Obviously, they are kind of big enough to do both — make a half hearted attempt and fight it all the same due to some internal politics. However, for something this existential, one would think that the smart people and the leadership would try to put some focus on the field. Was it that bad? Really, looking for some insight on what really went down.
The key that ultimately made it possible was the light source, and ASML is the only company that sells these light sources. ASML didn't invent the light source entirely on its own; there were a lot of ideas for light sources floating around and the only one that turned out to work was laser-induced plasma from tin microdroplets, which sounds completely crazy but it works [0]. ASML perfected that process (with -- to be fair -- some investment from Intel).
[0] https://www.asml.com/en/technology/lithography-principles/li...
Intel did fight EUV with a technology called SAQP which ultimately turned out not to work as well as EUV, but they were researching EUV at the same time. Here are some more historical articles about Intel's work on EUV in the past. Note the dates.
https://newsroom.intel.com/news-releases/intel-achieves-majo...
https://semiengineering.com/why-euv-is-so-difficult/
https://www.eetimes.com/intel-developing-euv-pellicle/
https://www.extremetech.com/computing/276376-intel-reportedl...
Was it just a matter of luck that ASML nailed the right one or was it the nature of exploring some riskier alternative (as you said "which sounds completely crazy but it works")?
There were several different light source ideas tried. Some at US national laboratories. Tin plasma was known to work but it left so much debris that it gummed up the optics so it was forgotten for a while. The key turned out to be tin microdroplets.
https://www.optica-opn.org/home/articles/volume_29/march_201...
Like anything, some of their PHDs were like “no that’s probably not going to work because xyz” and they trusted said PHDs.
It’s just science. It’s hard to predict.
Once it became clear that AMD and ARM (and by extension TSMC) were eating their lunch, they had great difficulty pivoting because they lacked the talent and the organizational will to do so -- at least until Gelsinger took charge. I have a lot of respect for Gelsinger and I think he just might turn it around.
Yet another example in a long history that modeling your talent pipeline as a JIT supply chain does not work in high cognitive input settings. This is a general unsolved management challenge: capturing sufficiently granular and comprehensive institutional knowledge to be able to efficiently restart organizations that rely upon it years down the line.
I don't think we will ever solve it until we learn how to share human mind states. The complexity of these high cognitive input activities at large scale has surpassed the ability of our capabilities to transfer comprehension between minds using conventional information transfer techniques (primarily written word and audio video). Even were I to guarantee the capture of all information at sufficient granularity, the only way to QA that is to de novo staff up a brand-new parallel organization, and have them reproduce the original organization's accomplishments. No one is ever funded for that.
This is a really interesting problem space for me because I suspect it is a dimension of technical debt very rarely explored because our species has not had to really grapple with it before as our technological progression has been slow enough we could "good enough" brute force our way through it whenever it came up in less severe forms.
The race to the bottom of physics is not a long ride.
A cursory Google search results in multiple search hits from recent news pieces announcing Intel buying their EUV kits from ASML.
If Intel is handing out small fortunes to ASML to deliver a machine that in the past Intel was expected to develop in-house, that does not sound like a success story.
Here's a Reddit thread on the topic:
https://www.reddit.com/r/AMD_Stock/comments/miar30/why_is_in...
The template is first printed on the glass. This is done by putting a light sensitive layer (photoresist) on the glass, and exposing some of it to light. When the light gets put on there the properties of the photoresist change so you can wash off the parts you don't want. Jl6 called this process "etching" (there may be additional steps that can also be described as etching, I don't know. Semiconductors are made with a lot of processes. This is the most well known process).
Then you spray on the chemicals you want, and then you wash away the remaining photoresist so you can put the next layer on.
This happens a lot of times for a modern chip.
[1]: https://en.wikichip.org/wiki/mask
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electron-beam_lithography
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wafer_fabrication
Here is ASML specifically, in a very slow slideshow format, representing our finest web technology.
https://www.asml.com/en/technology/all-about-microchips/how-...
The wavelength, or the color of the light here limits how much minified image we can shine and currently the Extreme ultraviolet lithography(EUV) is the state of the art where they use ultraviolet light with 13.5nm wavelength. As different materials behave differently under different light wavelengths, EUV requires different process to shine the mask over the silicon disk. One major difference from the previous processes is that in EUV lithography they use mirrors instead of lenses to direct the light.
So far, it's only the European manufacturer ASML who managed to perfect this process for mass production.
Where does it said that? They haven't even launched their first node with EUV yet. So arguably they haven't failed.
I am not entirely sure if Intel needs to overtake TSMC, they just need to be a good enough alternative. But I agree even that is a tall order.
It is the same with Samsung which arguably ship their 7nm ahead of TSMC. But with low volume, yield and poor performance characteristic it doesn't really matter. ( And I haven't even mentioned cost yet )
"We'll start with a focus on driving $3 billion of cost reduction in 2023, 1/3 in cost of sales and 2/3 in operating expenses."
"best-in-class semiconductor companies have a financial profile that includes gross margins in the 60s" (Intel's is in the mid 40's and fell last quarter)
So they're not only trying to change a gigantic part of their business model, but ALSO drive $3B of cost reduction and try and push gross margins back up to... where they were 5 years or so ago?
They're making it impossible for themselves IMO. Pivot or profit improvements, choose one. Doing both at the same time is surely going to lead to a huge mess.
Intel’s culture is that of a cash cow, not an innovator. So year, profit improvements come naturally, pivoting not so much.
I fear it is not in Intel's DNA to make this switch.
Okay I'll try to be constructive. TSMC is two things: The biggest contracting foundry in the world, and a leader in EUV application for tiny geometries. I think it's possible for Intel to become a contracting foundry; it goes against their DNA but Gelsinger very much wants to do it. So that's the first thing. Maybe it'll happen.
The second thing is much more problematic.
> Intel is still working on getting its 5-nm mass production going, and says it will begin manufacturing Intel 3 -- its answer to TSMC's 3-nm tech -- in the second half of 2023.
This I'm much more skeptical about. Intel tried to make EUV work before and failed. Still they seem to be buying ASML equipment and installing it at Ronler Acres:
https://www.protocol.com/enterprise/intel-euv-fab-chips
But it still sounds like a long shot to get it working in 2023.