News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by satysin on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:13AM (#33383366)
I have seen this first hand with a (non-teenager) family member. They self-diagnosed with ADHD over the past two years.

Then they paid to get a private assessment and sure enough got diagnosed with ADHD. Do I think they have ADHD? Nope, not at all.

So why the official diagnosis and treatment with pharmaceuticals? He learnt everything he needed to know to easily fool the doctor assessing him. He knew every test they would use and exactly how to respond. And as he is an intelligent guy he didn't go in there and flag every single thing but just enough to look like a legitimate person struggling with attention and executive function. He told me before the assessment he wants the medication and he got exactly what he wanted.

My son was diagnosed with ADHD a couple of years ago so I have seen first hand how the assessments work and it is a joke how much "flexibility" there is. It isn't like a blood or culture test where you can detect the presence or lack of some substance. It is mostly voodoo for want of a better word.

One question I ask myself is does he genuinely think he has ADHD or did he just want the meds and figured out a way to get them while looking genuine?

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by zrail on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:42AM (#33383551)
People who have nothing wrong don't seek out labels and treatment. If he identified so strongly with the ADHD things being put out there (the vast majority of which at least rhyme with the official diagnostic criteria) that he paid for an assessment that came back positive* then it might be best to believe him.

* I paid for an assessment from a neuropsychologist that came back negative. I dug into their assessment and it was basically just wrong (self contradicting and extremely biased, I.e. I was "too smart" to have it). I went to someone else and they picked up on it immediately.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by satysin on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:52AM (#33383618)
> People who have nothing wrong don't seek out labels and treatment.

Agreed, I do think there is something wrong I am just not convinced it is ADHD and my worry is now he has his diagnosis and some pills it won't help him in getting him the help he actually needs which I believe is more related to trauma from an animal attack combined with the pandemic.

I know it sounds like I am just disagreeing with his ADHD diagnosis and that I am in some way against ADHD diagnosis but that is not the case at all. As I said my son was diagnosed with ADHD not too long ago. I have no issue with ADHD as a diagnosis I just worry it is the wrong one for this person because they became so obsessed with getting adderall as some kind of fix for everything and when other options such as therapy are suggested they dismiss them instantly as "too much talking".

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by zrail on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:09AM (#33383726)
That's fair. The question is, are the meds helping? People with ADHD react very differently to stimulants than people who don't, to the point where it's usually apparent to others.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by sjy on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:13AM (#33384185)
“For years, it was assumed that stimulants had paradoxical calming effects in ADHD patients, [while] stimulating ‘normal’ individuals … It is now known that low doses of stimulants focus attention and improve executive function in both normal and ADHD subjects.” https://www.nature.com/articles/1301164
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by pxc on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:15AM (#33384751)
This old myth about ADHD is one of my pet peeves. Stimulant medications don't un-ADHD people. They're a handicap that has similar effects across the whole population, but which is considered highly dangerous and addictive, and for that reason, we only allow its use when we've identified a significant disability in the form of ADHD.

But it's not a magic drug which undoes ADHD and has completely different effects on the non-ADHD population.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by LocalH on Sunday October 30, 2022 @11:34AM (#33395320)
I have high hopes for the potential of low psychedelic doses aiding with ADHD, and even higher doses of certain ones from time to time. Psychedelics have stimulant properties, but much less addiction potential than actual stimulants (when was the last time you saw someone physically addicted to LSD or psilocybin mushrooms?). I had an intense DMT experience three years ago and still feel benefits and positive change from it (although it's about time I arrange another such experience).
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by satysin on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:22AM (#33384823)
> The question is, are the meds helping?

According to him yes, he can concentrate well now. He doesn't talk about his other issues and when I bring them up he doesn't say anything.

According to his wife yes his concentration is improved but not his anxiety, depression or anhedonia.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by pxc on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:13AM (#33384727)
> I know it sounds like I am just disagreeing with his ADHD diagnosis and that I am in some way against ADHD diagnosis but that is not the case at all. As I said my son was diagnosed with ADHD not too long ago. I have no issue with ADHD as a diagnosis I just worry it is the wrong one for this person because they became so obsessed with getting adderall as some kind of fix for everything

That is really hard. Your son may have to figure that one out on his own.

If I can give some unsolicited advice:

Make sure your son knows that you feel his problems are real and that he has important things to learn from others who have ADHD, because they do struggle with so many similar things. If it's ‘you're barking up the wrong tree’, he might be likely to reflexively dismiss you. But if it's ‘I see why you think this is a good place to look for help, but don't limit your search for tools to deal with this to things associated with ADHD’, it might be something he can better receive.

Also, as someone who has been diagnosed with ADHD and takes stimulant medication for it:

  - there are aspects of ADHD that stimulant medication just doesn't help with
  - there are aspects of ADHD that stimulant medication can make *worse*, if you're not careful
  - ADHD can be closely related to anxiety, even when ADHD is almost certainly part of the picture— when you have ADHD traits and behaviors, it's natural to fall into a habit of *leaning into those ADHD traits and behaviors* in order to cope with your anxiety, as a form of avoidance
Even if your son is certain that he has ADHD and he is basically right, that doesn't mean that his trauma doesn't matter or that there's not an interplay between his trauma and his ADHD. He'll be more successful in treating his ADHD if he also addresses his trauma, and working with a therapist can really help for the aspects of ADHD where stimiulant medication is not always that helpful a tool.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by satysin on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:41AM (#33384999)
That is a very thoughtful reply pxc, thank you.

Perhaps I am wrong but reading your reply I got the impression you thought I was talking about my son in my original reply? I just wanted to clarify that is not the case, I was talking about an adult family member not my son :)

As for my son it is quite clear he has ADHD and I indeed support him in every way I can. Currently that is not via medication however not because I object to it but because he only has one kidney and all of the doctors we have seen agree that we should try to avoid medication for now. Especially as he does not present hyperactivity. I am sure it is something he will try when older but for now we are trying to help develop tools (both mental and physical) to provide a supportive environment for him and it seems to be working quite well.

Regarding you point on anxiety and ADHD, this is very relevant to my son as he has developed some anxiety over the past few years (moving to a country where he had to learn a new language and of course the pandemic). We certainly notice[d] an increase with inattention when he is anxious. For example when my wife had to travel for work recently his anxiety was much higher. As you mentioned I ensure I do not use dismissive terms when he talks to me about how he is feeling. We have built a good, open way of communicating so when he feels anxious or overwhelmed he knows he can talk to us without issue.

I have to admit I have huge anxieties of my own as to whether I am doing a good job in supporting him but I am trying to do everything I can. Again I appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and knowledge.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by pxc on Saturday October 29, 2022 @02:37PM (#33386756)
Oh yes, looks like I mixed up two people you were talking about. Sorry for that! I'm glad that some of what I had to say was still helpful.

> As for my son it is quite clear he has ADHD and I indeed support him in every way I can. Currently that is not via medication however not because I object to it but because he only has one kidney[.] [...] [F]or now we are trying to help develop tools (both mental and physical) to provide a supportive environment for him and it seems to be working quite well.

FWIW I think the non-medical tools are the harder things to get going and the more essential. And because stimulant medication's efficacy is affected a lot by how structured the environment is, it tends to be a less decisive tool in college and in professional life than it is in elementary school or high school. So if you're having success and seeing progress without meds, I think that's likely to continue and to help make sure he has the right habits to make the meds actually effective for him in adulthood if that's what he needs.

> I have to admit I have huge anxieties of my own as to whether I am doing a good job in supporting him but I am trying to do everything I can.

To me you sound thoughtful, flexible, and caring in your approach to understanding and supporting your son. I think that is sure to make a huge, positive difference, no matter what.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by tpmoney on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:42PM (#33390057)
>Agreed, I do think there is something wrong I am just not convinced it is ADHD and my worry is now he has his diagnosis and some pills it won't help him in getting him the help he actually needs which I believe is more related to trauma from an animal attack combined with the pandemic.

I think the problem that most people in life that suffer from some sort of mental problem – be it depression, ADHD, Autism, axiety or any number of other issues – encounter throughout their entire life are hundreds of well meaning and otherwise people all with their own personal opinions about what's wrong with them. At best these people are doing nothing but adding noise, but at worst they're contributing to a life of hurt and unhappiness with being unable to be "normal". When these people find something that resonates with what's going on, they will latch onto that thing, whether or not it's the right thing. But for those people (and frankly for their well being) if it's wrong, that's often still better than having nothing at all.

The curse of having a mental disorder is that until you're diagnosed, no one believes anything is wrong with you they just think you're an asshole. After you're diagnosed, EVERYTHING in your life gets filtered through that disorder. But the important thing is people no longer think you're an asshole, which means they're more open to looking at something else.

Your friend has a much better chance of getting the help they need by someone looking at their diagnosis and going "hey, I can see where the docs got this, but these other things don't quite fit and maybe you've been mis-diagnosed or have some other thing" than they probably ever did before the diagnosis. So sometimes even the wrong diagnosis is helpful.

But you need to keep in mind that you're almost certainly not the only other person telling them the diagnosis must be wrong. And at a certain point when you know something is wrong with you and everyone keeps shooting down things around you, you become resistant to listening to ANYONE who wants to shoot you down, no matter how right. If you're worried about your friend, your best bet is to encourage them to keep digging, keep learning and keep checking rather than trying to encourage them to stop thinking they have ADHD. Because in the end, continued evaluation will either confirm the diagnosis or get them on a path to finding a better answer. Where as fighting them on it will just encourage tuning you out and digging in.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by yucky on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:22PM (#33390372)
Not quite, a lot of people earn extra cash doing this and selling their Rx on the street.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by ethanbond on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:22AM (#33383438)
A third option is that he does have ADHD and you, a bystander, are doing the misdiagnosis.

IMO for disorders like this it’s almost better to view it through the lens of the available treatments. Is the treatment, on net and relative to other possible strategies, going to be a positive impact on this person? If yes, then whether they have apparent Disorder X (a figment of imagination) versus actual Disorder X (which is itself also a figment of our collective imagination) isn’t super relevant. Obviously in the case of ADHD the prescription drugs are pretty intense and have pretty severe negative consequences, so this framework in that case would probably even yield that people with actual ADHD but mild forms shouldn’t have those drugs pushed on them either.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by satysin on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:39AM (#33383530)
> A third option is that he does have ADHD and you, a bystander, are doing the misdiagnosis.

Very possible. To me it is just very suspect given my near 30 years of knowing them and other events in their life not long before all of this started.

They have never presented any ADHD traits until recently when suddenly they went from 0 to 100. From being a successful engineer to being unable to concentrate on a crossword.

My personal opinion is they have untreated PTSD following a violent animal attack in early 2020 that caused life-long damage to their dominant hand. This in turn led to them suffering panic attacks around animals, anxiety due to the Covid lockdowns making treatment/physio complicated, furlough leading to isolation at home and being unable to do many of their hobbies from the physical injury (unable to play video games, the guitar, drums, etc)

Tangentially related but they have a history of drug misuse and when I asked if they just wanted the medication their response was "Absolutely". I have mentioned seeking therapy as I suspected PTSD (I myself have C-PTSD from childhood abuse) but he made it clear he has no interest in therapy and just wants the medication which to me is not a great sign.

Of course I could be wrong but I know him well and my worry is they will happily throw medication at him which will do nothing to help him deal with what I believe at the actual issues he is suffering from.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by meowfly on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:22AM (#33383828)
> Tangentially related but they have a history of drug misuse

There might be a tighter correlation than it seems. What makes drugs addictive is that they work on the dopamine pathways. ADD medications do this directly.

Drug abuse causes damaged memory and executive function because drug use downregulates and sometimes damages dopamine receptors.

> Thus, in addition to reward, addicted individuals can experience severe disruptions in learning (memory, conditioning, habituation), executive function (impulse inhibition, decision making, delayed gratification), cognitive awareness (interoception) and even emotional (mood and stress reactivity) functions.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2948245/

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by evol262 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:21AM (#33384238)
> My personal opinion is they have untreated PTSD following a violent animal attack in early 2020 that caused life-long damage to their dominant hand. This in turn led to them suffering panic attacks around animals, anxiety due to the Covid lockdowns making treatment/physio complicated, furlough leading to isolation at home and being unable to do many of their hobbies from the physical injury (unable to play video games, the guitar, drums, etc)

You answered your question. I was diagnosed later in life, as a successful engineer. I am not and never was at the "unable to concentrate on a crossword" level, but you seem to have some misunderstanding about what ADHD is. It is not the inability to concentrate on things. It is the inability to concentrate on _appropriate_ things. It's perfectly possible for them to just be completely disinterested in the crossword, yet able to be engrossed for hours in something which interests them. The medication levels this out so you are able to keep your attention on mundane tasks and complete them after the "interesting" part is over, or to start on mundane tasks at all instead of procrastinating until it's do-or-die.

Fundamentally, there's a strong intersection with the dopamine reward system, and a "history of drug misuse" and poor impulse control is completely in line with a diagnosis.

Personally, I went through a close family member's suicide, followed rapidly by moving across the country to an isolated town where my spouse developed a problem with alcohol, a couple years of abuse, a divorce, another move to a different area of the country, then all of the lockdown stuff. All of my (and their) unconsciously constructed support structures, reward activities, and safety nets evaporated. Stop.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by satysin on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:05AM (#33384651)
> but you seem to have some misunderstanding about what ADHD is. It is not the inability to concentrate on things. It is the inability to concentrate on _appropriate_ things.

I appreciate you taking the time to reply and clarify things but I would like to say I have a pretty good understanding of ADHD. As I have mentioned my son was diagnosed with ADHD a couple of years ago. I go with him to every appointment and support groups we are in. I have spent dozens of hours with his doctor, psychologists, etc. to try and learn as much as possible about ADHD to support him as best I can and to ensure I can get the support he needs in school.

My comment about the other family member not being able to concentrate on a crossword was more a summation of the issue not a specific example. He has always been an intelligent guy, he wasn't gifted nor did he need to push himself extra hard to succeed. He never had issues concentrating on "boring" tasks for all the time I have known him (30+ years at this point). Sure he was never super engaged with them (who would be?) but he didn't get lost in procrastination.

What I mean is these are all very new things for him. Even for things he used to love such as games he cannot find the "mental energy" (as he puts it) to play. To begin with I put this down to his injury and while his hand will never be as good as it was he can use it "fine" for such things now. He just has no interest. No interest in anything. Basically all he wants to do is just sit on the computer and mindlessly consume. He stopped coding, stopped playing games, stopped reading, not taking his drone out, stopped doing some 3D stuff in Blender, stopped watching the kind of shows he used to love, etc. Pretty much the only thing he does still do that he did before is go to gigs. And perhaps this is unfair of me but I suspect that is because he always takes some drugs while there.

What I mean is he had a large change in personality over the past two years since the attack, not just his executive functioning.

Now it is very possible he always had ADHD but like many he managed to cope with it via systems he developed and perhaps the attack (or the pandemic) caused those systems to fail him and maybe just medication will help him. My worry is that he has some other issues and for one reason or another he convinced himself it is ADHD and only ADHD.

This is a concern his wife also shares and we have discussed. When she has suggested therapy he dismisses it as "not something that works for him" (even though he has never actually had any to validate that claim). It is a tricky subject and he is now sure he is "fixed" as his concentration is indeed better as he is taking some kind of amphetamine 4 times a day, however his wife has told me there is no improvement in any other areas which she is worried will lead to a crash at some point.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by evol262 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @01:09PM (#33385960)
I understand that, but adult ADHD and childhood ADHD are very different.

The energy level in childhood, brain development, behavioral expectations in school, and everything else is very different. I'm old enough that ADD (now ADHD) wasn't really a thing when I was growing up. People had to learn to manage, without medication. Doing it with medication is different, but being a functioning adult is not the same, and the same knowledge should not applied.

Everything you are saying is from an outside point of view. He sounds depressed, but he went through a traumatic incident. That doesn't mean he cannot have both.

It's not even a little surprising that he had a change in personality. You sound extremely judgmental, to be honest. Your friend went through trauma. He may not have PTSD (that word is used a bit too freely these days), but it was a traumatic experience which sounds like it literally crippled his ability to do half of the things your'e saying he doesn't "want" to do.

He suffered "life long damage to his dominant hand". The hand he presumably uses to help fly the drone, to play music, to use the controller playing games, to use the mouse in Blender (maybe). It may be painful constantly, especially if the rehab/physio was hard to manage during lockdown. You would also have a "large change in personality".

There isn't a lot of psychiatric care which can be done in isolation. People who have ADHD/ASD are also more likely to be depressed, but you can't "root cause" this to a single issue, and saying "well, he's depressed/has trauma, so he should deal with that" doesn't mean he does not also have ADHD.

He is trying to tell himself to "fake it until he makes it" after a traumatic experience, and he does not want to relive the trauma in therapy, he does not want to risk whatever potential side effects from antidepressants.

He is trying to accept that this is his life now. This life of lifelong damage in his dominant hand which has forever put the thing he loves out of his reach, and _maybe_ dragging him out of the house to do new things would introduce him to something new he loves which does not remind him of the life he cannot have anymore. _Maybe_ doing that instead of gossiping with his wife about it and wondering why he no longer does his old hobbies would help.

It sounds as if he is living in limbo between a life he lost and finding new fulfillment. The thing about very traumatic experiences as an adult is that the medication he is currently on (and again, which he probably needs) has made his life somewhat bearable again. He doesn't sound happy, and he doesn't sound like he knows what will make him happy, but the current state of things is so much better than it was two years ago that he doesn't think it's bad, or he worries that making more changes would make it worse again.

Be your friend's friend instead of whatever you're doing now. Monday morning psychiatrist on HackerNews is definitely not.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by zozbot234 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @01:24PM (#33386123)
> he does not want to relive the trauma in therapy

AIUI, therapy is not really about "reliving trauma". It certainly sounds like this person could benefit from assistance by a professional wrt. managing his stress reactions. Medication is a crutch.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by fao_ on Tuesday November 01, 2022 @12:48AM (#33417060)
> Medication is a crutch.

The only people I've ever known to have said this, were not qualified therapists, councillors, or psychologists. Isn't that interesting?

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by satysin on Saturday October 29, 2022 @03:38PM (#33387288)
I just wanted to clear a few points up. This person is not just a friend they are family. I have known them since they were born while I was a child. We grew up together and have always been very close.

He and his wife are childhood sweet hearts, they have been together since they were teenagers. I have known his wife since they first started dating so more than 15 years now. His wife and I are not "gossiping" about him behind his back as you put it. We are concerned for him and worry he is fixating on one possible problem while dismissing outright every other possibility.

One thing I would like to clarify a bit is when you say "forever put the thing he loves out of his reach", this is not true. While he may never play the guitar quite as well as he used to he can still play, far better than anyone else I know personally. When I said life long damage to his dominant hand I was referring more to visual scars than anything else. He did struggle for about a year but he is perfectly able to play the guitar and use his hand much as before. Perhaps not quite as good as before but it is not like he lost his hand or it was horrifically damaged to the point it is useless.

Unfortunately I am unable to edit my previous comment. When I wrote "unable to do many of their hobbies from the physical injury (unable to play video games, the guitar, drums, etc)" I meant they were unable to do those hobbies at the time (i.e. in the 6-12 months post injury) due to them being in recovery not that they were permanently unable to do those hobbies for the rest of their life.

>Be your friend's friend instead of whatever you're doing now.

We are all trying to be there for them. Me, his brother, his wife, his parents. We're all worried about him and while I may come across as being judgemental I promise you that is not the case.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by chrsig on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:06PM (#33390249)
> I just wanted to clear a few points up. This person is not just a friend they are family. I have known them since they were born while I was a child. We grew up together and have always been very close.

How many of those years have you been a mental health professional?

> We are all trying to be there for them. Me, his brother, his wife, his parents. We're all worried about him and while I may come across as being judgemental I promise you that is not the case.

No, you're on the internet invalidating his diagnosis.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by Chernobog on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:39AM (#33383531)
I have ADHD and my flavor makes me look well adjusted on the outside while struggling hard. My mother completely dismissed the possibility of ADHD based on things like me getting a Master's degree. People see the decent grades, but don't see that you put in three times the effort.

Everything got much easier after getting the diagnosis and medication as a 33 year old.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by amf12 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @03:32PM (#33387237)
> I have ADHD and my flavor makes me look well adjusted on the outside while struggling hard.

This is me. Looking back at my school days, it is very obvious I had ADHD but neither my parents and I, nor my teachers knew such a thing existed to get diagnosed.

In adulthood, others might think I am doing well, but they don't know the constant struggle my life has.

> but don't see that you put in three times the effort.

This is on point. Sure, I am getting my work done, but they don't see how my constant procrastination, zoning out means it takes me 3x the time to get something done, and it makes me feel 24 hours aren't enough to have my life in order.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by tsol on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:14AM (#33383771)
>Is the treatment, on net and relative to other possible strategies, going to be a positive impact on this person? If yes, then whether they have apparent Disorder X (a figment of imagination) versus actual Disorder X (which is itself also a figment of our collective imagination) isn’t super relevant.

Just about every human being operates better on amphetamines. It increases dopamine and adrenaline, increasing attention span and motivation significantly while decreasing the need for food or rest. Medication simply improving performance is not really a working metric in this case

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by ethanbond on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:30AM (#33384889)
Very true if you’re counting only the positive effects, in which case it’s not “on net.” There are obviously significant downsides to amphetamines which is why we don’t treat them like caffeine or even vitamins.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by zozbot234 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:38AM (#33384962)
The obvious downside to caffeine is pretty much the same: it stops working if you take too much of it too often. Reserve your coffee for special occasions, and it will work as well as any stimulant.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by ethanbond on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:55PM (#33389712)
If you don’t see the obvious differences between amphetamine and caffeine, not sure what to tell you.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by rbinv on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:31AM (#33383489)
Do the meds help him?

I do understand what you're getting at, but tests and assessments will always be gamed by some people. Yes, he may have cheated, but until there is a more objective way to diagnose disorders like ADHD, something like this is simply part of the whole thing.

Consider him a false positive. You certainly wouldn't prefer having false negatives instead.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by satysin on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:43AM (#33383564)
He has been on them two months and while his concentration is better none of his other issues have changed for better or worse afaik (anxiety etc).

I should note he never had any concentration problems before 2020 and even he agrees with this.

I replied to another comment with additional details you may be interested in.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by HansKerneue on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:56AM (#33383643)
Some perspective from someone like your family member. ~2 years ago I self-diagnosed with ADHD and paid for a private assessment. I learnt everything about it before being assessed and therefore knew exactly how to respond, and was put on a prescription for methylphenidate.

The reason I went looking for the diagnosis was 10+ years of utter misery. I had been on various treatments for depression & anxiety, but found them minimally effective. I was getting by but was pretty apathetic about life. Over the years I'd investigated various other mental illnesses, but never came across one that seemed to fit me. I came across ADHD purely by chance, when an acquaintance was diagnosed and I looked it up. Previously I had probably ignored it assuming that it was just for hyperactive kids.

This one did seem to fit, and frankly I was desperate. The though of a pill that could actually fix some of my issues made it worth a try at the very least.

For the past two years I've been happier than any other time in my life that I can remember. Life was just easier. The most telling point for me was when I realised that I was no longer apathetic about life, I actively wanted to live, I had things that I wanted to do, goals to achieve - and I was actually able to do them.

I don't know if I actually have ADHD, I still question the diagnosis. It worries me sometimes that maybe I don't have it and that instead I'm just not very good at life. The truth is that it doesn't really matter, the diagnosis and treatment worked - If I payed for a placebo I don't really care.

Perhaps your family member is the same - maybe they have ADHD, maybe they just needed something to help them through life, maybe they had run out of alternatives - it just gets to a point where you wonder 'how much does it matter even if I'm wrong?'

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by tsol on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:19AM (#33383813)
Personally, my philosophy is that drugs should be viewed as tools. Now I don't recommend this to anyone else because there are a lot of negatives. Encouraging people to find their solutions in chemicals can be dangerous. For a non-trivial amount of people, though, I think a lot of their life's problems could be solved with responsible and moderate usage of certain drugs. But again-- I don't actually recommend this because most human beings are irresponsible with drugs.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by cpsns on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:03AM (#33383687)
I’m in this exact same boat right now, word for word, other than I haven’t had the assessment yet (very soon though).

I’m quite literally desperate for any answers at this point, my teen years and 20s were on the whole, an absurd nightmare.

The only thing that worries me is they’ll tell me I have it because that’s the easy thing to do. I don’t want a diagnosis unless they’re 100% sure and I worry that paying for the assessment will bias the outcome.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by HansKerneue on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:31AM (#33383878)
I will add then that while the meds have been very effective, equally helpful was accepting the diagnosis. It made it easier for me to accept some of my failings and forgive myself for them.

And secondly just to say that things definitely can get better (which I found very hard to be believe for a very long time, no matter how many people would say it)

Whatever happens, best of luck to you!

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by cpsns on Saturday October 29, 2022 @01:30PM (#33386182)
I'm certainly at a point where I no longer think things will get better and well I'm skeptical of the entire psychiatry industry, even the slightest chance is worth taking at this point.

Thanks for the well wishes, I really hope in a few months from now I can look back and see some progress.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by enragedcacti on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:41PM (#33390045)
I would recommend you check out "Taking Charge of Adult ADHD" by Russell Barkley. [1] It covers a lot of topics and dispels a ton of misconceptions about adult ADHD. On top of that one of the stated goals in the synopsis is "how to get an accurate evaluation"

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Taking-Charge-Adult-ADHD-Second/dp/14...

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by boc on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:38PM (#33390476)
If you’re looking for a comprehensive, accurate diagnosis you’ll want to find a good neuropsychologist. They aren’t cheap, but if you find a good one they can really help you uncover specific issues.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by cpsns on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:20PM (#33390689)
Something like that is unfortunately simply not available for even someone like myself who makes decent money in my province.

It was hard enough to even find the private clinic I did manage to get an appointment at. This has always been one of my biggest problems, even when I wish to take a step forward and figure things out, the system just doesn't meaningfully exist.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by notacoward on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:17AM (#33383792)
Thank you for that. The fact is that a lot of conditions are on a spectrum, and only the individual can decide whether it's affecting their happiness enough to be A Problem. For example, social anxiety plus executive dysfunction seems to be a super common combination among the students at my local high school. But really, who doesn't have at least a little of both? By identifying their vague "issues" as a specific thing that affects more than just them, people might be able to find a community that can provide support and useful advice, or professional help and perhaps even medication. That's what taxonomy and terminology are for: to be descriptive, not prescriptive, and thereby to understand the world. I've seen it help in far more cases than I've seen it cause harm - though the latter does happen, and it's a thing professionals know to look out for.

Also, gotta say, as much as I hate TikToxic there are even worse places to look for mental health advice. :looks around:

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by 331c8c71 on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:19AM (#33384231)
> ... was put on a prescription for methylphenidate .... If I payed for a placebo I don't really care.

What do you mean? Methylphenidate is not a placebo no matter how you look at it.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by HansKerneue on Sunday October 30, 2022 @02:35PM (#33397242)
Fair - it would be more accurate to say "If I paid for treatment and it's effective then I don't care whether it's treating ADHD or some other issue - or if it's treating nothing but I have the impression that it is"

i.e. The outcome is important to me regardless of the how and why.

I wonder if there's a term for that? Feels like there must be.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by enragedcacti on Saturday October 29, 2022 @09:36PM (#33390006)
ADHD is a different pattern of brain function than a 'normal' brain, and detect-ably so. ADHD medications, and particularly the stimulants, have a very different effect on someone with ADHD versus without. Assuming the medication is successful and without side-effects, a person with ADHD will report an experience a lot like yours, and a person without ADHD taking it will have mood swings, hyperactivity, loss of appetite, etc. [1]

I'm paraphrasing from "Taking Charge of Adult ADHD" which I highly recommend. Unfortunately I don't have it on hand so its not a very good paraphrase.

[1] https://www.seasidepalmbeach.com/addiction-blog/what-does-ri...

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by ryeights on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:19AM (#33391030)
This is oft-recited but never backed up with evidence.

The linked article, for example, is unsourced and undoubtedly biased (as an addiction treatment center).

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by froh on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:17AM (#33392662)
there is plenty of evidence that these amphetamines show very different effects in ADHD vs non ADHD individuals.

this is my first google hit for the search phrase "methylphenidate in non adhd vs adhd"

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3489818/

this is referencing several clinical studies in that vein.

and the search result has several more results, some just clinics which make the well founded claim in simpler terms, others more clinical papers.

I'm sure you find more going to Google scholar with your search.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by enragedcacti on Sunday October 30, 2022 @10:38AM (#33394846)
We still don't have a super strong idea of exactly what is going on but we know that it has to do with dopamine and norepinephrine and that a number of brain structures are noticeably different in people with ADHD.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attention_deficit_hyperactivit...

it's actually kind of hard to find an array of good medical sources googling for the second claim because there is so much anti-abuse stuff flooding results for a non-medical professional like me, but its somewhat intuitive in that raising dopamine levels from low to normal will have a different perceived effect than raising them from normal to high. There is perhaps a philosophical argument to be had but from a clinical standpoint my understanding is that there is a world of difference in the outcomes.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by LocalH on Sunday October 30, 2022 @11:30AM (#33395278)
Have you ever heard of implicit bias? Bias is unavoidable.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by skippyboxedhero on Saturday October 29, 2022 @08:35PM (#33389547)
My mother took me to a extremely expensive child psychologist as a child. I don't recall what she said exactly, but I think she inadvertently suggested that she "thought something was wrong". The diagnosis came, my mother ignored it, and I don't have whatever he said I had twenty years or so later (not a total waste of money, he did an IQ test, and a color blindness test, hard to fuck that up).

It is an industry. At the time this happened, wealthier parents were often taking their kids to these people so they would give a diagnosis for extra time on school exams (this is presumably why he diagnosed me with something, iirc my mum told him he was wrong, he said "what do you want me to do?"). Obviously, the medication is an incentive for some kids now too. And the industry does affect how people cope, everything is medicalised and diagnosed, that isn't very helpful. The fact that kids have so much knowledge is also impacting diagnoses because they know what to say (and their parents are concerned too, and maybe say "I think you have this" and they want to validate that).

Unfortunately, I don't think anyone is really getting helped. More resources are going towards the trendy stuff, normal emotion is getting "diagnosed", and it is the same old stuff if you actually have something wrong with you (unemployment rates for people with autism are 80%, "mental health awareness").

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by dham on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:09PM (#33390265)
The mind and body can manufacture so many things in general too. If you think you have ADHD(along with any other medical thing) it might just come to be in certain situations. Not saying it's a lot or anything, but could happen. When I was younger I would watch a pharmaceutical commercial and swear I had that disease. In fact I'm not sure why we don't ban those.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by propogandist on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:12PM (#33390296)
I've done the same to get RX to get through a particularly crazy college semester vs buying "focus meds" on the street at crazy markup, a long time ago. It was easy to figure out what the doc needs to hear from some light internet research and I even had calibrated my responses to get the drug of choice. Cost was pennies on the dollar with insurance.

The doc would encouraged moving up to powerful doses in follow ups, even though I was barely taking the initial dose... I've since learned these professional drug peddlers often thrive on pushing habit forming drugs that require an office visit to get a fix.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by ryandrake on Saturday October 29, 2022 @10:43PM (#33390516)
Slightly off-topic side-thread, but just a heads-up: anyone who might ever want to become an airplane pilot (even in little Cessnas) would want to avoid this whole "study up on the symptoms and go diagnosis shopping" business. The FAA still considers ADD, ADHD and other mental disorders disqualifying, and you will never get a medical certificate with a diagnosis, even if you are being treated for it.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by propogandist on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:18PM (#33390680)
it'll be trivial to get a diagnosis stating you don't have ADHD, just by using the same "diagnosis shopping" method. The FAA can't stop a motivated person from becoming an airplane pilot.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by jacoblambda on Saturday October 29, 2022 @11:57PM (#33390914)
This is not remotely correct. What is correct is that you can't fly with a current ADHD diagnosis or after having recently taken ADHD medication.

If you've had a diagnosis in the past, you need to be off the medication for at least 90 days and go through an evaluation and drug test as well as submit some extra documentation to show that you have been able to function since stopping treatment (or in general if you never received medication).

Given the prevalence of ADHD diagnoses where the individual ends up being able to function without medication, most organisations have protocols carved out to allow prior and even currently diagnosed individuals the ability to join/get certified provided you can get off medication.

Another commonly cited reason to avoid a diagnosis is commissioning in any of the military branches as an officer. You can still get a med waiver to commission as long as you show proof you've been off meds for a year.

Source:

https://www.faa.gov/about/office_org/headquarters_offices/av...

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by ryandrake on Sunday October 30, 2022 @01:55AM (#33391556)
Jeez, I'm -remotely- correct as it was a 2-sentence summary of complex government rules. Relax. Your details are absolutely correct, but what an "Ackshually" comment!
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by froh on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:23AM (#33392691)
I very much appreciated the nuance of the detailing clarification.

the "never" makes it sound like "never will you ever", not like "while you have symptoms and need treatment for..."

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by LocalH on Sunday October 30, 2022 @11:38AM (#33395364)
Given my experience with ADHD, I'd assume that if you have a person who has ADHD, and for whom flight is one of their interests, that you would want them to have that ability to notice things with almost cat-like reflexes (which is one of the benefits I have personally experienced, on multiple occasions I have noticed an object start falling off a shelf and reached over to catch it mid-air). The stimulant medications tend to lessen these abilities. I want my pilot to be able to notice aberrations quickly and be able to respond to them quickly.
Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by collegeburner on Sunday October 30, 2022 @12:52AM (#33391209)
opinion as someone who has been told he probably has ADHD by close friends a lot of times, but doesn't buy it: there are some people who have an actual issue. but i think a lot of this is just how guys especially are. when did we go from joking about "lol guys think about sex every 7 seconds" to "if you can't sit hyperfocused on a paper all day every day you have an attention deficit"?

exercise is a big part of this: my attention improved a lot once i started doing serious lifting combined with long cardio sessions. a good, clean diet helps too. plus a decent sleep schedule. lastly, getting enough social interaction. i have watched fixing this work really well for multiple friends who used to be on meds, too.

Re:Teens Turn to TikTok in Search of a Mental Health Diagnosis by jasongi on Sunday October 30, 2022 @05:30AM (#33392735)
Can I just put it out there how wild it is that so many people immediately assume people get ADHD diagnosis’s because they want to recreationally take stimulants rather than like, they have an issue they want treated.

It’s a lot easier, and to an extent cheaper, to purchase black market drugs. Yet people are always sceptical when people say they have an ADHD diagnosis, as if they’re just a meth fiend who wants a socially accepted reason to get high all day.

This line of thinking falls apart pretty quickly once you realise that ADHD isn’t socially accepted, as demonstrated by these kinds of comments you get whenever someone talks about it.