News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Bakary on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:08AM (#33120728)
I can definitely understand not realizing that you could lose access to your account if you lose your phone number. But once it happens the first time, could you not pick any free email that does not require 2FA, and warn fellow homeless to avoid gmail?

I disagree with the idea that because a very, very niche audience is in dire straits that the design decisions should be based on their needs. The forced 2FA system has probably prevented identify theft and financial loss for a very large number of people. I'm saying this as someone who thinks Google is a shady and dangerous entity in general.

It's similar to the idea that hard cases make bad law.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by IIAOPSW on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:21AM (#33120890)
The phone number decision is stupid. I up and jump countries every few years. Each time, I'm switching to a new number. I'm the opposite of homeless, I'm that jet set elite. The idea that you want, need, should or will tie your identity to a phone number where people can always reach you is long outdated.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by RupertEisenhart on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:24AM (#33120924)
Sticking my German sim card into my phone for fifteen minutes in all sorts of random countries and continents and waiting for a number to come through always feels absurd.

I pray for the rise of esims! I feel like it's on the cards.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by lxgr on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:31AM (#33121010)
I've been using eSIMs for the past couple of years for this specific use case, and while they certainly help, it's really just a stop-gap measure:

You still need your phone and cell signal to receive them (at least many European carriers don't support SMS over VoWIFI); the eSIM is "stuck" in your phone if it physically breaks (and on many carriers, you can't re-use an eSIM QR activation code in any case); in many countries, SIMs expire after a couple of months or even weeks of inactivity, losing your number permanently, to name just a few.

I've found Google Voice to work quite well as a workaround for almost all of these problems, but unfortunately, many US companies insist on not allowing VoIP numbers for 2FA or even plain account creation purposes. I usually try to avoid these companies.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by mwint on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:36AM (#33121066)
> the eSIM is "stuck" in your phone if it physically breaks

Wait, does this happen?

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by heavenlyblue on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:43AM (#33121165)
That's overly dramatic, of course you can re-create it on the other phone. But what's true is that you can't physically transfer it.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by lxgr on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:56AM (#33121375)
I wasn't trying to be dramatic here: Without deleting an eSIM profile from a device, all implementations I know indeed disallow reinstalling the profile on another device. (The eSIM standard effectively enforces the singleton nature of an instantiated eSIM profile.) But of course most providers can re-issue eSIMs if required, just like they can mail a physical SIM replacement.

But in many cases, they either charge for it, require more or less involved bureaucratic acrobatics (including sending the QR code via physical mail as proof-of-address, because they've been burned badly by eSIM swapping), or both.

So the assumption that an eSIM activation (QR) code is more or less like a bearer token that you can keep in your password safe and use whenever required often does not hold true, especially when needed most (traveling internationally etc).

Fortunately, my provider is pretty good about it (I can instantly self-serve reissue an eSIM in their portal free of charge), but that seems to be the exception, and I also don't know how I feel about that, security-wise. (They don't offer 2FA, as far as I know.)

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by jaclaz on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:07AM (#33121530)
More common case.

Your phone breaks (broken screen, swollen battery, whatever).

With a physical SIM you can physically extract the SIM and insert it in another (spare) phone (and you can even borrow one for a few minutes).

To transfer an e-SIM you need to authorize the transfer on the old phone (the one that doesn't work):

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32138466

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Timpy on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:34AM (#33121910)
I thought I got everything moved over to an authenticator app before leaving home but I forgot one, I got a "check your phone for verification SMS" earlier today. My American SIM could get the text but my foreign sim was giving my laptop internet access. Big pain in the ass.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by xani_ on Friday October 07, 2022 @06:41PM (#33127764)
Eh, I greatly prefer ability to move the very reliable thing from one phone to another, just use another phone instead of going into paperwork to move it if my phone gets damaged or something
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by uup on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:23AM (#33120912)
So use one of the other 2FA options.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by esperent on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:36AM (#33121068)
Not always a possibility. Many banks require phone number based 2FA, for example. And you're required to use it any time you want to make a transaction that exceeds some threshold.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by netheril96 on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:46AM (#33122899)
We are talking about Google here, right?
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by jbay808 on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:37AM (#33121076)
(FWIW, my bank does not provide any other 2FA options.)
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by wavelen on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:26AM (#33120946)
afair you need to set up a phone number before you can choose to add another 2FA option (which is stupid imho)
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by UncleMeat on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:45AM (#33121190)
Even if this is the case, this isn't a problem for the poster. They have a phone number, it just changes frequently. They can sign up, enroll in a TOTP or U2F system, and then they are set.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by yellowapple on Friday October 07, 2022 @02:02PM (#33124836)
Except if you're using e.g. Google Authenticator and you lose that phone, you've now lost your TOTPs. The most unhoused-friendly solution there would be to use something like Authy instead (which is another password to remember, but at least it makes it easy to recover your TOTP keys on a new device without needing the old one); next best would be to use something like andOTP which supports backups (but then you'd need someplace to store those backups, which introduces the same problems as safely keeping a phone on your person).
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by UncleMeat on Friday October 07, 2022 @03:12PM (#33125654)
The context for this post is a person who moves between countries frequently and therefore gets new phone numbers. This person has consistent access to the same phone.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by yellowapple on Saturday October 08, 2022 @01:19PM (#33134130)
The context of the overall post is the posted Twitter thread, wherein the specific issue is the phone itself being lost/stolen.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by borissk on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:46AM (#33121216)
It's not stupid - Google wants to track everyone everywhere and a phone number is a good way to link an account to a real world person.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by oceanplexian on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:02AM (#33121457)
What’s painful is that I’ve ported my phone number out to a VoIP provider similar to Google Voice for exactly this purpose, but something like 25% of providers now block using SMS for 2FA unless it’s tied to an approved mobile phone operator.

Turns out 2FA is also being used as a low-effort form of a captcha in addition to being a tool for data harvesting and “device identification”. I wouldn’t be surprised if legitimate users simply never receive a 2FA SMS because someone used a prepaid phone or something.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by judge2020 on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:06AM (#33121518)
Using mobile phone numbers as a makeshift captcha is the #1 tool any security team has to prevent fraudulent signups. Because they're expensive to get, it puts any attack at a baseline cost $x, so many would-be attackers that only stand to gain $y just don't carry out the attack when $y < $x.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by throwawaysleep on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:08AM (#33121550)
It is more that generating thousands of phone numbers is extremely expensive. It is cheap for real users, but scammers and spammers have to pay a lot.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by tehwebguy on Friday October 07, 2022 @03:08PM (#33125606)
Was just reading about how Overwatch 2 won't let people register with a prepaid phone number.

I'm sure there is some good reason to want to avoid people spinning up free or ultra low cost phone numbers to make extra accounts but some users were like, "I've been using TracPhone for a decade" or something like that. Also pretty surprised that it's this easy to detect the carrier. Guessing we'll see this more and more!

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by danuker on Friday October 07, 2022 @06:41PM (#33127763)
The problem will solve itself. People unwilling to sign up for a mobile plan for playing a game will automatically boycott the likes of Overwatch 2, which will result in revenue lost (perhaps to competing games that allow prepaid cards).

I have only ever used prepaid cards. I would rather be cut off from communication (or buy a local prepaid card) than get a surprise bill of hundreds of euros for visiting a country outside the EU.

I guess a lot of people have the same thought process as me around Europe, because there are lots of smartphones available with dual SIM cards.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Wowfunhappy on Friday October 07, 2022 @07:06PM (#33128050)
I'm not so sure the free market will resolve things here, because people who use prepaid mobile plans are also typically lower income. They might not be considered a significant loss on net.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Beltalowda on Saturday October 08, 2022 @12:02AM (#33129703)
Is the loss of income enough to offset against the benefits (fewer trolls, spammers, scams, etc.)? I'm betting it's probably not.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by benhurmarcel on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:36AM (#33121962)
I've lived in different countries along the years, it's simple and best to just keep a permanent phone number in the country you consider the most like "home". Get a cheap phone-only plan, stick the SIM into a dumbphone or your second SIM slot. Done.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by jbay808 on Friday October 07, 2022 @07:24PM (#33128193)
That phone number will not necessarily get reception when travelling in foreign countries.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by xani_ on Friday October 07, 2022 @06:40PM (#33127744)
> The idea that you want, need, should or will tie your identity to a phone number where people can always reach you is long outdated.

Yeah I have no idea why phones still use numbers. It would be so easier if same address for e-mail worked for voice, just add some DNS records that point at my phone provider to domain and done.

Then again, spam calls would probably be so much worse...

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by sowbug on Friday October 07, 2022 @08:43PM (#33128738)
Fortunately Google doesn't require phone numbers for account access. See, for example: https://www.androidauthority.com/gmail-without-phone-number-...

You do need to be able to receive a texted code at a phone number to create a brand-new account. This is to deter spammers from creating lots of accounts. But once that's done, you can remove the phone number from the account.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by gerash on Friday October 07, 2022 @08:51PM (#33128782)
you can also use a security key or a onetime password from an authenticator app (plenty of options for each) or a separate device logged into Google as your second factor. You have plenty of options
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Beltalowda on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:59PM (#33129694)
I'm in the same boat; it's always a pain for services you don't login to that often but do need every 1-2 years. Account recovery ranges from "a pain" to "damn near impossible". I wasn't able to recover my PayPal account for example.

I also don't use my phone much, and the only reason I even have one of those things is because it's "needed" for so many things.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by rex_gallorum2 on Saturday October 08, 2022 @06:34PM (#33136676)
Absolutely true. I am a serial expat who has lost numerous numbers over the years by switching countries. I at least hope to keep the same basic online services running when crossing borders, but I swear, in the last couple of years, it has become an absolute nightmare. It is getting harder and harder.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by tomxor on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:13AM (#33120789)
> because a very, very niche audience is in dire straits

Not very niche.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by kthejoker2 on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:31AM (#33121005)
Wtf Calling homelessness a "niche" .. peak apres moi le deluge
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by esperent on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:39AM (#33121093)
Exactly. The word people should be looking for is "vulnerable". They are not a niche category, they are a vulnerable category, and need protection, not dismissal.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Kalium on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:34AM (#33121918)
You're absolutely right.

Now let's talk about how much effort and what level of resources it's reasonable to expect a commercial entity to invest in extending protections to vulnerable people in need who happen to not be customers.

Perhaps we're asking the wrong entity to address this problem? This seems more like a public service infrastructure problem.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by nyuszika7h on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:41AM (#33122027)
Google is a multi-billion dollar company, they barely have to lift a finger. They simply have to provide an option to opt out of 2FA. Add a bunch of warnings if you must. Even if Google was a small startup it would be trivial for them to do this.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Kalium on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:44AM (#33122061)
To be clear, your answer to vulnerable people needing protections is to lower the minimum level of security for everyone using Gmail. Do I understand correctly?
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by WithinReason on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:56PM (#33123938)
No, please reread.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Kalium on Friday October 07, 2022 @01:12PM (#33124177)
Ah! Then the problem is solved, I suppose.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by WithinReason on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:55PM (#33123922)
There is already an option to opt out of 2FA:

https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/1064203

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by crooked-v on Friday October 07, 2022 @07:31PM (#33128252)
If you turn off 2FA, it will still force you to add a phone number and use an SMS verification code sent to it whenever the big machine feels like it.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Bakary on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:12AM (#33121601)
This is the sort of performative response that is the problem. Let's say we force Google to switch off 2FA. Now we have exposed millions of people who don't know any better to phishing attempts and financial loss. And the group we are trying to help isn't really better off. There are so many other questions we could be asking. Why are they directed towards picking Gmail by default? Why is the system to give a replacement phone every 12 weeks instead of investing in a dedicated device that's much harder to damage or lose? Why is keeping the same number a hassle? Why are we tackling the problem with caseworkers instead of something more ambitious, that would ironically be less costly in the long run? There are so many angles we could go for, but instead we are stuck on this performative nonsense that gets retweets. It's pseudo-empathy at best, because it's not oriented towards a real solution.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Edman274 on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:59AM (#33122257)
> Why is the system to give a replacement phone every 12 weeks instead of investing in a dedicated device that's much harder to damage or lose? Why is keeping the same number a hassle?

If you're homeless, you're getting robbed. It doesn't matter that a yubikey would be worthless to a person mugging you, they'll take everything including the worthless stuff. Or you're being picked up by an ambulance and taken to a behavioral health center after a mental health crisis and when they do that they take your clothes off and stuff goes missing, even if it's worthless.

Keeping the same number usually requires paying into an account which requires being able to make consistent payments, which is not easy to do. Or a credit card or bank account is required. You are maybe unbanked in this scenario.

> Why are we tackling the problem with caseworkers instead of something more ambitious, that would ironically be less costly in the long run?

Caseworkers make practically nothing. Does your solution get rid of human beings to act as agents for people who sometimes lose touch with reality? Will there be an AI assistant to guide someone through a schizophrenic break and get them to a hospital and help get them reoriented after they regain contact with reality? That's what's necessary and you're treating actually understanding what they're going through as if it's virtue signalling.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by crooked-v on Friday October 07, 2022 @07:29PM (#33128238)
The downvotes are strange to me, because absolutely pointless thefts absolutely do happen in urban spaces, even for the non-homeless. Why would someone smash a car window just to steal a pair of prescription sunglasses that would be completely useless to 99.9% of people? I have no idea, but it happened to me.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by xani_ on Friday October 07, 2022 @06:42PM (#33127778)
> This is the sort of performative response that is the problem. Let's say we force Google to switch off 2FA. Now we have exposed millions of people who don't know any better to phishing attempts and financial loss.

Could be just option hidden somewhere in the settings. Don't need to turn it off for all

> And the group we are trying to help isn't really better off.

That's just your assumption

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by everforward on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:24PM (#33123444)
In the US, they are a niche at 0.2% of the population. Vegans are an order of magnitude larger at 2%.

They are a vulnerable niche, but a niche nonetheless.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by sp332 on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:51AM (#33121305)
There are over half a million homeless people in the USA right now. And only a quarter are "chronically homeless", meaning for ober a year or more than once. There are many, many people who will be homeless for a few months at some point during their lives.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Bakary on Friday October 07, 2022 @10:26AM (#33121796)
There are 1.5+ billion gmail users. I don't have stats, but that intuitively means millions of vulnerable people who could be scammed or phished or whatnot because they would never think of using 2FA at all.

Among those half a million homeless, how many use gmail and are unable to change for whatever reason? Among those, how many have issues with 2FA? Thus we advocate for increasing the vulnerability of millions to do something that would not even help the homeless that much. The whole problem of having to replace their phones every 12 weeks sounds like a far more pressing issue to investigate and find solutions for.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by Handytinge on Thursday October 20, 2022 @07:59PM (#33282469)
What a viewpoint.

The number of gmail users in the USA is obviously significantly lower, and the number of homeless or people in similar situations globally is obviously significantly higher.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by ridgered4 on Friday October 07, 2022 @12:50PM (#33123841)
> I can definitely understand not realizing that you could lose access to your account if you lose your phone number. But once it happens the first time, could you not pick any free email that does not require 2FA, and warn fellow homeless to avoid gmail?

Almost every free email service I've tried now requires a phone number to setup. Even protonmail required it for a brief while, although they now are back to captcha and a stern warning. I actually can't think of another free service besides protonmail that this isn't now true for.

An annoying trick some of them use is to allow you to setup the account and then lock it some time later. I've seen on immediate login (irritating waste of time) or after you've used it for awhile (what you used the account for is now held hostage unless you cough up a phone number).

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by stavros on Friday October 07, 2022 @09:40PM (#33129044)
Fastmail doesn't require a phone number for 2FA.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by ridgered4 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @02:00PM (#33166647)
It doesn't seem like fastmail is free, just a free trial.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by lazyasciiart on Friday October 07, 2022 @06:59PM (#33127980)
And what, find every system that has your existing email address and change it?
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by anigbrowl on Friday October 07, 2022 @11:41PM (#33129606)
> and warn fellow homeless to avoid gmail

Besides the fact that this doesn't scale at all, not using gmail is arguably a bad decision. If you have an email address at shiftydomain.com, some services won't accept it because its low barriers to entry may have been exploited by spammers or similar.

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by austinjp on Saturday October 08, 2022 @07:08AM (#33131341)
> very, very niche audience

The homeless are certainly not a niche audience. There might be between 13 and 26 million people in the US alone who have experienced homelessness at some point in their lives [0].

Besides, issues around permanent access to security devices are not exclusive to the homeless. The problem described in TFA impacts a far larger segment of society.

Critical services are increasingly only available online -- and online services are increasingly critical. The people governing access to critical services are willfully ignorant to the difficulties that vulnerable people face, and often make those difficulties worse.

[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK519593/

Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by parkingrift on Saturday October 08, 2022 @07:28AM (#33131439)
That headline number is garbage. It’s 550,000 people at any given time.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by austinjp on Saturday October 08, 2022 @08:38PM (#33137356)
It's certainly not garbage, read it again: people who have "experienced homelessness at some point in their lives".
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by parkingrift on Monday October 10, 2022 @07:56AM (#33150253)
Yes and that “experienced homelessness” figure includes people who moved in with friends, family, or relatives. The headline number is garbage.
Re:Gmail 2FA causes the homeless to permanently lose access ... by austinjp on Thursday October 13, 2022 @07:02PM (#33197601)
If I was homeless I'd certainly try to move in with friends or relatives.

Not garbage :)