There’s a lot of important social questions to ask about the future of pornography, but I’m sure not going to be the one to touch that with a thousand foot pole.
Now, if you meant gross cartoons, yes, those get posted daily. But there are no children being abused by the creation or sharing of those images, and conflating the two types of image is dishonest.
Isn't the main feature of stable diffusion is that it doesn't?
I very much doubt the police will look at AI this way when such models do eventually hit the web (assuming they haven't already) but at some point someone will get caught through this stuff and the arrest itself may have damning consequences throughout the AI space.
This is a huge missed opportunity to actually help society.
What do you propose? The FBI releases a CSAM data set for devs to use for “training”?
Would you be the one to create the model? Would you run a business that sells synthetic CSAM?
Anyway, one obvious application: FBI could run a darknet honeypot site selling AI-generated child porn. Eliminate the actual problem without endangering children.
It's very unlikely AI generated child porn would even be illegal. Drawn or photoshopped photos aren't so I don't think AI generated would be.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_status_of_fictional_po...
Don't forget that pornographic images and videos featuring children may be used for grooming purposes, socializing children into the idea of sexual abuse. There's a legitimate social purpose in limiting their production.
That being said, this is a question for sociologists/psychologists IMO. Would giving people with these kinds of tendencies that kind of material make them more or less likely to cause harm? Is there a way to answer that question without harming anybody?
In the mean time, stay away from 4chan.
Apparently Facebook has a huge problem with distribution through messenger.
Since you answered yes to question one, here’s the final question: how do you clean up the release of the biggest CSAM collection in existence from becoming a mainstay on the HD of every pedophile on the planet?
This stuff is so hilarious, like how is it not hard to arrive at “maybe don’t distribute csam” as a basic ending point of thinking? How does somebody that doesn’t want to look at csam think that it’s important that they should have access to it?
I can't judge how likely that is.
I guess I also don't care much as I only really care aboit stopping production using real children, simulated CSAM gets a shrug and even use of old CSAM only gets a frown.
My (lol now flagged) opinion is that it’s kind of weird to advocate for the CSAM archive to move into [literally any private company?] to turn it into some sort of public good based on… frowns?
I swear every time I find myself thinking “Hey, stop being so cynical and jaded all the time”, I stumble across something like this.
This not a game release. It doesn't matter if it's cracked tommorow or in a year. On open source no less, it's going to happen sooner rather than later.
As disgusting as it is but somebody is going to feed CP to an A.I. Model and that's just the reality of it. It's just going to happen one way or another and it's not any of these A.I. Companies fault.
[0] https://old.reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/comments/y9ga5s/sta...