If a construction company said: “The only projects we can make a profit on are skyscrapers, but we do not know how to make a skyscraper without having it fall down and kill everybody in it.” They are not allowed to build skyscrapers no matter how important it is to their bottom line.
Well wait a minute, couldn't you say the same about the ISPs that host websites in the first place? Isn't the standard pro-big-tech-censorship position "if you don't like it, make your own website"? If Facebook has to moderate content (according to any standard) in order to exists, why don't hosting providers also have to moderate? (FWIW I'm anti-censorship)
The article asserts that Facebook’s moderation is defective. The person I was responding to presented a standard generic argument that is of the form: “Yes, it is defective, but the problem is too hard for anybody to produce a non-defective solution. Therefore, the provider has no choice but to provide a defective service.” I am arguing that is untrue. If a service is defective, it can and should just not be offered.
Note this is entirely contingent on the service being defective according to your value system. I have made no claim as to whether or not I agree with the specifics here, just that the generic conditional argument presented is flawed.
It is similar to: car manufactures can’t guarantee that their cars won’t kill people therefore their products are flawed and shouldn’t be sold. In this case, the user is held liable for ensuring that it is safely operated.
By your logic, we would stop building roads or ask car manufactures to stop selling cars because people cause accidents that kill other people.
The condition “service providers must moderate content and adjudicate disputes” is what’s flawed.
The Rolling Stone thinks Facebook is providing a defective service (i.e. a service that is net harmful). If you agree with that contention, then you should also agree that Facebook should not offer that service. The comment I was responding to was making the generic argument that: “The problem is too hard. Nobody can make a non-defective solution. Therefore, the provider has no choice except to provide a net harmful service.” That is a flawed argument.
You may also disagree with the premise: “Facebook is providing a net harmful service”, but that is independent of the invalidity of the argument presented which assumed it was providing a net harmful service, but they should be allowed to do so anyways due to the argument presented.
The previous poster didn't say all ISPs or all social networks should be banned. They were simply talking about Facebook.
There is no stopping.
Norm MacDonald (I didn't even know he was sick) is said to have made the following quote, which is an interesting filter to look at all you know about history through.
"It says here in this history book that; luckily, the good guys have won every single time. What are the odds?"
> will not be recognized by any machine we have nowadays. The first is true, the second is bullshit, how algorithm can now this?
Forget algorithms for a second, even humans can't adequately judge nuanced issues, particularly issues that they're unfamiliar with and lack the context around, and particularly with a definitive time limit to work against.
Now think about how social media giants operate. They have teams all over the world, say in Bangalore, trying to judge the nuanced political arguments of foreigners having discussions about their own country's history that they don't know intimately. Oh, and they probably have to judge most issues in less than 30 seconds or they'll be too slow to keep their job.
It's like asking an average American to intelligently weigh in on some complicated political argument around Kashmir with a few seconds to read a post and decide who's claim is right. It's absolutely ridiculous that this is the moderation standard that exists.
Is that really true?
The conquest of the Americas is near-universally seen as "evil" defeating at least "innocent" if not "good". Leaving aside the people who say "The Aztecs had it coming".
The Roman empire did some pretty shitty things, that most people would recognize as evil (slavery, Celtic genocide) but is still regarded warmly today as the ancestor of modern Western society, morality, and culture. That counts as a "win".
That's sort of the joke. It's another way of saying "the victors write the history books"
I think judging past history reasonably from our current perspective isn't quite so easy.
From the perspective of today, virtually every human that ever lived in the past had views that could be considered some kind of racist, sexist, homophobe, religious extremist, etc even if they were very decent humans by the standards of their day. Even the great abolitionists, philosophers, people considered to be saints, or other humans that tried to be wholesome in their time likely had some views that would be considered totally repugnant to many today or committed actions that were considered reasonable then, but akin to war crimes now.
From the perspective of 100 or 200 years from now, I'm sure everybody living today around 2022 will be considered to have committed gross and obvious crimes against decent human morality and will be considered to have had totally backwards thoughts on something or another. I'd hope proper context is taken into account when they look back at us, so I think it's fair to try and do the same when we judge the past.
Of course they do. Do you have any examples to the contrary?
Many times, their distant ancestors look back and realize their actions were poor, and revise the history books, but that usually takes generations at least.
More violent than the Europeans that conquered them?
And I think we already covered the Aztecs. It's not like the Europeans treated non-Aztecs any differently though.
I think the "reddit model" where you have smaller communities with community mods works much better than the Facebook or Twitter model where there's one "global community". Not that reddit's moderation is perfect or that you can 100% rely on community mods, but overall, it seems to work much better.
By no means is reddit 'the model'. In practically any sub except the explicitly Jewish ones, I will find an avalanche of antisemitism on any post that touches on Judaism/Israel/Jews.
That place is a cancer.
When I was in college, I was looking around an FTP server and found a holocaust denier book. So I read it. Well, more moderately skimmed (not lightly).
It was exactly like this - it purported to be a sober view of history, well cited and no name calling. Literally none of the references were to anything real; it was all fabricated bullshit trying to push the reader to a particular conclusion (Jews are bad).
Not being able to tell the difference is entirely the point. These bastards are sneaky.
But the problem is that censorship assumes that you are too stupid to come to that conclusion yourself and must be protected from the "misinformation".
It also robs the marketplace of the ability to hear the legitimate criticisms and the opportunities to expose said bullshit.
With regards to:
> But the problem is that censorship assumes that you are too stupid to come to that conclusion yourself and must be protected from the "misinformation".
> It also robs the marketplace of the ability to hear the legitimate criticisms and the opportunities to expose said bullshit.
Do you think the public on the first count, and the marketplace on the second count are doing a particularly admirable job here? Because, I don't. And that failure comes in no small part because of other vested interests who prop up said bullshit, because they see an opportunity to profit and gain more influence from it. How do you propose we address that?
But that's precisely the problem these days. We have seen recently that the government has been colluding with the tech companies to censor content that they deem "misinformation" and individuals whom they deem "problematic". It's no longer just about a private company deciding what they will or will not allow on their platform.
https://nypost.com/2022/09/01/white-house-big-tech-colluded-...
> "Do you think the public on the first count, and the marketplace on the second count are doing a particularly admirable job here?"
It's not about whether the "group" is coming to the decision or conclusion that you or I would like them to reach. It's about whether we, as individuals, have the right to view the totality of the evidence and arguments and then make up our own minds.
Some people see through the bullshit and some don't. That's the nature of humanity. And, to be fair, what you and I might think is bullshit might turn out to actually be completely the opposite. We're not infallible. But the fact that any of us might make mistakes in judgement or analysis is not a valid reason to prevent unpopular or unverified (or however you want to label it) information from being disseminated or accessed.
The first amendment just ensures the government cannot punish you for what you say.
If you are arguing for implementing that ideal, well and good. I disagree that in our current media ecosystem that that is a good idea. But I cannot fault you for advocating for an ideal.
If you are suggesting the public has a right to see all content on a platform without any moderation, you are wrong. No such right is enshrined in US law.
I don't read /pol, /publicfreakout or any of these other communities and that means I am completely unaffected by whatever nonsense they have going on.
Reddit shuts down other kinds of hate, the double standard is glaring. The fact that it doesn't impact you personally is so not the point.
The problem with “Jews destroyed German economy before the war” is that it’s extremely vague and difficult to verify. There’s no good basis for the claim, but it’s not even a historical detail that could be easily verified; it’s more of an overarching theoretical opinion.
As for “Jews were murdered by Germans during the war”, sure. That’s an extremely well documented fact. They were also murdered by Romanians, Lithuanians, Bulgarians, Hungarians, Ukrainians, and other collaborators, but in context, we know that the Germans were organizing the whole thing. We also know that there’s a different context today in 2022 where some people might want to emphasize and others might want to minimize the complicity of Ukrainian collaborators.
It’s sad that you’re blind to the fact that that statement is just as ‘racist’ and untrue as the original.
Jews were not murdered by Germans.
Rather, Some Jews were murderer by Some members of a political party that was primarily — but not exclusively — German.
The overwhelming majority of Germans never murdered anyone.
Just a minor correction, the Polish were sent to Haiti in 1802, way before Napoleon had started losing.
I disagree. The problem is that nobody is willing to be realistic about the limitations of automated moderation and proceed accordingly.
If we can't create an automatic method that catches context, the solution isn't to bemoan that AI can't magically do what we want. The solution is to remove the rules that require AI to understand context in the first place, because it is fundamentally outside of our technical ability, and any attempt to achieve it will fail.
The problem is people who think that context-based censorship is reasonable for a massive platform. It simply is not. It is reasonable at an individual level. It is reasonable at an interpersonal level. It's even reasonable at a small-group level, where specific individual human beings who are invested in the community can be aware of these context issues.
It is not reasonable at Facebook scale, full stop. Facebook should not be in the business of deciding to ban things like this. That is a responsibility that belongs at a lower level. What does that look like in practice?
If an individual posted it on their wall:
* That individual uses their judgement and chooses to post it or not
* The people who see it use their judgement and click the block button if they don't like it
If an individual posted it in a small group:
* The group can socially police such actions by commenting that they are upset by it
* The group's administrators can privately reach out to the person who posted it, explain that they can't post such things in that group, explain why, and explain what actions they could take to remain in good graces
* The group's administration can make a judgement call and remove the post, not on the basis of crude keyword detection, but on the basis of human understanding
If an individual posted in a large group:
* The large group can adopt clear and unambiguous rules that do not require context to administer, and enforce them accordingly on a case-by-case basis
* The large group can pre-commit to not dealing with such issues, and require their members to deal with it privately, like human beings
Trying to automate this process will always fail, and it will cause massive false-positive and false-negative issues as it does so. Engineers used to understand these concepts when I first entered industry 20 years ago. It's very disappointing to me that they either can't or won't now.
Even from a product point of view, that's basic: your product feature doesn't pass quality, you don't ship it.
It was a plain power struggle where two superpowers decided to invest their resources to deny the other a base in Africa. The local proxies were fine with this since they wanted nothing but to kill each other. The result was a bloodbath that went on for decades.
Like voting weights the value of peer's votes and such.
I think it's the only way.
Otoh, the true Lord of the Flies might emerge that way. Maybe democracy is inherently flawed. I dunno. Experiments are called for.
How do we test social media designs?
"Well, just make everything legal."
It seems crazy that it's impossible to find a major platform that has this policy.
If Facebook allowed pornography, it would quickly overwhelm the platform due to engagement metrics.
It would make the platform unusable.
Vile hate speech? Completely legal.
But its mere presence would turn away huge numbers of users.
It would make the platform unattractive and hurt the business.
It is in the platform's best interest to block otherwise legal things.
You're arguing with hypotheticals even through real world examples exist.
Reddit has lots of porn and it's nowhere to be seen on the frontpage.
Allowing something doesn't mean you shouldn't classify it and filter it.
Reddit has a fundamentally different approach to front-page content and discovery, and moderation in general.
But even on Reddit, which is fairly permissive, they have hard boundaries which have little, if anything, to do with the "law".
This story is from 2013: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/classroom/2013/06/facebook-and-...
Maybe super early it was a free for all, but it had a lot less users then. The impacts mattered less.
These interventions became important as the companies grew, and needed to attract the largest possible number of users.
There are places with VERY open content policies. You can join them today.
Those places attract a niche audience and I'd wager always will.
It's not hard to see why major platform has such a policy
Also I don't want people to get blocked for pirating stuff. Or weed.
> "Well, just make everything legal."
It's a bit of a straw man to say that GP meant we shouldn't enforce the law in the real world.
GP wasn't very clear what he meant, but presumably he's referring to not doing excessive moderating and instead rely on the law mandates.
More ~~laws~~rules, less justice. When you have a lot of internal policies, you're inevitably going to have ridiculous results such as this one. If you only follow the legal rules (which you have to) there's less unfairness.
(Of course, you have to have some internal policies such as not allowing spam, but the point is: the fewer onerous rules, the better.)
The issue here is more like defining what crime is, though, not stopping it. Stopping stuff on FB is easy. Figuring out what to stop, is hard. Figuring out if a disputed case should have been stopped is hard. For the 'real world' we have parliaments and courts, but there's FB has only the equivalent of police, not the other parts of the system. It is, in effect, a police state.
More, even if Facebook employees humans to do moderation still for some contractor from Asia "Jews destroyed German economy before the war" might not be easy to verify. For a contractor maybe Jews did that, who cares, I have 20 seconds to moderate this and move to other post. The same way if I was asked to moderate some historical details about India-Pakistan conflict or other historical facts about Asia, Africa I have no knowledge about at all.
I was reading quite a lot recently about war in Angola and still I have doubts which side was "good" and which was "bad", besides that people who lived there were hurt in the history like almost no other nation.
Even worst. Some, especially historical, facts are judged from different perspective. For instance in Poland Napoleon Bonaparte is a mythologized person that brought hope to Polish hearts to get back their homeland [1]. From the point of view of someone from Austria or Italy, well, Napoleon is considered to be far from hero.
We don't have to go back that far in the history. US intervention in Afghanistan or Iraq can be seen differently depending on somebody views.
How to moderate all this?
[1] Fun fact: not a big surprise that Napoleon didn't give a crap about Poland, he even refused to give them a proper King at the short time he could (he has chosen some Saxon prince). At the end, when Napoleon lost, remains of Polish military units were sent to Haiti to help France to maintain their colonies. Many Polish soldiers died from tropical illnesses there, many joined Haitians as they saw that those people were fighting for their freedom like Poles were.