News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by daveslash on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @03:45PM (#33085701)
Re >> "with an ability to reflect around 98% of incoming sunlight"

Seems like a mirror would reflect even more light. Now, obviously we don't want to make the exteriors of our buildings and cars a mirror!. but it made me wonder: What's the difference between a really really really white paint that reflects 98%+ light, vs. a reflective surface? Is it that the white paint reflects the light, but in a "scrambled" form, thus losing the image?

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by adrian_b on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @03:54PM (#33085820)
Nope.

Silver reflectivity is about 95%, aluminum reflectivity is about 90%.

So the best metallic mirrors are worse than the best white paints, even if they can be better than the frequently used white paints based on titanium white (89.5% reflectivity).

Total internal reflection might be closer to 100%, but that cannot be used for the light that comes from the air on the surface of a mirror.

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by njdvndsjkvn on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @03:59PM (#33085886)
A simple way to verify this is to observe that common mirrors also tend to be green, showing that the other colors are absorbed more by the mirror. If you face two mirrors towards each other you will see a lot of green.

edit: here's an example: https://i.imgur.com/Ar80FYZ.jpeg

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by adrian_b on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:05PM (#33085957)
The common mirrors have the metal on the back side, so their reflectivity is diminished by the absorption in the glass.

The better mirrors, which are used e.g. in telescopes and some other optical instruments, have the metal on the front side, but that limits the metal choice to aluminum, because silver is tarnished quickly by the sulfur compounds present in the air.

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by njdvndsjkvn on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:22PM (#33086230)
so why don't common mirrors just use aluminum? It's already cheaper than silver, right?
Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by adrian_b on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:32PM (#33086381)
The common mirrors have been using aluminum for a long time.

I do not know when aluminum has replaced silver, but it was probably not a long time after WW2.

The silver mirrors had the advantage that the metal could be easily deposited from a water solution, anyone could make silver mirrors at home, if desired.

The aluminum mirrors use a vacuum deposition process, which requires very expensive equipment, but the cost per mirror is much less.

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by njdvndsjkvn on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:53PM (#33086665)
Ah. I misunderstood your earlier comment. Thanks!
Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by floxy on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:24PM (#33086248)
You can have dielectric coatings on a mirror that increase the reflectivity to >99.9% (and over a wide range of wavelengths). You can of course get a lot more 9's if you only care about a narrow band.

https://materion.com/products/precision-optics/application-f...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dielectric_mirror

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by adrian_b on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:10PM (#33086956)
99.9% for visible light does not mean 99.9% for all the solar light.

Most dielectric coatings absorb ultraviolet light so they reflect much less of the total solar light, most likely less than 90%.

Such a mirror with dielectric coatings would not be able to cool the object on which it is applied, unlike the paints which are discussed in the article, which are based on boron nitride, barium sulfate, calcium carbonate or fluorinated polymers, all of which do not absorb ultraviolet light.

The common white paints based on titanium white or zinc white also absorb ultraviolet light, so they cannot be used for cooling an object illuminated by the Sun.

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by ben_w on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:21PM (#33087109)
What I’ve seen says silver and aluminium are both a bit better than that.

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Reflectance-versus-wavel...

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Reflectance-of-Ag-Au-and...

I think this better fits my observation that a clean mirror can easily be unnoticed in an environment similar in all directions, such as woodland or a messy room.

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by adrian_b on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @05:51PM (#33087540)
What counts is not the peak reflectivity from those graphs, but the integrals over the solar spectrum.

Aluminum has lower reflectivity everywhere, but it retains a high reflectivity in ultraviolet.

Silver absorbs ultraviolet, which lowers the integrated reflectivity over the complete spectrum.

A few percent difference in the total reflectivity can make a large difference in the cooling power of a paint, but a few percent difference in the reflectivity of a mirror is unlikely to be perceived visually.

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by ben_w on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:48PM (#33088190)
Fair, I was only thinking of the visual spectrum and in this context that’s not right. :)
Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by tomcam on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @07:03PM (#33088350)
I love HN for answers like this
Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by GuB-42 on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:57PM (#33086728)
To make things simple, yes, that's is. White "scrambles" the light, the correct term is "diffuses" but that's the idea.

Maybe quantum physicists will disagree but the difference between a mirror and a white surface is that a mirror is perfectly flat and therefore will reflect light at always the same angle. It may absorb some of it, or even most of it (black mirror!) but what it reflects, it will do it always the same way.

A white painted surface can be thought as a surface covered in tiny mirrors, all pointed in a different direction, and depending on which tiny mirror a ray of light will hit, it will be reflected in a different direction. With large pieces, like with a broken mirror, you will still see (as you said) scrambled images. But because the pieces are so tiny, you won't be able to make out an image and you will only see white. A glass pane can look like a mirror, but reduce it to a powder and it becomes white. It has nothing to do with absorption, you can have a 1% reflective mirror, and 100% reflective diffuse white.

The way the "tiny mirrors" that make up the white paint are oriented give out its general look. Have them oriented mostly with the surface and you get a glossy finish, have them randomly oriented in many directions and you get a matte finish (this is called specular reflection btw).

I've seen mirrors be called "smart white", it is white because it reflects most light in most wavelengths, and it is smart because it keeps the rays of light oriented.

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by njdvndsjkvn on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @03:51PM (#33085784)
yes. A white surface scatters the photons and a reflective one keeps them in the same position relative to the others. If you make a surface smooth enough it starts becoming partly reflective. There is also scattering of photons that happens in object itself

I found this video about the topic to be interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1n_otIs6z6E (title: Why aren't Mirrors White? Why isn't EVERYTHING a Mirror?)

Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by wffurr on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @03:47PM (#33085723)
Yes, it's not reflecting the light so much as re-radiating it in a diffuse pattern.
Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by thehappypm on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @03:49PM (#33085752)
I don’t think there’s a physical difference between reflection and re-radiation, is there? Reflection is just highly organized/non-diffuse.
Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by Fronzie on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @04:08PM (#33086001)
reflection is coherent, a single physical process. The light keeps it's phase and polarization. Re-radiation is incoherent, caused by multiple particle interactions (physical processes). So there's quite a difference in physics.
Re:Whitest paint is now thin enough to coat cars and planes by thehappypm on Tuesday October 04, 2022 @06:15PM (#33087828)
Can you explain? As I understand it, in both cases, a photon comes in, gets absorbed by the material, and then gets re emitted.