Google makes $5-$10 per Android phone, maybe 10% of what it's partners make. That's about the same amount as Microsoft makes off each Android phone and is perhaps 1/50th of what Apple makes off each iphone.
Even worse it turns out that the half empty gold mine is on public land and any crazy old coot can waltz in and start mining themselves:
Android won their "empire" by being the only credible licensed iphone clone in 2009. The real question is whether this empire is going to be of the Han/Roman/Windows variety as so many commentators assume or will it be a short lived dynasty like the Qin/Napoleonic/Netscape variety.
I'll put my money on a Three Kingdoms scenario playing out. Why do I think WP 7 has a ghost of a chance when everyone's done nothing but dismiss them? Let's review:
Android phones started shipping in Fall 08. However they really didn't have any traction until Fall 09 when Verizon started pushing the Droid. And it wasn't until Froyo phones shipped en masse in Summer 2010 where Android started to dominate carrier shops.
In the same way WP7 launched buggy, incomplete and lackluster in late 2010. It had no traction for it's first 3 quarters. Lately though we've seen a mature OS update released on a 2nd generation of phones that were designed for it.
More importantly Microsoft has made no secret of it's desire to buy market share with retail subsidies. And it will certainly be buying this market share at Android's expense. How much they're willing to lose buying this market share isn't clear but if it's anything like the money they've plowed into Bing that's a lot.
I work for TomTom who's been battling for years to collect GPS probes so that they could provide the best HD traffic.
Google recently announced their Traffic layer which magically offered almost similar quality with full world-wide coverage all made possible by their thousands and thousands of free Android GPS probes.
Just a small reminder that there might be more hidden benefits of Android.
They also have an ad business which gets to safely live on the most popular smartphone OS without real risk of it being shut down for competitive reasons.
They have a massive lever with which to move other projects as well. They have millions of users of their maps program on mobile, for example. They get voice search data. They get people doing searches. They get many more Gmail subscribers. Soon those millions will be nudged toward using G+ because it comes on their phone and offers some nice benefits.
As for whether or not Android is here to stay, there's a measure of user lock-in just like there is with the iPhone. You already have your applications and media that you have paid for.
And according to most everyone, their latest version of the OS is a marked step forward, bringing Android's weak points up close to parity with iOS while continuing to build upon the relative strengths that have been there for the past few major releases.
Microsoft may gain traction with their phone and ecosystem, but I'm not sure why that's any reason to forecast that Android will go the way of Netscape.
Also, you're neglecting to account for the money they're making from the Android market: apps, movies, books, etc.
Exactly. They set themselves up so they could quickly react to disruptive change in the smartphone market. The iPhone happened to be what came along.
Most people don't understand what an impressive accomplishment this is. Let's look at how long it took for some other smartphone competitors to release their response to the iPhone:
Palm took two years (and started over from the ground up). Microsoft took three years (and still doesn't have traction). Nokia took took four years (and then threw it away). RIM still isn't there yet (next year?).
And Google? They took one year. They clearly were doing something right.
BTW, props for remembering Danger. So many people don't in these discussions and (for someone who was working with smartphones back then) it is incredibly frustrating.
> And Google? They took one year. They clearly were doing
> something right.
Like buying Android Inc. in 2005?Android the company was built to sell to a larger company. The acquisition could be attributed to the shrewdness of Android's sales pitch to Google.
Real cost of Android =
Android acquisition price +
Motorola acquisition price ($12.5 Billion) +
Lawsuits
Android enjoyed a 2.5x growth rate in revenue over the last year. If that continues for a few years, your formula will seem pretty cheap.
On the motorola acquisition, it's fairly hard to calculate what it saved Google. Will the patent portfolio they picked up save them billions in settlements/legal costs? Quite possibly.
They did not report mobile quarterly figures or costs and profits.
But. we can extrapolate:
$2.5 Billion annualized == $625 million quarterly mobile revenue.
Elsewhere in the earnings report:
$10 Billion total quarterly revenue
One of the costs broken out was TAC (Traffic Acquisition Costs,) -- these were $.25 for each $1 of revenue.
Assuming that TAC costs are consistent across mobile and non-mobile that means:
quarterly mobile revenue - TAC == $470 million
ANAICT, Gross margins were 40% of revenue - TAC
quarterly gross mobile profit == $188 million
No figures were given, so let's assume that 50% of mobile comes from Android phones (50 % from iPhones and all other smart phones)
quarterly gross mobile profit from Android == $94 million
No direct expenses/costs were given for mobile, Android development, etc.
If we assume Google has 10 people on the Android team @ $100,000 each, per year (Pay, office, equipment, benefits, etc.) or $.25 million per quarter
That would leave:
Android quarterly profit before taxes == $93.75 million
Obviously, these are just SWAG estimates (and I hope my math and logic are correct) -- but they are an attempt to put in context the headline of this article"
---------
Google announces $2.5 billion in mobile revenue/run rate == $93.75 million Android quarterly profit after taxes (30%)
$93.75 Million quarterly profits from Android is peanuts. Apple earns more selling smart covers.
First of all, you're not counting growth. Smartphones sales have been up 74% in Q2 2011 since the same quarter last year, while PC sales have had only a 2% growth. The smartphones market is about to explode.
Also, as I said in another message - because Androids do have a good share of the market, if Apple switches to another search provider, they'll be technically and from a brand perspective at a disadvantage (people say google it for a reason). Because of Android, Apple simply cannot create customer expectations in terms of the search engine used, like they did with other issues (e.g. Flash), quite the contrary I've seen people bitch about the lack of proper integration with other Google products.
And you know, Apple was thinking about switching to Bing. They haven't. You should really be adding the search traffic Google makes from iOS too ;)
Because that's what Android is about: control / keeping the competition focused on anything else but Google's Search. Quite a genius move if you ask me.
Android has been successful already, even without that.
Lawsuits
Only Oracle has sued Google over Android, and the outcome of that is far from settled.
Like iOS device, it's also creating an ecosystem of devices/service. How many people now have gmail accounts, and are searching through google then before they had Android devices?
Google hopefully understands (don't see any indication they don't) that they are getting a channel to market directly to users as well as obtain new users. This system gives them a platform to directly compete in a variety of media markets, now as a content provider in addition to their ad model.
Google wants to create a platform that will dominate all mobile devices for years to come. Cell phones (and, more recently, tablets) are just one aspect of that. They want a standard OS for any small-scale device. In their vision of the future, your coffee maker, refrigerator, and laundry machine may all use an Android-based platform.
This is one of the reasons why they are perfectly happy with Android being used for cheap smartphones which are really just amped-up feature phones. They don't want to be seen as elitist, the way that Apple tries to market itself as high-end. They want to have high-end products, sure, but it's equally important to them that they cover the range of that spectrum.
I don't know if they had exactly this in mind when acquiring Android, but by now, it seems clear to me that this is their goal.
Judging by Android users I see around me, not a single one.
Apple has that pesky hardware business eating at the margins. They are a very, very efficient manufacturer, but hardware margins are always less than software (especially search, which might be the most profitable business ever in terms of margin).
(Also, don't forget Google makes a huge amount off mobile search on iOS devices).
Google's profit margin is 26.7%[1] which includes all the money the spend on non-revenue generating engineering like Chrome, ChromeOS, etc etc.
Apple's profit margin is 23.95%[2], and they have very few non-revenue generating activities.
Android is the new Nokia. Lots of worthless Market share, Zero profit.
EDIT: I realize i'm going to be down voted for this. But if you don't think it's true, you're delusional.
Android is clearly a goldmine. The goldmine is the incremental search revenue Google gets from controlling the Android platform. Why do you think the search volume on mobile is a hockey stick at Google? Literally every single android device has a dedicated search button on it; iOS devices do not. Which device do you think has higher searches per user? The incremental search volume (and search ad revenue) is enough to justify the entire Android investment.
More importantly, without Android, Apple had the ability to lock out Google from mobile search by changing the default search provider to non-Google. The lost revenue if Apple changes its mind and Google is locked out of mobile search? There's your 2nd goldmine.
The argument that Android is not a money maker is like the argument that Gillette selling razors below cost is bad idea. At the end of the day both Gillette and Google make a tons of money off selling something that isn't exactly the main product, but is peripheral to it. In Gillette's case it's razor blades, in Google's it's search.
I could take a guess.
"Google Exec Testifies Before Senate That Two-Thirds of Mobile Search Happens on iOS Devices"
http://9to5mac.com/2011/09/21/google-23rds-of-our-mobile-sea...
When Android got #1 market share the Apple fanboys decided that direct profit is the only number that matters.
And that makes Android's success even more amazing.
I still find unbelievable they can make that much money just with ads – I do believe they do, it just befuddles me – on a phone it's even harder to display them and in fact you don't see as many in the mobile web, are we really sure that Android is profitable? Maybe it's not yet and they're still trying to find the business model for it. Maybe it will never directly be, it will just serve as measure to not be excluded from the mobile world and keep competitors (not derogatory) from eating into Google.
I do as well, and wish there were more research available on internet advertising. I'm sure a few companies at the top of the pyramid make money, but everyone else (IMNSHO) is taking money out of their left pocket and putting it into their right pocket (A buys ads on B, B buys ads on C, [...] Z buys ads on A; in the end, a zero-sum game).
I'm sure we'll be shouted down, but you're not alone in your opinion.
Have you actually looked? It's one of the most actively researched fields in the world at the moment.
Try http://www.iab.net/insights_research to start.
I'm sure a few companies at the top of the pyramid make money
This is absolutely, completely untrue. One of the reasons internet advertising is so popular is because its effectiveness can be proven - advertising companies can show how people exposed to ads buy at a higher rate. The improvement in rate can be calculated exactly, which shows the advertiser exactly how much they should spend.
Take a look at http://www.aimia.com.au/enews/IAB/IAB%20Retail%20Study%20-%2... (skip to roughly half way thorough).
There they promoted a new product in one market exclusively online, and did no promotion in the other market. Sales in the promoted market were 11% higher than the control.
Don't believe it? Try it yourself - I wanted to understand it better, so signed up for an affiliate account and did some Facebook advertising. It worked quite well - I was able to make around $15 for every $1 spent (obviously this was a very specific market segment).
http://www.iab.net/about_the_iab
"The Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) is comprised of more than 500 leading media and technology companies that are responsible for selling 86% of online advertising in the United States."
Aside from anecdotal evidence (your returns of 15:1) I haven't found any long-term studies done by independent researchers that prove internet advertising is any more effective than other forms of advertising, if it's effective at all. The only real accomplishment internet advertisers can lay claim to is training the general population to never even glance at the left / right / top / bottom navs on a page.
In general, the poll results and comments in another recent thread on HN on ad blockers (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3324709) seem to support my theories about how ineffective internet advertising is. I'd be interested in seeing some untainted long-term research on this subject.
iOS is the place where people like 37Signals can thrive. Android is the place where people like Facebook can thrive.
They've got a market of millions of people who don't buy anything, but click ads occasionally. Android should team up with AdBusters because on the Marketplace everyday is buy nothing day.
1) Apple switches to another search provider, in which case iPhones will have a functional and brand disadvantage as Google Search is both good and a synonym for searching on the web
2) Apple does not switch to another search provider, in which case mobile searches are dominated by Google, as iOS and Android represents a majority
3) Android ends up on 90% of all smartphones, like Windows, making whatever Apple does irrelevant, even if Apple continues to enjoy the highest margins in the industry
You're clearly not seeing the forest from the trees.
http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2011/11/21/piper-jaffray-android...
They explicitly compare their estimate of 6.5 billion Android downloads with 18.5 billion iOS downloads. Free downloads are included in both cases (but the Android estimate is way, way out)
(Edit: To make it doubly clear, I'm implying that their estimate of revenue share shouldn't be trusted either)
In the business of selling apps I'd much rather I went to market underestimating the size of the market than overestimating it. To me, one more download is one more client to support with no revenue upon which to service it. I guess if I developed for the Marketplace I could have 40% more freeloaders than anticipated. Awesome, just what I needed, more expenses and the same rev.
I'm not in the business of cheerleading mobile operating systems, I'm in the business of selling stuff. (To be fair, I do cheerlead Apple because people can't buy my stuff on Android, perhaps the market is changing and I'll have to adapt, but once my stuff is available on both platforms, I really wouldn't care what people use)
I'll be ecstatic when the marketplace is at a billion a year but I think that's a bit off at this point. App Store vs. Marketplace is like Google vs. Bing for traffic, if you're a huge site you'll see 15% of your traffic from bing, but if you're a smaller player you'll see 99% from Google. Likewise when doing SEO work I don't care about bing because it doesn't drive traffic for me like Google does. On the other hand I use Bing for SEM because it has cheaper CPCs with a better conversion rate.
There are a couple of platform zealot prats rambling on with their standard, dated anti-Android nonsense in here. It is disheartening that they haven't been carpet bombed into the hellban so many voices of reason end of enduring.
I'm seriously considering picking up some android kit after reading more about how the marketplace works now.
Do you think it would be worth it to just focus on ICS at this point?
On iOS I just support the latest. (I figure users with the older versions can stay on them til they upgrade and it reduces support issues drastically)
Every user having their searches funneled through your search engine. Tight integration with your e-mail service, your video sharing service and your VOIP service. Much, much more.
Millions of people conducting their lives through your product is definitely not 'worthless'.
iOS currently has all of that except the VOIP, FWIW.
If your theory is correct and Android has simply replaced Nokia, it's making a good amount of money for someone. (Unless $1B == 0 in your world.)
Android makes Google $2.5B/yr (that's a run rate, up from $1B this time last year). Google's total run-rate is about $35B by comparison.
Given that it's in land-grab mode, I imagine they are re-investing like crazy in Android-- they realize that the dominant smartphone operating system has a lot of market power. As an example, Microsoft makes more on Office/Server stuff than they do on Windows.
tl;dr Comparing a dominant operating system (Android to a hardware company that grudgingly made software (Nokia) isn't really valid.
Worthless market share? Zero profit? Such emotionally-driven hubris has no place on HN.
Google often get slagged for the unfocused, perpetual beta thing. But laser focus is overrated. For example, given the choice of only picking Chrome OS or Android, a laser focused Google would have never gone Android. Overall I think it is much better to admit the future is unknown, and be prepared (especially for a large company with Google-sized resources).