News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by thepasswordis on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:07PM (#33407777)
You have no time to waste on western civilization's foundational text?

edit: to the people who want to argue this: show me a body of work which has been more influential on western society. What people seem to identify as 'western' values are largely just judeo christian values. The influence of the bible is so ingrained into our society that you will live out the values within it even if you don't realize it.

And that kindof makes sense, doesn't it? Some guys wrote down some stories which at the time were being passed orally, these stories became really popular, and the society which was telling these stories and using them to pass their moral philosophy became prosperous.

The Catholic Church was a (not so)pseudo government in Europe for almost 2000 years, and was the leader and authority in philosophy and art. The idea that somehow none of this is foundational to western civilization is absurd and completely ahistoric.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by dekhn on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:12PM (#33407849)
You mean the Odyssey?
Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by Matl on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:21PM (#33408011)
Not everyone eats everything Jordan Peterson says. The values you say are 'Christian values' are expressed, (in many cases more eloquently), in classical Greek texts. Values like democracy itself are indeed much more prominent there than in the Bible, which is why I imagine you're seeing the sort of replies that you are.
Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by thepasswordis on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:26PM (#33408096)
This is so frustrating to me.

People hear "the bible is foundational" and I think they're hearing "the magical stories in the bible are literally true. God sat on a cloud and poofed western civilization into existence!"

What I'm saying is that, the Dawkins sense, The Bible was an extremely successful meme. I don't think that's even up for debate.

>Not everyone eats everything Jordan Peterson says.

People need to find more internet people to hate. Christopher Hitchens was saying the same thing to impressionable teenagers in the early 2000s, and so was Richard Dawkins. Before that there was this little known German Philosopher saying something similar too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Nietzsche#Death_of_G...

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by Kbelicius on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:48PM (#33408535)
Just because a book and an institution were present for the last 2000 years doesn't mean that they were the foundation of a society that exists today. Especially a society that most likely exists despite of them then because of them.
Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by dekhn on Monday October 31, 2022 @01:03PM (#33408833)
I think the 30 Years War, which tore apart Europe for decades over a disagreement over details in the interpretation of Christianity (and the Protestant and Catholic bibles differ).

I would say at the very least the bible is one of the most important pieces of literature in the world, has had a tremendous impact in all its forms, played a role in the formation of the modern world's moral codes, and at the same time, is not the unique, one, and only "foundational" document leading to the modern western world- there isn't one.

(FWIW, I really do respect the King James bible as a world of literature, even though I am agnostic and consider the Silmarillion to be a more enjoyable origin story)

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by joenot443 on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:50PM (#33408578)
Namedropping Peterson when he has 0 relevance to the conversation at hand is just juvenile flamebait and a pretty easy tell that the GP isn't really acting in good faith. I don't think @matl is interested in a serious conversation about the historical relevancy of the Bible, nor are they equipped to have one.
Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by Matl on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:45PM (#33411759)
> Namedropping Peterson when he has 0 relevance to the conversation at hand

He absolutely has relevance considering he's the most recent prominent public figure pushing the Bible as "the foundational stories" without which we cannot live. Yes, there are others and it may be that OP arrived at this independently, but I've heard this most from his followers.

I acknowledge that I may've been slightly nudged by OP's unfounded "You have no time to waste on western civilization's foundational text?", which sounded extremely judgmental to me, but shouldn't have jumped on the bait.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by joenot443 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @08:13AM (#33420129)
He really doesn't though. Just because you personally make company with his followers doesn't mean anyone else on this site does. In all my time here I don't think I've _ever_ seen someone take his side, I've only ever seen him used as a weird strawman in the same fashion you are.

I think it's a pretty dull tactic to namedrop e-celebs you don't like as a very crude way of making a point. Clearly you have some fairly progressive views, so it'd be a bit like if I brought up other e-celeb clowns like Hasan or Destiny specifically so I could make a bad dunk. That kind of discourse just doesn't have a place on HN, imo.

I don't doubt you can think of better ways to articulate your points, and I'd encourage you to do so.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by Matl on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:43AM (#33421124)
As I said in my previous reply, I don't disagree I could have framed my response better, however I am not just throwing Peterson here for fun, I am reacting to "You have no time to waste on western civilization's foundational text?" which is in my opinion a non-constructive argument of the sort that the likes of Peterson use to make people who disagree with their arguments feel like they're just not on the same level if they're missing the brilliance of the Bible.

I came across this sort of thing a lot in my life from Christians trying to convert me so I don't necessarily have the same amount of patience as others might to these sorts of tactics.

Note that I'm not even arguing against reading it to inform oneself, (something I've done multiple times), just this particular tactic of trying to get people to read it.

That's all.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by WanderPanda on Monday October 31, 2022 @12:56PM (#33408691)
I think it could only ever have been such a successful and resilient meme because it resonates deeply with human social dynamics.
Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by Matl on Monday October 31, 2022 @03:42PM (#33411679)
> People hear "the bible is foundational" and I think they're hearing "the magical stories in the bible are literally true. God sat on a cloud and poofed western civilization into existence!"

That's not what I hear. What I hear is more along the lines of "What's in the Bible is somehow original/more profound than what came before and so THAT is the book to take note of", which just isn't true.

> People need to find more internet people to hate. Christopher Hitchens was saying the same thing to impressionable teenagers in the early 2000s, and so was Richard Dawkins.

Yes, they all pander to similar audiences be it back when Hitchens and Dawkins are more akin to Sam Harris imo.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by mchaver on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:44PM (#33412760)
Agreed, that is what I hear as well. It is kind of like Neo-reactionary gotcha, like ok, you are not Christian, but you still need to accept the bible as being really important.

That being said, there are lots of Bible references in the canon of English language literature. So if ones goal is to understand that, then a synopsis of the Bible stories and commonly quoted phrases might just be sufficient. The book is dry, repetitive and a bit inconsistent. It's value is that it is really old and is associated with a big religion. If a modern writer created the same thing it would have a really low rating on Goodreads.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by lern_too_spel on Monday October 31, 2022 @01:32PM (#33409406)
Euclid's Elements is the foundational text of western civilization, popularizing reasoning from first principles. The Bible is a foundational text of western mythology, not much different from the mythological texts of any other part of the world.

You will find no mention of The Bible or any of its characters in The Federalist Papers. You will find much discussion of classical governments and several references to Montesquieu. John Locke specifically cited Euclid as his influence and structured his writing to match. Lincoln, perhaps the most stridently moral of America's presidents, was known as the village atheist when he was a young man, studied Gibbon's The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, which put much of the blame on Christianity, and Paine's The Age of Reason. He carried Euclid's Elements with him until he could derive any of the propositions in the first six books at will.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by mchaver on Monday October 31, 2022 @04:36PM (#33412638)
> to the people who want to argue this: show me a body of work which has been more influential on western society.

A potential competitor would be Ancient Greek Philosophy (Socrates, Plato, Aristotle). Though it is hard to measure.

> What people seem to identify as 'western' values are largely just judeo christian values.

Nope, 'Judeo-Christian values' is a horrible Christian-Americanism that seems to erase the vast differences in Jewish and Christian experiences.

Judaism is a tribal religion with a huge focus on commandments given to said tribe and understanding the texts. Christianity is a religion concerned with the beliefs of all people, including non-Christians. The structure of their societies are quite different and historically Christian countries did not treat Jews well.

So I would add 'Judeo-Christian values' to the list of absurd and completely ahistoric ideas.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by joenot443 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @08:18AM (#33420169)
'Judeo-Christian values' is actually phrase coined by George Orwell, but it's clear that you're much better studied on the topic.

Any Christian or Jew will obviously acknowledge the many differences between the faiths, but I'm confused that you seem to be saying there aren't HUGE similarities in their value systems. Do you have many Jewish or Christian friends? I feel as if your understanding of Jewish/Christian culture is much more based on internet comments than lived experience.

If you want to understand, I encourage you to spend some time with devout Jews or devout Catholics and you'll begin to see the similarities.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by mchaver on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @09:45AM (#33421159)
> 'Judeo-Christian values' is actually phrase coined by George Orwell

I didn't know that, but this phrase seems to be common in the US. I have not encountered it much elsewhere.

> I'm confused that you seem to be saying there aren't HUGE similarities in their value systems

I don't deny there are many similarities, but my lived experience is that the core values and tenets of the two religions are quite different. Maybe you have a different experience.

Judaism also has many similarities with Samaritanism and Islam. So why don't we speak speak of Abrahamic values? My point is I am suspicious of the term 'Judeo-Christian values'.

Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by joenot443 on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @03:23PM (#33426126)
Ultimately I agree, Abrahamic is a much better term.
Re:George Hotz is leaving Comma.ai by tensor on Friday November 04, 2022 @06:04PM (#33474518)
Not for current day issues no I don't. I've certainly read parts of it and have watched numerous documentaries, museums, etc on it. From a historical point of view it's of course valuable. But it's not valuable to me for current day issues any more than flat earth theories are or outdated science textbooks.