News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by akomtu on Monday November 07, 2022 @03:09PM (#33511660)
"Married people have higher net worths and are more likely to be homeowners" - homesless men are more likely to live in a tent, so the first step to get out of poverty is to stop living in a tent.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by snapcaster on Monday November 07, 2022 @04:09PM (#33512487)
This general reasoning error (or purposeful trick? always hard to tell) is in almost every single news article I come across. Almost every car accident happens close to home between sober drivers, so I always make sure to be far from home and very drunk when I drive
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by chii on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @05:34AM (#33529598)
And the chance of finding two bombs on the same plane is next to zero. Therefore, I always carry a bomb on the plane when i board!
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by DontchaKnowit on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @10:56AM (#33520378)
I don't get what you're saying here. Of course married individuals are more likely to be homeowners because they are far more likely to be dual income.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by lifeplusplus on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @02:09AM (#33528338)
Or they are married because they were rich enough to get married
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by blacksmith_tb on Monday November 07, 2022 @03:26PM (#33511893)
https://archive.ph/VFp4P

Only passing mention of filing taxes jointly (which isn't always a plus, but certainly can be), joint accounts and greater ease of getting a mortgage, etc. Clearly there are already economies of scale from living with roommates, but it doesn't seem too shocking that being married gives a lot of people a leg up. The better question to ask would be "does it continue to be in the interest of society to incentivize marriage by offering these benefits" - which may or may not be true.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by odysseus on Monday November 07, 2022 @03:58PM (#33512344)
Some of the answers from the article:

> “Married people may be much more likely to have these conversations around what goals they have for their financial future,” she said. “There seems to be something very special and unique about deciding to share finances.”

> Unmarried couples may be less willing to commingle their money, said Prof. Garbinsky.

The number one cause of divorce in America is money fights and money problems ( per https://www.k-state.edu/media/newsreleases/jul13/predictingd... )

Couples who pool their finances increase relationship satisfaction - especially in low income families - per https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2022-42962-001

Combining accounts is something my wife and I decided to do right away when we got married. It's way less complicated than the alternative. We don't have fights about money. We talk about big purchases before we make them. Since she's more of a free spirit to my money nerd, sometimes I have a little trouble bringing her to family budget reviews, but eventually she finds some time to talk.

Reviewing our budget/financial health gives us an opportunity to talk about our future financial plans, what we want to be able to afford, our hopes and dreams. And we never have to think about who's going to pay for what out of what account. The money earned in the family isn't "her money" and "my money", it's our money.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by brailsafe on Monday November 07, 2022 @05:25PM (#33513430)
Wouldn't your lack of bad conflict regarding money be less about the fact that you combined finances, and more about you yielding to the conflict and accepting its presence in a different way? Based on your choice of words, it seems like budgeting is a option rather than critical, so if that's the case, how would you approach things if both of you needed to have the same relationship with spending?

It would seem to me like combining finances would only lead to less actual conflict (good or bad) if you've both already synchronized your relationship to the money coming in, rather than a solution in itself.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by odysseus on Monday November 07, 2022 @06:42PM (#33514142)
> Wouldn't your lack of bad conflict regarding money be less about the fact that you combined finances, and more about you yielding to the conflict and accepting its presence in a different way?

A simpler way to put it is we communicate with each other our plans for the use of our money, especially when it concerns larger amounts.

And it's easier to think of it being "our money" when it's pooled in shared accounts.

> Based on your choice of words, it seems like budgeting is a option rather than critical, so if that's the case, how would you approach things if both of you needed to have the same relationship with spending?

What do you mean by "needed to have the same relationship with spending"? Whether we budget or not depends on our financial circumstances. In leaner times, budgets become critical. Most of all, it's a monthly opportunity to talk about the family's financial health and spending/saving/giving priorities. If somebody is spending too much or conversely, being too thrifty, we talk about it.

> It would seem to me like combining finances would only lead to less actual conflict (good or bad) if you've both already synchronized your relationship to the money coming in, rather than a solution in itself.

I don't fully understand what you mean by "synchronizing your relationship to the money coming in". If it's a fancy way of saying "we talk about the money we earn and how we spend/save/give it", then yes, we do.

I agree that pooling finances is not the whole solution. The main solution/bad conflict preventer is thoughtful communication and trust. To use a git/coding analogy, studies have shown the act of combining finances is a small (but important) commit on the trunk of your overall commitment to each other in marriage.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by brailsafe on Monday November 07, 2022 @11:25PM (#33515856)
I think your first clarification answered my question. It just seemed like you were saying something along the lines of "I'm interested in being diligent about the finances, and she pays less attention but occasionally agrees to talk about it" which would indicate there's some level of disagreement in spending patterns from the same pool of cash. But I think that was just a misinterpretation of how you initially phrased your comment and I'd agree with your last paragraph.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by odysseus on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @01:41PM (#33522604)
In most (but definitely not all) relationships, one person is more diligent about finances, and the other person is a bit of a free spirit ("budgets are boring").

Is there disagreement? Sure. But not at budget reviews - we agree on shared goals. More at the level of "I'm thinking of buying a ..." We check each other. Sometimes we convince the other to not to buy something, other times it's totally OK, and in a few, we compromise/disagree and commit. Each person understands the financial + practical consequences in that last case. The important thing is there's easygoing communication happening before big money actually gets spent (or not spent).

There's no hiding purchases (or accounts) from the other person. Everything is out in the open. There's also "blow money" / "fun money" - a sum allocated to each spouse that they can spend or save on whatever they want - no discussion necessary.

-----

(I have relatives that are both free spirits, and in that case, it's tough to see so much money flying out the window. But they keep their income up, and they also automate a lot of their savings so they don't have to think about it.)

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by aradox66 on Monday November 07, 2022 @07:40PM (#33514595)
Regular check ins, whether or not there is an "issue", is a good way to keep a big issue from arising.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by m463 on Monday November 07, 2022 @10:30PM (#33515602)
and a budget
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by bergenty on Wednesday November 09, 2022 @02:00AM (#33528302)
That’s stupid. We don’t combine anything and my wife asks for permission each time she needs to buy something. Works flawlessly.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by bradknowles on Saturday November 12, 2022 @03:42AM (#33571290)
That's stupid. We combine everything, neither of us asks permission for anything. Works flawlessly.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by ramesh31 on Monday November 07, 2022 @04:52PM (#33513066)
It's simple self selection, showing the class divide in the US. Marriage is an intentional act. Cohabitation is, more often than not, out of necessity.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by refurb on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @12:25AM (#33516142)
Not sure why you’re downvoted.

Causation can always be argued, but I think correlation between education level, income level and propensity to marry (and stay married) is pretty high.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by skymer on Monday November 07, 2022 @06:26PM (#33514001)
It could be that married couples get large financial gifts/boosts from their parents more often than unmarried couples. If this is the case, then the involvement of the parents in the marriage ceremony may be a major factor in this outcome.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by 1123581321 on Monday November 07, 2022 @08:44PM (#33515011)
I wish! Though, there might actually be a correlation here, since parental stability, income levels and education affect marriage/divorce rates, and parents with their act together would have more money to give, and more of a chance of a meaningful estate to bequeath.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by crazygringo on Monday November 07, 2022 @06:45PM (#33514164)
The article meanders all over the place, but from the snippets it seems pretty clear that they've got causality backwards. It's not that marriage brings financial benefits, but rather that people already in better financial situations are more likely to get married. The two key quotes:

> “What this means is people see an economic bar they need to clear before they get married. Couples wait until they have good jobs, a car that won’t break down, maybe even a house. Then, they get married.”

> Socioeconomic factors play a role in the difference between married and partnered wealth; the higher your income, the likelier it is that you’ll marry, a 2017 report by the American Enterprise Institute found.

But overall the article (and especially the headline) seems to have a bit of an ideological slant that is pro-marriage, which makes sense given that the WSJ is pretty conservative.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 on Monday November 07, 2022 @09:09PM (#33515163)
Divorce doesn't seem to be discussed (caveat paywalled).

That's a big hit to net worth what with legal fees and maintaining two households.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by treeman79 on Monday November 07, 2022 @09:21PM (#33515228)
Could be value system. Traditional people get married before moving in. That already proves a huge ability to wait for rewards.

Same people are Probably more likely to plan for financial success then people drawn to instant gratification.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by pyuser583 on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @12:10AM (#33516061)
Marriages have an expectation of permanence. This allows for long range planning.

On flip side. Divorce is really, really expensive for exactly the same reason. You’re breaking apart an organization that assumed it would never be broken apart.

Lots of people described Brexit as a divorce for this reason.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by renewiltord on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @01:24AM (#33516431)
Less access to the one true leveraged instrument: home ownership.
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by askiiart on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @02:16AM (#33516694)
[archive.ph/VFp4P](https://archive.ph/VFp4P)
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by WeylandYutani on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @08:19AM (#33518631)
Because American law was written by a deeply conservative Christian society and never updated.

My own country spent the last 40 years liberalising the shit out of tax laws.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by snapcaster on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @09:10AM (#33519095)
Which country? what did they do and what was the impact?
Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by culopatin on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @08:36AM (#33518767)
My gf and I share finances this way:

I gave her a credit card out of one of my accounts, the one with the best cash back. We use that anytime we are together. Restaurants, groceries, dog, flights, hotels, etc. the cash back goes back into the account.

For everything else, we use our own cards and if there are any balance differences, like when I pay rent from my account, she just pays more on the CC than I do.

This way we avoid sending money back and forth and we can track everything in one place. There is no burden when buying something knowing it’s fair for both without having to keep track of it later and ask for money from the other, etc.

Re:Moving in Together Doesn’t Match the Financial Benefits o... by PeterStuer on Tuesday November 08, 2022 @11:07AM (#33520513)
Woman more likely to hard commit to wealthy catches would be my guess.