News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by ls15 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:36AM (#32992130)
I can buy 10 used but running ICE cars for the price of an EV and could probably buy a couple of years worth of gas for the money that I saved, even at current prices.

We need some actually cheap EVs, so probably models that are not so full of electronics like the current ones. Just some basic models without self-driving hocus pocus and futuristic bling.

I also would never buy a car that keeps up a constant network connection to its manufacturer, so that's a requirement I'd be looking for as well.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by gambiting on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:51AM (#32992216)
>>We need some actually cheap EVs, so probably models that are not so full of electronics like the current ones. Just some basic models without self-driving hocus pocus and futuristic bling.

Those exist, just buy yourself an e-Up/Citigo EV/Mii Electric, it's very cheap, it's very basic, has 160 miles range, it even comes with a normal analogue cluster. Or another cheap choice is an MG ZS EV or EV5 - both fantastic cars, both pretty basic without a whole lot of tech.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by ls15 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:13AM (#32992345)
More affordable than Tesla, but still 10x of the cheap used ICEV that they are competing with.

But basic?

https://www.just-auto.com/analysis/interior-design-and-techn...

> The Mii doesn’t offer a built-in touchscreen – not even as an option. Instead, it comes fitted with a smartphone dock located on top of the dash. While it may appear low-tech compared to its rivals, it does the job by allowing the driver to link their phone to the car via two apps: Mii Drive and SEAT Connect. The latter provides remote access and management of the vehicle, so drivers can review driving data, parking position, the vehicle’s status, including doors and lights, manage the charging process via the e-Manager and the ability to control air-conditioning remotely from the app.

How to repair this at home if it breaks?

Can I make sure that my car does not send any data to the manufacturer?

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by gambiting on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:23AM (#32992397)
I mean, I have the e-UP so I can answer any questions you have I suppose.

Yes, you can make sure the car doesn't communicate with the VW servers - either through the option in the menus, or if you don't trust that just pull out the SIM card below the dash.

>>How to repair this at home if it breaks?

If what breaks?

>>but still 10x of the cheap used ICEV they are competing with

I'm so confused why you say that a brand new EV is competing with a decade old petrol car(because only those will be 10x cheaper)? Like.....when I was car shopping it hasn't even crossed my mind to look at cars that old. I want a warranty and I want a very basic EV car - a decade old petrol car fulfils neither requirement.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by ls15 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:26AM (#32992418)
Any of it, really.

There are cars that you can fix at home with a hammer, but this is getting rare, unfortunately.

> I'm so confused why you say that a brand new EV is competing with a decade old petrol car

If people want to buy the cheapest vehicle, then they are limited to ICEV, because the cheapest EV is much more expensive.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by gambiting on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:40AM (#32992524)
>>Any of it, really.

I mean, sure, but then the argument is that this car literally has a battery, EV motor, one ECU, cabling for the brakes and the AC, and....that's about it? Yes you won't open the battery or the motor in your driveway, but other parts are no more complicated than in a normal car, and there's very very very few of them. I know some people who have already put 100kkm on these cars and the only thing they had to change was tyres - even the brakes don't wear out at all because you just use regenerative breaking.

>>If people want to buy the cheapest vehicle, then they are limited to ICEV, because the cheapest EV is much more expensive.

Yes, but why were you comparing a brand new EV to a decade old petrol car?

>>There are cars that you can fix at home with a hammer

I just want to add to this - I think maybe that is true, but that must be 0.00001% of drivers who have that ability, if not less. I used to have a Fiat Cinquecento, you couldn't imagine a simpler car(mechanically), it didn't really have electric anything on it other than lights, and I still wouldn't have any clue how to fix an engine issue for instance. I could replace the brakes or suspension elements myself, but I can do that in the e-Up too.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by ls15 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @04:08AM (#32992714)
The initial question was about cost difference between EV and ICEV. I think it is fair to compare the cheapest of both options.
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by gambiting on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @04:19AM (#32992784)
Well then let's compare a 10 year old EV(like a Nissan Leaf) vs a 10 year old ICE, not a brand new EV vs 10 year old ICE?
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by ls15 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @04:37AM (#32992896)
Then I am still looking at a 5x price difference and a massive difference in range.
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by fragmede on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @06:02AM (#32993402)
For hammer-grade fixing, EVs are way simpler than an ICE, which consists of tens of thousands of precision machines parts to control thousands of expositions every second. An EV is a battery pack, some power electronics, and two wires going to a motor. And a couple other parts if you wanna get fancy, but seriously, EVs are dramatically simpler than an ICE to the point that it’s not even funny. Don’t let BigAuto and BigEV confuse you. If you’re able to keep a thirty year old ICE car running, you can build your own EV. And if you build your own, you can be sure it’s not phoning home.

If you’re looking at the cheapest end of the spectrum, try looking at golf carts or importing something from China. $4,000 gets you quite the cart, well within the price range of a used, old ICE vehicle. And likely competitive too - my sister’s last car was an old (ICE) beater and couldn’t go fast enough for the freeway.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by Underphil on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:38AM (#32992137)
You and me both, but I think we're the minority. I want bell-and-whistle free ICE cars when I buy but those are becoming harder and harder to obtain.
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by ls15 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:39AM (#32992151)
I'd be fine with a bell-and-whistle-free EV as well. I think there are just none on the market, except a couple of Chinese models that you cannot try before you buy from a Western country.
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by vincnetas on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:57AM (#32992251)
Get VW eUP. It's discontinued but you could find year old ones. So almost new. Perfect city car.
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by fyvhbhn on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:52AM (#32992224)
Actually, we don't need cheap EVs.

The only thing we really need is less ICEVs

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by dmitriid on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:59AM (#32992260)
Yes. Yes, we do need cheap EVs and the infrastructure for them.

I'm in Sweden, and the cheapest EVs are often more expensive than fully kitted-out ICE versions of the same cars. Even an ardent proponent of EVs will think twice before buying an EV (unless they are rich and live in the city center)

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by fyvhbhn on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:30AM (#32992451)
I don't see the problem. If he thinks twice, he's going to save a ton of resources that may be used better elsewhere.
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by dmitriid on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:56AM (#32992634)
No, he's not. If he's going to think twice, it means he's going to use ICE for longer.
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by fyvhbhn on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @04:07AM (#32992701)
Perhaps, doesn't even have to be a bad thing.

E.g. producing a new BEV can have a worse impact than driving an ICEV a little bit longer.

However, long-term, it is the task of governmental bodies to make the cost using ICEVs reflect the real cost to society, making it probably even less affordable.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by dmitriid on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @04:19AM (#32992779)
So, you're not proposing to make EVs cheaper, but to make transportation as a whole unaffordable.

And no, "affordable public transportation" doesn't solve the problem. I live in Sweden where you have busses going to even the most remote of places. The farther you are from a big city center, the more yo need a car. And unlike the US being far from a city doesn't mean you live in a big house where you can put your own charging station etc.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by fyvhbhn on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @04:34AM (#32992876)
I am proposing to make prices reflect the real cost. Even today many can't afford a car, this doesn't mean transportation as a whole is unaffordable for them. It is possible to live without a car, you know.

> I live in Sweden where you have busses going to even the most remote of places.

Sounds good. I live in Germany where you don't have that, I still don't need a car, even though I use one once in a while because it's so cheap.

> The farther you are from a big city center, the more yo need a car.

So what? Doesn't mean you need a car at the end of the day, let alone own a car, especially when you're not living in the US. It only means cars are more helpful than at the city centre. The same probably holds for your own helicopter

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by dmitriid on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @07:16AM (#32993842)
> > The farther you are from a big city center, the more you need a car.

> So what? Doesn't mean you need a car at the end of the day, let alone own a car.

And your proposal is what exactly?

BTW car sharing and carpools have been a thing for a while, including EVs. They are 2x or 3x more expensive than owning a car. And also not available as soon as you move about 10-10 kilometers away from the city center.

I live in a suburb with a population of 60k people, 11 km from the city center. There 20-ish charging outlets (3.7 kW and 11 kW) mostly in paid parking lots (2 EUR per hour after second hour of parking). There are two car pools offering a total of 10 cars at completely ridiculous prices (Volvo's M, I'm looking at you: >25 EUR just to start the car, 30 EUR for 10km purely electric, 27 EUR for 10 km ICE).

> It only means cars are more helpful than at the city centre.

Exactly. They are more helpful, and your proposal is to make them unaffordable for people who need them

> The same probably holds for your own helicopter

Reductio ad absurdum isn't nearly as strong of an argument as you think it is.

You can't pretend that the cost of EVs (both the cars and the infrastructure needed for them) isn't an issue just because you say "ah, they don't need it all the time" or "yeah, but steelman argument is public infrastructure". This just pushes reckoning with reality farther away, possibly beyond the point where it can be solvable.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by ls15 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @02:58AM (#32992254)
How does an economy work without affordable transportation?
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by saagarjha on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:04AM (#32992306)
The strawman argument is "nobody has affordable transportation". The steelman one is "we add affordable public transit".
Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by ls15 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:17AM (#32992358)
And when? Public transport is a strawman if it does not exist in sufficient quality and quantity to replace all personal transportation and it takes decades to get to that capacity.

I am writing from Berlin. We enjoy one of the best public transport networks in the world, but it is still not affordable enough for many and there are still good reasons to own a car in Berlin.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by fyvhbhn on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @03:25AM (#32992415)
It's not a straw man. I have my doubts you know what you are talking about.

EVs for everyone doesn't work, and ICEVs even less so.

People who really need it for their life style will either have to change their life style and habits or pay enough for it.

And with respect to the economy: supply and demand will solve it

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by ls15 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @06:55AM (#32993698)
> It's not a straw man.

What I meant to express was that the GP was making a fallacious argument themselves by claiming that mine was fallacious when it is not.

Take personal transportation out of the equation without sufficient replacement and the economy (and quality of life, as well as social peace) will take a massive hit, because so many people rely on it for their needs.

Transitions to better models are great if they are planned and executed well. Suddenly pricing people out of their lifes, because required planning and investment 20 years ago was avoided is not a great way to proceed if you value social peace.

Re:Cost of public EV charging rises by more than 42% in four... by notacoward on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @07:06AM (#32993763)
> The steelman one is "we add affordable public transit".

What about better urban design so less transit of any kind is necessary?