News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by dools on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:45AM (#33421880)
Imagine how much better the program could be if it were directly funded by the government instead of being indirectly funded by the government and enriching the world’s biggest arsehole in the process
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by dotnet00 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:52AM (#33421992)
It would cost 10x as much and would be 5 years behind schedule, intended to be the main vehicle for several decades (rather than soon to be replaced by an even more capable vehicle), entirely expendable, still stuck to its original parameters due to risk averseness and not at all commercially competitive. See: SLS, Space Shuttle (and to a lesser extent, Ariane 5 & 6)

Falcon reusability was perfected through lots of explosions in landing attempts, good luck getting NASA or ESA to risk that given how dumb the average taxpayer can be about iterative development like that.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by CrazyStat on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:30AM (#33422558)
> Falcon reusability was perfected through lots of explosions in landing attempts, good luck getting NASA or ESA to risk that given how dumb the average taxpayer can be about iterative development like that.

It's even worse than just risk averseness. There was a very telling comment by the CEO of ArianeGroup a few years ago[1] about why they weren't investing in reusable rockets--they were afraid that it would be too efficient, so they would end up laying off workers because they wouldn't have enough demand for new rockets. In the twisted world of government programs efficiency is often seen as a bad thing. Space programs are jobs programs. The SLS program was hamstrung by Congress requiring that it reuse 50-year-old Space shuttle tech because it's a jobs program. Getting to space efficiently isn't even a priority.

More recently ESA has reversed course[2] because SpaceX is eating their lunch, but they're still probably a good decade out from having a reusable rocket, and it's unlikely they would be heading that direction at all if not for the pressure from SpaceX.

[1] https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/05/ariane-chief-seems-f...

[2] https://arstechnica.com/science/2021/03/european-leaders-say...

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by AustinDev on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:51AM (#33422867)
This is exactly the reason I don't do R&D work for the DoD anymore. Cost plus contracts incentivize the performer to have more staff than required to make more profit and to never deliver anything early or over perform in any way. I just couldn't live with myself if I min-max'd the situation.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by dotnet00 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:31PM (#33423518)
To be fair, their concern about having so few payloads that they wouldn't be building enough boosters isn't completely wrong for Europe. There is some merit to the idea that they needed to maintain a large workforce trained in rocketry to hold onto their capabilities and that government funded programs are good for that until private industry firmly takes hold.

The issue of course was that they were giving into stagnation and assuming that demand wouldn't grow to meet supply, while SpaceX took it the other way and came up with the demand to utilize the supply they had created (also helps that Russia torpedoed its own commercial launch industry and all other providers are stuck in a delayed generational transition, highlighting the unpredictability of demand in the industry).

Now that European launch companies are starting to make progress, perhaps this need for government 'protection' will also go away. It desperately needs to go away in the US since we already have several private companies who've made it to orbit (plus a nearly 20 year tech lead on the rest of the world courtesy SpaceX) and hopefully SLS's obsolete-ness will quickly become too hard to ignore when the Artemis 3 crew is shown transferring from the cramped Orion capsule to the spacious HLS.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by pavon on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:27PM (#33424346)
And to add to this, SpaceX isn't enriching Musk, quite the opposite. Half of his PayPal wealth was invested into SpaceX to develop Falcon 1 (the other half was invested in Tesla). Then SpaceX was awarded a NASA contract to develop Falcon 9 and Dragon. All the profit they made from that was reinvested into developing Falcon Heavy, and all the profit SpaceX has made sense has been reinvested into Starlink and Starship. Musk hasn't gotten any return on his investment into SpaceX, and rather continues to invest more money (earned from Tesla) into SpaceX to speed Starship development.

I'm not saying this to play up Musk as some philanthropist, but to point out that SpaceX is a passion project and would likely never have accomplished the things it did if it was run primarily as a profit-making endeavor, or as a utilitarian government project.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by Vermeulen on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:46AM (#33421903)
You don't need to imagine - just look up the SLS program and it's budget + timeframe
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by thallium205 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:53AM (#33422017)
And the fact it will cost about 10x as much compared to SpaceX rockets to deliver something to orbit. SLS is a total failure.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by misiti3780 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @10:58AM (#33422101)
It's amazing how many people hold thing opinion (OP) when it could be resolved with < 1 minute of research.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by comeonbro on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @02:10PM (#33425035)
Ideological commitments that could be resolved with < 1 minute of research, will not be resolved with < 1 minute of research.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by pkage on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:16AM (#33422380)
You can blame Boeing for that, it's not like NASA is directly creating the rocket in-house. SpaceX is just disrupting the current MIC contracts.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:07PM (#33423170)
You can absolutely blame NASA for that. They are calling the shots and making the design decisions.

Its not like NASA puts out a check and simply waits for the rocket to arrive. With the NASA process, they own the design, they are in meetings on specifications, they requests tests, ect. They micromanage and direct work down to the nuts and bolts, literally and figuratively.

By analogy, they are the head Chef in the kitchen. With SpaceX, they are the customer at the restaurant.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by CrazyStat on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @02:58PM (#33425801)
A lot of it is above even NASA's level. SLS had a bunch of requirements imposed on it by Congress who see NASA primarily as a jobs program/pork barrel and want to make sure the money goes to the right places.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by malfist on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:08AM (#33422251)
Depends on what you consider it's mission objective. If you consider it a jobs program that we happen to get a rocket out of, it's an astounding success. If you consider it a rocket program it's an abject failure.

To give you an example of why it's a jobs program and not a rocket program. Congress forced NASA to build a multimillion dollar testing facility they never intended to use for the SLS nor for any other rocket NASA has.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by MichaelCollins on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:43AM (#33422750)
Even judged that way, SLS is substandard. As a pointless jobs program, the TSA definitely has SLS beat.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by nwah1 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:10AM (#33422282)
The point you are trying to make is that that government is unlikely to succeed in terms of timeframe or budget, and that is probably true. Yet, your argument doesn't support that point. SLS is also a project that is built by private corporations. SLS vs Falcon Heavy is simply a battle between two different government contractors. One is not more government-based than the other.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by nrb on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:21AM (#33422438)
Research how and where SLS must be designed, manufactured, integrated, and tested. Then research who designated that process and how.

Calling Falcon Heavy and SLS equivalently government-led is laughable. The amount of by-design government red tape and congressional district handouts is astounding.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by nwah1 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:10PM (#33424079)
SLS is a joint project between many large bureaucratic private organizations, and thus design-by-committee is more of a function of the way that those institutions operate, and their need to coordinate with one another.

Congress cared that it met payload requirements and mission requirements. That these institutions were unable to deliver within reasonable time and budget limits is a result of their own dysfunction.

Since rocket production is extremely capital-intensive, the market is very thin. The number of players capable of even giving it a go is low. And thus, it has all the hallmarks of a typical market failure.

Private companies the entire time could've realized the potential profits and competently worked to achieve them, even outside of begging for government contracts. That they didn't do this for many decades is their own fault.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by nrb on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @02:12PM (#33425071)
> Congress cared that it met payload requirements and mission requirements.

This is just not correct if you mean that they only cared about payload and mission requirements. Congress mandated that certain technologies were to be used from non-competitive, single-source suppliers in order to prop up industry in particular congressional districts. Cost overruns are practically by-design because as long as it doesn’t raise too many eyebrows it’s just more money to their local industry and constituents.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by nwah1 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @03:29PM (#33426215)
It isn't as if there was this long line of sad rocket companies waiting out in the cold, shut out of their dreams of outer space by the mean old government. There simply weren't any others except for the go-to contractors that NASA always relied on.

Now that there is a critical mass of billionaire nerds and venture capitalists who want to build rocket companies, there is now competition in this sector. It is a case of monopoly vs competition. That is the real answer.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by CrazyStat on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:36AM (#33422645)
> SLS vs Falcon Heavy is simply a battle between two different government contractors. One is not more government-based than the other.

This is completely false. SLS was established by Congress with various mandates on the technology and process to design and build it.

Falcon Heavy was not.

Many of the issues with SLS can be traced to Congress's requirements that they put on the project, like forcing it to reuse 50-year-old STS technology.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by nwah1 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:18PM (#33424205)
If congress asked Intel to build a computer meeting specifications from 50 years ago, regardless of how stupid that request is, and they somehow failed to do that in a resonable amount of time or budget... it would be an astounding display of incompetence. And failing to even try to create a new showcase technology of something better is just additional incompetence.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by CrazyStat on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @02:54PM (#33425764)
That may be true, but it's orthogonal to the truth of the original statement that the SLS program was not more government-based than Falcon Heavy.

SpaceX over the last two decades has been a superb illustration of the value of private enterprise.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by dotnet00 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @01:39PM (#33424558)
You're confidently incorrect to be claiming that one is not more government-based than the other.

SLS follows the old model of NASA contracting where NASA sets all the design requirements and the contractor follows them (ie the choice of solid boosters, the use of Shuttle technology etc was all set by NASA and the final vehicle is owned and operated by NASA). The contractor is effectively given a blueprint and asked to build it, with all construction costs covered.

This is in strong contrast to F9 and FH which follow the new model where the government only sets the rough requirements (payload capacity, target orbits, vibration tolerances etc) but doesn't care about the specific details (beyond making sure that they make technical sense). Payments are made for reaching specific milestones, how that relates to internal costs is entirely on the contractor and the final vehicle is still owned and operated by the contractor, with NASA acting as just another client. It's a much more hands off approach compared to SLS.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by sbuttgereit on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:08AM (#33422262)
Let's not forget Shuttle.... which at some level is a fair amount of SLS as well.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by fallingknife on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:45PM (#33423695)
The Shuttle was at least an innovative vehicle and a first attempt at reusability. It was a failure, but most first attempts at anything will be.

This doesn't compare at all with the SLS, which is just recycling old tech, and even going backwards from the Shuttle in that it gives up on reusability entirely instead of trying to learn and improve from the Shuttle's mistakes.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by Nicksil on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:01AM (#33422140)
>Imagine how much better the program could be if it were directly funded by the government instead of being indirectly funded by the government and enriching the world’s biggest arsehole in the process

There are plenty of other threads on HN where you can talk about how much you hate Elon Muck and the like. This is not one of those threads. Just let people enjoy things.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by nrb on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:08AM (#33422246)
Judging by the shuttle era and our lack of ability to even launch Americans into space for the last decade thanks to failed programs that have come since, I think it’s a matter of how much worse this program would be.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by coffeeblack on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:13AM (#33422343)
You mean ULA and Boing? Costs usually 5 times as much and takes three times as long to develop it, if it works at all in the end.

Why the jealousy about people getting good money for good work?

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by MichaelCollins on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:38AM (#33422666)
People seem to forget that NASA isn't much of a rocket manufacturer. Those "NASA rockets" of the past were manufactured by corporations contracted by NASA. Space Shuttle orbiter? Built by Rockwell. Mercury-Atlas launch vehicle? Convair. Saturn V? Various contractors, particularly Boeing for the first stage and Rocketdyne for the F-1 engines.

This ruffles the feathers of a certain sort of "space commie", who have traditionally hoped that exploration of space would be impossible for capitalism, leaving space as the great utopia for the future of state-run communism. This was always a dumb point of view, but SpaceX has them particularly upset now because NASA is less involved in the design process than ever before, and it's becoming apparent that capitalism has no trouble getting to space.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by anon291 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:13AM (#33422331)
It's pretty amazing and makes me feel proud that in our country, America, there are several private individuals and companies who are capable of launching rockets into space (it's not just Mr Musk), despite the fact that in other countries, this is something that requires massive government support. America's private-sector is heads and shoulders more advanced than many foreign governments. That's amazing to see.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by natch on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @08:10PM (#33429722)
In the US there is government support in the sense that companies can compete for and win government contracts, fwiw. But I get what you’re saying. We are lucky to have the right conditions overall for entrepreneurial efforts to have a chance at succeeding. And it would be wise to continue fostering this.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by mordae on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:04AM (#33422190)
I am there with you.

If only we could somehow make the public sector hire it's own personnel, pay it well and let it build the rockets instead of feeding either Boeing shareholders or the narcissistic idiot.

Most people convinced of public sector inferiority only perceive the hollowed out and thoroughly corrupted husk left by the neoliberal policies. Mostly because it's been systematically destroyed their whole life and they never noticed.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by MichaelCollins on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:40AM (#33422703)
Boeing, as well as many other contractors, got America to the Moon. The thing you are pining for is utterly Soviet, not the way America's space program has ever worked.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by coffeeblack on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:18AM (#33422409)
You mean the Russian space program? They are still flying their one good ship developed 70 years ago. And the money goes to a handful of corrupt people who are good friends with “the leader”.

Or take ESA. They are currently struggling to finish development of Ariane 6. A rocket with tech already obsolete years before it is even ready to fly for the first time.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by CommieBobDole on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:04PM (#33423126)
As others have noted, NASA's rockets have largely been designed, built, and operated by private contractors for its entire history. The difference was that those projects were managed by NASA via cost-plus contracts, often at mind-boggling cost.

The crowning achievement of this system was the Apollo program. Which was followed up by the Space Shuttle, a system so expensive and full of compromises that it wasn't really good at much of anything except freezing the state of US space travel at the technological level of 1976 for thirty years.

NASA doesn't design and build its own one-off plane when it needs to send some people to a conference in NYC; they buy them commercial airline tickets. Likewise, purchasing launch services from a commercial provider is far cheaper and more effective than engaging contractors to build a rocket to spec.

Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by s1artibartfast on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:21PM (#33423368)
NASA Rockets projects were never largely designed by the corporations. NASA has always been deeply involved in the design and micromanaged decisions down to the nuts and bolts.
Re:Falcon Heavy Launch Live by notright5 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @11:56AM (#33422968)
go away troll