Maybe, but it is much more common to summon money out of nothing and give it to the rich. At least in the US this happens in the form of buying securities from entities that hold them, which from what I understand is kind of similar to proof of stake (you stake some of your currency by buying a security for a chance to get more when you sell it).
https://www.pcmag.com/news/microsoft-patent-describes-tracki...
No the central banks of the world are all working on fiat crypto, so we'll get the worst of both worlds.
Did society fall apart when current fiat currency with the government as the central trusted authority was adopted?
Just because you can join a staking pool which often takes a cut and makes it easy doesn't invalidate what is actually going on.
> The barrier for entry in the legacy financial system is way way higher. Have you ever applied for a banking license?
One doesn't have to have a banking license to use the local fiat currency of one's nation (basically, one is born into it). And one must do almost nothing to get a check from the government if they decide to stimulate the economy by handing out money to those who showed they had very little on their last tax return.
If you're into UBI type stuff, yeah, there are multiple UBI projects on Ethereum https://www.proofofhumanity.id
There are a ton of other projects that allow people to share storage space, compute, art, information, etc to earn cryptocurrencies. People contribute what they can to the network, and are compensated for their efforts. Projects like gitcoin are raising millions of dollars for people who volunteer to provide public goods, from performing security audits on large open source projects, to cleaning plastic out of rivers (https://gitcoin.co/grants/). Seems to me like the Ethereum ecosystem is far more altruistic than many current governments.
Can you buy the same things for 1 USD as you could then? (no)
1. If you want to run a validator node, i.e. run the architecture you need to have 32 ETH to be eligible to provide this service. And it does not mean immediately that you will earn something. https://ethereum.org/en/staking/
2. If I stake the equivalent of 5 USD I will likely get a 5% return on it per year making it much less interesting from an investment perspective given volatility and opportunity cost.
3. Staked funds are locked and can't be used anywhere else or for anything else. At least GPUs can be used for mining AND general purpose computing.
4. It is much easier to go to any random money exchanger and go USD/EUR or USD/JPY
5. Getting a retail bank account can be done in a matter of minutes online.
Both Ethereum's and Bitcoin's regular nodes don't make any money.
This is why I'd rather see development of privacy coins, like zcash, and less concerned with the decentralization issue (I've yet to see a project actually address centralization or even acknowledge the issue you're bringing up: momentum). We're moving away from a cashless society and while that has a lot of great benefits it also has a lot of detriments. So why not have digital cash then? ZKPs for transactions.
If you want to promote democracy you should also want to decrease the ability for authoritarians to arise, which in our modern era means how much data they can get their hands on and abuse. There's common cop-outs like how will taxes work etc, but society ran pretty smoothly on cash before. Companies still have to report incomes and salaries. We can still do consumption taxes. So we have our income and consumption easily solved. I'm even fine with a small transaction fee, which I know others aren't, but we already pay this in the world of credit cards (2-4%). I think we could really bring down the Visa/Mastercard tax (maybe something like 0.1%/0.5%?) and it would all be a win for everyone.
It is clear to me that cryptocurrencies aren't going to get us this world, so let's start thinking about other means.
Is there a currency - even theoretical - where 'capital-breeds-capital' is _not_ a side-effect?
In crypto, possessing money generates money, without investing it or putting the money "to work." This would be like if the dollar bills in your wallet periodically grew another dollar.
They also have the authority to conjure money out of nothing and hand it to the rich.
There was some crypto startup that wanted to do this and was going to different cities and doing retina scans. I wonder what happened to them?
I suppose you could outsource it by donating to GiveDirectly, but that would require conversion to real money and then (by GiveDirectly) to mobile phone payments. In that case, the cryptocurrency isn't solving much of the problem.
For a technology that claims to be decentralized, it is simply one more major flaw in an already terrible design.
The stimulus checks were a door prize.
Issuing those loans prevented nationwide layoffs and insurance termination for millions of people.
Update: 10.2 million PPP loans were forgiven. Here's why.
> If borrowers use at least 60% of the loan to cover payroll within 8 or 24 weeks after receiving the loan, they can submit an application to have the loan forgiven.
-----
edit: if anybody can clear this up for me, I'd appreciate it, but what could it possibly mean for "at least 60% of the loan to cover payroll?"
Does that mean that the company has to spend its way into insolvency first, then after becoming insolvent pay out 60% of the loan to employees, or does it simply mean that an employer's payroll has to sum to at least 60% of the loan within 24 weeks, no matter how much cash the employer has?
It seems like the difference between 1) handing out gifts to employers of up to 40% of their 24-week payroll, or 2) handing out gifts to employers that are up to 166% of their 24-week payroll. But I'm not a math scientist.
Either way, making direct cash payments to employers in proportion to their payrolls is as stark an example of welfare for the rich as you could cite. That's like paying money to people in proportion to their total stockholdings, as long as they promise to spend at least 60% of those payments to buy more stock. Even worse in the execution, where tons of the smallest employers and the self-employed were left out in favor of companies with high-powered accounting firms or lawyers on staff.
Businesses that wanted to be legit put this money into a specific account (in their accounting system) and tracked all expenses against that specific account for auditability.
The only loans that had less strict rules were for sole proprietors/self employed businesses. But the size of the loan was capped pretty low relatively.
Of course this program was highly flawed. But it was thrown together quickly in response to the pandemic. Personally I wish our government would already have plans in place ahead of time so everything wasn't done so hastily and last minute causing massive fraud.
Did they at least have to prove that it would be financially beneficial for them to do layoffs?
> Of course this program was highly flawed. But it was thrown together quickly in response to the pandemic.
Eh, this isn't a deep dive, these are basic questions about the concept. Not that a deep dive wouldn't be warranted with tens or hundreds of billions at stake.
If that had happened, all of those people would have been applying for unemployment, COBRA, Obamacare plans, Medicaid, etc as well. It was more a question of which Federal accounts to drain. By giving businesses a clear path to making sure they could keep paying people regardless of whether money was coming in from customers, that was avoided. In order to get business owners to take it though, you had to basically give it to them.
It was highly variable which businesses could find a way to keep operating in the conditions of lock down and COVID protocols. Remote work was easy. Running a bar was not.
Even then you also had exorbitantly high unemployment payments for a long period of time. It wasn't as if the PPP loans were the only money being injected.
> If that had happened, all of those people would have been applying for unemployment, COBRA, Obamacare plans, Medicaid, etc as well.
If we don't prefer direct aid over middlemen, why don't we route all social programs through middlemen? I'd like to volunteer, as long as I'm allowed a 40% cut off the top.
I have no objection to the government sending money to people who were made unemployed by covid. I have little objection to the government propping up marginal businesses that serve a valuable purpose in better times, but would otherwise fail during covid without aid, although I feel it was largely a landlord subsidy.
I'm asking a process question.
There were lockdowns for 2 weeks. Any customer facing business that couldn’t have customers walking in to do business was going to have no income for at least that long. If you don’t have income, there’s no money for expenses like payroll.
Unless you operate an extremely high margin business, your only options are to not pay staff during that time or to have layoffs.
Most small businesses aren’t high margin.
As for middlemen, given the short timeline what were the real options for the government? Setup a channel where every individual could apply for direct relief or use existing heavily regulated channels through banks?
Keeping the economy moving needed to be the top priority, so existing channels made more sense.
We applied for a loan at our small business. We worked with our accountant and banker to make sure everything was handled properly and then documented everything so that we could apply for forgiveness. We didn’t have any issue since our staff had grown by a couple of positions from the prior year.
Even though revenues did take a hit, the temporary allowance for telepractice options helped to lessen the overall impact.
If not for the PPP loans our business and a lot of others like it would have been staring down bankruptcy and layoffs for about 30 people. And we run a tight margin business.
I can’t say that there wasn’t fraud in some places, but for us it worked exactly as intended.
The combination of PPP with high unemployment payments that lasted much longer than needed pretty well spread things around. Both of them had an impact on the overall economy.
In hindsight, we probably would have been best off by just having people take precautions and avoid lockdowns entirely. Hopefully we will learn from the mistake.
To get your loan forgiven, you had to take a loan and show documentation of having spent loan amount of dollars on qualified expenses. There is no "must prove you were saved by the loan" requirement.
edit: thanks for the edit.
There was an income limit of $75,000, thats not close to everyone.
Stabilizing an economy when a national quarantine had shut down production and trade is one of those challenges that's much easier to solve in a centralized fashion.
You want to talk really uplifting those in poverty, we need to talk stipend.
This isn't exclusive to capitalism; there are other ideologies that work this way. However, they are ever more intolerably authoritarian than capitalism. Capitalists at least offer the promise of growing the economic universe alongside themselves - you can get 10x richer by taking 50% less profit in some businesses. But fascists, criminals, and dictators also play this game - not to create wealth and grow the size of the pie, but to shrink it so their share gets bigger. And without a government to enforce rules, capitalists will be out-moded, out-gunned, and out-played by thieves of various stripes every time.
Making this worse is the fact that Bitcoin mining is inherently and deliberately zero-sum. It has to be, because it pays in inflation (block subsidy) and confiscation (transaction fees). So capitalists can offer no wealth creation here.
In other words, Bitcoin is how authoritarians trolled right-libertarians into building and buying into a system that creates the thing they hate.
What do you mean? Holding a currency involves zero value creation.
Fiat currency has issues, but at least a government has the authority to conjure money out of nothing and hand it to the poor.