News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by ghaff on Monday October 17, 2022 @03:56PM (#33238737)
Well, not something I use a lot but Uber/Lyft. I don't need to use my banking app but otherwise I'd have to drive to an ATM to deposit a check. Again, not essential, but there would be a lot more friction when traveling than otherwise.

(And certainly there are a lot of things on the web that are hard to go without and I assume the typical case where someone doesn't have a smartphone doesn't have easy access to a computer either.)

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by messe on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:03PM (#33238822)
> but otherwise I'd have to drive to an ATM to deposit a check

Are cheques really that common in the US still? In Ireland, and as far as I'm aware, the rest of the EU, it's rare to see a cheque at all these days. Almost everything is paid either on cards or some other form of electronic transfer.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by rootusrootus on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:27PM (#33239102)
> Are cheques really that common in the US still?

Not really. Happens enough that you can't call it a surprise to see one, but they're only used in certain niches at this point. I write a check about once a year, for some edge case like I'm paying a contractor who refuses to just get Venmo or equivalent.

Even where they are used (as someone mentioned, you do occasionally see elderly folks write them at the grocery store) they tend to be just a slightly different version of a debit card w/o PIN -- the stores now can instantly run them, there's no way to float one.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by messe on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:35PM (#33239193)
> they tend to be just a slightly different version of a debit card w/o PIN -- the stores now can instantly run them, there's no way to float one.

That's actually the most surprising thing I've heard in this thread. Having that ability would probably go some way toward explaining their longevity. Like I said in another comment, I don't even know if a grocery store / supermarket would accept a cheque here, mostly because they wouldn't have the ability to run them.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by ghaff on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:47PM (#33239314)
Yeah. I don't know the details and I very rarely see them in stores. But there's some sort of system that, as parent says, basically immediately locks the funds so (as I understand it), there's no risk to the store.

I assume things like car dealerships use the system as well. When I bought a car recently I just gave them a personal check which they were fine with. In the past I had to go to my bank and get a cashier's check.

You don't even generally see signs about returned check fees these days.

They're not super-common in general for most use cases but they're still the most straightforward way to make personal payments (other than in-person cash payments) without going through some process that's more involved than giving someone a piece of paper.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by ryandrake on Monday October 17, 2022 @11:35PM (#33242666)
I've written about 25 checks for "one-off stuff" in the last year or so, -not including- the checks that pay my electric utility, Internet, trash, water/sewer, auto insurance, and so on. Property taxes are check-only in my area. A lot of kid stuff at school like PTA, reading activities, sports and such are cash or check only. Home maintenance things like painters, gardeners, pool service, trash hauling take checks only. I can't see a way to get along without physical checks, at least in the USA, unless you take a big sweaty wad of cash everywhere you go.
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by scarface74 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:39AM (#33243365)
Where in the heck do you live? Even my kids school had a portal for payments. My yard guy does get paid by check. But I do that via bill pay and the bank sends a check. Even independent painters take Venmo cash app or PayPal
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by ghaff on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:10PM (#33238905)
Common enough. Ignoring the ones that I never see because my bank writes and delivers them for me, I still periodically get payments for things like FSA as a check. I also write maybe a couple dozen a year for various home service stuff.

(That said, I probably only deposit 5 or 6 checks a year. So putting them in an ATM at the bank wouldn't be a horrible inconvenience. And they are getting less and less common.)

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by scarface74 on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:40AM (#33243371)
And I deposit checks by taking a picture on my phone.
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by alistairSH on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:08PM (#33238888)
Yes, sadly they're pretty common. My wife's side business is almost always paid with a check. I regularly, but not frequently, receive doctors bills or similar without online payment options, so I have to write ~12 checks/year. My housekeeper doesn't accept Paypal/Venmo, so she's paid with a check as well. Sane for some random laborers (lawn, paint) who are working by word of mouth (and not employed by a larger firm). And it's pretty common for elderly people to use them to pay for groceries.

I guess my counter-question is what does the rest of the world do for doctors bills or paying laborers who don't accept payment via Paypal/Venmo?

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by warp on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:36PM (#33239206)
Here in Ecuador it's mainly cash, but it's becoming more common to just do a normal bank transfer from a mobile phone. The banking app of my bank here (Pichincha) has a built-in option to share the payment as a .jpg via Whatsapp (or any messaging app) as a sort of confirmation to the recipient.

In the Netherlands banking apps let you create "Payment Requests", which is basically a URL you can share with someone to have them pay you (you can pre-fill the amount they need to pay). Typically, if you open such an URL on your phone, it will let you jump into your banking app of _your_ bank to make the actual payment (even if the payment request is from a different bank than the on you're using).

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by messe on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:15PM (#33238965)
> And it's pretty common for elderly people to use them to pay for groceries.

Interesting. I'm not even sure a grocery store / supermarket would accept a cheque here.

> My housekeeper doesn't accept Paypal/Venmo, so she's paid with a check as well

Here it'd be either cash in hand, or a bank transfer (same as rent, really). All you need is their IBAN (International Bank Account Number) and BIC (Bank Identifier Code), and most mobile banking apps will let you set up a monthly direct debit. You can sometimes run into issues if their bank account is in a different country to the bank you're transferring from—it's unlawful to discriminate between IBANs in different countries, although it tends to goes unpunished—but there's usually workarounds to that.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by alistairSH on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:17PM (#33238991)
same as rent, really

Also frequently paid by check.

All you need is their IBAN (International Bank Account Number) and BIC (Bank Identifier Code), and most mobile banking apps will let you set up a monthly direct debit.

What is this dark magic?!?! lol. The US is comically awful at consumer banking.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by messe on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:25PM (#33239078)
And actually just to add to the last question of your comment. We'd also pay for doctors bills by either cash, card, or direct debit. Healthcare in Ireland isn't perfect (long waiting times—but you can go private for quicker care), but it's relatively cheap (free under a certain income, in the cases of certain long-term medical conditions, and above a certain age), and heavily subsidized.

My sister recently had a stay in hospital, and then later an emergency room visit. As far as I'm aware, it all totaled less than €200 (half of which will be refunded by insurance, and another 20% of the remainder as a tax credit), which was all paid for partially by card (to the GP who referred us to the hospital), and partially by bank transfer (to the hospital).

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by MandieD on Monday October 17, 2022 @08:27PM (#33241460)
You still get printed bills with the bank account number to send the money to in Germany; only big change in the past decade is that that bank account number is a long IBAN number with the bank’s ID and a checksum rolled in.
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by iso1631 on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:11PM (#33238925)
Still exist in the UK. I had to cash a cheque a few years ago, very amusing having to get my bank to send me some book of paper to do so.
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by messe on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:17PM (#33238993)
I mean, they still exist here in Ireland, my biological grandmother sent me one last christmas; it's still sitting on my desk and I haven't gotten around to cashing it.
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by tobias_smollett on Monday October 17, 2022 @05:43PM (#33239899)
If your grandmother balances her checking account every month, it's extra work for her to have outstanding checks. Also, people at the poverty level often don't know how much money they have to spend for the month until their rent and utility payments are deducted from their account. (they don't do math)
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by messe on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:31PM (#33240355)
> Also, people at the poverty level [..] (they don't do math)

I'm sorry, but what the fuck sort of paternalistic and defeatist attitude toward education is that?

EDIT: I would like to apologize, I swore in my previous edit of this comment. I did not swear enough. Seriously what the absolute fuck sort of attitude is that toward people and swearing?

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by ghaff on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:01PM (#33240078)
They may also not be cashable after some length of time like 90 days.
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by LinuxBender on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:07PM (#33238875)
Uber/Lyft

Ah, that makes sense. I've never used those. I've used taxi cabs but maybe I am missing out or paying more than I should.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by nobody9999 on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:13PM (#33238948)
>I've never used those. I've used taxi cabs but maybe I am missing out or paying more than I should.

At least in my experience, you're not doing either of those things.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by duderific on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:02PM (#33240087)
Uber/Lyft are so much more reliable than a standard taxi. Before the ridesharing apps, I'd had several experiences of trying to call a taxi company to come pick me up (this is in San Francisco). It never arrived after repeated calls to the dispatcher, saying "it's on the way." If they're overbooked, they simply ignore the requests and you have no remedy other than to call another taxi company, which is likely similarly impacted.
Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by theodric on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:03PM (#33238826)
'I like to use' is not the same as 'mandatory.' You can call a taxi, you can beg a lift, you can hitchhike, you can walk, you can drive.

The Netherlands has a supermarket (Marqt) which does not accept cash. Thankfully, there are alternatives. Marqt is also so expensive that you're either a yuppie with a debit card or can afford to pay a shopper if you're getting your food there.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by morpheuskafka on Monday October 17, 2022 @05:24PM (#33239689)
That seems rather circular. By definition Uber is a (supposedly) improved taxi service built on mobile computing/data service. If you were transported back in time before smartphones were common/socially essential, Uber wouldn't exist at all.

That would be like an older person complaining they "have to have a smartphone" to see pictures of their grandkids, when it's actually the other around. Because smartphones exist, they can see pictures they otherwise would not have seen at all because no one would have driven to the store, printed them out, and mailed them (or had a camera to take them with) without that technology.

Contrast that to something like parking, where using a phone app provides convenience and decreased operating costs, but the service itself is in no way dependent on people having phones.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by ghaff on Monday October 17, 2022 @05:36PM (#33239829)
>Contrast that to something like parking, where using a phone app provides convenience and decreased operating costs, but the service itself is in no way dependent on people having phones.

Well, if you can no longer pay for something that you used to be able to pay for with coins, you've lost something with a smartphone requirement.

Otherwise I get your argument but, if instead of smartphone, you say computer--now say that you don't really need a computer. You can phone people on your landline but many people won't pick up. OK, you can't use Amazon but there are local stores you can get to. And so forth. At some point, it's probably not like you'll starve but you're cut off from a lot of modern interaction.

Re:Does cashless society discriminate against the poor and e... by MichaelCollins on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:10AM (#33243197)
> drive to an ATM to deposit a check

If you think of it like that, then it's awfully inconvenient. But what you do, what I think most of us used to do, is pair that errand with another, like grocery shopping. Chances are fairly good there is an in-network ATM in route to the grocery store, if not at the grocery store. It only adds a minute, maybe a few minutes, to a trip you were going to make anyway.