News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by christkv on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:13PM (#33098332)
I rather be dependent on a democracy than a totalitarian state so a great first move. Now move some production to Europe and the us and we are talking.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by kranke155 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:16PM (#33098382)
It’s hard to see how much Índia will remain a democracy and it does have its problems. But certainly it seems far less of a revisionist power than China.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by achow on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:46PM (#33098819)
This is new.

You mean the current right wing ruling party? It has a very large vocal, visible and genuine support from large population of India. That is democracy by any definition. This support is for progressive policies and anti-corruption principles.

Not all section of population agree on progress at the cost of right wing philosophies, but that again is in line with the rules of democracy.

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by smoldesu on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:30PM (#33099411)
Democracy and authoritarianism are not mutually exclusive. I think most people's gripes aren't with their political leanings, but the way they chose to respond to things like the Farmer Protest (where Modi's administration basically admitted they were wrong). Stifling communication and censoring the internet isn't what any just democratic ruler does, regardless of their party affiliation.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by kumarvvr on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @10:03PM (#33103465)
Stifling communication and censoring the internet happens in Kashmir, where 6 decades of cross border terrorism by Pakistan have made security situations a hell to maintain. The USA tacitly supports Pakistan and looks the other way when its funds are used for terrorism.

When you have a large part of population as riot hungry foreign funded troublemakers, to maintain peace, cutting off the internet in times of escalating situations is necessary evil.

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by KrishnaShripad on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @11:08PM (#33103904)
> where Modi's administration basically admitted they were wrong

It is not at all an admission of wrong but a forced retraction due to circumstances. The Farm laws were actually extremely progressive of all laws passed by the Government. The issue was more to do with raising the spectre of the dead Khalistani movement and Terrorism spillover that India had to deal with in the 80s and 90s. India cannot afford a weak border with Pakistan at this juncture and with Punjab (border state) being the epicenter of protests did not make things any better. Repealing the Farm laws took India's agriculture backward by at least 2 decades [1] and [2] as the protests were orchestrated by wealthy farmers of Punjab, Haryana and to some extent UP. They are not representative of farmers across India, who are so poor that they could never have had the ability to organize large scale counter-protests. The consequence of repealing the farm laws have hurt the poor farmers whose grievances have gone completely unheard.

> Stifling communication and censoring the internet isn't what any just democratic ruler does, regardless of their party affiliation.

Isn't this exactly what Trudeau did when Farmers protested in Canada? By freezing their bank accounts and censoring channels that supported the protests? I have seen this exact thing done in multiple first-world "Democratic" countries with no one calling them out. Feels like "Democracy for thee — but not for me".

[1]: https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/repeal-of-farm-...

[2]: https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/opinion/five-implications-...

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by kranke155 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:02PM (#33099011)
I’ve heard mixed things from Indians. I suppose the question might *not* be how much it remains a democracy - you are correct that the ruling party appears to have wide popular support - but how limited some freedoms might be for non Hindus.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by ignoramous on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @09:53PM (#33103405)
> you are correct that the ruling party appears to have wide popular support

And where they don't have that support, they "buy" elected reps: https://www.google.com/search?q=bjp+buy+mp+mla

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by programmer_dude on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @03:49PM (#33100448)
Please name some of these limitations.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by KrishnaShripad on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @11:17PM (#33103959)
> but how limited some freedoms might be for non Hindus.

Where exactly is freedoms limited for non Hindus? Can you name some of these freedoms that have been limited?

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by naruvimama on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:55PM (#33101149)
India sent out vaccines to 70 countries even as she herself was suffering in the crisis.

Millions of does were given out for free to the most vulnerable and poorest countries.

We were all witness to what was happening in the "wealthy liberal world" .....

You can label it what you want, but the world is much better off with India.

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by ignoramous on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:03PM (#33100608)
> You mean the current right wing ruling party? It has a very large vocal, visible and genuine support from large population of India... This support is for progressive policies and anti-corruption principles.

It is vile, divisive, and hate-filled politics that the masses have turned to.

Cognitive dissonance can be quite a thing.

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by pyuser583 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @04:33PM (#33100935)
There are very concerning things happening in India, but it is a very democratic country.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by shmde on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:33PM (#33098605)
Treading on slippery slope are we. You talk about democracy but the USA itself is a two party democracy not a true democracy at heart. In India you can start your own political party and contest in elections. Since it got independence from the Britishers, India has stayed a democracy and will hopefully remain so. (Unless maybe CIA organises a coup d'état)
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by bcrosby95 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:59PM (#33098975)
It's not that simple in the US.

For example, many states have proposition systems which is a direct democracy: the residents can vote directly on laws themselves. There's good and bad things about this, but overall I think it's good - it's a way around a state legislature trying to do wildly unpopular things.

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by cronix on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:52PM (#33098894)
If you elect representatives to vote on your behalf, it's not a "true democracy."
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by KrishnaShripad on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @11:25PM (#33104005)
When you vote directly, you risk voting for an authoritarian whom you can never recall in case he doesn't work in your interest or turns into a Dictator. In a representative democracy, the representatives are more approachable to the Citizens. This allows one to hold the representative accountable in case the Leader turns autocratic/dictatorial. Citizens can build pressure on Representatives from their own area rather than trying to galvanize a nation-wide agitation against a Dictator. And with a billion+ people voting, there is no way to reasonably expect to hold a single Leader accountable.

Direct Democracy doesn't work if the population is too big. Anything greater than a few thousand people you will need Representative Democracy.

So when one says "True Democracy" it invariably points to Representative Democracy with a Multi-Party system. Direct Democracy is a dead idea from the get go.

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by vivegi on Thursday October 06, 2022 @01:42PM (#33111406)
India is a democratic republic. Says so in the preamble of our constitution. It is a parliamentary democracy. We directly vote for the representatives in our local municipalities/corporations, state legislatures and central (federal) legislature.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by yrgulation on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:18PM (#33098409)
Just the other day indians were blaming their pollution on the west because we moved manufacturing to that country and china. I fail to understand why we would want to continue outsourcing to india all things considered.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by shmde on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:41PM (#33098741)
> Just the other day indians were blaming their pollution on the west because we moved manufacturing to that country and china

Well isn't it true ? You act like people are lying when they say the west pays countries to take off their garbage and dump it in their own nation. With all the things that USA imports from other countries as manufacturing it inside the US will decrease their profits. Classic Murica, offshore all the dirty work to the east, blame India and China for rising pollution when the final product is ironically coming back to USA and pat itself on the back for cutting down carbon emissions.

Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by pb7 on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @01:59PM (#33098977)
If you pay someone to dispose of waste and they just dump it in the ocean and pocket the money, what do you call that? They can just refuse to accept the deal or charge enough for it to be feasible to dispose of it sustainably.
Re:Apple asks suppliers to shift AirPods, Beats production t... by alehlopeh on Wednesday October 05, 2022 @02:27PM (#33099362)
That’s what we call recycling.