When I initially started 3 years ago maybe you could get by with just meeting 2 of the 3 criteria you mentioned. My apps at the time were useful and easy to use, but not really beautiful.
The free version of one of these apps was getting about 400-500 daily downloads. After a much needed UI update (and one to the corresponding paid version) daily downloads jumped to more than 3000 a day. No promos, no divine Apple intervention, just Polish Polish Polish.
5 of the 6 really good iOS developers I know personally work for clients. The 6th works for a mobile startup and has turned more into a manager.
However, most of them are getting into product as they have done enough consulting to see it is just like a normal job in many ways, no ownership.
I will buy your app later, look forward to showing it to some friends who dabble in music.
Despite that I do think you prove the point that the previous poster requested. Unfortunately yours is one of many examples of well-done apps that doesn't get traction.
Do forgive the critique, I hope it will be helpful to you in going on to make ever more amazing apps. And I'll curtail my suggestions here. :)
One day I'll hopefully manage to make a new game, with both parts done well.
I'm curious: did you make the puzzles by hand or generate them algorithmically?
Algorithmically. The game actually came out of a research project into generating and automatically ranking the difficulty of puzzle games.
I have a long term plan to write a new game, with different puzzle games in it, using the same technique. The main slowness is a) Playing around with HTML5 and b) Figuring out how to make money off it (as with a webapp, you can actually lose a lot of money with hosting and servers, instead of the $100/year cap from Apple!)
Is a preliminary paper, we have a longer one in the works.
Suggestions:
- Add a tweening for picking up and dropping letters
- centering of the board should happen automatically
- put the restart button somewhere else. It looks weird when you drop a letter on top of it and it appears behind it (e.g. the 'm' in 'seem')
- can't really tell from the video whether you already did this, but implement iPhone-like scrolling w/ momentum and bouncy behavior
Getting attention is hard. Ridiculously hard. Insanely, impossibly hard. I couldn't get a review from a single website. I submitted the app to dozens of review sites, food/drink blogs, and tech blogs and didn't get a single response. Actually, that's not true. I got responses from app review sites that wanted me to give them money in exchange for a review.
I made a trailer that has gotten 2,700 views (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ctsk1QVs8OI). Almost all hits came from a video a friend and minor internet celebrity made for me. His video has 14,000 views. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rFn6eW2Kb0g
I fully admit my app is a niche app, but I think it's worth more than $420. Sites like Gizmodo have run "Best Cocktail Apps" and Apple regularly lists "Martha Stewart Cocktails" in Staff Favorites for iPad. It has approximately 12 total recipes but lots of high quality, high res images.
Compare with the Martha Stewart app. It is extremely polished and the photos look gorgeous.
I am not a designer, but you should get one to give you some suggestions. In any case, I just bought your app......happy to help out a fellow HN-er :) Hopefully this will help improve my cocktail-making skills.
PS> Check out a book called Tapworthy.
Also, the random feature on Alcohology is really interesting and would be incredibly useful. But why is it limited to an urbanspoon-style restaurant finder? Drink components don't seem to map well to that layout.
Perhaps allow for the input of an arbitrary number of components into a "bar", which then generates a list of potential drinks.
Or at least simplify the roulette selection to: primary component, style (cocktail, mixer, shooter, etc) and difficulty.
e.g. I have Whiskey, I want a cocktail and I don't want to spend a lot of time straining and cutting fruit.
That is exactly what it does. The second line of the description states "Alcohology is specially designed so you can see what cocktails your home bar can actually create" and the 3rd and 4th bullet points are "Customizable ingredients for your bar. Toggle to see all recipes or only recipes your bar can make"
Your comment has made it obvious that I have utterly failed in getting that point across. I'll re-work the description and screenshots to change the sales pitch.
To succeed, it seems that you now either need a mountain of luck, or a killer marketing engine and a fair amount of luck. Mathematically, it seems unattractive compared to other ways of applying the same time and skills unless you have something you're obsessed with building and want to produce irrespective of the outcome probabilities.
E.g. a $1.99 app pays at $1.393, so you need to move 34893.75 paid copies in order to clear a $50,000 gross. For SaaS and the same target, you only need 208.33 customers at $20/mo. The capture difficulty is not identical between cases - but if you have good marketing and are assuming serendipity on either side, it's quite feasible to hit 208 customers. Furthermore, it's often easier to grow once you get there, and it's quite possible to charge at much more than $20/mo/customer.
Mobile apps are great, but not a "for profit" activity for me. I'm all for doing them for fun or ad hoc, and if that takes off - great. But it seems to be a very difficult business model compared to applying similar resources elsewhere.
(I think the App Store gets a lot of ink because people have this notion that Apple does the marketing for devs like you. Which is true, in approximately the same sense that the MBA does marketing for basketball players like Shaq.)
For SaaS, it's also important to model things like trial conversions, turnover, etc. which don't appear in a single-sale case. There are a lot of differences. But the odds still seem better there.
And of course I am completely overlooking the "what about ads" question, mainly because you need a ton of installs before that starts being a significant amount of money. Better than not, helps feed conversions, but doesn't change the equation for me.
That said, the students loved it. And, he could also update the app as the course went along. Finally, although he only made enough through App Store sales to maybe go out for a nice meal, it translated into promotions, bonuses and the like. So ultimately, it paid off.
My main point is: in addition to selling niche apps at a premium, there's also the opportunity to develop cheap/free apps that otherwise help you move ahead within a niche market.
Polished and went nowhere. Breaking the top 25 for an indie dev is hitting the lottery. It takes a big Ad budget and great PR.
I've been trolling around the app store for awhile trying to understand the market and what I see are tons of novelty apps, fugly apps (by anyone's standards), buggy apps, and apps that break usability in all kinds of ways. And judging by the lack of any reviews for these apps, it's hard to imagine they spent much time on marketing, even just sending some free copies to bloggers to get their feedback and see if they might review it.
I'm not saying it's easy to hit points 1-3 above; it's not. But I wonder if a lot of indie app developers threw together something crappy in a few weekends of work because of all the stories out there about the big money being made, and then when it failed to materialize for them, they just gave up.
The App Store has gotten millions of people to collectively pay billions for software made by indie developers, which is amazing. But it's still a marketplace and the normal rules of any marketplace apply.
I would love for an experienced iOS developer making money to tell me if I'm wrong, and why.