News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot by xtracto on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:16PM (#33458629)
Say you publish a song and copyright it. Then I record it and save it in a .xz format. It's not an MP3, it is not an audio file. Say I split it into N several chunks and I share it with N different people. Or with the same people, but I share it at N different dates. Say I charge them $10 a month for doing that, and I don't pay you anything.

Am I violating your copyright? Are you entitled to do that?

To make it funnier: Say instead of the .xz, I "compress" it via π compression [1]. So what I share with you is a pair of π indices and data lengths for each of them, from which you can "reconstruct" the audio. Am I illegally violating your copyrights by sharing that?

[1] https://github.com/philipl/pifs

Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot by 2muchcoffeeman on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:21PM (#33458688)
I was thinking of something similar as a counter argument and lo and behold, it’s a real thing maths has solved with a real implementation.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot by Aeolun on Thursday November 03, 2022 @06:44PM (#33458983)
What you are actually giving people is a set of chords that happen to show up in your song, the machine can suggest an appropriate next chord.

It’s also smart enough to rebuild your song from the chords _if you ask it to_.

Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot by varajelle on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:00PM (#33459161)
I take your code and I compress it in a tar.gz file. Il call that file "the model". Then I ask an algorithm (Gzip) to infer some code using "the model". The algorithm (gzip) just learned how to code by reading your code. It just happened to have it memorized in its model.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot by Aeolun on Thursday November 03, 2022 @08:47PM (#33460204)
Yeah, and that’s completely fine.

I’ve seen this point made before, but it assumes you use the entire input as output, which is silly.

Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot by varajelle on Friday November 04, 2022 @02:44AM (#33462977)
Oh no, I'm not using the entire input, just a few functions of interest. And not the copyright headers of course.
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot by BizarroLand on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:03PM (#33459184)
With the exception that there are infinite types of chords in this case, and even though many musicians follow familiar chord structures the underlying melodies and rhythms are unique enough for any familiar person to be able to differentiate "Red Hot Chill Peppers" from "All-American Rejects", and now there is a system where All-American Rejects hit a few buttons and a song is generated (using audio samples of "Under the Bridge") that sounds like "Under the Bridge pt 2, All-American Rejects Boogaloo".

That's why it's actionable and why there is meat on the bone for this case. The real issue is going to be if they can convince a jury that this software is just stealing code and whether its wrong if a robot does it.

Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot by williamcotton on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:20PM (#33459334)
Re:We've filed a lawsuit against GitHub Copilot by obiefernandez on Thursday November 03, 2022 @07:23PM (#33459365)
This analogy is flawed