US would be better off if land was owned by the people and reclaimed by the people after a generational time period.
Part of why China now has a imploding property market is that governments got addicted to leasehold revenues to keep taxes low, and so encouraged a lot of artificial scarcity. Affordability is much worse there; house prices in NYC are 10.5x income, SF is 12, LA is 13.
Shanghai has a house to income price ratio of 47
It looks great in China and Singapore because, well, the leases haven’t run out yet.
They’ve just started to in Singapore and the end result is “you have until the end of the month to leave and you receive $0 compensation”.
As a result they have to spend a ton of money on social housing and create massive disruption in the lives of seniors.
There is no free lunch here.
(it's quite bizarre how this story seems to have brought out a desire on HN for Soviet levels of state controlled farming!)
And nothing about our current land use and tax policy results in good land use. It can, at best, result in good land use for some of the people owning it, but that doesn't optimize for what is good for anyone else.
If you let the situation rot too much, the same factors that drove that revolution can result in similar political instability. I don't believe we are close to that point, though.
[1] Of course, ironically, a coup backed by a strong public desire for peace resulted in a civil war which was in every respect worse than World War I for every participant.