News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by deltree7 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @04:25PM (#32891168)
Naive understanding of the world / information.

Say, In a world of 1,000,000,000+ great products, reaching consumers through word-of-mouth is hard.

I bet there are products that solves a lot of your current problems at a decent price. But you don't know about it and none of your friends or network have the same problem for you to give you the solution.

The only way to solve this problem is for the product/service provider to know about you and the fact that you have a problem.

Advertising is actually an optimal / scalable way for companies to reach you.

In a Billion+ product world, you need at least 10 Million Trust worthy reviewers to give you an unbiased review of everything. But, how do you trust the reviewers?

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by NikolaNovak on Sunday September 18, 2022 @06:04PM (#32891916)
>>"The only way to solve this problem is for the product/service provider to know about you and the fact that you have a problem."

Only way?? No.

No no absolutely not.

If/Since we are talking ideas and hypothetical, the preferred way would be for me to search for a product / indicate my need, and then marketplace to provide / compete for it.

The whole notion that advertiser must understand what I need, all the time, without my involvement knowledge or permission, then shove what it thinks I need up my throat constantly, is dystopian.

Basically, I think we are mixing up a pull paradigm to satisfy the consumer, with a push paradigm to satisfy the business. This is not to be naive about realities of world, business, saturated market, crappy products and differentiation, etc. But it peeves me when companies lack self awareness to be honest with themselves about which model is beneficial to which party.

Edit (and if we are going to talk about consumers being ignorant of the realities, let us not please pretend that the ultimate purpose of advertising is to perfectly satisfy a need with optimal product. Ultimate purpose of advertising is to make a sale. Sometimes, that sale is in fact optimal for the consumer. We can disagree how often that occurs as a percentage.)

Edit edit : the more I think the more I disagree. It's the word "optimal" that really bugs me - there's nothing optimal about modern online advertising. Clever, persistent, pervasive, desperate, obnoxious, hard work, devious, are some attributes that come to my mind. But it feels far from optimal - there's so much money and effort in this arms race which is increasingly hostile between an advertiser and consumer, and knowingly so; google and meta are 300 billion worth of not optimal :->

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by fuzzfactor on Sunday September 18, 2022 @09:42PM (#32893332)
There was a recent Ask HN from someone who was concerned that maybe greed was the only reason people would work for places like Facebook or Google any more.

That thread was quickly killed before it could grow any legs, but I did have a knee-jerk response anyway:

I'm sure there are some other reasons for those employees having potential to do more noble work, but aspiring to become an "ad man" on an aggressive media platform has always had an appeal to a certain amount of selfishness at the expense of others.

Now when the entire process is geared to appeal more strongly to even more greedy individuals, that's what you're going to end up with more so than anyone else.

I'm certainly not the innocuous one, with the toxic petrochemicals and all, where the oil business has always appealed more strongly to the greedy get-rich-quick types in its own way.

Rather than add to the size of a growing behemoth, I chose to do my survival activities more as a parasite instead.

There's definitely less money for the taking when you have to earn every dollar by adding value to resources, as opposed to collecting pay from accounts where funds were accumulated wildly before you showed up.

But that's the kind of decision you've got to make.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by MichaelCollins on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:08PM (#32893851)
Organizations that are trying to do something disreputable or shameful (or just something that could be construed that way by a nontrivial portion of the population) often come up with sweet little lies about their motives that help their employees sleep better at night.

It's not about making money by serving ads, it's about "organizing the world's data". It's not about winning defense contracts to put military hardware into space, it's about "colonizing mars to save humanity". It's not about printing money by getting poor people to sign up for 50,000% APR payday loans, it's about "providing liquidity to undeserved communities". Etc.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by bee_rider on Sunday September 18, 2022 @10:26PM (#32893596)
Hypothetically working on the security aspect doesn't seem so unethical. I mean, it is helping the evil empires in a sort of abstract way, but realistically people are going to use the services because they are ad-funded (and so, appear free). The direct harm to people who have their communications which they believe to be basically private (in the sense that they are only spied on by the service provider) broken into seems to be more significant.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by bzmrgonz on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:00PM (#32903126)
Agree with you wholeheartedly, just look at the advances in AI defined graphics, why can't the search engine be the same, we give the search engine a query and click on whether we want paid product ads to be included in the search. The web is getting so convoluted, that we(the consumer) will have to install pihole into our own version of "assistant software" in possibly our own design of an android and funnel every web interaction thru that android/assistant. They are making it to the point that we will not trust their "asistant software", nor their ad platform, and anything else they build. Essentially we will filter and curate all web interaction that is not text. And even text may need to be curated to avoid echo-chamber.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by galaxyLogic on Monday September 19, 2022 @01:12AM (#32894507)
> the preferred way would be for me to search for a product / indicate my need

Yes and then AI to find the best matches for me.

But there are also things that would benefit me that I don't even know exist, so I can not ask for them.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by vladvasiliu on Monday September 19, 2022 @03:01AM (#32895180)
Isn't this what catalogs used to be about?

I sometimes browse random awesome-[thing] lists just to see what they have in store and if anything in there gives me any new idea or seems to scratch some itch I didn't even know I had.

No need for any invasive tracking or obnoxious pop-ups.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by twic on Monday September 19, 2022 @07:22AM (#32896862)
> But there are also things that would benefit me that I don't even know exist, so I can not ask for them.

True, but those are categories of products, not products. That's not something companies are interested in advertising to you, so you can't rely on advertising to learn about them.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by tsimionescu on Sunday September 18, 2022 @04:34PM (#32891250)
Even though this idea of visibility is often touted, the vast majority of advertising is in practice all about obfuscating the actual uses (and especially limitations) of a product.

Furthermore, rather than trying to find the few people whom a product matches, it is often about pushing the product on people who never needed it in the first place - such as the diamond industry marketing inventing the practice of giving diamond rings for engagements, or the toy industry creating ads to specifically teach children to nag their parents. Or the vast amounta of pills promising penis enlargement.

Sure, these things may not happen so much in B2B specialty advertising, but in B2C they are the norm, and exceptions are few and far between.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by waynesonfire on Sunday September 18, 2022 @07:51PM (#32892583)
> who never needed it in the first place

Absolutely. How else are you going to grow 15% YoY or hit your sales quotas?

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by datavirtue on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:58AM (#32898375)
Obfuscate facts. Appeal to emotions. To appeal to emotions with the kind of results they are expecting you have to target women and children...ideally by driving an invisible wedge between them and their supporting caregivers.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by tsimionescu on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:16AM (#32898653)
> To appeal to emotions with the kind of results they are expecting you have to target women and children...ideally by driving an invisible wedge between them and their supporting caregivers.

Are you comparing women to children in their ability to discern advertising drivel from real facts about a product? Not only is that insulting, it is obviously false.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by deltree7 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:42PM (#32891762)
You can reform the Ad industry in several ways (enhancing "truth in advertisment")

i) You can only use factual information.

ii) You can't use visual props unrelated to the product (sexy women, beaches, fancy cars, spas)

But to burn advertisements due to shortcomings is like hating/shutting down internet because of 4chan or QAnon

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by BlueTemplar on Sunday September 18, 2022 @09:00PM (#32893080)
Ads => Consumerism => Destruction of the biosphere and depletion of natural resources => Hundreds of millions of extra deaths over the next few hundred years.

Now, this is simplified, they don't get to bear all the blame, and there are worse industries, but we better reform them fast, and radically.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by tsimionescu on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:48PM (#32891804)
If 4chan and QAnon were the vast majority of the internet, I would agree with the comparison.

But as I said, the vast vast majority of advertising by any measure you chose to use is of the manipulative kind, not informative. And this despite the existence of truth-in-advertising laws for decades.

And banning advertising is not even that harmful to industry - we have the case study of the tabacco industry, which didn't exactly die away once advertising of all of its products was entirely prohibited in all wealthy countries.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by withinboredom on Sunday September 18, 2022 @08:55PM (#32893043)
I’ve worked at two places that turned off Google ads for some number of months (except trademarked keywords they had a license for). There wasn’t a significant change to sales or traffic.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by bzmrgonz on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:11PM (#32903264)
I don't know about this, I suspect it depends on the product. What about that experiment AMAZON did down in Mexico, where it stopped advertising on google for 6 months and their revenue tanked?
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by withinboredom on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @03:37AM (#32908807)
Amazon and e-commerce, in general, have a different usecase for search engines. IME, the two products were people searching for the best solution to a problem and had fairly strong organic channels because they solved the problems people were looking to solve and were blogged about all over the internet.

E-commerce: people are looking for the best deal. You pay google to “show up first” and capitalize on brand awareness once they see your competitors. The customer is going to think, “ah nice, at least it’s on Amazon in case all these other stores are too sketchy.” The other stores probably play a better SEO game than Amazon because /they have to to survive/ while Amazon merely throws money at the problem to capitalize on the brand.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ipaddr on Sunday September 18, 2022 @08:49PM (#32892998)
Limiting advertising created bigger tabacco companies that shut out newer companies. Demand remained constant because it's a drug...That might work for other drug like coffee or pop/soda or social media but will not work for Tom's hardware and nails having an excess inventory of power drills
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by tsimionescu on Monday September 19, 2022 @02:15AM (#32894854)
People will still always need power drills and nails, even more so than cigarettes. Do you honestly believe the hardware industry would collapse if it were forced to stop advertising?

Now, the biggest problem with advertising is that it is an arms race. If your competitors are advertising and you are not, or are investing significantly less than them, you're very unlikely to remain competitive for long (assuming the products are even vaguely similar in quality).

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ipaddr on Monday September 19, 2022 @02:37AM (#32895015)
With a ban on advertising the biggest companies the ones we all know will benefit as no alternatives would be known. Some brands can spend endless amounts of money and I wouldn't purchase their product because of past experience or reputation.

Banning advertising would collapse industries or reduce market size and limit any expansion efforts.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by tsimionescu on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:43AM (#32896206)
> With a ban on advertising the biggest companies the ones we all know will benefit as no alternatives would be known.

Why? If I go to a hardware store and see a new power tool on the shelves that looks sturdy and costs less than the existing ones, why would I not buy it, or at least look for reviews on it?

Edit: this would be especially true in the longer term, as consumers start forgetting the marketing and there are no more "premium brands". In the near term after a ban, the older advertising still holds some sway, which of course creates a disadvantage for new brands. Still, a small price to pay for making the market more rational.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by MichaelCollins on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:10PM (#32893860)
Advertisers have done more to attack my ego and self image than 4chan or Qanon, or any other fuckwit internet forum ever has.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:54PM (#32891849)
Define advertising by segmenting off of Poetry, Prose, and Aphorism.

You can't. I don't understand how so many engineers can't do basic logic.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by tsimionescu on Monday September 19, 2022 @07:17AM (#32896827)
Advertising is "pay someone to say/show something about your product", where "pay" can refer to any kind of payment. It's really really easy to separate, conceptually, from any other discourse.

Now, there are situations where this is more ambiguous, and in general any display of a company's products or brands, especially one that is not critical, is suspect of being advertisement for that brand.

I'm not even sure how you can even claim that there is any sort of ambiguity between, say, The Raven and a Super Bowl commercial.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:49PM (#32915258)
Advertising is a judgement. It is a synthetic definition (defined but it's relationship to other concepts), but you want it to be analytic (ex: the number 5).

You completely dodge my point because it's a stake in the vampire heart of your non sequiturs.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by CuriouslyC on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:15PM (#32891578)
If I have a know I have problem, I'll look for a solution myself, and perform an objective comparison. I don't need some marketing asshat's stilted sales copy designed to con idiots into buying.

Convincing people who are happy that they have problems they need to spend money to solve for your personal benefit is morally dubious at best.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by deltree7 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:45PM (#32891788)
Unknown Unknowns.

How would you let people people know that they may be prone to cancer?

How can you inform the world population that there exists coursera that teaches you skills on any imaginable subject that may change their lives?

Most people aren't looking for those categories of information.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by MichaelCollins on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:12PM (#32893871)
> How would you let people people know that they may be prone to cancer?

Provide universal healthcare and continuing education for doctors.

Advertisers sure as shit aren't the answer.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by deltree7 on Monday September 19, 2022 @03:11AM (#32895241)
Pray tell me how would you provide Universal Healthcare for someone in Kenya or Bangladesh.

HN is full of elitist arm-chair critics, whose life is so good that they need to feel persecuted by ........ Advertisements. OMG

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by micromacrofoot on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:27PM (#32891645)
don’t you form an opinion by looking at reviews made by the idiots conned by those asshats?
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by Dylan16807 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:24PM (#32893947)
Some of the reviewers were conned, some weren't, but they actually have the product in front of them and they're generally honest.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by micromacrofoot on Monday September 19, 2022 @09:27AM (#32898005)
Unfortunately the prevalence of reviews in exchange for money or free product warps this significantly. In those cases, reviewers are being paid to con you with their bias, even if they're unaware.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:51PM (#32891824)
It's too subtle a point. The argument here is not about logic, but about intellectual honesty.

The parent you replied to believes everybody else is unduly influenced by 'asshats' and that his/her favored influencers are not 'asshats.' As if Ezra Pound or Edmund Teller weren't 'asshats' for nuclear explosive mining, or fascism.

Dismissing advertisers for being into the 'filthy lucre?' So what should we do with all the engineers doing the same?

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by intrasight on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:15PM (#32893892)
Not naive at all. Certainly, there are a billion products. Group by things that don't matter in the first analysis, and you probably knock it down one or two orders of magnitude. But the consumer knows what they need - and can tell Google. An educated consumer (can we grant them that) will find trusted review sites. That knocks the list down to like ten! At ten, the burden really shifts to the manufacturer to have a quality web site. This, in my opinion, is where most fail.

I’ll use a recent example of my own. I am in the market for new hardwood floors. Some Googling confirmed my believe that engineered hardwood floors are the best option. A couple of good review sites then told me the features that I should care about. From those I also found six candidate manufacturers.

One of them seemed to have a nice product, but their web site was just awful and had literally no information. You had to download hard-copy PDF to get any info – and good luck there. The others were better. One really stood out in the breadth and depth of information provided.

Friday, I emailed the four that made the short-list asking for more information in the context of my specific project.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by InCityDreams on Sunday September 18, 2022 @04:34PM (#32891261)
In a funny kind of way, I'd rather have unsolvable problems than be advertised at.

If the problems actually need solving, ill go looking.

If I'm not looking, there's no problem (to be solved).

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by geoduck14 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:20PM (#32891611)
>If the problems actually need solving, ill go looking.

What if you are looking, but an advertisement helps you find it faster?

As an example, I was shopping for a keyboard the other day. I spent several hours looking through different specs. It would be handy if a website would have popped up "hey, here are the 3 you are probably looking for, pick one!".

The benefit would have been for me (less time looking) and for three site (less server time serving pages to me)

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by plorkyeran on Sunday September 18, 2022 @06:57PM (#32892275)
When I am looking to buy something, ads actively get in the way of that. Ads are why we don't have websites that tell you "these are the 3 options you're probably looking for" any more because people figured out that they can make sites like that where the three choices are just ads rather than good recommendations. There's been times when I've simply given up on buying something because I got sick of wading through ads looking for any actual information.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by piva00 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @08:08PM (#32892726)
> There's been times when I've simply given up on buying something because I got sick of wading through ads looking for any actual information.

It's happening more and more often to me. I've been caught on this spiral of mistrust ever more often, even when wading through what once was a good place for human reviews: reddit.

I can't tell anymore what's an honest review to a paid one, be it affiliate links bullshit all the way to astroturfing on social media, it's exhausting.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by Larrikin on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:32PM (#32891689)
In my experience all three options are usually crap and I would have been better served doing my own research.

The only time advertising has been of use to me is advertising clothing. It's an extremely saturated market, so searching for "cool t shirt" or "nice jeans" is worthless. Before COVID I would go to a nice area in Tokyo, NYC, or some other major city and just load up when it was time to buy new clothes.

I block most ads, but a couple ads have gotten through over the years and I've learned about new brands or atleast new styles and had a jumping off point.

I still feel I am way better off blocking as many ads as I can, but can't say they've been completely worthless.

Most of the HN crowd can't fathom the idea of spending money on clothing outside of necessity. Shirts that will last ten years is more popular of a topic than shirts that actually look good.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by int_19h on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:23AM (#32895694)
You basically want an oracle. That's fine, but none of what you just described requires a push model - you have a specific query, "best keyboard for me", so what you want is a service where you can go and explicitly ask that question, and get an accurate answer.

OTOH if an ad popped up and said "here's the best keyboard for you" - or even "here's the top 3 choices for you" - would you seriously trust that?

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by deltree7 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:32PM (#32891687)
Newsflash: There are unknown, unknowns.

The vast majority of the population, they don't even know there are solutions that would change their life.

E.g: In a world of 8,000,000,000 how many people know that there is Coursera which has top-level courses that can change their lives, improve productivity and make impact?.

"I know everything, don't tell me. I'll ask" is exactly the attitude that prevents learning (and prevents people from knowing about coursera). You are just advertising that personality to the rest of the world

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by tsimionescu on Sunday September 18, 2022 @06:06PM (#32891928)
> In a world of 8,000,000,000 how many people know that there is Coursera which has top-level courses that can change their lives, improve productivity and make impact?.

I would bet there are more people who know Coursera exists than people whose lives would literally change if they took a few Coursera courses (though that doesn't mean that there aren't some people whose lives could be changed by Coursera if they knew about it).

However, seeing an Ad for Coursera is not likely to help anyone find out whether Corusera can actually help them or not - since there is absolutely no way to tell from an ad whether the product being presented is going to be even close to fit for purpose. The only thing the ad tells you that can be trusted is "Coursera is a company that is trying to sell online courses" (note: that doesn't mean that they actually provide online courses, you can only trust that they are trying to sell them - see the myriads of ads for mobile puzzle games whose gameplay has literally no relation to the game play shown in the ad).

Note: I'm not trying to take potshots at Coursera here - they are a reputable business and have many good courses - which I know from my own and friends' personal experiences. I'm trying to look objectively of what an ad for a company you know nothing about can actually tell you.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by batch12 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @06:26PM (#32892075)
> The vast majority of the population, they don't even know there are solutions that would change their life.

> I know everything, don't tell me. I'll ask" is exactly the attitude that prevents learning

This feels parental-- a version of mommy knows best. Why not let me, by default, decide if I want personalized advertisements? What if I want to be ignorant in regards to the new fad product? What if I don't want companies to mine my interests, location, prior searches, etc just to tell me that coursera exists? Advertisers are afraid of using an opt-in model because they know most people won't do it.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by FridgeSeal on Sunday September 18, 2022 @10:45PM (#32893712)
The best solution for the argument that “ads help people find stuff when they do go looking”, is an ad-directory.

Want to buy some new clothes and shoes soon? Go to an ad directory and browse the offerings - it’s beneficial for everyone. Users, because they’re getting what they want (when and how they want it) and for providers too: their audience are self-selecting their target, they have high intent to buy. This would make actual advertising cheaper, brands would get more creative freedom (have to stick out more, have to help your target market quickly identify you and you don’t need to spend oodles of time and money setting up complicated arms-race-sequence AI targeting run by a duopoly of “totally trustworthy companies”). Users are happy because they’re freed from the cognitive burden of constant harassment.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by einpoklum on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:49PM (#32891816)
The thing is, the mass of advertising isn't about helping you know the unknown unknowns, it's about manipulating you into wanting things you know about, more, or wanting things you don't need / wouldn't really want in a fair evaluation.

The thing is, in our society, institutions mostly develop venues for advertising rather than for listing - since both the owners of the venue and the entities offering products/services have overarching profit motives, and advertising is more profitable.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by NumberCruncher on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:55AM (#32896267)
> it's about manipulating you into wanting things you know about, more

you just described the ad retargeting industry, like Criteo

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @09:24PM (#32893226)
How is that definition of advertising different from language and symbol?

Would an Icelandic saga be considered an advertisement for murder?

You really have not thought this through.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by tsimionescu on Monday September 19, 2022 @05:50AM (#32896242)
Are you aware that advertising is explicitly defined in law, and already regulated, even in the USA?

In fact, the definition is extremely simple: if a company payed you (with money, free product, free trips etc) to say or show something about their product, that is advertising, regardless of what you are saying or of whether you believe it. No more, no less.

Note: some countries extend this to any display or mention of branding, whether payed for or not, at least in broadcast media. So, for example in my country, a TV show has to blur out brands on bottles of water or cars shown, or display an explicit "this is advertising" logo on the screen while the branding is shown.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:53PM (#32915319)
You add more premises without first evaluating or addressing my point.

You imitate the tone of rationality, but you cannot even follow the simple rules of debate.

You need 2 premises to rebut my 1. In logic, we call that a f*kk up.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @01:45PM (#32915205)
Law doesn't trump language when it comes to the truth. Nazis had laws too
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by suoduandao2 on Monday September 19, 2022 @10:40AM (#32898964)
I saw a commentary on education - I think on HN actually - where the writer was suggesting that the prime directive for each student should be 'know thyself'. Advertisers know me in a shallow way only, and they aren't really served by knowing me in a deep way - they need to know me well enough to know if I might buy a given product, the why of that is immaterial to them (and they have no direct access to it anyway).

There is an ideal world where everyone spends a lot of time getting to know themselves on an intimate level and then broadcasts their very personal desires to an advertising industrial complex, which finds the solutions to these deep and difficult-to-articulate drives. But the advertiser can't realistically get that kind of information on anyone. I know that's not what advertisers claim, but I'm confident in calling bullshit on what they say about knowing their customers. They can't even tell when they're irritating someone to the point of installing an adblock, and they're supposed to know what self-actualization looks like to each of their many customers? I ain't even renting that.

I agree with the basic premise that advertising can be a force for good. But the advertisee has to be an active participant, else the advertiser will reliably determine that the target's telos is 'maximize shareholder value for <advertiser>'.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:44PM (#32891777)
Seems obvious. I agree. However I think you're not going to get through to those with central planning biases. By which I mean, the notion that perfect planning can beat the market.

The Palace Economy central planner says, "give me wheat." The Soviet central planner says, "more steel comrades." The American style technocrat planner says, "we will tell you what you want and then deny market alternatives."

I think there's no reasoning with these people

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by int_19h on Monday September 19, 2022 @04:28AM (#32895747)
How, exactly, each person deciding on their own whether to look or not look for information on a particular subject matter translates to economic centralization? It's the other way around - the ads, with their push model, naturally produce centralization, which is why we have the duopoly this article is about.
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:08PM (#32915597)
We're talking about advertising, not monopolies. That's your first fail.

Second, you present a false binary that we have either the duopoly, or the self-starting individual.

Marketing is a subset of Influence. Influence is a subset of the Arts. Arts being defined as non-axiomatic symbolic ordering.

You want to ignore all these distinctions, so you can stop annoying advertisers.

In the process of doing that, you either push advertising into the arts, or you kill the arts. Both are stupid. And that shows so are you.

You would dispense with the market, because you don't like that it's a meany.

You conflate because that's the standard tech scumbag method: you interpret 'restrictions' as 'damage' and route around it. Like a virus that crashes the whole system.

How would you find a book that didn't try to influence you? How would you find information that did not exist to influence? You are asking for an invisible pink unicorn. It does not exist. Your whole argument is stupid, sloppy, and sophomoric.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Tuesday September 20, 2022 @02:35PM (#32915971)
The centralization has to do with cheap money. That appears to be a topic beyond your pay grade. Hacker News has a low skill base when it comes to economic understanding. VC funded enterprises all have a magic money aspect to them that proper entrepreneurs (bootstrappers) do not have. Your post reeks of it. That was not the issue.

You want to strawman my point, because...?

InCityDreams: "In a funny kind of way, I'd rather have unsolvable problems than be advertised at. If the problems actually need solving, ill go looking.

If I'm not looking, there's no problem (to be solved)."

Summary: "If I'm not looking, there's no problem (to be solved)."

Then Deltree replies:

"Newsflash: There are unknown, unknowns. The vast majority of the population, they don't even know there are solutions that would change their life.

E.g: In a world of 8,000,000,000 how many people know that there is Coursera which has top-level courses that can change their lives, improve productivity and make impact?.

"I know everything, don't tell me. I'll ask" is exactly the attitude that prevents learning (and prevents people from knowing about coursera). You are just advertising that personality to the rest of the world"

Summary: ""I know everything, don't tell me. I'll ask" is exactly the attitude that prevents learning."

Me: "Seems obvious. I agree. However I think you're not going to get through to those with central planning biases. By which I mean, the notion that perfect planning can beat the market. The Palace Economy central planner says, "give me wheat." The Soviet central planner says, "more steel comrades." The American style technocrat planner says, "we will tell you what you want and then deny market alternatives."

I think there's no reasoning with these people"

Summary: Yes, I know everything don't ask people can't be reasoned with. Same as Soviets or Palace economists. Same as American duopolies, which have gotten worse and stronger as government spending and share of national economy has increased. I took for granted that this is obvious, as others in the thread seemed to instinctively grasp this point.

Not you though.

Duopoly exists from too much government influence so solutions involving more government influence are doomed to failure.

Let's teach you to fish anyhow: the duopoly only mirrors the power structure of the government which allows it. More regulations to enforce what is advertising and what is art, means lawyers are then involved with case uses of the English language. An area that is a known incompetency for the trade.

Any individual who says, "I know everything. If I don't, I'll ask." How did they know anything in the first place? From the government schools? From their parents? Parents can't know everything. And AHA! Government schools are influencers and NOT AT ALL institutions of learning. Any learning done is incidental.

This is Kuhn's argument: you cannot revolutionize a flawed paradigm inside the flawed paradigm. If you prefer, you could say it's the Dunning-Kruger effect.

You're a jack@ss. I addressed my interlocutors arguments directly. You do not. Eff off, you MF.

EDIT: And as a concluding point, because you're so daft, this means that only influence from outside a power structure can possibly change the decision control flow. Ie Art, the child of which is applied symbol, the child of which is advertising.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by ajl666 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:56PM (#32891867)
Hey downvoter. If the point is so weak, surely you can refute my moronic self with some cunning argument.

Why are so many information scientists afraid of information?

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by tsimionescu on Sunday September 18, 2022 @06:08PM (#32891946)
You're not making any points, and your comments are written to be inflammatory (unlike deltree7's, who is clearly advancing the conversation, even if I don't agree with them).
Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by marssaxman on Monday September 19, 2022 @08:31AM (#32897455)
> Advertising is actually an optimal / scalable way for companies to reach you.

I don't need companies to reach me - that's their problem.

> I bet there are products that solves a lot of your current problems at a decent price.

I bet not. The problems I care about are not solvable with products. Even if there were unknown products I might be willing to learn about, the problems they solve would necessarily be minor things relative to the primary concerns of my life, and I will very happily forego the opportunity to discover them in order to shut down the overwhelming firehose of inane, manipulative toutery.

Re:The $300B Google-Meta advertising duopoly is under attack by jen20 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @09:49PM (#32893369)
This attitude is why I hope government crushes the advertising industry. No one is entitled to my information to sell me shit. No one.