News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by keiferski on Sunday October 30, 2022 @11:57AM (#33395558)
PKD is one of my favorite sci-fi writers and I recommend Ubik if you're a new reader, although like the article mentions, you definitely need to be in a certain mindset to "get it." The Man in the High Castle has an interesting concept but I don't think it's particularly well-written.

One thing that I think goes unnoticed about PKD is how some of his earlier short stories are undeniably, unquestionably bad. Fair Game, for instance. He wrote it in 1953, a decade+ before his work started to get really good: The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch was written in 1964, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? in 1968, and Ubik in 1969.

I personally find this a bit reassuring. It's nice to know that even someone as influential as PKD took a long time to develop.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by x86x87 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:05PM (#33395620)
PKD is my favorite writer of all times. I believe that even for his greatest works the writing could have been more polished, way better. The thing is PKD does not get you with the form of the writing but with the ideas that he captures. Truly visionary.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by moris_borris on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:08PM (#33395654)
That last bit could be said of any of my favorite sci fi thinkers. I love Asimov and Frank Herbert but not because I think they were great writers.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by Barrin92 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:41PM (#33396686)
it's funny because for me the prose of a lot of science fiction writers was always what turned me away from the genre. I could barely make it through Dune and gave the Foundation up. A lot of science fiction authors which I came to love a lot like Gibson or Le Guin I think I mostly got into because of their sense of style.

Stephenson for me is probably the worst offender for this. I've met so many people both online and offline, particularly other programmers who always told me to read his stuff but he's straight up pasting pages of Wikipedia into his books, I felt like I was being trolled.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by x86x87 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:54PM (#33396826)
Stephenson is a bit more polished than PKD but your point still stands.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by pmoriarty on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:59PM (#33397462)
I had high expectations from a bunch of friends recommending Snowcrash, but when I read it I found it to be so awful I couldn't even finish it. It was just so childish and stupid. I don't get why people like it.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by Jtsummers on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:24PM (#33397691)
Snow Crash is either an accidental or deliberate parody of cyberpunk. The main character is Hiro Protagonist. When he goes into a VR world and is "fighting" with a sword he's swinging a sword around wildly in the real world too, while around other people. And then in Diamond Age Stephenson [rot13]xvyyf gur zbfg plorechax punenpgre va gur svefg be frpbaq puncgre[/rot13].

When I read Snow Crash the first time it was back when cyberpunk was still a pretty hot style, and I was also reading a lot of Gibson and others. It fit well within that context. Then later I reread it and realized what I wrote above, it was parodying elements of the genre while creating almost a quintessentially action-adventure cyberpunk story with a programmer/pizza delivery driver hero. And then it had the typical Stephenson ending, which is to say

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by FPGAhacker on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:53PM (#33398555)
> And then it had the typical Stephenson ending, which is to say

that made me laugh out loud

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by flybrand on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:56PM (#33398582)
Thank you for commenting on Stephenson’s plot resolutions. I love his writing and his stories, but the end of his books are just so unfulfilling. Especially Anathem!
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by pmoriarty on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:14PM (#33398786)
Yeah, I got that it was a parody. It just wasn't funny.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by cableshaft on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:43PM (#33398454)
Of his books that I read, it is definitely the one that comes across as the most childish and stupid (with a few good ideas). His other books aren't like that.

I had trouble getting through them as well, but for other reasons. For Cryptonomicon it was his "let me prove how smart I am" diversions off the main story for dozens of pages at a time, and for Anathem it was an interesting idea told in a boring yet difficult-to-parse way, at least as far as I got.

The quality of the prose in those other two books seemed better, at least.

Big fan of PKD books, btw, although I think his writing style and characters are pretty plain and not that compelling on their own (but they are quick to read as a result, I could knock one out in about 4-6 hours, usually). The ideas, dialogue, and often the endings make them all worth reading, though.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by pmoriarty on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:20PM (#33398846)
"his writing style and characters are pretty plain and not that compelling on their own"

Dick is a champion of the underdog everyman. His protagonists tend to be humble repairmen and other "losers" in the lower stratum of society... I find those characters very human and relatable.

The other type of Dick protagonists are those who think they're on top of the world, until their world turns upside-down and so they get to experience being dragged through the mud.... usually finding out that what they thought was a perfect world was broken, hostile, and sometimes even evil.

His writing style is direct and economical. I really don't have a problem with it.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by Slow_Hand on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:53PM (#33400343)
I can relate. I'm massive Dune fan, but I see why people would have difficulty with Frank's prose. It's dry and not particularly sensual. However it is incredibly functional and lucid once you acclimate to the world he's building. He has a strong way of making you very aware of how everything relates to one another, both in space and conceptually.

Stanislaw Lem, on the other hand. The substance is usually fantastic, but the reality of the characters tends to get obscured by long, intricate sentences that lack the precise objective descriptions of Frank's writing and lose a sense of where everything is in relation to one another. Lem tends to be extremely light on description in many instances. Perhaps that can be partly attributed to translation difficulties, as I've never read the Polish source.

On the other hand I'd disagree about Neal Stephenson, I'm reading Snow Crash for the first time (halfway through it right now) and I loved the opening chapters. There's a real kineticism with Hiro and YT speeding through traffic that I find very evocative and leaves me pining for my days of doing irresponsible shit in traffic. He really has a way of writing action that feels exciting and focused.

Neal has some hilarious descriptions that really paint a picture. There's a great description of the "rat thing" robotic sentry disarming a lawn full of aggressors with blinding speed and he describes one of the aggressors as having "had his trousers torn from the waistband all the way down to the ankle, and a strip of fabric is trailing out across the lot, as though he had his pocket picked by something that was in too much of a hurry to let go of the actual pocket before it left."

That said, if do have one gripe so far it's the five uninterrupted chapters with Hiro expositing hard with the Librarian daemon about Sumerian mythology. The concepts being discussed are really interesting but it becomes tiring after a while, even when broken up by a few interstitial chapters following YT.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by skyechurch on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:01PM (#33396207)
Dick can be really rewarding, although he's definitely not to everyone's taste, or a particularly good stylist. This is true of other great writers who deal in extreme psychological states - Dostoyevsky for example. The extreme state for PKD was a metaphysical paranoia (probably augmented by amphetamine abuse), which many people can relate to, although it's usually not as intense or as intricate as in his novels. Dick was often writing autobiographical science fiction, which is an absolutely unique vision, though not one I'd like to experience first hand.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by x86x87 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:56PM (#33396851)
Yup. Sort of upset as I think with better form/style more people would have been exposed to his idea.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by xhevahir on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:50PM (#33399837)
I'm no authority on Russian literature but I've never agreed with this criticism of Dostoevsky. His writing is of a different kind, one that has its own logic. This article does a good job of explaining it I think: https://www.americanpurpose.com/articles/the-master-of-peter...
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by alex_suzuki on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:18PM (#33395745)
Did you give the TV adaption of The Man in the High Castle a try? It’s on Prime, I found it quite enjoyable.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by keiferski on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:07PM (#33396294)
No, it seemed a bit generic to me, but maybe I'll take a second look.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by aidenn0 on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:12PM (#33400475)
It's not really worth a second look. It started out fairly strong but didn't seem to go anywhere.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by fastball on Sunday October 30, 2022 @11:53PM (#33401868)
Kinda like the novel, tbf.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by mmarq on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:17PM (#33398222)
The first season was good, then it quickly degenerates into nazi porn and finally into a bad version of Rick&Morty
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by leephillips on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:24PM (#33395807)
I found Ubik somewhat intriguing. I’m about 60 pages unto Valis, and so far it’s mostly bad philosophy and theology, thankfully saved by occasional flashes of humor, and the almost-interesting fracturing of the main character into at least two people. Does it get any better?
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by abruzzi on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:42PM (#33395980)
I don't reccomend Valis for anyone but the most diehard Dick fans. Its an attempt to fictionalize an experience Dick had and spent the rest of his life trying to understand. It has some great moments, but it doesn't hold together terribly well as a story. I much prefer more focused stories like Scanner Darkly, Flow My Tears, or even Divine Invasion.

Supposedly Dick's experience conceived three published novels--Valis, The Transmigration of Timothy Archer, and Divine invasion. There is a fourth, unpublished novel--Radio Free Albemuth that came from it as well. Valis seem to be the most personal since it someone named Philip Dick (or Horselover Fat) having the exact same experience then trying to make sense of it. Divine Invasion has more of the feel of a traditional Dick novel with someone forced to live in a hovel on an alien planet. Timothy Archer is borderline non-SciFi, with only a tiny influence of SciFi, IIRC. And Radio Free Albemuth felt a bit like a cross between Scanner Darkly and Valis--i.e. the Valis story in a dystopian future surveilance state.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:11PM (#33396351)
There's a film version of Radio Free Albemuth https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1129396/

It's watchable, but my experience is soured by the terrible experience of contributing to the KickStarter and then not being able to get my reward for years due to living in the UK rather than the US (licensing issues).

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by cturner on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:06PM (#33396273)
I have read a fair bit of pkd and found Valis an unsatisfying struggle. Radio Free Albemuth is an earlier attempt at similar ideas and is accessible.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by pmoriarty on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:51PM (#33397376)
I consider Ubik to be Dick's best work... so if you found it only "somewhat intriguing", I doubt you'll be any more pleased with anything else he wrote.

That said, if you are interested in reading more by him, of his books I can recommend:

- The Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch

- Martian Time-Slip

- Galactic Pot Healer

- Eye in the Sky

- the middle part of Lies, Inc

Some of his short stories:

- Beyond Lies the Wub

- Faith of Our Fathers

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by cgh on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:26PM (#33398893)
I'd like to add Dr. Bloodmoney and A Scanner Darkly to your recommended list.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by jrumbut on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:45PM (#33399091)
It's funny, I'm a big PKD fan and I didn't care for Ubik. I enjoyed the first half or so of VALIS immensely but my favorite of his is A Scanner Darkly.

I think, in 2022, people will understand Scanner better than they used to or maybe it is on the verge of being outdated?

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by pmoriarty on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:55PM (#33399873)
I didn't like A Scanner Darkly. I thought it was mediocre. VALIS was better, but not in the top tier of PKD's books, IMO.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by ndsipa_pomu on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:06PM (#33396271)
I haven't read The Man in the High Castle for a long time, but I thought that it was a rarity amongst PKD's output in that he edited it rather than just writing and selling it. It's also notable for winning a Hugo.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by bryanrasmussen on Sunday October 30, 2022 @03:33PM (#33397787)
>The Man in the High Castle has an interesting concept but I don't think it's particularly well-written.

It should be noted that Ursula K. Le Guin disagreed with your assessment in her famous essay Science Fiction and Mrs. Brown, in which she felt that The Man in the High Castle was one of the only science fiction novels that had a human character - a Mrs Brown.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by thundergolfer on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:54PM (#33400347)
I read The Man in the High Castle about one month ago, and contra OP think it's one of the better written sci-fi books.

Its problem is that it is hard to extract meaning from, and the plot kind of goes nowhere. I found it unsatisfying, but not uninteresting.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by yarg on Sunday October 30, 2022 @04:57PM (#33398585)
He also had a problem with women (to be fair, he was a professional writer - and apparently his wife wouldn't let him use the house).

I don't think I've read a single well-meaning intelligent women in a PKD story.

I remember being surprised at the start of one of his books, that the female character introduced at the beginning was clearly competent - turned out she was evil.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by atombender on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:31PM (#33398947)
I would argue that Juliana Frink in The Man in the High Castle is certainly a "well-meaning intelligent woman". His strongest female character is probably Angel Archer, who narrates The Transmigration of Timothy Archer, his last novel.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by yarg on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:44PM (#33399079)
You've got me there.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by skmurphy on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:35PM (#33398987)
Off the top of my head: Juliana Frink, a central character in "Man in the High Castle," is well-meaning and intelligent.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by ggorlen on Sunday October 30, 2022 @11:49PM (#33401850)
PKD was largely a product of his time in terms of gender roles, but his short story "The Impossible Planet" may be a counterexample.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by DontchaKnowit on Monday October 31, 2022 @05:57PM (#33413864)
Really? I can think of 2 competent and well meaning women in Ubik alone.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by xhevahir on Sunday October 30, 2022 @06:35PM (#33399687)
Ubik is the only PKD novel I've read and man did I struggle to finish it. Once in a while a passage caught my interest and then I would realize that I was reading was basically a summary of some myth from Gnostic scripture. A real slog, on the whole.
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by anigbrowl on Sunday October 30, 2022 @08:28PM (#33400597)
Ubik is hard, I'm rather surprised this writer recommended it as she did. I always suggest people just start out with short story collections to get used to his weirdness and the various sci-fi tropes he reuses a lot (eg 'homeopapes' that printed newspapers on demand). Pick a collection that includes Second Variety.

Flow my Tears is probably his most accessible novel. Do Androids Dream is very disorienting if you were expecting a novelization of Blade Runner and that probably puts a lot of people off him.

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by DontchaKnowit on Monday October 31, 2022 @07:45PM (#33415016)
Really? I did not get any gnostic vibes from Ubik at all. Now Valis on the other hand is like a schizophrenic reckoning with gnostic ideas
Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by diydsp on Sunday October 30, 2022 @07:07PM (#33400002)
> PKD took a long time to develop.

His personal life has some interesting events. But largely he was trying to feed his family by cranking out popular stuff. It's tragic how little he was recognized in his lifetime :(

Re:The Essential Philip K. Dick by gmuslera on Sunday October 30, 2022 @09:36PM (#33401032)
Reading most of his short stories in order is a great experience. Yes, you hit some not so great stories, but from time to time you hit gold. Beyond Lies the Wub, Meddler and Paycheck are some of his early works that worth a read.

Regarding Ubik, there is a Russian movie, Koma, that looks like it had Ubik as inspiration, and in that probably is more faithful than most Hollywood adaptations of his work.