News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by hammock on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:30AM (#3304475)
"I buy the music of bands I really like. I buy their albums as a conscious choice to support them."

This argument is made a lot, but it's weird. Music isn't CHARITY! It's a manufactured good. I don't give KitchenAid $150 for a stand mixer to "support them and the great things they create." I do it to buy their stand mixer.

Just to be clear, I'm not a copyright advocate. Just think it's a twisted frame of mind to think about music as above.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by AndrewDucker on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:38AM (#3304521)
Well, if you're not a copyright advocate then you pretty much believe that the cost of music ought to be the marginal cost of duplicating it (i.e. as close to zero as makes no difference).

If you think it should be higher then you _do_ support the right of the owners of the music to forbid others from copying it (i.e. copyright).

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by cbs on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:21PM (#3304754)
Just think it's a twisted frame of mind to think about music as above.

Most people who are serious about music buy merch at shows for the explicit purpose of supporting the artist. It is a pure form of voting with your wallet, "I want you to exist, sell me unrelated goods I have no need for".

I gave MC Lars $X for two t-shrits, not because I wanted T-shirts but because I wanted to support him and the great things that he creates. Hell, I even bought a floppy disk full of animiated .gifs from Math The Band. I don't even have a floppy drive, I just had a good time at their show.

It's a manufactured good

A good that, unlike a mixer, has no utility and the only reason for purchase is that you like it.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by billybob on Friday December 02, 2011 @07:07PM (#3306336)
If people really only want to support musicians, it would make more sense to just hand them a nice note with some cash and walk away.

I mean, isn't it weird that they want to make music, and you want to hear music, but it doesn't pay unless they make and you buy a t-shirt that you don't want? It's like, you make software that I want, but I won't buy software. I require you to make and sell me a lawn ornament, which I will throw away.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by burgerbrain on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:01PM (#3304631)
Actually, this attitude is the traditional one, and your's is the more radical.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patronage

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by guard-of-terra on Friday December 02, 2011 @05:18PM (#3305959)
If music was manufactured good, we'd be buying cheap Chinese knockoffs.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by chunkyslink on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:52PM (#3306740)
You need to do some reading up on the subject. You are also comparing apples with oranges with your KitchenAid example.

Even through legal and established channels Artists dont make much money through the actual music. Its all the stuff around the music which is profitable. Merchandise, concerts etc.