>>"You can't take water and export it out of the state, there's laws about that," said Arizona geohydrologist Marvin Glotfelty, a well-drilling expert. "But you can take 'virtual' water and export it; alfalfa, cotton, electricity or anything created in part from the use of water."
Seems it is time to put a stop to a LOT of that. Fortunately we already are returning semiconductor & other mfg. Must keep this up...
Even if, and especially if, a mfg process is highly automated, it takes myriad layers of expertise to get it right. That is the LAST thing you want to ship overseas to your adversaries, which both increases their expertise in the field and your dependence on them.
Economically, it is long-term-stupid. Strategically, it is suicide.
The purpose aligned pretty much with your observations and the utility of this was involved in building a billion+ of devices.
I did see one case where it sort of made sense to offshore to China, and then only to have production near some other markets. The company literally prepared and shipped only the final secret input chemical and it's curing agent, to be mixed in a certain ratio, poured into a big vat, then cut into slabs. They were still wicked nervous about it, and I don't think the arrangement lasted long.
Even if all the components are made here, with all the materials engineering, CNC machining, molding, forming, fabrication, etc. done here, and only final robotic assembly done in China, that is still a non-trivial skill to program and maintain those robots. And at that point, it's only a few experts, so why ship it and not keep it here?
They made sure that the availability of components for all these global (mostly US it seems) companies wanting to rent time in their factories would face minimal supply chain difficulties, by making the component availabilities a local thing.
It's very orthogonal to all you mentioned, which I agree is logical. Also, programming the robots could be done domestically, then binaries of the programs run in the contract manufacturing facilities. Point is, I think what you emphasize actually has long been a priority.
https://grist.org/article/the-butz-stops-here/
many American hippy environmentalists cried in pain, since some of these farms are their birthing grounds; but in the mix was a hopeless morass of post-Civil War small holders with provably dysfunctional operations, and the promises of Big Returns for Big Capital on the other side of that fence -- where the grass is always greener.
American investors incl. Private Equity are still owning and buying up quite a lot of foreign companies. European countries are quite afraid of the pockets of American PE and VCs to gobble up the most promising or profitable businesses.
A great many countries don’t allow foreign nationals or foreign corporations to own land. Most you can get is a long term lease.
The land remains in America subject to American law which is decided by American voters. The value of the land can be recovered for Americans by e.g. taxing it and spending the money on services for citizens.
Not a libertarian anymore, but this sentiment has nothing to do with libertarianism. You also can't recover something like water with taxes. It takes years to refill those aquifers if you begin overusing them.
Thousands of years if not longer in the case of fossil aquifers. In regions where the aquifers are capped by an impermeable layer, rain water does not replenish the ground water at any meaningful speed. In these regions, using ground water is unsustainable no matter how much money you're charging for it or what you're using it for. Some of these aquifers were filled thousands of years ago during climate conditions drastically different from today, and these will never refill under present or foreseeable climate conditions.
Let people farm there using the finite water supply and they'll make a lot of money up front, but that gravy train has to stop eventually. But by the time the water runs out they've made a lot of money, and probably use that money to lobby for wetter regions to hand over their water too.
Tapping fossil aquifers should be illegal. If you can't make due with surface water and/or aquifers that refill regularly from surface water, then you should go somewhere else. Don't farm in deserts.
What I always said about the Bush wars. For the cost of those wars, we could have bought all of rural Canada.
US would be better off if land was owned by the people and reclaimed by the people after a generational time period.
Part of why China now has a imploding property market is that governments got addicted to leasehold revenues to keep taxes low, and so encouraged a lot of artificial scarcity. Affordability is much worse there; house prices in NYC are 10.5x income, SF is 12, LA is 13.
Shanghai has a house to income price ratio of 47
It looks great in China and Singapore because, well, the leases haven’t run out yet.
They’ve just started to in Singapore and the end result is “you have until the end of the month to leave and you receive $0 compensation”.
As a result they have to spend a ton of money on social housing and create massive disruption in the lives of seniors.
There is no free lunch here.
(it's quite bizarre how this story seems to have brought out a desire on HN for Soviet levels of state controlled farming!)
And nothing about our current land use and tax policy results in good land use. It can, at best, result in good land use for some of the people owning it, but that doesn't optimize for what is good for anyone else.
If you let the situation rot too much, the same factors that drove that revolution can result in similar political instability. I don't believe we are close to that point, though.
[1] Of course, ironically, a coup backed by a strong public desire for peace resulted in a civil war which was in every respect worse than World War I for every participant.
The other issue you've touched on is a mistake that even economists make, which is to conflate the freedom of trade with the free movement of capital. These are two entirely different things. If you buy something, that's trade. If you sell land, that's the movement of capital. You can and should have policy that honors that distinction.
About the time the TPP was being rejected, I saw this comic [2], which honestly is worth a read as it explains pretty accurately this distinction.
Another angle to this is debt trap diplomacy [3].
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triffin_dilemma
Incidentally the debt America is running up is ultimately owed to the Federal Reserve, which is a creature of the US government. There are major unsustainable problems with US economic policy, but Congress borrowing from a bank that it controls[1] isn’t one of them.
[1] As Dune taught us the power to destroy a thing is the power to control it, and Congress can assuredly destroy the Fed.
I can't comment for the rest of the world, but US corporations are certainly buying up farming and forestry land in my country, New Zealand:
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/united-states-buying-up-...
In Warren Buffet's explanation he uses selling farm land as this exact example.
Of course under free trade we would expect foreign buyers to own bits of land. The challenge for America: these are not land swaps. America is not buying up bits of land elsewhere. Instead America is selling these bits of land for trinkets.
The US Dollar is a global reserve currency. Which in the abstract sounds nice to have other countries sell US things in exchange for more US debt: but in practice that means selling assets. US Government Bonds or US Farm Land. Both are assets openly traded.
The issue is not foreigners. The issue is America is running up a debt and is selling the farm.