News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by AtlasBarfed on Saturday October 29, 2022 @12:21PM (#33385459)
Green hydrogen in theory is valid and a very worthy target of research.

In practice it remains a FUD/policy distraction by petroleum interests to develop an energy ecosystem that is reliant on fossil fuels for the foreseeable (and profitable) future.

This is research that falls into the former category, but it's presence and other "green hydrogen" headlines in the news feed is due to the influence of the latter.

The economics of solar/wind/battery are and will be the driver of primary carbon reduction for the next decade, likely two decades.

Practical hydrogen has the same issue new nuclear has: what price target? LCOE and many other measures of solar/wind/battery have fallen at 10 percent or more per year for the last decade, and while "who knows" when that exponential curve tails off, looking at the scale of what's needed, forthcoming techs like perovskites and forthcoming production of sodium ion / LFP / LMFP and the prototypes of Lithium Sulfur / Solid State in batteries, there is likely another decade of improvement at those rates.

So like "new nuclear", sure, keep up the research, and if price competitive applications can compete with sodium ion batteries (which I think will be a killer app in grid storage based on the materials and gravimetric densities), sure, but I think these techs will be kind of like magnetic RAM vs DRAM: it simply missed the boat of the economies of scale rampup, and now has to wait for that curve to stabilize before anything competitive can crop up.

For hydrogen to be practical in any green form in large scale requires a huge development in generation (which this is), storage, transport, and infrastructure. Fundamentally that hydrogen creation/transport/storage/delivery infrastructure, which is 99.99999% unbuilt, competes with the existing power grid, which likely has TRILLIONS of dollars in accumulated investment and will receive likely another trillion or two globally over the next two years to adapt to dirt cheap solar and wind, to say nothing of what will be invested in home / commercial distributed solar generation and battery storage which hydrogen is not applicable.

Big Oil had a chance when the Bush Administration was talking about hydrogen circa 2003. But the fat cats sat on their hats, and Tesla and solar/wind left them in their dust. The only ones really pushing hydrogen are those and Toyota, who perplexingly missed the EV boat despite releasing hybrids in 1997 and should have been providing an entire product line of PHEVs by 2005 that pushed the entire industry towards PHEVs for all consumer transport by 2015. We'd be immune to OPEC and russia if that had happened, and 70-80% of daily miles would be electric with no range anxiety.

Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by wedn3sday on Saturday October 29, 2022 @02:01PM (#33386452)
> The economics of solar/wind/battery are ...

Its always been my impression that the only practical use of hydrogen is as a pseudo battery to buffer energy from renewable sources. No need for expensive/dangerous transmission or fueling infrastructure if the hydrogen is stored in the same place it was generated, and then passed through a fuel cell to turn it back into juice when demand increases.

Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by kotlin2 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @02:56PM (#33386934)
You can also use green hydrogen in place of blue hydrogen, e.g. when making ammonia.
Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by tuatoru on Saturday October 29, 2022 @05:19PM (#33388060)
Electrolysis at scale has to happen for green hydrogen to replace coking coal in iron smelting/steelmaking (~9% of global carbon emissions)[1] and to replace steam reformation of fossil methane for making ammonia, for fertilizer (~1%).

Those applications don't require an elaborate transport infrastructure; just that the plants be located near large PV farms or vice versa.

Why write "trillions" in capital letters? Is it supposed to be impressive? A trillion dollars is one percent of global GDP. Oil, fossil gas, and coal extraction cost 5 TRILLION dollars a year, and the infrastructure for their use (vehicles, boilers, etc.) cost TRILLIONS more. And that's just to offset depreciation.

1. An alternative to using hydrogen for iron smelting is direct electrolysis of molten iron ore, but that is at early research stages. It can't be rolled out globally in the next four decades; development will take longer than that.

Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by AtlasBarfed on Saturday October 29, 2022 @06:00PM (#33388371)
Because current investment in hydrogen infrastructure is likely ONE MILLIONTH of that ... or more. As in it is so far behind that there is no feasible way to catch up.

But mostly ecause numbers with lots of zeros are important to keep in mind.

Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by tuatoru on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:20PM (#33389401)
If it's growing at tenfold per year, that's only six years' growth.

I don't know what the actual growth rate is, but I don't think there's cause for concern, except to coal miners.

Edit: there aren't any material limitations. The current hotness is proton-exchange membrane technology; the coming thing is solid oxide electrolysis (promises lower cost); the century-old technology (that has been ignored for most of that time, so hasn't been properly cost-optimised) is alkaline electrolysis using caustic potash or caustic soda.

Alkaline is slightly higher cost, but as I said no significant effort has been put into it for a while.

There is no way we can ever run out of sodium.

Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by AtlasBarfed on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:47AM (#33391183)
Yes, which is why CATL's sodium ion 160 wh/kg mass production in 2023 battery is such a big deal.

Hydrogen can grow 10x from where it is now because it is paltry in size, but then, no way. But as you yourself point out, hydrogen is all research and prototypes, but EV / Solar / Batteries / Wind is production or near-production.

At this point the planet needs what works now.

But will hydrogen extraction/electrolysis ever be cheaper than grabbing it from methane? I doubt it. That's one of the big big big issues with hydrogen, the "green hydrogen" supply chain can be exposed to fraudulently sourced hydrogen. Don't assume regulatory controls will be in place everywhere, companies will simply arbitrage the lowest common denominator regulation or under the table it. It happens to this day with petroleum from Iran and Russia.

Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by robocat on Saturday October 29, 2022 @06:42PM (#33388698)
Presumably the electricity network can often be used to transport the power, so only the hydrogen electrolysis plant needs to be near the industrial consumer.

The possibility is very dependent on the network constraints to the load: there is often excess network capacity on many links or excess capacity at certain times of day, because the network is built to handle peak loads. There is also availability of capacity on network secondary-links that have reserved backup capacity (to handle failover from network primary-link failure).

One major constraint for green power is locating it near a network node that can accept the power.

Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by tuatoru on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:43PM (#33389610)
Yes, although siting the electrolyzer at the PV farm uses DC from the modules directly, avoiding DC-AC inversion losses, transmission losses and AC-DC rectification losses. Having the smelter there too avoids hydrogen transport and storage costs.

All that, of course, has to be balanced against ore transport and slag disposal costs.

Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by robocat on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:33AM (#33391783)
Network and conversion losses are often surprisingly small. For example a 600km DC link in NZ[1] has total losses of 1.42% on the first 323MW and 3.30% on the next 753MW[2] (age of rectification & inverter equipment varies). There is AC to DC conversion at both ends, so that is equivalent. DC transmission losses are less than an AC segment would be (220kV AC to 350kV DC with 40km underwater).

[1] https://wikipedia.org/wiki/HVDC_Inter-Island

[2] p23 of https://environment.govt.nz/assets/Publications/Files/Assess...

Re:Breakthrough electrolyser development: 200 times less iri... by patall on Saturday October 29, 2022 @05:31PM (#33388136)
Your thinking ignores that there are many other uses for hydrogen. There is this chart [1] that clearly states where we should go for clean hydrogen production first and where it may not be worthwhile. And what I am noticing, that is more or less where the industry here in europe is going: some experiments in different areas but focus is the chemical industry and soon steel. Everything else will (mostly) come later.

[1] https://mobile.twitter.com/MLiebreich/status/143199000314453...