will terminate you if you have questionable transactions. Owning the bank means you don't need to answer a lot of these questions like "where did this money come from?"