I confess that I don't follow this.
I only have assets on Coinbase and generally assume they're reliable enough (from a technical/security stand-point and legal) that I don't bother jumping through hoops to do a wallet on my own device or hardware wallet.
Is it stupid? Maybe, but I think I'd be more likely to screw up somehow with the other approaches.
With real banks, there are pretty clear pecking orders for creditors vs depositors and depositors have FDIC to cover at least some in the worst disasters.
Would you have higher priority in getting your own coins back over senior debt holders?
“Not your keys, not your coins” is exactly what it sounds like. You really have no say at all in how the above scenario plays out.
There have been a hundred+ years of laws to figure out how to give rights to cash, bonds, equities to people who have them held by an institution. That hasn’t happened with crypto.
But who can tell how long until you get your coins in such a situation.
By contrast, as another commenter alluded to, fiat banking has an extensive system of laws and precedents that decides what happens in cases like this, which crypto lacks.
It feels like yet another “crypto people discover organically why centralized banking is the way it is.”
How do you do the "Fi" bit of "DeFi" if all you do is HODL?
With Celsius, the contract doesn't maintain this because the contract owner can freeze funds at any time. Because of this, your keys are no longer enough to access your funds. You also need "consent" from Celsius to withdrawal.
Compare this to a smart contract where the contract owner can't arbitrarily freeze or seize funds, alter state, or upgrade/modify the contract (or at least require some level of community consensus to do so). These platforms can still largely do what Celsius did but with the caveat that everything needs to be done on chain or through some auditable/provable off-chain method. Likewise changes to parameters or code would need to be done using either some consensus method (higher centralisation risk) or manually by users migrating to a new contract (lower risk).
Which just highlights why "crypto" is largely useless. The vast majority of people are incapable of operating sufficiently secure infrastructure. And even for people who can, it doesn't offer any meaningful advantages that would justify the enormous effort required.
> Privacy should be a basic and legally protected feature of blockchains.
This is impossible when you are using blockchains, because all data is, by design, public, and there is no way of preventing anyone from data mining it.
Monero does it and to an extent shielded transactions in zcash too.
I'm blown away by the complete disregard most of this community has for crypto. Yes, it is currently full of scams and charlatans. But you honestly believe there are no meaningful advantages to decentralized currency?
Is anti-censorship not an advantage? I'm not a huge fan of the government's ability to seize assets without any due process (See, e.g. Canada https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-60383385), which corporations are starting to get interested in (see, e.g. Paypal https://fortune.com/2022/10/10/paypal-users-fine-misinformat...). Bitcoin and other coins go a long way to solving these issues.
How about effectively free, instant transfers at any time of day or night? Traditionally if I wanted to wire money oversees, it's a full-day affair. I can transfer any amount of crypto I want in seconds to minutes, for far less than a wire fee.
How about the ability to instantly settle debts and contracts? This was literally impossible just a few years ago.
I know it's easy to shit on crypto (and there are many legitimate reasons for doing so), but you guys need to dream bigger.
Privacy in blockchains is certainly possible. Tornado cash, Monero, zcash, Aztec.
The alternative being you hold your keys.
This is another area where I swear it's almost as though the entire crypto space is run by aliens or a poorly trained AI.
Interview 100 people and ask them two questions:
1) Have you ever had to reverse or dispute an electronic (credit card) transaction?
2) Have you ever forgotten a password?
The answer for 100 or 100 million people to both of these questions is "YES". 100% of them. Yet the main foundational principles of crypto operate directly against both of these universal human truths.
It's utterly bizarre.
Crypto works the same way, except it's new and people aren't educated about it, so the space is filled with grifters and con artists.
Furthermore nothing prevents you from using an escrow/third party for transactions in crypto that you hope to be able to reverse under a certain time.
But obviously you lose some of the main advantages of crypto. It provides this optionality, soon, with the accelerated dispariton of cash money this choice will not exist with fiat money... even less with CBDCs in my estimation.
2) People forget stuff and lose things. Shit happens.
Not to be snarky but if we can't agree these are universal human truths I'll assume you're a chat bot run by the crypto AI I've been talking about...
Also, please stop saying it's new. Bitcoin came out in 2009 - the same year as Android, Venmo, Uber, Square, and countless other companies, platforms, and concepts overwhelmingly positively and safely used by millions if not billions of people every day.
"Mobile works the same way, except it's new and people aren't educated about it, so the space is filled with grifters and con artists."
"Ride sharing works the same way, except it's new and people aren't educated about it, so the space is filled with grifters and con artists."
The "it's new" excuse ran out at least half a decade ago.
And we have the courts to solve any disputes. What jurisdiction does bitcoin reside in?
All people I know IRL only ever carry small amounts of cash at a given point in time. The bulk of their liquidity is held at a financial institution.
While I appreciate the tremendous risk they run of having that institution go bust, the significant improvements in regulatory oversight of the past centuries have made it, in my mind, an acceptable compromise.
Meanwhile, the risk of getting cash stolen or lost remains uncomfortable.
Unfortunately, that risk is also present for people that manage their own keys. Either the private key is on a physical device which can be lost or pickpocketed, or they memorized a random sequence which they input in a hackable device every time they pay, to get a key they enter in various software at risk of vulnerabilities.
If you are just storing a moderate amount of USD in an account with no interest, the safest option is a bank with FDIC insurance. If you don’t happen to live in a country with this kind of banking and insurance, or if you are investing higher than FDIC limits, or you are seeking higher yield, this is where people begin to look at options like Celsius and Aave.
1. The crypto mantra "not your keys, not your coins" rings true.
2. Entrusting your personal financial data with a private company is sure to end in disaster, either by hack or court order. Privacy should be a basic and legally protected feature of blockchains.
3. Centralized Finance or CeFi is mostly a sham and deserves to be heavily regulated. Not to be confused with on-chain and transparent Decentralized Finance or DeFi platforms like Aave that have behaved predictably through this downturn, and have never required KYC.