News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by user- on Monday October 24, 2022 @09:52PM (#33325198)
Can they open source their algorithirm so I can figure out why I get no matches
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by smt88 on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:41PM (#33325536)
Dating apps are tailored to people in the top X% of attractiveness. Don't take it personally. Most people aren't successful on them, even the ones who get a lot of matches.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by godmode2019 on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:30PM (#33325844)
I'm relevantly good looking, no problem with getting a beautiful woman IRL, but on dating apps I get no matches. Or if I do its girls who are either average or tinder addicts who everyone should avoid.

My working theory is on a dating app woman have unlimited access, so tend to go torwards the top 99.9% of men.

Solution: Shadow ban hyper attractive people.

Solution 2: Only show people a similar level of attractiveness as yourself.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by borissk on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:36PM (#33325878)
Your theory makes no sense. First you obviously mean the top 0.1% of men. Second the top 0.1% of men can't date more than a few percent of the women.

Much more likely you don't put enough effort into your profile or you have something on, that is a red flag for most women.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by frontier on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:59PM (#33326039)
You are 100% correct, unsuccessful guys need to seek help and there are paid services out there. Or speak to a few women on these platforms (chicken-egg I know) and you will be told what others are doing that is turning them off. You need to treat this for what it is, marketing. You don't just put up your first attempt and say women aren't into me. You need to iterate and experiment. I know, it's hard work, 90% of guys won't put in the effort, they will just complain they aren't in the top 0.1% in attractiveness.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by godmode2019 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @01:13AM (#33326503)
Yes I did mean the top 0.1% of men.

I disagree with that the top man can not date more than a few.

A single woman needs a romantic partner let's say ever three months, a man can have one every day. We see this in gay men having 500+ average sexual partners. Gay men can have sex as much as they want, because of access.

Top 0.1% of men can also have sex when ever they want, they are getting constant matches with 6,7,8 level woman. Well below their level, because its easier to get people below your level into bed without courting.

They have sex, he doesn't call her back, she is mad at men for another three months.

A few men can soak up all of the above average woman, considering they are on a bell curve and are rare them self. Only a subset of people are even on these dating apps.

Average looking people don't have this problem, because they are happy with matching other average woman who the top men are not interested in.

Summary: top men can date below their own level because a 7 woman, three below them is still very beautiful. But a 7 man can't date three below their own level because a 4 is not attractive and not worth the time using a app for.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by socialismisok on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @02:06AM (#33326833)
Judging by how you are framing the issue and the way you've talked about women in this thread (which has been a red flag for me, at least) I suspect your experience has nothing to do with your physical traits.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by Beaver117 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:46AM (#33327892)
Please focus on the argument and don't attack the poster's character. This isn't reddit.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by borissk on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:35AM (#33328673)
If you'd read the thread, you'll find out that the poster's character is a part of the discussion (as he claims his character has nothing to do with his lack of success on dating sites).
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by socialismisok on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:52AM (#33331270)
The argument is, "I'm having trouble getting women to approve of me because of systemic issues with women."

I'm pointing out that the causal relationship the poster is making might be wrong. The issue could be the behavior if the poster, not some systemic issue with women.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by rabuse on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:16AM (#33326167)
The paradox of choice
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by vidarh on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:46AM (#33327890)
A less dramatic version of your first solution is to show a profile progressively less the more matches are pending, and the more selective you are in rejecting pending matches.

Couple that with trying to predict likely matches and weight towards showing profiles which are likely to match and you would likely approach solution 2 without explicitly focusing only on attractiveness.

But at the same time you'll have killed a major revenue driver for a lot of dating sites: frustration over few matches.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by godmode2019 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @05:59AM (#33328416)
How do dating apps make money? They were all prerevenue last time I used one.

I think trying to move away from images is a good idea, so people can showcase their worth to better compete with the physical gifted people who benefit from images.

I thought of a idea where you have to have a reel 10second video showcasing 5 traits

Let's say, you see the list of options and choose

Cooking Humour Adventure Intellect Strength

Say those are your traits, your reel will show case them. With the aim of creating relationships rather than hook ups.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by vidarh on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @02:50PM (#33334632)
Most of them make apps either by upsells or via ads, both of which gives them an incentive to prolong your usage of the site.

The typical user stays only for weeks or months at a time. Many users come back rarely enough that e.g. Bumble offers a lifetime premium membership for less than it costs you to renew their quarterly membership a third time ($149 for the lifetime membership I think), which should tell you something about how long they expect even the most committed users to hang around.

Which makes sense. After all, if they do their job, you'll meet someone and not need the app any more, and if they do nothing for you, you'll get tired of them and disappear eventually. Only a very narrow subset of users use the non-hookup focused sites for very long.

The challenge then is that this puts a very severe ceiling on your customer acquisition cost. Who knows what their average lifetime value of a user is, but it's going to be a small fraction of that $149 lifetime membership, with most users never paying anything at all.

If you can make one that is good enough that you don't need to advertise much, you might have a chance, but it's a very tough, very crowded market (for every Tinder and Bumble, there's are hundreds of dating sites which nobody remembers).

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by borissk on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:30PM (#33325845)
If that's true the person to figure out how to make dating apps work for average guys can make a lot of money...
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by Bakary on Monday October 24, 2022 @11:54PM (#33326004)
That doesn't sound logically possible, and if it were it would not last long as average men get wind of it
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by borissk on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:09AM (#33327195)
Why is it not possible? In a society where multi marriages are not allowed there's a woman for every man.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by Rufbdbskrufb473 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:47AM (#33327430)
Most dating doesn't lead to permanent pairings, so the fact that there are roughly equal numbers of men and women isn't that relevant when people are free to date at different frequencies and durations.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by Bakary on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @11:48AM (#33332190)
For that to work in practice implies a rigidly monogamous society where almost everyone participates in the same context, bonds for life and does so at an early stage of their lifecycle, as well as few mismatches between both relationship goals and pairing criteria. That's essentially the traditional non-polygamous agrarian civilization model if we ignore the fact that the 0.01% or so of nobles had multiple partners. On dating apps the dynamic is very different.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by smt88 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @12:48AM (#33326364)
I think lots of people have tried.

I agree that among the pool of people on these apps, there are lots of matches that would work out among average-looking people. So why doesn't that happen?

It's because a lot of attraction is based on things that photos and profiles can't convey. The medium of "digital app" is just very, very wrong for optimizing dating.

I've seen research that the most efficient way to handle dating is in-person speed dating.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by globular-toast on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:54AM (#33331305)
> It's because a lot of attraction is based on things that photos and profiles can't convey.

Especially for men. The worst thing is the imbalance. Compatibility in a long-term relationship is certainly based on factors other than looks for both sexes but, like it or not, all relationships start with basic attraction. Women's basic attraction comes from their looks in the vast majority of cases. But for most men, it has to come from somewhere else. Usually status, power, ability, humour etc. So it works absolutely fine for women, but is a complete non-starter for the average man.

I'm not surprised speed-dating is more efficient. My experience with online dating is that even if I find a woman physically attractive I might not find her attractive in real life. We might simply not hit it off, or there can even be other factors like smell that are off-putting. Speed dating eliminates those immediately as well as allowing people to show off non-physical attractive qualities. I still don't think it's optimal for men, though. The best way is to get good at something and show it off in public. Like playing in a band, public speaking, leading and commanding respect of other men etc. That can make otherwise physically repulsive men attractive. There are countless examples.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by Rufbdbskrufb473 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:44AM (#33327408)
Dating apps end up mostly being used for casual dating and hookups. The closest thing to that for average or below average guys is prostitution, which of course has been around a while and much money was and is being made.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by borissk on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @06:37AM (#33328688)
IMHO most users of such site do hope to find a permanent partner.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by vidarh on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:41AM (#33327857)
Not convinced. There are obvious steps that'd be more "average guy" friendly, but would kill engagement and so revenue.

E.g. slow down showing profiles when they have more than X pending matches. An ex told me she'd paid for Gold on Tinder once out of curiosity (let's you see how many have swiped right on you). Her pending matches was in the 4 digits. These profiles "soak up" a lot of the time and attention of people on these platforms without creating a real chance of matches for users who aren't super aggressively matching everyone.

This again trains for a behaviour where men match a lot, and women can afford to be very selective.

But reducing the displays of the most popular profiles so their pending matches queue is never very deep won't do anything good for revenue.

Another option is to train models to predict likely matches, and sort displays accordingly, but that again won't do much for revenue, because it would mean average men would be more likely to be shown women closer to their attractiveness level which there is less competition for rather than women with 4 figure deep queues of waiting matches.

Remember, most dating sites make money from making it hard enough to get a match that people pay for premium services to increase their chance. They have a built in incentive to exaggerate the possibilities while maintaining friction in actually meeting someone. It must be hard for you to find someone for most of them to do well.

If you can convince people to pay for a less perversely incentivised model, maybe. E.g. a "pay per match" model maybe, if we'll protected against scammers. But suspect it'd be a very hard sell.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by globular-toast on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:54AM (#33331325)
Or just stick with the tried and tested way of convincing average guys you can make them more attractive without actually making them more attractive.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by thrown_22 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @01:49AM (#33326709)
>Dating apps are tailored to people in the top X% of attractiveness.

They aren't. I'm in the top 1% for income and top 5% for looks. I used to get no matches on tinder. I asked a few female friends to come up with a profile they thought would be more attractive. After I saw what they came up with (I have a boat, I fly first class, I'm in a holiday in Europe) I deleted it and move them to acquaintances.

The type of woman who would find that sort of thing attractive is _not_ the type of woman who I'd want to sleep with let alone have a relationship with.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by slingnow on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:29AM (#33330210)
Top 5% of looks based on what exactly?

Something about your story doesn't add up. I would certainly consider myself NOT in the top %5 of looks, and get plenty of matches. And I'm not looking for trashy women who are only into material things either.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by thrown_22 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @09:40AM (#33330314)
> Top 5% of looks based on what exactly?

On looking at the average person I see on the street. Do you not have eyes?

>and get plenty of matches

Matches are the first step, then you have chatting, organizing a date and then a hookup/relationship. The attrition rate is abysmal at every level. It's just not time efficient to use online dating.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by Nimitz14 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:34AM (#33330997)
A close friend of mine kills it on tinder. He just has pics of himself looking good and smiling. He basically doesn't need to book a place to stay when going on holiday (lol). I would not put him in the top 5% (maybe top 10).

Your pics either sucked or you're not as attractive as you think you are. You don't need pics of yourself being rich. Or maybe you're older (he's 27).

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by globular-toast on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @10:57AM (#33331380)
He's either far more attractive than you think. Or he's grossly exaggerating his success (like all men). Most likely a bit of both.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by adrr on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:06PM (#33325303)
Have you tried asking people to send you pictures of hotdogs.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by hsavit1 on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:08PM (#33325317)
does anyone actually use bumble and enjoy it? serious question
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by astrange on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:26PM (#33325437)
My coworkers tell me it's the only app that worked for them. I'm not in the market so can't comment myself.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by andirk on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:16PM (#33325378)
I got a girlfriend from it once.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by nl on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:18PM (#33325395)
Sure, it's worked great for me. Couple of good long-term relationships and plenty of fun short term relationships too.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by petesergeant on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:56PM (#33325625)
had a great time on it, culminating in meeting my wife
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by probably_wrong on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @03:07AM (#33327185)
Based on conversations with (male) friends, it seems to be the place for those who can't deal with Tinder anymore.

Personally I'm back to OkCupid - it may not have the number of users the others do, but at least I now get to know something about potential matches other than 5 pictures and that they enjoy traveling.

Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by vidarh on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @04:47AM (#33327902)
Have had some success with it in the past. Less casual hookup focused than Tinder, which can be good or bad depending on what you're after.
[dead]
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by logicalmonster on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:02PM (#33325273)
I realize that this isn't exactly Reddit, but good God man, has the capacity for a simple self-deprecating joke been lost here?
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by nickmooney on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:07PM (#33325309)
The issue isn't that it's self-deprecating, it's that it's not funny, esp. given the context. "Read the room" type of thing.
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by dymk on Monday October 24, 2022 @10:10PM (#33325329)
Speak for yourself, I found it chuckle worthy
Re:Bumble open sources Private Detector, AI tool to detect u... by oneoff786 on Tuesday October 25, 2022 @07:32AM (#33329133)
I don’t get it? Are they suggesting then that their normal photos are being tagged as lewd?