News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by codeflo on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:45AM (#32888499)
From the outside perspective of a younger democracy, the fact that the US political system treats this ancient legal document with the same reverence that one might pay to the biblical stone tablets, where it would be sacrilegious to even change the font, let alone bring it up to speed with almost 250 years of progress in ethics, political practice and technology, seems like it might explain some problems.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by wonderwonder on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:29PM (#32889470)
The world is full of younger democracies and very few contiguous older ones. Depending on how you want to measure it, the United States is the worlds oldest democracy based on an original constitution or set of rules. The longevity of the US constitutional democracy is in most part because of what an incredible job the original writers of the constitution did in drafting it as well as the massive effort and agreement required to change it. The same large scale leadership problems that exist today existed then. The key to a long term democracy is slow change, not fast.

Many of the world's young democracies exist because of America; notably those formed out of the collapse of USSR. All of Europe's democracies exist because of the US role in WW2. Same as the current governments in Japan and Taiwan. Don't get me wrong I am not arguing America is perfect, there have been plenty of egregiously harmful moves, including what's currently happening in Iran, Afghanistan and Iraq. Although Iraq is technically a young democracy now because of the United States.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by tdeck on Monday September 19, 2022 @02:41AM (#32895044)
The phrase "depending on how you want to measure it" is doing a lot of work in this post, the rest is American exceptionalism. San Marino has a constitution that edates back to 1600. Iceland has had a parliament for 1,000 years. Even leaving aside the fact that many of the world's democracies were deposed by the US government in the 20th century, the US has neither a notably long-lived nor notably democratic system of government. What it has is a huge military budget, and that enables it to seed governments in the way that it chooses.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by 7sidedmarble on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:47PM (#32889629)
> All of Europe's democracies exist because of the US role in WW2.

Can you explain what you mean by this? Continental Europe's relationship with republicanism and democracy dates back to the same roots as what spawned the ideas that led to the US's formation, and that is the European Enlightenment.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by thechao on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:19PM (#32889960)
This is the "if you were occupied by a foreign aggressor, it breaks the contiguity of government"-argument. Obviously, there is some truth to this argument; but, honestly, we'd need to address each constituent state in Europe to determine its factuality.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by wonderwonder on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:09PM (#32889843)
Yes, you are right, my point is more straight forward in that without the usa stepping in to win ww2, all of Europe would be part of the Reich.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by jleyank on Sunday September 18, 2022 @03:49PM (#32890845)
Stepping in? Blame Japan for us entry and all of the downstream effects. Hitler was being careful to not give fdr an opening.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by wonderwonder on Sunday September 18, 2022 @06:05PM (#32891919)
Doesn't really matter why it happened only that it did and because of that Europe and Japan are democracies.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by qsort on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:29PM (#32888864)
As another non-American, I'm curious as to why you would say that.

The US constitution was objectively very far ahead of its time, and it still is a far better attempt at a constitutional order than most.

Very rarely can a country's problems be blamed on its constitution. The UK doesn't even have one and it's still one of the world's most advanced democracies.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by lovich on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:58PM (#32889162)
Well if you go by the sentiments of some of the authors of the document, they’d likely be appalled we’re still using it. Jefferson wanted it to expire every 19? 20? years so that the country wasn’t governed by the sentiments of long dead men
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by MichaelCollins on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:49PM (#32889658)
The "founding fathers" had a diverse set of beliefs, you can pick and choose to support a variety of diametrically opposed points of view.

Consider for instance John Jay, who thought that Christian rulers guided by Christian principles were necessary to maintain order and freedom, and thought the Republic would be doomed if it ever forgot this. A far cry from Jefferson's deism.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by lovich on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:11PM (#32889869)
They did have varied beliefs especially between New England and the southern colonies, but I am referencing Jefferson here as he was one of the main authors of the constitution and not just a signatory
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by dragonwriter on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:10PM (#32889283)
> Very rarely can a country's problems be blamed on its constitution.

Actually, the usually trace back to the constitution, one way or another.

> The UK doesn't even have one

Yes, it does. [0]

It's not an explicitly separate written document, but that's not required of a constitution. The idea of a constitution predates the spread of the practice of having them as distinct documents.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_United_K...

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by JumpCrisscross on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:28PM (#32889457)
> that's not required of a constitution

It's not, but it helps.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by FerociousTimes on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:16PM (#32889349)
The USC so far proved to be resilient, adaptable and durable but timeless?

It remains to be seen but I have my doubts esp. in a future socio-political context where post-modernism and cyberpunk ideals reign supreme.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by azinman2 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:58PM (#32889157)
You have the Magna Carta
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by pmyteh on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:26PM (#32889441)
Kinda. Bits of it are still in force[0], despite us not having a definitive text, but much of it was written to deal with contemporary political problems and was repudiated fairly quickly. It's more important as the start of a (semi-mythical) tradition of political liberty then as an ongoing source of constitutional law.

Even more excitingly, some of the documents we consider constitutional aren't even statutes. My favourite is a pseudonymous letter to The Times sent in 1950, which authoritatively established a constitutional convention for when the monarch can refuse his Prime Minister a dissolution of Parliament[1]. (The writer, 'Senex', was the King's private secretary Sir Alan Lascelles).

[0]: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/aep/Edw1cc1929/25/9

[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lascelles_Principles

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by ben_w on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:29PM (#32889467)
As a totemic icon sure, but it has mostly been repealed, and it was more of a peace treaty between the king and his barons.

Also:

> Neither side stood behind their commitments, and the charter was annulled by Pope Innocent III, leading to the First Barons' War.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by samatman on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:53PM (#32889108)
Most Americans would greet "we must teach cursive so children can read the manuscript form of our founding documents" with the same bafflement you do. Even in the civic religion surrounding all that paper, this is not a normal expression of reverence.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by yonaguska on Sunday September 18, 2022 @11:56AM (#32888582)
It's slow to change by design. I don't know that ethics and political practice really has "progressed" all that much just 250 years.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by teolandon on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:53PM (#32889107)
Yeah I can't think of any Civil Rights issues that have changed at all since 1787.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by JumpCrisscross on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:30PM (#32889471)
> can't think of any Civil Rights issues that have changed at all since 1787

OP was discussing constitutions, structure of government. We haven't made that much fundamental progress on design of government compared with the eighteenth century.

Are there housekeeping fixes the Constitutions needs? Yes. Do they reveal glaring, fundamental errors in the system's design? No.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by throwaway2037 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:03PM (#32889793)
You are right. /s/ Here is a good example: <<Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Term of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons>>. If you choose to reply to this post, please carefully consider how Black and Brown Americans would feel knowing this was deeply embedded in this history of their country's founding document. (It is horrible!)

This segment is widely called the "Three-fifths Compromise" in American English. It refers to the fact that enslaved people would be counted as 3/5 of a person for the purpose of determining gov't representation.

From a modern perspective, this section is wholly demented and supports the institution of slavery. This support for the institution of slavery in the founding document of the United States is a terrible stain upon its reputation.

The biggest issue I have with the US Constitution in a modern society: It is too hard to change. (When is the last time the US had a serious effort to pass a new amendment? 1970s / 1980s-ish: Women's equality, but still it failed!) Many successful, younger democracies have found ways to allow non-extremist changes to their constitution, to support "futurism" (my own term) -- the progression of society. Personally, I am a big supporter of regular (frequent), small changes to a country's constitution to support, and facilitate, social change.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by JumpCrisscross on Sunday September 18, 2022 @03:06PM (#32890448)
> Personally, I am a big supporter of regular (frequent), small changes to a country's constitution to support, and facilitate, social change

Sure. But that's a preference, nothing more. We don't have strong evidence one way or another, nor over-arching theories supporting or rejecting seldom-messed-with versus frequently-adapted constitutions.

That's my point: we haven't made progress beyond preferences. As such, denigrating the Constitution on account of its age falls flat. Modern concepts of governance were largely already in place at its drafting.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by thechao on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:31PM (#32890089)
There are four major structural issues I can think up off the top of my head (this is unfair — we're discussing my wife's job):

1. Modern gerrymandering is probably the Achilles heel that'll bring the US to its knees.

2. Judicial capture is the standard playbook for autocratic take-overs of democracies — there needs to be a reaffirmation process & it needs to be a "yes - no > 1/2*senators".

3. The electoral college is particularly vulnerable to bad actors at the state level, and the opportunity cost to capture the college is higher than the capture cost.

4. The Senate, itself, was a known-to-be-bad compromise to build a confederation, rather than a formal union into a single, sovereign State.

I'm not entirely convinced of the last one: I kinda like the idea if 50 separate competing democracies all trying to come up with great ways to be a state, with a fairly low barrier-to-migrate.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by JumpCrisscross on Sunday September 18, 2022 @03:04PM (#32890432)
You're still describing the same fundamental system, with tweaks. Fundamental changes would be things like a unicameral legislature, Supreme Court without judicial review or President who isn't commander in chief.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by cnelsenmilt on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:44PM (#32889606)
I truly can't think of a more fundamental element of a democratic system than who is enfranchised, and there have been two or three enormous changes in the answer to that since the founding.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by bobthepanda on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:21PM (#32888787)
Well, amendments used to be more common. We just haven’t passed a non-academic one since 1971.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by throwaway2037 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:08PM (#32889832)
I am confused by this post.

From here: http://hrlibrary.umn.edu/education/all_amendments_usconst.ht...

I see the final amendment: << AMENDMENT XXVII - Originally proposed Sept. 25, 1789. Ratified May 7, 1992.

No law, varying the compensation for the services of the Senators and Representatives, shall take effect, until an election of representatives shall have intervened. >>

First: Holy Sh-t: This is a long time between propsal and passage / acceptance!

Second: Do I misunderstand? Do you consider this amendment academic? It sounds like reps cannot increase compenstation during their term.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by bobthepanda on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:21PM (#32889979)
The reason I call it academic is this:

> The proposed congressional pay amendment was largely forgotten until 1982, when Gregory Watson, a 19-year-old sophomore at the University of Texas at Austin, wrote a paper for a government class in which he claimed that the amendment could still be ratified. He later launched a nationwide campaign to complete its ratification.[2][3]

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty-seventh_Amendment_to_...

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by revscat on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:42PM (#32888993)
I would argue too successfully. There are fundamental changes that could and should be made to the Constitution, especially in regards to climate change and information warfare.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by ben_w on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:34PM (#32889518)
Climate change is too big for one nation, even a big nation, I'd say the de jure solution there is more a job for international treaties (while the de facto solution is making tech such that the right action is automatically desirable).
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by revscat on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:18PM (#32889950)
I think the idea of codifying the repair of the environment as a foundational legal concept to be an interesting one, and one arguably necessary to successfully combat the problem. Treaties tend to codify shared values between states; since almost all modern nations are capitalist, treaties tend to focus on trade and capital. Climate thus gets second tier status, which is the opposite of the ideal.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by ben_w on Monday September 19, 2022 @06:04AM (#32896324)
I can sympathise with the argument, but economics (of which Adam Smith's capitalism; Karl Marx's communism; the original Liberalism, its successor Neoliberalism, and the Keynesian form between them, are all subsets) all pull in much the same direction with regard to the environment (i.e. valuing it mainly for what it can do and only protecting it when the cost of doing so is negligible, because the nations all compete with each other for power and influence under the constant threat of becoming irrelevant due to the growth of the others.

Other than a single world government, or treaties with similar effect, I don't see how to achieve what I think we both agree would be a good outcome.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by dragonwriter on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:05PM (#32889238)
> From the outside perspective of a younger democracy, the fact that the US political system treats this ancient legal document with the same reverence that one might pay to the biblical stone tablets

As a whole, it doesn't, both the major parties have elements of it that they are strongly attached to, but each have also made amendments to it, and hacks around parts of it, key parts of their agenda.

> where it would be sacrilegious to even change the font, let alone bring it up to speed with almost 250 years of progress in ethics, political practice and technology,

Um, it's been updated quite a lot since initially adopted (and I’m not talking about the font or other presentational issues.)

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by chrisco255 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:41PM (#32888985)
There's a reason why the U.S. is the oldest democracy. Strong culture. It's also the legal foundation for the establishment of the country and all laws passed hence are a derivative of it.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by dragonwriter on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:23PM (#32889414)
> There's a reason why the U.S. is the oldest democracy.

Under most viable definitions of democracy, the US isn't the oldest. If you restrict to non-aristocratic (i.e., not limiting franchise by ancestry) representative democracy, Finland and New Zealand, among others, achieved that first; if you accept participatory democracies, the Iroquois Confederacy has it beat by even more; you need to tightly define “democracy” around exactly the US model at a particular time to make it first.

> It's also the legal foundation for the establishment of the country

No, it's not, the country was established before the Constitution.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by chrisco255 on Monday September 19, 2022 @12:01PM (#32900124)
> No, it's not, the country was established before the Constitution.

OP mentioned the Declaration and the Constitution in the same sentence, but for the record, both are revered and held to high regard and do provide the legal foundation for the nation in its current iteration (Articles of Confederation were older than Constitution but have been cast aside due to their ineffective results).

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by _dain_ on Sunday September 18, 2022 @05:18PM (#32891601)
>Finland

didn't exist until 1918

>New Zealand

didn't exist until a century after the US was founded

>Iroquois Confederacy

extinguished utterly, nowadays an object of idle revisionism

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by Izkata on Sunday September 18, 2022 @02:34PM (#32890120)
> where it would be sacrilegious to even change the font

This is a misunderstanding of the actual concern there. The way I've heard it explained is, once it's all online in printed form and people can't read the original physical document, the online versions can be tweaked by the platforms and no one would be able to read the original to prove it's been changed.

This is an extremely common trope in sci-fi, where only a small group of people understand the language of the "sacred texts" and have been claiming it says something different than it actually does and no one is able to challenge it.

I think both versions stem from real-world religions where the translations have to make adjustments because the source language has concepts that don't quite fit in the new language.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by deep_merge on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:00PM (#32888612)
Right, sure, that’s all true. Now consider that many people can’t read the document.

I guess your analogy still checks out. Neither Old nor New Testament are written in English. And thus English-speakers rely on translations.

Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by patrick451 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @12:22PM (#32888799)
What are you talking about? Do you think we still own slaves and prohibit women from voting in the United States? Updates to the constitution are exactly why neither of those things is true. These updates are called amendments, and the constitution itself outlines that process. In 250 years, we've passed 27 amendments. The most recent amendment passed in 1992. Pretending even the most strict constructionist treats the constitution as an immutable document is just ignorant.
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by Jaruzel on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:48PM (#32889645)
At which point is it better to just write a new constitution? 100 amendments? 500? Or never?
Re:Gen Z never learned to read cursive by Hnrobert42 on Sunday September 18, 2022 @01:01PM (#32889192)
To be fair, it has been amended 27 times.